Knowing when to quit

misssmarita

I did yoga today for the very first time in my life. Now let me just say that I am ve-ee-ee-ee-ry out of shape. The thing is, it went quite badly. And when I say quite badly, I mean I couldn't do 3/4 of the poses, and the ones I could do I probably didn't do right. The instructor came over to me twice and quietly asked me if something was wrong. She was nice about it, but I felt so out of place.

Now, the question is: should I quit? I've been reading up a little on yoga, and it sounds like my thing. Learn to support your own body weight, better posture, mind/body connection, build lean muscle mass, yada yada. That sounds like the perfect form of strength training for me. But it was so difficult, and I felt so embarrased in a room with 20 - 30 other people who could do every move nearly perfect. I do wanna try new things, find out what works for me, but I don't wanna bounce around endlessly from class to class, because I know I am so out of shape that EVERYTHING will be hard in the beginning.

So, what do you think?

TavistockToad

I know I am so out of shape that EVERYTHING will be hard in the beginning.

So, what do you think?

i think you answered your own question.

if you quit, you wont ever get any better at it...

majope

If you want to stick to that particular class, go early next time and introduce yourself to the instructor and tell her you're brand new to yoga. If she's good, she'll be able to offer alternate poses or easier versions of the one the class is doing. But there's nothing wrong with sampling other classes--one might be more beginner-friendly.

Best of luck!

baileysmom4

Is there a beginning class you can take? I would feel the same way if I was in a room full of people doing perfect poses! I'm about as flexible as a stick! A beginning class would have others like you who are learning the poses. Just a thought.

kbeech06

Was it a beginners class? If not, then maybe find one? If it was, then don't worry...it will get easier. I can't imagine trying yoga...I have no balance at all, I would definitely be falling over :laugh: All new activities are hard, and you feel like an idiot, but we've all been there before!

Athena53

Persistence is key in anything. Yoga is probably more difficult because the moves can be complex and you need to develop some flexibility but hey, that's why you're there! If you were saying that all your muscles and joints were screaming, that might mean you overdid it, but it doesn't sound that way.

It might help if you have a brief conversation with the instructor and tell her you're a newbie and it's going to take some time for you to get the moves but you're willing to work at it. (I have terrible gross motor co-ordination and cannot process instructions like "do this with your right hand and that with your left, and balance on your left foot, now shift your weight to your right..." so I can sympathize.)

Just take the attitude of "I don't get this now but I'll work at it till I get it" and it will rub off on your classmates.

NewFrenchFemme

What type of yoga was it? It sounds as though the class was at too advanced a level for you - maybe try to find a beginners' class? Failing that, there are some good introductory level videos on the internet that you could try to get you into it. I have just re-started yoga, and am having a series of one-to-one sessions, which I find very helpful, if challenging! Please don't give up on yoga, as there are so many different disciplines that I am sure you will find something that you can do now and progress with.

volleygirl1980

If you want to stick to that particular class, go early next time and introduce yourself to the instructor and tell her you're brand new to yoga. If she's good, she'll be able to offer alternate poses or easier versions of the one the class is doing. But there's nothing wrong with sampling other classes--one might be more beginner-friendly.

Best of luck!

^^ This. The first time I took yoga I was terrible. I never developed a taste for it, but I definitely got better..same thing now for me with TRX classes. The nice thing about struggling in the beginning is that you've got lots of room to grow!

I'd also recommend trying different yoga classes as there are so many types and the teacher makes a big difference..

I read somewhere (I think Gabrielle Reece said it) that you should try something new seven times before you give up..

Good luck!

Keto_T

One of my mom's quotes: "Can't couldn't and quit"

sandobr1

No you should not quit, keep going and go more then once a week if you can. If you are worried try the library get some videos and practice at home, I have an app that is simply yoga that has a 20 minute workout look around for ways to do yoga more often.

Watch this video, and I think you might change your mind. Hope it works, if not You Tube it is called, Never, Ever Give Up. Arthur's Inspirational Transformation. Someone had linked it here a while ago.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qX9FSZJu448

You are young quitting because of a little embarrasment is really silly in the grand scheme of a lifetime of enjoying yoga.

imhungry2012

Don't quit! I guarentee 2 months from now you will have a NSV about how you were able to complete all of the posses and you'll be so glad you stuck with it Try other classes as well, I do not do yoga but have to imagine that mixing it up would be good and make you stronger so the posses become easier overtime.

You could also buy a yogo DVD and do it at home, too.

You can do it!

sd75

Yoga is excellent - but it does take time. I agree with the above - a good teacher will advise on how to make the most of the poses.
One thing i was always told with yoga is that its all about your own personal acheivement and not about what others in the class are doing - so keep going - and you will get better. Don't focus on how 'nimble' others in the class are, and instead focus on your breathing and lengthening etc - and in a few months you'll be glad you didn't quit. I do think its important to connect with the class teacher tho too - makes such a difference to any kind of exercise class i think.
Also as an aside - you could perhaps try Body Balance as an alternative - its basically the same moves but in a slightly less regimented fashion, but equally probably means its not quite as good for you.

AnabolicKyle

ive done yoga a couple times, never been flexible 6ft 4 i stand out from everyone & probably looked like a dingus.

but...

there is some great one hour long youtube videos for yoga and they helped me out a lot i will probably being going back to class in the near future.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PcC8hZPwj6w

edit

resting position!!!!! WTF

Downward Dog

Downward Dog

Downward Dog

I hate this position with a passion!!!

Alexfit12

Don't quit. It will only take a few workouts until you are able to the moves correctly, and the benefits are countless. I suggest you download the P90X Yoga video, and start working with it at your own pace. It will explain all the poses and you can get a little practice before doing it in a studio again, which may be a little embarrassing if you are a beginner.

KellyL23

There is a video online about a disabled veteran who couldnt walk without assistance, started doing yoga every day, and made AMAZING transformation and now he runs marathons. I cried like a baby when I watched it. The key message was that he stuck with it and didnt give up. Persistance is key.

Frankii_x

I've personally never done Yoga - but I did start running. I started by running a mile...I stopped 3 times in the first half a mile and then walked the rest. In September 2012 I did my first half marathon. In May of this year I'm doing my second. Trust your abillity.

I don't know if you're a fan of "Friends" or not but there's one part where Monica is taking part in a dance class and the instructor shouts "Hey, you at the back! You're doing it all wrong" and Monica replies with "But at least I'm doing it"

I always keep that in mind. It's better to be doing it and not being that great than to sit on the sofa wondering what it would have been like if you hadn't given up.

xx

lacroyx

"Never give up! Never surrender!" ~Buzz Lightyear

FlaxMilk

Make sure you are in a beginner's class. The instructor will expect you and everyone else to have some trouble and you won't feel out of place.

Sweet_Pandora

Everyone was a beginner at one time.

Karen

Mistyblu08

dont quit- just remember when you are in class watching those other people ....at one time they were you ....they got better with practice! Stick with it
I am thinking about doing yoga as well and that is one thing that has stopped me too is that I am about as inflexible as a 2x4 lol but I know I wont get better til I do it regularly....I am going to try doing it at home with dvd until I can at least touch my toes

EmilyOfTheSun

Get a yoga DVD and do it at home. You will improve and then you won't feel so out of place at a class.

auddii

No you should not quit, keep going and go more then once a week if you can. If you are worried try the library get some videos and practice at home, I have an app that is simply yoga that has a 20 minute workout look around for ways to do yoga more often.

Watch this video, and I think you might change your mind. Hope it works, if not You Tube it is called, Never, Ever Give Up. Arthur's Inspirational Transformation. Someone had linked it here a while ago.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qX9FSZJu448

You are young quitting because of a little embarrasment is really silly in the grand scheme of a lifetime of enjoying yoga.

I was going to search for this video. I tear up every time I watch it.

The biggest difference with him is that he had an instructor who believed in him, and gave him extra time and help (although I'm not sure it was ever in person or not). If your instructor isn't helpful, you may want to find a different one, but she may not have even known you had no idea what you were doing and how out of shape you are. Like someone else mentioned, I'd talk to her before the next class. Don't give up!

BerryH

I thought I was really fit and flexible, but I found my first few yoga classes really hard. Stick with it. Don't be embarrassed about the instructor coming over frequently, that's what she's there for. It shows you're in a good class that she keeps asking after you. Do take the opportunity for her advice as much as you need, don't feel you have to push through on your own. Getting the technique right is very important to get the greatest benefit from yoga.

Think about it, you wouldn't expect to run 10-minute miles or bench-press your own body weight on your first time. Every type of exercise takes some practice. You'll get there!

katie__pillar

A friend of mine used to rave about Abby Lentz's heavyweight yoga. I've never done it myself, but she said it was great. http://heartfeltyoga.com/

nikkilou_hawley

Oh your post broke my heart!!!

Yes, yoga is difficult. I have a shoulder injury and have to modify positions so that I don't make it worse. I fell out of a pose yesterday because I was so concentrated on staying focused that I didn't realize that I was leaning very badly to the right. IT HAPPENS.

Biggest thing to remember about yoga is that there is no competition. Not between you and the instuctor, you and another person in the class, or even you against yourself. Listen to your body and try. My instructor says give it three times before your judge it.

I watched a motivational video that really pushed me to believe that I could do it. The man in the video is a retired military vet who was told he would never be able to walk unassisted again.

http://www.military.com/video/specialties-and-personnel/veterans/disabled-vets-amazing-transformation/1628380623001/

Honestly don't give up on anything if you think it is for you. If you try it a couple of times and you just dont enjoy it, then try something else. But if it is something that you really feel like you need to try then keep going.

prophetessmom

I did yoga today for the very first time in my life. Now let me just say that I am ve-ee-ee-ee-ry out of shape. The thing is, it went quite badly. And when I say quite badly, I mean I couldn't do 3/4 of the poses, and the ones I could do I probably didn't do right. The instructor came over to me twice and quietly asked me if something was wrong. She was nice about it, but I felt so out of place.

Now, the question is: should I quit? I've been reading up a little on yoga, and it sounds like my thing. Learn to support your own body weight, better posture, mind/body connection, build lean muscle mass, yada yada. That sounds like the perfect form of strength training for me. But it was so difficult, and I felt so embarrased in a room with 20 - 30 other people who could do every move nearly perfect. I do wanna try new things, find out what works for me, but I don't wanna bounce around endlessly from class to class, because I know I am so out of shape that EVERYTHING will be hard in the beginning.

So, what do you think?

I think you shouldn't give up. I agree that you should speak to the instructor before class and just explain that you are new. It sounds like she's really nice and she should be able to modify until you improve. Most yoga instructors want you to love it and improve. She might also have some suggestions on things you can do at home in between classes to help you along. Just don't give up!

ames105

I've been doing yoga again for 15 months, taking beginner classes once to twice a week. This past Saturday was the first class where I felt like I achieved all of the poses with strength and balance. Even then, I still did one pose modified because the extra weight around my middle makes it difficult for me. But its taken me 15 months to get this far!

Yoga isn't about walking in and being perfect on the very first try. Its about the journey of getting there, the self discovery, how you feel on the inside. Its about taking care of yourself and learning. A good yoga instructor will teach you modifications and provide encouragement. Also, as you lose some weight, you will notice yourself becoming stronger and more able to hold poses.

Don't give in! Giving in is what caused all of us to have weight problems in the first place. If you like it and think this is something that would be good for you, keep going, keep looking for an instructor that you feel comfortable with. Keep trying. Good luck!!!

Laney2r

I would say give it another try and look into the different types of yoga. Hatha yoga is good for a beginner and vinyasa with adjusted poses can be good too. My yoga instuctor starts each new session with a reminder that we leave our "ego" at the door. We are not doing yoga as a competition but to become more flexible and strong. A good instructor will help you get the poses right. I have been doing yoga for quite some time and I still need adjustments sometimes, its no biggie I promise. I really felt like I was out of place when I started but now Tuesdays and Thursdays are my favorite days because I get my yoga class at the end of the day.

Yoga is not for everyone, same as zumba, spinning, ect. You have to find what works for you but give yourself a month at a new activity to determine if you like it.

Good luck!

BendySpartan

If its something you think you will enjoy then stick with it! Some will do a one on one session so you can have some time focusing on technique! Or hit youtube and practice at home. The only way we get good at stuff is practice!
Good luck xx

gothyogini

Don't quit! I started yoga when I was much heavier. Yoga has helped me through my physical challenges as well as some mental blocks. If you stick with it you will be amazed how it can transform your body and mind. The hardest part is to not give up. Just remember that it takes practice and patience with yourself.

Micahroni84

Dont quit! Last year i was in the same place as you but i kept at it. Out of shape or not, yoga is more about balance and if you stick with it in a few weeks to a month you will feel a significant improvemnt. I was taking both pilates and yoga classes and it was really hard at first. Now i mostly take pilates with a few yoga classes but becuase they are so easy to do at home i can maintain. Stick with it for sure. You will feel so proud in your improvement in just a few weeks. Dont worry about being able to do all the poses. Ask your instructor for modified versions if she isnt offering them.