How about you shut up about what I am eating!

smantha32

Oh and I get this ALL the time at home. I get it about my workouts. I get that my husband is much faster than I am in the pool, but when he calls me on how fast he is, I point out that I swim for an HOUR of non-stop laps, where he does one fast one and has to spend ten minutes in the shallow end. Who's the bi*ch?

Actually your husband might be doing it the better way. There is an indication that people who do high intensity for a few seconds and then rest until their heart rate comes down, actually lose more body fat.

http://www.builtlean.com/2010/06/04/high-intensity-interval-training-hiit-best-cardio-to-burn-fat/

Buff2022

I would say this person is already a better friend because they are taking the time to look over your diary and relate it to what they know about you. Personally I would prefer someone who makes this sort of effort over the normal 'Good job!', 'Good day', 'Yummy day' sorta rhetoric I see day after day.

If somebody were making comments I regularly found hurtful I would first thank them for paying attention and trying to help me. Then I would mention how their words made me feel. If they were truly a good friend, I hope they would change.

If they couldn't and it got too much, there's always friend removal.

This was not about anyone here. Everyone here is being supportive. It was a family member. One who eats **** all the time and yet talks about me.

Buff2022

I think OP is making two points:

1. Her diary is open and she welcomes MFP members' comments re her diary.

2. She does not appreciate people who observe what she is eating for lunch or dinner and making unsolicited negative comments, while they, themselves, are eating poorly.

Me - I don't appreciate my SO telling me I spend more money on food because I eat chicken -- he thinks my $1.99/lb chicken is more expensive than this $3.99 box of crumb cakes and apple danish that he stuffs his face with. I just smile and offer him some chicken (which, by the way, I paid for).

Let's face it, unfortunately, most of us (not all) have a history of past failures. But there comes a time - like now - when we will be successful !!

VICTORY to the MFPers!!

1. exactly -- If someone here says hey you should watch that you are eating ABC. I would think about. But when someone in my house says that crap they do.

2. That is exactly my point

Buff2022

I may have the wrong end of the stick here, but it sounds like the person who was criticizing her was there in person, not on here. The people who were offering her advice on here were the ones she was pointing out in a positive manner.

YES YES YES!!! NO ONE here has been nasty to me. This person was in my house an I am related to them.

I appreciate people on MFP looking and commenting on my food choices.

craigmandu

I may have the wrong end of the stick here, but it sounds like the person who was criticizing her was there in person, not on here. The people who were offering her advice on here were the ones she was pointing out in a positive manner.

YES YES YES!!! NO ONE here has been nasty to me. This person was in my house an I am related to them.

I appreciate people on MFP looking and commenting on my food choices.

I completely mis-read your opener...I thought you were initially saying you didn't want people to "judge" your diary, if they had certain things in theirs...

Now, about your real issue...I would simply reply with something like..."I'd rather throw away some fruit, than eat that fatty calorie laden junk you are eating"....I am very direct with people that criticize me in real life, much moreso than people here. I usually regard people here as trying to accomplish what I am doing, so they actually get "more" leeway with me than someone I know could really care less.

Good Luck with the home folks...I know it can be challenging.

mccbabe1

No matter how well I eat now, after so many years of eating poorly I don't think I have the right to make negative comments about anyone's food choices. I guess you could say that my diet criticism license was revoked by the food police!

LOl cute.. love the honestly too and you are humble! :drinker:

Monny287

My parents are starting to accept my healthier choices but at first they actually got annoyed with me, saying I was eating weird stuff, taking offence if I wanted to eat something different or eliminate something from the meal, mocking me... but now they just accept it, and are even taking on board some of my habits (:

My family was the same way! My grandmother, especially. I lived with her until about six or seven months ago and I decided to cut out junk food and most processed foods last summer in an effort to lose the weight I'd gained during my senior year of college. I told her and she could not believe what I wasn't eating anymore! I wouldn't eat most of what she bought at the store and she got upset! It wasn't "junk food" per se, just a LOT of processed food. I wanted to eat more fresh food. When I started to bike four miles a day and bake my own wheat bread every week (ugh, to have that sort of time again!), my family branded me a "health nut."

Now, I get flack from my co-workers about my dieting habits, mostly for the fact that I batch-cook on Sundays and bring the exact same lunch to work almost every day. This is generally leftovers of something I made on Sunday. It usually lasts me until Wednesday, then I pack something else. Meh. I like what I cook and it works for me.

rudz99

great job! Why worry about what other people are saying when you already lost 25lbs! You must be doing something right!

Contrarian

It makes me laugh that so many people assumed it was someone on this site.