Non-Scale Discouragement

FlannelMothman

Some background on me:

I've been losing weight since September-ish, and my final weight goal is 130lbs. Before breakfast I was 161lbs, for a total loss of 54lbs. I am 5'5 1/2 (closer to 5'6 though) and have more of an hourglass shape. I have a feeling I'll be "skinny fat" and tried to lift weifhts but I have an ulcer (due to severe stress, not due to dieting) so I've been asked by a doctor to wait until it heals so not to aggravate it further.

My discouraging moment:
So I saw Starsky and Hutch again last night, and in it was Brande Roderick. She states her height at 5'7", her weight at 117-ish in the movie. I'm 5'6. This is extremely discouraging, as I thought twenty more pounds and I'd be good... No, turns out I need to lose 45-50lbs more. I thought being 130 would be healthy and almost "too thin" looking for me, but she does not look anorexic. She looks healthy. Super discouraged that I'm "only halfway", and not as close to my end goal as I apparently thought.

Anyone have any advice/words of wisdom/etc? The way I see it, if I'm shorter, I could conceivably - and maybe should - weigh less than her. Am I wrong?

petersonabt

I am 5'5 and hit 130 (you can look at my pics on my profile) for me 117 would be way to thin. I used to be about that when I was younger and looked ill.

Everyone's body is different. so keep that in mind. get to your goal of 130 and then reevaluate. don't let it bring you down!

AllonsYtotheTardis

First of all - actresses and models lie about their weight all the time.

Second - comparing your body to someone else's body just leads to discouragement, for most people

third - work on getting where you want, and see how you feel when you reach goal weight. You might be pleasantly surprised. Or you might feel like you want to do a little more work on recomp, and that's fine too.


Do not panic - this isn't a race. You will be fine.

xsmilexforxmex

Don't base your goal weight off someone elses body. Everyone is different.

jennagoogles13

Everyone's body is different. I'm 5'6" and my goal weight was initially 130, and I'm now only a pound away. Sure, I'm happy with the number, but far from happy with my appearance. I really want to build muscle, and if that means I end up gaining weight, so be it. I think having a goal "look" is far more important than a goal weight. Just keep doing what you're doing, and I wish you the best of luck:)

_SABOTEUR_

Use a mirror, a camera and a measuring tape in conjunction with the scale. And ignore the scale.

MayaSPapaya

I agree, use the mirror for a goal look. I've had a lot of people guess my goal weight, and it's lower than the one I have in mind. If I can get there, sure, but right now I have MY goal in mind. And I'm way more concerned with being able to look good in a bikini, despite what the scale says at the end of june :laugh:

cook6609

I'm 5'6" and my goal is 130.... That is about middle for the normal BMI. While I'm going to decide when I get to that goal where I'll go from there, I know that I am not going below 120. For me I feel that anything below 120 will put me close to the unhealthy BMI range. I didn't work this hard to throw myself in the other unhealthy direction. Also, I wouldn't stress what actors/actresses say about weight... either A) they are lying or they just have a different body type... I'm willing to bet A.... Also, they tend to do extreme dieting measures to put them self at that low body weight, but then they end up gaining it back later... Don't stress... Just focus on your body... Congrats on your weigh-in :-)

BeachIron

If you're 5'5 1/2" but closer to 5'6" then wouldn't that be around 5'5 3/4"ish?

AESprouse

I'm 5'1 and my goal is 130. I haven't been that small since I was a preteen so I'll be happy. My point: do what makes you happy and don't worry about what other people look like. If you are happy with how you look at 130,, great. If not, do what you need to do so that you are happy. Don't don't base yourself off of any else's weight.

iulia_maddie

Stomach ulcer? I don't see how lifting would affect that in any way. And lololololol at wanting to weigh what and actress "claims" she weighs.

theCarlton

You're not Brande Roderick. Don't bother to compare yourself to someone else.

Cindyinpg

Go here: http://www.mybodygallery.com/search.html?height=5+6&weight=130&pant=any&shirt=any&zphoto=Large&new=1
It is called mybodygallery and shows pictures of real women at different heights and weights. it is a real eyeopener. You will see plenty of women at your goal weight (and higher) who look very slim and fit. Everyone is different and its amazing how we view others less critically than we do ourselves. After spending some time on that site I actually adjusted my goal weight upwards.

DavPul

*waits patiently for someone to point out that all celebrities lie about their body stats. they aren't that tall, they don't weigh that little, their waist and bust don't measure out to those numbers. hell, they weren't even born in that year. if she said it, she was lying.*

brenna8806

Stomach ulcers can bleed. Straining can cause bleeding more.

FlannelMothman

Stomach ulcer? I don't see how lifting would affect that in any way. And lololololol at wanting to weigh what and actress "claims" she weighs.

Actually, she's a Playboy Bunny, and Playmate of the Year, so her weight is actually correct. So correct in fact, that it's on Wikipedia.
I understand people lie, and I am not trying to say I necessarily want to weigh what she weighs. What I am saying is yes, I want to look like her(to a degree. Not a fan of her breast implants, but whatever), and being that we are similar heights and body types, shouldn't I typically weigh less than her, which would mean I'm far from done my journey, and thst freaking blows.

And as much as your opinion is valued as far as lifting with an ulcer goes, this was advice from two doctors: a general practioner, and the ER doctor(when I didn't listen to Dr No.1's advice).

FlannelMothman

*waits patiently for someone to point out that all celebrities lie about their body stats. they aren't that tall, they don't weigh that little, their waist and bust don't measure out to those numbers. hell, they weren't even born in that year. if she said it, she was lying.*

Again, I know the internet can be changed, but still... It's on Wikipedia.

FlannelMothman

Stomach ulcers can bleed. Straining can cause bleeding more.

^^ thank you

megsmom2

Dont compare yourself to a celebrity. (Who I never heard of.....) they lie. Plus..they have personal trainers and assistants and spend all their time just maintaining that body to have a career. You be YOU. Be the best YOU you can be. Don't try to be anyone else. Be YOU.

spruitt417

Some background on me:

I've been losing weight since September-ish, and my final weight goal is 130lbs. Before breakfast I was 161lbs, for a total loss of 54lbs. I am 5'5 1/2 (closer to 5'6 though) and have more of an hourglass shape. I have a feeling I'll be "skinny fat" and tried to lift weifhts but I have an ulcer (due to severe stress, not due to dieting) so I've been asked by a doctor to wait until it heals so not to aggravate it further.

My discouraging moment:
So I saw Starsky and Hutch again last night, and in it was Brande Roderick. She states her height at 5'7", her weight at 117-ish in the movie. I'm 5'6. This is extremely discouraging, as I thought twenty more pounds and I'd be good... No, turns out I need to lose 45-50lbs more. I thought being 130 would be healthy and almost "too thin" looking for me, but she does not look anorexic. She looks healthy. Super discouraged that I'm "only halfway", and not as close to my end goal as I apparently thought.

Anyone have any advice/words of wisdom/etc? The way I see it, if I'm shorter, I could conceivably - and maybe should - weigh less than her. Am I wrong?

I'm 5'8" & weighed 118 lbs while in college. That was way too thin! At 135 I looked & felt healthy. At this stage in my life I'm shooting for 150. I believe that is a healthy weight for me & I know all the clothes I can't fit right now will fit at that weight. Why would you compare yourself to someone on tv? You need to identify what is healthy for you & be comfortable with that.

chillmcgren

Just because she looks healthy in film/pictures does not mean she looks healthy in real life.

Getting healthy and fit is very important, but the scale does not define your worth. Not that you said it does, just a reminder.

melaniecheeks

Actresses are not good role models/ aspirational goals!

Choose your own goal, not what looks good on someone else (if its believable)

Rikki007s

Actually, she's a Playboy Bunny, and Playmate of the Year, so her weight is actually correct. So correct in fact, that it's on Wikipedia.

Like the others said, you should make your goal and then reevaluate.

Wikipedia is user created, so we can trust it only as much as we can trust the references included in the article. I noticed there is no reference provided for her weight on the Wikipedia page and her personal website doesn't seem to mention her stats either. The Wikipedia page could very well just be quoting the stat from the movie.

She looks pretty small though, so she very well could weight 117.

Barmaidsah

LOL...It's on Wikipedia!...LOL There's a reason most academics won't accept Wikipedia a reference for research. It's fine to start there, but it is user edited and NOT the ABSOLUTE truth. Don't worry about what others say their stats are. Get to your original weight goal and go from there.

Also, I have COPD, so lots of cardio and strenuous lifting are out of the question for me. HOWEVER, I still take a resistance band toning class and will be starting a Zumba class in June. Any instructor worth taking a class from can and will adjust the exercises to allow almost anyone to participate.

claritarejoice

Yes actresses work very hard and spend a lot of time and money to be thin, but they aren't necessarily happy about it. It's a job requirement and it's not fun or normal for most people to have to be so restricitve in our eating, when it's not required for us. Also often they don't look as good in real life as they do on film or camera. Right now the people around me think I look fantastic, and they think I look very thin. I am 5'7 tall and around 140 pounds. I'm happy and healthy and look good for a normal (non-hollywood) person, so why would I want to lose more? Oh and, the healthy weight range for a 5'7 female is 120-160 pounds. So if she is 117, she is underweight - something most of the world would be happy to avoid.

okcat4

I am 5'7", current 187. Goal 150, have hourglass figure, hips and butt. I was 148 high school thru college before gaining > i know I feel good at 148- 150, and look good. In my Opinion, 130 would be unrealistic for me to even attempt 130! Also, 150 puts my in proper BMI without struggling every day or being too thin. Would I love to be 140 or less? Sure, but know it is not likely! 150 is a safe, obtainable goal for me, especially if I am healthy in my other areas of life. Curves are wonderful and think how boring if we all were sticks!

LorinaLynn

First off... what everyone said about actresses and models lying about their weight. That's something I figured out as a skinny teenager when I'd sneak a peak at my brothers' Playboys. I was about 110 pounds and 5'5, and pretty much a skeleton. The playmates were taller than me, and every single measurement was bigger than mine, but miraculously weighed 107 pounds. Bullpoopie on that.

Secondly, scale weight is largely meaningless.

I was about 120 pounds in the first picture, and almost 15 pounds heavier in the second. The difference? In the first pic, I'd lost weight with a jaw problem (couldn't eat) and in the second, I was eating right and exercising right, so I have a lot more muscle mass.



I'm a good 20 pounds heavier in the second picture here, but the same vintage dress fits. My arms are no longer spaghetti noodles. That's the biggest difference. Well, that and I got a better hairdresser that didn't give me Spock bangs.



There's more pictures of a similar vein in this thread: http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/886672-1-5-million-calories-in-775-days

Forget the scale. And don't compare yourself to others.

girlwithcurls2

I'm 5'8" & weighed 118 lbs while in college. That was way too thin! At 135 I looked & felt healthy. At this stage in my life I'm shooting for 150. I believe that is a healthy weight for me & I know all the clothes I can't fit right now will fit at that weight. Why would you compare yourself to someone on tv? You need to identify what is healthy for you & be comfortable with that.

Sage advice. I'm 5'7". Weight in high school: 134 College: 145 Prepregnancy: 155 Starting MFP: 180 Goal: 160 and we'll reevaluate. Will I EVER get to 134 again? Hopefully not. My body isn't 18. My priorities are health and fitness. And as for the many, MANY women who are 5'7" on this board and aiming for 130 pounds, good luck to you. It won't work for me. I'm a big broad. But I'm a strong, badass mom who isn't worried about the scale (don't even own one). Just the shape.

Hang in there. Change your mindset. And for pete's sake, give up comparisons to celebs. Nothing about most of them is real.

~Curly

DavPul

*waits patiently for someone to point out that all celebrities lie about their body stats. they aren't that tall, they don't weigh that little, their waist and bust don't measure out to those numbers. hell, they weren't even born in that year. if she said it, she was lying.*

Again, I know the internet can be changed, but still... It's on Wikipedia.

Oh, I didn't realize this was a troll thread until just now. Good one, you totally got me there.

LorinaLynn

LissaK1981

Actually, she's a Playboy Bunny, and Playmate of the Year, so her weight is actually correct. So correct in fact, that it's on Wikipedia.

LOL....I am so happy, my drivers license still says 160, so I must be 160 still. :laugh:
Cmon who even puts their real weight on a drivers license anymore. So much of the big screen and mags are photoshopped. Look up whoever without makeup. You will see human everyday people and not these unattainable beauties you think are real.