Diet coke - does it make you put on weight
Replies
-
Nothing *makes* you put on weight but yourself making unhealthy food choices and eating a calorie surplus0
-
I rarely drink fizzy drinks, they make me feel bloated and crave food.0
-
THIS. How does it MAKE YOU put on weight when it has no calories? Is the Diet Coke pushing you into the donut shop? Several CLINICAL PEER REVIEWED STUDIES have been done on diet soda causing cravings and it's all been in CORRELATION and not considered the CAUSE.I don't believe it makes you put on weight.
YOU make you put on weight. If you find yourself getting hungry straight after you have a diet coke, prepare for it and simply don't eat. It's just fake hunger (unless you truly have got an empty stomach) owing to the chemicals.
It's not very good for ya but it won't 'make' you put on weight.. it has no calories..
People put on weight because of over consumption. Learn to control your over consumption and it's not an issue. I've been drinking Diet Pepsi (as well as my parents have) for 30 years now.
A.C.E. Certified Personal/Group FitnessTrainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 28+ years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition0 -
One other thing to consider is smoking. For decades smoking was encouraged. Go back far enough and children smoked "to keep the cold out of their lungs"-that is fact- yes it was 100 years ago but its still fact. It was encouraged by doctors. Then 20 years ago Doctors and the government told you not to eat fat - now they tell you to take Omega 3 - because its not 100% one way or the other. If you look at the research on aspartame none of it tends to be far reaching - government tends not to fund this because people dont want real evidence to exclude this crap and kill a billion dollar industry. The industries certainly wont fund it. If your thinking you want to give it up then you should. What do you have to lose - worse case scenario your drinking water or some other low cal drink. I will say i do love all the experts who have all the 100% answers - if everybody had all this figured out already then why do they have tickers under their name with "XX number of pounds to lose"????0
-
And that goes both ways. Mercola is out to prove that it's bad, so they're only going to list studies that support that view.Mercola is a berk. Look at his positioning on vaccines as well. Complete raving loony thats out there to grab headlines, nothing more!
Mercola just compiled a list of 68 studies, none of which were done by Mercola. Not one or two. Sixty Eight! Most of them say who the study was funded by. Of the studies I looked at from this post claiming aspertame is fine and dandy, NONE showed who funded the study. Admittedly, I didn't look at all of them so maybe you may have posted a study which listed it's funding source. As mentioned in my previous post: If you want to drink it, feel free. I really don't care.0 -
For me the carbonation has been a problem. I always had swollen feet and ankles and attributed it to being rather quite overweight and dealt with it. I only drank diet soda - nothing else ever. The amount of water I drank was what I put on my toothbrush to brush my teeth.
I gave up diet soda completely a week ago. My feet are actually skinny now and there's no more swelling in my ankles. It's not the sodium - I salt everything I eat. It's not the artificial sweetner - I'm drinking Crystal Light instead. I believe it's the carbonation that was causing the swelling.0 -
Diet sodas never actually made me gain weight, I am not even sure why some people say that, however, I have also been craving all the bad foods, and I have not been drinking anything but water! So, I am not sure if it is fair to blame the diet coke, but if you think it is a factor, give it up, no need loosing progress over an artificially sweetened beverage.
BTW- congrats on all of your success!!!0 -
The laws of the universe says its impossible to gain weight on a zero calorie drink. Furthermore it doesn't increase insulin nor blood glucose.
It can't cause weight gain.
That logic is 100% wrong. Just because something like diet soda doesn't DIRECTLY cause weight gain (it's zero calorie) doesn't mean it can't INDIRECTLY cause weight gain by stimulating some sensitive people to crave sweets.0 -
THIS. How does it MAKE YOU put on weight when it has no calories? Is the Diet Coke pushing you into the donut shop? Several CLINICAL PEER REVIEWED STUDIES have been done on diet soda causing cravings and it's all been in CORRELATION and not considered the CAUSE.I don't believe it makes you put on weight.
YOU make you put on weight. If you find yourself getting hungry straight after you have a diet coke, prepare for it and simply don't eat. It's just fake hunger (unless you truly have got an empty stomach) owing to the chemicals.
It's not very good for ya but it won't 'make' you put on weight.. it has no calories..
People put on weight because of over consumption. Learn to control your over consumption and it's not an issue. I've been drinking Diet Pepsi (as well as my parents have) for 30 years now.
A.C.E. Certified Personal/Group FitnessTrainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 28+ years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
LOL, how does gastric bypass make you lose weight if it doesn't cause you to burn any calories? It's all about affecting your appetite. You probably dont' want to hear that because you obviously like diet soda.0 -
The laws of the universe says its impossible to gain weight on a zero calorie drink. Furthermore it doesn't increase insulin nor blood glucose.
It can't cause weight gain.
That logic is 100% wrong. Just because something like diet soda doesn't DIRECTLY cause weight gain (it's zero calorie) doesn't mean it can't INDIRECTLY cause weight gain by stimulating some sensitive people to crave sweets.
That is a matter of opinion. My opinion is that the cause of the weight gain is the high calorie item you ingested after the diet soda, not the diet soda. You have a choice to overcome your cravings. If you are too weak willed to do that, for sure don't drink it. But don't pretend like it isn't a personal responsibility. French fries sitting on a table don't make you fat, eating a ton of french fries does.0 -
Did no one from the uk watch the secret eaters program?
1 guy used to drink alot of diet coke a day, probably about 2ltr as he was trying to lose weight, and what it does is, you think it supresses the urge for fizzy drink, but without the sugar intake. But it will make you want to eat more sugary foods as your taste buds are not getting that sweet taste and kick, so you will actually eat more! There is still alot of hidden sugars in diet coke as well.
No, there aren't any hidden sugars in diet coke.
I drank diet soda all through losing weight. At one time, I did think maybe diet soda was hindering my weight loss. So, I cut it out completely and everything else with artificial sweeteners. Nothing changed. My weight loss was still slow, my hunger was the same. I added soda back in, because I wanted it and continued to lose weight.
You control your weight loss.0 -
I was addicted to diet soda (any soda really) as well. I haven't had any soda in about a month now (although, I did have 1 or 2 cans on a day I was indulging but that didn't really "count".)
I agree, give them up! It sounds like you have already pretty much answered your own question.
For me, they made me thirstier - but I didn't want any stinkin water! Pffft, I wanted to drink the "tasty" stuff. Which starts the perpetual cycle you described. I also think that it messes with my skin and hair and how healthy it looks and feels. Plus, it adds to bloating...I think.
To transition, I switched over to drinking MIO in my water - now I am trying to switch from MIO to 75% water 25% MIO water.
*Edit - after a few weeks of no soda, when I did drink it...I wasn't as excited by the flavor. It didn't taste anywhere near as great. I probably will still drink other sodas (I still like Sierra Mist) but just in moderation.0 -
That logic is 100% wrong. Just because something like diet soda doesn't DIRECTLY cause weight gain (it's zero calorie) doesn't mean it can't INDIRECTLY cause weight gain by stimulating some sensitive people to crave sweets.
That is a matter of opinion. My opinion is that the cause of the weight gain is the high calorie item you ingested after the diet soda, not the diet soda. You have a choice to overcome your cravings. If you are too weak willed to do that, for sure don't drink it. But don't pretend like it isn't a personal responsibility. French fries sitting on a table don't make you fat, eating a ton of french fries does.
Well if you're the Iceman with your diet, and you never get bothered by cravings or over-eat, then congrats. You don't need a weight-loss website since you would have never gained weight nor had any difficulty losing it in the first place. However, for the rest of us mere mortals, food cravings can be an issue.0 -
No, but it makes me ridiculously bloated, which of course makes me look a hell of a lot fatter.
I used to drink a few cans a week to maybe one a day, but I only have it on occasion now. Once I cut right down on it, I noticed immediate reduction in the size of my stomach.0 -
What about the mio drops? They make water taste better.0
-
I adore diet coke and I used to drink it first thing in the morning and then at least 3 during the day.
I gave it up about a month ago. I still miss it. The first week without was horrible.
But now I do feel better (especially first thing in the morning) and I do notice that my cravings for sweets are reduced. Its easier for me to just eat yogurt or fruit than it was before, where I would make and eat muffins or cake.
And at the same time (coincidence or correlation or causation, not sure which) as giving up diet coke I am reducing my calories a couple hundred a day and being able to stick to it far better than I was before, when I was drinking the diet coke.
Good luck to you.0 -
That logic is 100% wrong. Just because something like diet soda doesn't DIRECTLY cause weight gain (it's zero calorie) doesn't mean it can't INDIRECTLY cause weight gain by stimulating some sensitive people to crave sweets.
That is a matter of opinion. My opinion is that the cause of the weight gain is the high calorie item you ingested after the diet soda, not the diet soda. You have a choice to overcome your cravings. If you are too weak willed to do that, for sure don't drink it. But don't pretend like it isn't a personal responsibility. French fries sitting on a table don't make you fat, eating a ton of french fries does.
Well if you're the Iceman with your diet, and you never get bothered by cravings or over-eat, then congrats. You don't need a weight-loss website since you would have never gained weight nor had any difficulty losing it in the first place. However, for the rest of us mere mortals, food cravings can be an issue.
I am the only person on the planet that has enough willpower to say no to a craving?
So long, suckers!
*uses super powers to fly off into the sunset*0 -
I agree with the poster who said "practice moderation".
Diet coke itself [and most diet fizzy drinks] have zero nutritional value. It shouldn't have any direct effect on weight either way... it's not going to help you lose or make you gain weight in itself, it will depend on what other calories you take in and what exercise you're undertaking to burn them.
I believe the often quoted addage that to lose weight you simply need to consume a percentage less calories than the calories your body has burned in a given time period.
Having said that, I'm not really a fizzy drink fan, prefer water still and generally flavoured.0 -
When ever I indulge in Diet coke it seems to increase my appetite for some reason.... Happens every time... Like it turns on the munchies....0
-
Since I've quit drinking it completely (about two weeks), I no longer have swelling in my ankles or feet and I rarely have headaches.Guess I just responded badly to it...it might also have to do with drinking much, much more water.
Do what works for you. It cannot, by itself, make you gain weight, but it does trigger cravings for some people.0 -
I definitely don't think diet soda has any direct effect on weight. However, it may increase sugar desire, which I've not only read about, but also experienced. And if there is one thing that gets in the way of dieting, it's those ridiculous sugar and high carb cravings.... so it may be a benefit to some, including myself, to avoid.0
-
There is alot of sodium..salt in diet drinks0
-
Lol, it's kinda tough to compare the 2 since smoking wasn't really "studied" during the time it was being endorsed. We have several peer reviewed clinical studies that debunk a lot of what is BELIEVED.One other thing to consider is smoking. For decades smoking was encouraged. Go back far enough and children smoked "to keep the cold out of their lungs"-that is fact- yes it was 100 years ago but its still fact. It was encouraged by doctors. Then 20 years ago Doctors and the government told you not to eat fat - now they tell you to take Omega 3 - because its not 100% one way or the other. If you look at the research on aspartame none of it tends to be far reaching - government tends not to fund this because people dont want real evidence to exclude this crap and kill a billion dollar industry. The industries certainly wont fund it. If your thinking you want to give it up then you should. What do you have to lose - worse case scenario your drinking water or some other low cal drink. I will say i do love all the experts who have all the 100% answers - if everybody had all this figured out already then why do they have tickers under their name with "XX number of pounds to lose"????
A.C.E. Certified Personal/Group FitnessTrainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 28+ years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition0 -
There's more in chicken breast. Just sayin'. And 70mg of sodium really isn't A LOT.There is alot of sodium..salt in diet drinks
A.C.E. Certified Personal/Group FitnessTrainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 28+ years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition0 -
There's more in chicken breast. Just sayin'. And 70mg of sodium really isn't A LOT.There is alot of sodium..salt in diet drinks
A.C.E. Certified Personal/Group FitnessTrainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 28+ years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
Its tiny. Anyway, if you train you want extra salts as ninerbuff would agree.
PLUS!
Watch this -
http://youtu.be/y1RXvBveht0?t=32m51s 0 -
I have lost over 50 lbs and I can honestly say while I'm not super proud of it I drink probably a bit too much diet soda. I have quit a few times and never felt less hungry or lost any weight. For me diet soda takes care of a craving and gives me some energy without the calories. Is it great for me? Probably not. But I'd rather drink a can of diet soda than eat a chocolate bar.0
-
Diet Coke / Coke Zero / Fake Sugar in general do not seem to have any negative effect on me in terms of my weight. I don't notice any weight gain or weird cravings as a result. Not saying they're good for me, but they're definitely not making me fat.0
-
There is alot of sodium..salt in diet drinks
12oz of diet pepsi has 35mg of salt0 -
On Friday, my massage therapist told me that aspartame causes belly fat (I drink 3-4 cans of Coke Zero a day). The belly is the only area I have left to lose fat, and it seems like it's going slow, so I googled it. Read an article on livestrong.com that confirmed what she said. As painful as it will be, I'm going to give up my beloved Coke Zero for the rest of the month and see what happens.0
-
Definitely does not make you put on weight - several years ago I lost 30kg in 6 months while drinking about 2 glasses a day. That said, I don't believe it is "good for you" - I believe I am quite addicted to it (could well be the sweeteners) & I suspect I may lose weight more easily if I didn't drink it at all. But I don't drink tea or coffee & I have 4 young children (including a baby) so I really need the caffeine!!!!!! I tried clean eating a few months ago & lasted about a week without it but unfortunately now I am back on it. I'd say if you can live without it, it's probably better.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.2K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 421 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions