Skip to content
  • Register
    • We are pleased to announce that as of March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor has been introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

    Favorite Peanut Butter

    13»

    Replies

    • Posts: 996 Member
      Pb2 chocolate! Haven't tried the regular yet but I'm hooked & won't change!

      I like the chocolate better than the regular. Regular is a little bland to me.


      Okay so it seems I need to spread my PB wings a bit and try some new kinds! Some of these sound delicious!
    • Posts: 44 Member
      Definitly my favorite peanut butter is Crazy Richards chunky all natural. Only ingredient is Peanuts. healthiest and best tasting ive found....
    • Posts: 194 Member
      PB2 is my new favorite, I also buy freshly ground at a small grocery store near me. Krema natural is good too, I use to buy that all the time.
    • Posts: 512 Member
      I love PB2 , just has a great flavor
      pb2.jpg
      I'm a pb addict. Where do you get this and what are the prices?
    • Posts: 137
      SMUCKER'S ALL NATURAL All the way!
    • Posts: 1,309 Member
      Earth Balance Coconut and Peanut Spread!
    • Posts: 32 Member
      Absolute favorite is Justin's Chocolate Hazelnut Butter. I get it at Target, it comes in a jar as well as squeeze packs (always keep a few in my purse :) ... the close seconds are PB & Co Dark Chocolate Dreams and Justin's Honey Peanut Butter.
    • Posts: 153 Member
      I still love Jiff creamy, I also love the Jiff Reduced Fat...and I use Great Value Natural so I like 3 of them but Jiff is the best IMO
    • Posts: 996 Member
      show previous quotes
      I'm a pb addict. Where do you get this and what are the prices?

      I bought it on amazon, but you can also buy here http://www.bellplantation.com/

      I think amazon is cheaper.
    • Posts: 1,157 Member
      I like which ever one is on sale...since it's almost to the price of gold now...
    • Posts: 126 Member
      Adams all natural hands down
    • Posts: 78 Member
      whole foods grind your own peanut butter
    • Posts: 4 Member
      Justin's Maple Almond Butter!
    • Posts: 290 Member
      Smucker's Natural Peanut Butter....Ingredients: Peanuts!!

      This. Why add oils & sugar?
    • Posts: 2,066 Member
      Adams.
    • Posts: 805 Member
      JIF Low sodium natural creamy peanut butter is my favorite.
    • Posts: 1
      Nothing better than creamy Jiff!!
    • Posts: 445 Member
      I put peanuts in the food processor til it is creamy....one ingredient, peanut butter shouldn't have all that sugar and stuff in it!
    • Posts: 183 Member
      I love PB2 , just has a great flavor
      pb2.jpg


      I have wanted to try this but can't find it locally. I found it on Amazon but I believe one has to be 8 or 12 jars. What if I don't like it? I LOVEEE pnut butter. So much that I can't keep it in the house. It's my weakness. I keep it at work. In the winter in a lunch bag in my car. I have some on a Joseph's flax wheat 1/2 pita and that "does" it for me. But if it was around in the evenings, I'd be over calories every day. Honest moment. :)

      I like Simple JIF when I can't get to Trader Joe's, etc.
    • Posts: 1,296 Member
      I love PB2 , just has a great flavor
      pb2.jpg

      This. Just tried Peanut Butter & Co and it was pretty good too.
    • Posts: 32 Member
      Dark Chocolate Dreams is my favorite with a crispy sliced apple! Cannot wait for those incredible Honey Crisp apples to come into season. They are the greatest!
    • Posts: 4
      I love the Private Selection chunky at Kroger - it's rich and has great texture! :)
    • Posts: 210 Member
      Currently digging Simply Jif. :)
    • Posts: 155
      Crazy Richard's Chunky or Creamy!!! SO good!!! Also Whole Foods ground peanut butter that you do right there is amazing!!!
    • Posts: 77 Member
      PB2!!
    • Posts: 77 Member
      show previous quotes


      I have wanted to try this but can't find it locally. I found it on Amazon but I believe one has to be 8 or 12 jars. What if I don't like it? I LOVEEE pnut butter. So much that I can't keep it in the house. It's my weakness. I keep it at work. In the winter in a lunch bag in my car. I have some on a Joseph's flax wheat 1/2 pita and that "does" it for me. But if it was around in the evenings, I'd be over calories every day. Honest moment. :)

      I like Simple JIF when I can't get to Trader Joe's, etc.


      I have a friend in Canada I told about this and he ordered 5 jars off the website, it was cheaper for him to buy off the site than it was for me to buy local from whole foods.
    • Posts: 32 Member
      Nothing but the best. Whole Earth it has to be.....

      ourRange-peanutButter.png

      Love the stuff. http://www.wholeearthfoods.com/products/1.html
    • Posts: 7
      i use to be all chunky peanut butter until i got skippy natural
    • Posts: 7
      Crazy Richard's PB... It's all natural with no additives and is super yummy
    • Posts: 44 Member
      Agreed 100%, didnt think anyone else ate crazy richards. Best hands down
    This discussion has been closed.

    Welcome!

    It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.
    Sign In
    Register

    Quick Links

    Categories