How to deal with weight loss advice you don't agree with?

A co-worker approached me this morning, and told me about something he had read this past weekend. Apparently I will get 'better' results if I limit my eating to only six hours a day. He said that humans previously only ate infrequently because food was hard to get (caveman days, apparently), and that we've grown accustomed to eating too much. All I would need to do is figure out which six hours I would eat, and then only drink water (I guess) the rest of the time. All I could say was "I don't agree with that", and fortunately, had to leave for a meeting.

I don't want to even get into a discussion with him about this, because he would get really defensive and spend hours researching to prove his case. It's really bothering me that maybe I could have handled it better, but would love to hear other thoughts about this. I really had to bite my tongue before I said the word "ridiculous". And no, he isn't just pulling my leg, I think he really believes it.

Ask him how long the average caveman lived, if he thinks that was a happy carefree life, and if he would bang a cave-woman.

Then walk away.

Brace yourself for the paleo fans!

Cavemen can't use the Internet, I'm not too worried about it.

A co-worker approached me this morning, and told me about something he had read this past weekend. Apparently I will get 'better' results if I limit my eating to only six hours a day. He said that humans previously only ate infrequently because food was hard to get (caveman days, apparently), and that we've grown accustomed to eating too much. All I would need to do is figure out which six hours I would eat, and then only drink water (I guess) the rest of the time. All I could say was "I don't agree with that", and fortunately, had to leave for a meeting.

I don't want to even get into a discussion with him about this, because he would get really defensive and spend hours researching to prove his case. It's really bothering me that maybe I could have handled it better, but would love to hear other thoughts about this. I really had to bite my tongue before I said the word "ridiculous". And no, he isn't just pulling my leg, I think he really believes it.

I hate going through this exchange with people also.

"You should eat X many meals a day."

"You should ONLY eat soup!"

"You should cut meat completely out of your diet."

"You should only eat meat."

"Only eat the items on this list... find a way to make the three items you are allowed to eat delicious and variable!"

"Eat nothing but salad, but don't put salad dressing on it!"

"Eat salad and put any dressing you want on it."

"Do the Subway diet!"

"Drink Slim Fast!"

"Put your underwear on backwards, hijack a plane to Ireland, steal a sheep, shave all of its wool, roll around in it and glue it to your face, then strip off all your clothes and dance naked on the 3rd Friday in July when the moon is full, but only if it's raining or you will have to turn around in a circle 15 times, cut off your pinky toe as a sacrifice to the sheep gods who will then judge you by the amount of fabulousness you were able to create with your recent woolybeard and if you pass their inspection, aliens will descend upon you and fly you to the moon where you'll be nearly weightless, but since your fat *kitten* is clearly not an astronaut you will be sucked into space never to be seen or heard from again, but hey! You'll be light as a feather for about 2 seconds!"

I've lost almost 40 lbs doing this diet and exercise the way that works for ME. I know what I am capable of doing. I know that I can't eat just one thing for the rest of my life. I know that if I even tried, eventually I'd have to work other foods in. Just being AWARE of what I am eating and how much of it has helped me immensely and most of the people who are giving me advice aren't doing anything about their own weight and don't really have a leg to stand on when it comes TO giving advice. Meh.