Help for 47 y/o woman

dovari4
dovari4 Posts: 3
edited December 2024 in Health and Weight Loss
I am in need of help. I have been gaining weight over the past 5 years. 20 pounds in the last 3 months! I have tried many different diets and find that when I lose some weight, I gain it back and then some. Blood tests show no problems with thyroid.
How many calories and how much excersize does it really take to lose weight? I weigh 230 pounds and am 5'7.
Is there anyone out there that can relate to my experience? Does anyone have some advice on what I can do?

Replies

  • popzork
    popzork Posts: 78 Member
    I can really relate! That was about the age that I stopped being able to lose weight. I did weight watchers and would lose about 10 pounds but then stop losing.

    I tried eating more, eating less, upping exercise, blood tests, eliminating processed foods, no alcohol, and about everything else you can think of.

    Ultimately, my journey took a couple of turns recently. I was talking to an expert (radio call in show) about people my age and not being able to lose weight. I asked what the key was for peri- and menopausal women. He said that the answer isn't one that most want to hear. He said you have to exercise 300 minutes a week now.

    I didn't want to believe it, but shortly after that, still seeking how much I should actually eat, since these website recommendations weren't working for me, I found a place that tested RMR. It's a breathing test. My theory was that the calorie recommendations were based on averages for our weight/sex/age, but something was off for me.

    I took the test and found out that I actually had a resting metobolic rate of 1022. The average for my age should be 1490. In order to lose weight I had to eat less that 1000 calories a day. I tried for 2 days, and instead chose to up my exercise instead.

    Since that time, I've lost 5.4 pounds in a month. It took me 4 months to lose 5 pounds before this.

    I hope this helps you. Not the answer you probably want, but it is my reality.
  • It is sooo nice to hear that someone can relate to my weightloss struggle!
    I do have admit that I did not want to hear that exsersize is the answer. How many caloires did you burn each day? How did you manage to eat less than 1000 calories a day? Did you just get used to it?
    I find that when I eat less in the daytime, I end up eating too much at night. Maybe excersize in the evening is the answer! LOL
  • needamulligan
    needamulligan Posts: 558 Member
    I can also relate. My thyroid tests came back normal for years but the weight kept piling on and my binge eating was out of control. I tried WW several times lost some gained more. MFP wasn't working for me initially either. I'd have some success, fall off the wagon, gain that weight back and more. Since June 2012, I seem to have managed to get my diet under control and the weight is starting to come off. I haven't felt out of control and haven't binged. I've been losing about 2.3 lbs/week. I don't know why but I'm happy to be in control. What seems to work for me is reducing carbs and sodium and eating more protein. Drinking lots and lots of water. Reducing processed food and virtually eliminating fast food. Everyone is different but alcohol and eating out do slow down my progress even when I allow for the calories. For me all calories are not created equal. White bread, white rice, pasta, processed food and even diet pop can make me feel out of control. I truly believe that there is some combination of carbs, sweets, sodium and fat that is addictive. So, I'm keeping an eye on all of those tasty things!

    I have a long way to go. I hope I can continue to feel in control. I have complete confidence that tracking everything and staying within the guidelines works. I know that my weight will fluctuate but will continue to go down. I've been entering the 5 week weight target MFP calculates for me in the notes for that day 5 weeks away. Guess what? Today, it said that I would weigh 259.2. My weight this morning was 259.5. Just stick with it. It works if you are patient and give it a real chance.
  • TheRealParisLove
    TheRealParisLove Posts: 1,907 Member
    I had the same problem. I also had to seriously increase exercise to make any headway. I also had to make some major changes in my eating habits, reducing sodium, increasing protein and seriously reducing grains and sugars. That was hard! I had to learn how to feed myself all over again.

    I had done the South Beach Diet back when it was really popular, and had to dig out that old book again to get back into the low carb groove. But that diet is still too high in fat and sodium, and really low in fiber, so I had to just learn how to plan my menus to fit in my macros.

    Planning is key. Plan your menus, plan your workouts in advance. That way you don't have to make yet another decision about your eating or exercise on top of all the stress day to day living makes on us.

    You may also want to get checked for sleeping problems. If you have sleep apnea, it will be next to impossible to lose weight until you get that issue resolved. That is like a catch 22, because the sleep apnea makes you gain weight, and extra weight causes sleep apnea.
  • pamperedpenguin
    pamperedpenguin Posts: 95 Member
    I too am 47 and although I'm doing more exercise then I have EVER done the weight is much slower to come off. I have come to be happy with a 1-2 lb. per week lose instead of the 5 lb I used to have when I was younger.

    I reduced carbs, sodium as well. I try to keep my fiber up with my food instead of taking a supplement. I plan my meals, sometimes a couple of days ahead, and I make sure to drink at least the 8 glasses of water a day.

    But I think the biggest thing for me was no more fast food. I allow myself 1 iced coffee from McDonald's once a week, plus it's a medium. I was drinking 2 large a day before. Plus since I was going to the drive thru I would always get something for my kids, which was hurting them, too.

    If I do eat out I make sure to pick restaurants that have their menu/nutritional info on line and I chose one that fits into my plan.

    Anyway, that's my 2 cents. Hope it helps :)
  • Gentyl
    Gentyl Posts: 184 Member
    Hi there! I can totally relate. I'm 45 and had been trying to lose weight for soooo long. Even with 1200 calories a day and moderate exercise, that scale would not budge after the initial 10 pounds or so. Recently, I was diagnosed with diabetes type II and put myself on the LCHF diet.. lots of proteins, and Very low carbs (emphasis and the miniscule amount of carbs--recommended less than 30 grams). My nutritionist hated it, but my doctors loved it. All of a sudden, I dropped 8 pounds in 2 weeks and the scale is still moving in the right direction. I never feel hungry, my blood sugars are fantastic.

    About the nutritionist.. she pitched a fit.. so for 2 days I went back on the high carb (165 to 175 mg of carbs) and felt all the fatigue return.. so back on LCHF for me, and I'm starting to feel great again. It's quite amazing.

    Just a note: I'm new at this, so I haven't hit 30 grams of carbs often. But, I'm a work in progress. :)
  • I am so grateful for all the advice and support!
    I do think that lowering my carbs will make a difference. I did lose weight 7 years ago with a low carb diet. It seems to be more difficult now. I want to find more food that offers a low carb option. I think that will help me stick with it.
    Ok, I guess I need to excersize more. This is what I have to do! I have to keep telling myself this.
    After reading your notes, I realized that you are all making this a lifetime diet. Slow and steady. Patience is key.
    Thank you again for your help!
  • QueenofScott
    QueenofScott Posts: 305 Member
    I can totally sympathize. I am 49, and have found that once I was about 45, losing weight became so much more difficult than it was before (and as an added "bonus" it comes on so much faster, as well). I, too, had my thyroid checked, as well as a bunch of other bloodwork. Everything came back normal,except for my cholesterol. It was high -230. While I was waiting on the loud work results to come back, I began to research diets. I settled on the South Beach diet, because it should help lower the cholesterol, AND it was supposed to help me kick my carb cravings. I was skeptical, but it has worked! I am no longer craving sugary treats, chips, bread, etc. I think that has been a major key for me. I started 5 1/2 weeks ago. As of Saturday, Sept 11, I have lost 11.2 pounds. Tha tis better than I have been able to do in the last several years, and I feel like I can stick to it. I really hope you can find just the right thing that works for you! Feel free to add me as a friend, if you like:)
This discussion has been closed.