Naturally thin people
Are there truly naturally thin people? I see some folks who seem to be able to eat whatever they want, whenever they want and don't appear to ever gain weight. I know they may or may not be healthy, but it's the weight thing I'm interested in. What is different in a thin person who doesn't seem to have to be aware of every portion and minute of exercise to maintain an acceptable weight, and a person like me, who needs to exercise good self control and motivation to prevent gaining? Would every person gain weight if they didn't practice this self-control? Do the 'naturally thin' people exercise portion control and motivation to exercise without even having to think about it? Are the obese (like me) just the humans for whom eating without paying attention results in weight gain?
Thoughts?
Thoughts?
0
Replies
-
My guess is that it boils down to genetics. i have a friend who can't gain weight to save his life. I'm sure if he ate nothing by junk food and never got off the couch he could put on some pounds, but he's juse one of the lucky folks with a really high metabolism.0
-
It can have loads of reasons. Genetics, fast metabolism, loads of activity etc.
I know a girl that is so thin that her doctor sent her to a dietician to gain weight, but no matter how much her dietician makes her eat, she can't gain weight at all.0 -
It can have loads of reasons. Genetics, fast metabolism, loads of activity etc.
I know a girl that is so thin that her doctor sent her to a dietician to gain weight, but no matter how much her dietician makes her eat, she can't gain weight at all.
My sister is like that. They're having a hard time getting her to gain weight even though she's 5 months pregnant. She's only put on 2 pounds so far.0 -
It's something I used to really struggle to understand when I was younger. It used to really upset me that some people could do whatever they wanted and never gained weight. But I suppose it's just one of those things. I'm always going to be pretty heavy I think, i'm never going to be 'skinny' But I will get down to what i'm comfortable with.
I almost feel sorry for them now. I can work at getting mt weight down, and manage it, but I know people (like my mum) who find it almost impossible to gain....0 -
My son is like that and I have no idea where he got it. Both my husband and myself have to watch absolutely everything we eat because it likes to stick around and stay. My son is a twig! No fair!!!0
-
My boyfriend is so thin it's unreal. If he turns sideways he disappears. He can eat and eat and eat and not put on anything. He doesn't do any form of exercise and sits on his *kitten* all day.
Apparently he has some thyroid thing, I don't know much about it but his metabolism is mega fast.0 -
My husband is thin as a rail and eats nearly constantly. I only have to look at food and it throws pounds on me. LOL.... not fair!0
-
2 Friends like that...Father and Son...Both eat like pigs and drink like fish...And haven`t any bodyfat between them..0
-
Here's a great documentary about it: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jPsKpnu0-X40
-
My mother in law is like that! All she eats is junk all day long and has a desk job plus all she does when she gets home is reads, knits, or plays on her laptop! No physical activity ever! She drinks Coke all day everyday and snacks on fruit loops! WTH!! lol! And she is tall and thin, while my father in law struggles to lose weight. Fortunately for my daughter, she has taken after her grandmother.0
-
I WISH0
-
Sure genetics play an important role, but I don't think anyone can just eat anything and everything they want and not gain weight. If you look at most of the people who you think have "good genes" or a "great metabolism," you'll often find that they don't eat so much, after all. Better food, smaller portions, etc.
Lots of people want to think they were just screwed at birth with bad genes, whereas their thin friend was blessed... And while in reality genes are obviously a factor, more important is what you put in your mouth, and how often you move your body.
--P0 -
yes there are naturally thin people, they are the ectomorphs of the world. we all fit into one of three general categories.
ectomorphs are naturally thin and have a hard time gaining weight. (marathon runners)
endomorphs are naturally large and have a hard time losing weight ( offensive line football players)
mesomorphs are those in the middle that can either gain or lose weight quickly ( this is the most coveted by me, the actors who can go from skinny to huge and ripped in a matter of a few months, like Hugh Jackman or Chris Hemsworth)0 -
.0
-
I was extremely thin (5'9" 110lbs) when I was younger despite eating an amount of food that would shame the average elephant, however, getting older and a more sedentary life has put me at more of a healthy weight (153.8 currently). I do log everything I eat, and I exercise a lot, but I still eat much more than all of my heavier friends who do no exercise. I don't know if it's just the movement that burns so much extra and enables me to eat more, or if it's just that I tend to eat more of what I consider "real" food. I have noticed my heavier friends tend to eat out frequently while I eat out only 2-3 times a month...and that they tend to eat much more processed foods...like 100 calorie packs of chips and cookies...or lunchables...or foods out of a box or can...and lots of soda or diet soda...my own eating habits tend to be more natural, fresh fruts and vegetables, whole grains (if you can cook it in less than an hour it probably isn't a whole grain), and I don't eat meat or animal products except seafood...so, I really don't know what the answer is...I don't think it's genetic, most of my family is overweight/obese and most of them were not when they were younger...but I see them eating a lot of processed foods and restaurant meals too, and almost no exercise...I really think everyone's best chance for health - including a healthy weight - is to be as active as possible and eat as naturally as possible...if you can pick it off a tree, dig it out of the ground, or it grows as part of a plant, then it's probably healthy to eat...otherwise I stay away from it.0
-
Personally I think, a lot goes back to how you grew up, foods you ate etc. I.e. chubby kids often have chubby parents. The type of foods you are used to are what you buy. and of course genetics play their part. Check what in your grocery trolley. Fresh unprocessed foods generally don't attract gst! Try to reduce your gst each time you shop. It is on the bottom of the docket.0
-
Most of the people on my mom's side of the family are naturally thin. They don't have to worry at all about food intake and exercising to stay thin. It's remarkable! Also not so good for me, who must've took after my dad's side. It's hard to be around people who enjoy food without a care.0
-
I think they tend to move more, eat slowly and frequently (which makes it look like they are always eating) and stop eating when they feel full, and they don't use food as an outlet for stress. At least that's true for me.
In fact, when I'm stressed, I lose my appetite. And I don't eat when I'm bored, I just get sleepy and nap instead. I'm actually infamous for being the last one done when eating a meal - in a restaurant I often have to have my leftovers packed to go, because I don't want to make everyone wait for me to finish and I don't want to stuff myself until I'm sick like some others do. I walk really fast and tend to be physically moving around as much as possible when working - slow walking/meandering irritates me. So maybe that's true for other people who tend to be "skinnier than average."0 -
My husband..well, I cant call him thin, cause he is well built ( 6.4 and 235lbs)..
I cant believe how much that man eats. He eats so much that years ago he decided to make that a hobbie, so he got into eating competitions. He has won the national perogie eating competition, ice cream and sausage competitions ( different years). I have seen that man eat so much food that its disgusting. Last week he started "training" again because he hasnt done any competetions in a while. The man had 7 hot dogs in a little over a min and then asked whats for dinner.0 -
yes there are naturally thin people, they are the ectomorphs of the world. we all fit into one of three general categories.
ectomorphs are naturally thin and have a hard time gaining weight. (marathon runners)
endomorphs are naturally large and have a hard time losing weight ( offensive line football players)
mesomorphs are those in the middle that can either gain or lose weight quickly ( this is the most coveted by me, the actors who can go from skinny to huge and ripped in a matter of a few months, like Hugh Jackman or Chris Hemsworth)
Crack is whack
So are somatotypes0 -
No but I wish I was one. Then I would be pretty all the time and wouldn't have to worry about getting fat.0
-
Look up horizon
Why are thin people not fat
It covers it pretty well but genetics is the main reason
Unlike fat people, some people have a fat limit. all fat people can loose weight. Not everyone can gain.0 -
My hubby is one of those naturally thin people. He doesn't watch what he eats, he doesn't exercise, and he's only 180, at 6'1" (and he's in his 40's, he's not some young fella). It's good genetics - his father was the same way.
It bodes well for our kids though - between me teaching them about eating well and those great genes, they should be golden.0 -
i would like to know the answer to that! i am not sure that it is genetics as stated before since i have struggled with being overweight most of my life, where my brother, is one that can eat whatever whenever and remain thin.0
-
I found this very interesting.
It's a part of a BBC documentary - two friends, one thin and one chubby who claim that it's their metabolism because the thin one eats much more than the chubby one, and they put it to the test and discover they were simply wrong.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eTr1JUvEiUU
People always claim I'm naturally thin but I don't think that's the case- I know I gain weight when I eat more. I'm just generally avoiding junk food, am vegan and pretty active person. I grew up in a house where we weren't allowed any fizzy drinks or juice and only one snack a day.
I always try claiming my boyfriend eats a lot and never gains weight but honestly, he doesn't eat enough for someone who's 6'4. I believe he might reach 2000 cals maybe once a week but most days it's fewer than that. I think he has this delusion that he eats so much because he sees what shorter people eat and has the sense that he's eating a normal amount while he should be eating more than they do.
I guess while there might be people like that, in most cases it's not really true. Well, that's my personal experience on the matter.0 -
They are probably skinny on the outside but have a lot of visceral fat on their internal organs, especially if they eat crap and don't exercise.0
-
There are also people who don't take any pleasure whatsoever in overeating... I know a few. And envy them0
-
I've got friends like that, who are really thin and do no exercise, and eat what they like.
As much as I'd like to be like that, I know that when I reach my goal I will not only be slim, but toned and healthy as well.
I'm hoping my children inherit my husband's fast metabolism though! Plus I will also ensure they are active and healthy. My 3 year old son is tall and skinny so far, but he doesn't eat much. My daughter is 16 months and eats well, but doesn't stop moving! I hope they stay this way!0 -
I used to think this as well . People will say " I'm naturally thin . I can eat whatever I want " but if you spend some time with them you will see they eat very small portions and eat very infrequently .0
-
There ARE naturally thin people. I have a good friend who is one. She's almost 30 and still a size 2 with a 34c chest. It's their genetics & metabolism. I found out I have an incredibly slow metabolism, so I have to make huge constant efforts in food and exercise just to NOT GAIN anything.
Here's my example that shows proof: She and I had a 5 day girls' trip together in San Diego. We ate the same things at restaurants (like literally I was watching the portions, and we were sharing large dishes & eating/drinking the same amounts), getting the same amount of treats. We did all the same activities: hiking, biking, beach, Magic Mountain walking all day, shopping, sightseeing, getting the same amount of rest, etc. At the end of the five days, she exclaims: "Oh wow, I've lost 3 pounds this trip, with all our walking around!" I checked my weight, and I'd GAINED 3 pounds. A SIX pound difference between us. Even if you expect slighly different food portions to have happened, there is no other way to account for a 21,000 calorie diference (3,500 a lb multiplied by 6 lbs), unless it's just her body burning it all off SO MUCH FASTER than mine, NATURALLY.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 430 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions