'Targeted' Fat Loss - Does It Work?

I mean if I were to focus on doing 100 squats a day would it make me lose weight in that area since I am working those specific muscles?

If not, then is the point of 'targeted' exercises only to gain strength/muscle mass in that area?

I'm so confused.

Replies

  • Help???
  • Acg67
    Acg67 Posts: 12,142 Member
    I mean if I were to focus on doing 100 squats a day would it make me lose weight in that area since I am working those specific muscles?

    If not, then is the point of 'targeted' exercises only to gain strength/muscle mass in that area?

    I'm so confused.

    You cannot spot reduce
  • TavistockToad
    TavistockToad Posts: 35,719 Member
    Nope!
  • I mean if I were to focus on doing 100 squats a day would it make me lose weight in that area since I am working those specific muscles?

    If not, then is the point of 'targeted' exercises only to gain strength/muscle mass in that area?

    I'm so confused.

    You cannot spot reduce

    Thanks! Then just do cardio to increase overall fat loss?
  • Lift_hard_eat_big
    Lift_hard_eat_big Posts: 2,278 Member
    I mean if I were to focus on doing 100 squats a day would it make me lose weight in that area since I am working those specific muscles?

    If not, then is the point of 'targeted' exercises only to gain strength/muscle mass in that area?

    I'm so confused.

    To strengthen that muscle and burn calories.
  • Nope!

    Can you explain a bit pretty please ?
  • jevoyager
    jevoyager Posts: 59 Member
    Nope, fat comes off where it wants to come off. Unfortunately :p I always loose in my face first, thighs last. Drives me nuts.
    Targeted exercises develop your muscles in those areas, which can result in a physique that looks better to you.

    Edited to add that its good to do both cardio and strength training, just doing cardio can result in fat AND muscle loss. Do both, that way you can burn fat, but work on muscle development with the strength training. Or just do strength training if you don't have all that much you need to loose, because you will burn fat doing it too though maybe not as much as with cardio (depends on what exercise you're doing and how much).
  • Acg67
    Acg67 Posts: 12,142 Member
    I mean if I were to focus on doing 100 squats a day would it make me lose weight in that area since I am working those specific muscles?

    If not, then is the point of 'targeted' exercises only to gain strength/muscle mass in that area?

    I'm so confused.

    You cannot spot reduce

    Thanks! Then just do cardio to increase overall fat loss?

    I'd focus on my diet before worrying about exercise selection


  • You cannot spot reduce

    Why not?
  • BRenkwell
    BRenkwell Posts: 30 Member


    You cannot spot reduce

    Why not?

    Because Biology.
  • californiagirl2012
    californiagirl2012 Posts: 2,625 Member
    I mean if I were to focus on doing 100 squats a day would it make me lose weight in that area since I am working those specific muscles?

    If not, then is the point of 'targeted' exercises only to gain strength/muscle mass in that area?

    I'm so confused.

    Nope that won't work.

    The only thing that drops fat is a calorie deficit. Exercise is for toning up the lean body mass only. You don't want to only exercise one muscle group because that will make you imbalanced. You want a full body workout for women, at least 3 days a week. Weight lifting will give you the most bang for your buck. This is what worked for me and I was quite successful --> http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/740340-i-lost-60-lbs-at-age-51-anyone-can-any-workout

    My shape dramatically improved by putting weight lifting first and cardio 2nd, as well as the calorie deficit.

    You can't out exercise too much food, and you can not control where the fat comes off. The body does it's thing with a calorie deficit. The only way for fat loss is a calorie deficit.
  • psuLemon
    psuLemon Posts: 38,431 MFP Moderator
    I mean if I were to focus on doing 100 squats a day would it make me lose weight in that area since I am working those specific muscles?

    If not, then is the point of 'targeted' exercises only to gain strength/muscle mass in that area?

    I'm so confused.

    You cannot spot reduce

    Thanks! Then just do cardio to increase overall fat loss?

    Weight training > HIIT > Cardio for fat loss. As acg said, diet is key for fat loss.


  • I'd focus on my diet before worrying about exercise selection

    Can you give me a rough break down of the kind of diet you would suggest for me? What percentage of carbohydrates, fats, and protein?

    I'm 24 years old
    5'7''
    33% body fat - I had this measured by a friend last night who is also a personal trainer
    workout 6 days a week, 3 strength training, 3 day cardio
    I work a desk job
    no medical problems
  • TavistockToad
    TavistockToad Posts: 35,719 Member
    Nope!

    Can you explain a bit pretty please ?

    Your question was does targeted fat loss work, and that was my answer!

  • Because Biology.

    That's really not my specialty, is it possible to explain it a little better so I could understand? If not I understand :)
  • Nope!

    Can you explain a bit pretty please ?

    Your question was does targeted fat loss work, and that was my answer!

    Yes and then I asked you a new question.


  • Nope that won't work.

    The only thing that drops fat is a calorie deficit. Exercise is for toning up the lean body mass only. You don't want to only exercise one muscle group because that will make you imbalanced. You want a full body workout for women, at least 3 days a week. Weight lifting will give you the most bang for your buck. This is what worked for me and I was quite successful --> http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/740340-i-lost-60-lbs-at-age-51-anyone-can-any-workout

    My shape dramatically improved by putting weight lifting first and cardio 2nd, as well as the calorie deficit.

    You can't out exercise too much food, and you can not control where the fat comes off. The body does it's thing with a calorie deficit. The only way for fat loss is a calorie deficit.

    OMG YOU ARE SUCH AN INSPIRATION! I WOULD KILL TO LOOK LIKE YOU!

    THANK YOU!
  • girlykate143
    girlykate143 Posts: 220 Member
    targeted fat loss is one of those myths that magazines use to sell you their mag. Your body doesn't work like that, plain and simple.
    If it were true, my mouth would be super skinny as would my entire neck and throat because my bf says I talk non-stop when I'm at home. Srsly.
    25% fat, 40% good carbs, 35% protein. Also, ask the personal trainer friend for help and explainers too.
  • TourThePast
    TourThePast Posts: 1,753 Member

    Because Biology.

    That's really not my specialty, is it possible to explain it a little better so I could understand? If not I understand :)
    You don't need to know how the biological mechanisms work, and if you do there are plenty of heavy textbooks you could study if you're actually interested in spending a chunk of your life understanding it.

    While it's interesting to know how an internal combustion engine and gearbox work, most learner drivers don't have a clue and this doesn't influence their driving technique in the slightest.

    You just need to know that there is no way for you to influence which parts of your body that fat disappears from.

    Not by exercise.

    Not by eating certain things.
  • astrampe
    astrampe Posts: 2,169 Member
    [

    Nope that won't work.

    The only thing that drops fat is a calorie deficit. Exercise is for toning up the lean body mass only. [/quote]

    As much as I have loads of respect for your achievements, this is just not true...

    You can use exercise to create a calorie deficit - and that helps you to not eat at such a huge deficit that you are constantly hungry and grumpy and weak....
    If I eat X amount of calories and not exercise, I will not lose weight. If I eat a litlle more than X amount and exercise, I will lose weight....The second one is much more fun - for weird people like me who loves both food and exercise....
  • myfitnessnmhoy
    myfitnessnmhoy Posts: 2,105 Member
    If not, then is the point of 'targeted' exercises only to gain strength/muscle mass in that area?

    Yes.

    Your body will lose fat where it loses fat, when it loses fat there. When your body calls on fat reserves for energy, it doesn't necessarily call on them from the same spot the energy is being used. There's a common myth that you are actually burning fat in a specific spot and somehow turning it into muscle when you exercise - if only that were true! In reality, you are creating a calorie deficit, your body draws on fat, muscle (bias toward unused muscle), organs, and whatever else it needs to help make up that deficit, and then it creates muscle in places where you are using it.

    The only way to lose fat in a specific spot is to lose fat everywhere until you lose it in the spot you want to lose it. For me, for example, it's the belly. Now 2 pounds overweight and a bit of a spare tire, that's me. Of course, a lot of that is because I'm losing fat and muscle at about the same ratio.

    The best way to burn energy and increase stamina is cardio.
    The best way to retain muscle is heavy lifting or high-intensity intermittent training and eating enough protein and nutrients.
    The best way to lose weight is to eat at a modest caloric deficit.

    So, it stands to reason that the best way to burn off FAT is to retain as much MUSCLE as possible while maintaining a calorie deficit but eating plenty of protein. You can use cardio to help create that deficit, but to retain muscle you have to lift - the heavier the better.

    So if you want to lose weight, increase cardiovascular capacity and stamina, and retain as much muscle as possible, you need a mix of cardio and lifting, a reasonable caloric deficit, and a diet rich in good quality proteins and all the vitamins and minerals you need. This is the optimal road to weight loss AND better health.

    If you just want to lose weight, and don't actually care about lean muscle mass (if you're OK looking good only when clothed), you can eat at a larger deficit with no exercise and/or do lots and lots of cardio as your only source of exercise. Trust me on this one - I haven't been doing the weights like I should and that's part of the reason my body fat percent is not changing and still a tad high even though my BMI is rapidly approaching normal. I'm not unhealthy by any stretch, but if I had put more emphasis and time into lifting, I'd probably have burned off more fat and have a little more 6-pack, a little less keg.
  • Wow. Thank you everybody!!!
  • TourThePast
    TourThePast Posts: 1,753 Member
    If not, then is the point of 'targeted' exercises only to gain strength/muscle mass in that area?

    Yes.

    Your body will lose fat where it loses fat, when it loses fat there. When your body calls on fat reserves for energy, it doesn't necessarily call on them from the same spot the energy is being used. There's a common myth that you are actually burning fat in a specific spot and somehow turning it into muscle when you exercise - if only that were true! In reality, you are creating a calorie deficit, your body draws on fat, muscle (bias toward unused muscle), organs, and whatever else it needs to help make up that deficit, and then it creates muscle in places where you are using it.

    The only way to lose fat in a specific spot is to lose fat everywhere until you lose it in the spot you want to lose it. For me, for example, it's the belly. Now 2 pounds overweight and a bit of a spare tire, that's me. Of course, a lot of that is because I'm losing fat and muscle at about the same ratio.

    The best way to burn energy and increase stamina is cardio.
    The best way to retain muscle is heavy lifting or high-intensity intermittent training and eating enough protein and nutrients.
    The best way to lose weight is to eat at a modest caloric deficit.

    So, it stands to reason that the best way to burn off FAT is to retain as much MUSCLE as possible while maintaining a calorie deficit but eating plenty of protein. You can use cardio to help create that deficit, but to retain muscle you have to lift - the heavier the better.

    So if you want to lose weight, increase cardiovascular capacity and stamina, and retain as much muscle as possible, you need a mix of cardio and lifting, a reasonable caloric deficit, and a diet rich in good quality proteins and all the vitamins and minerals you need. This is the optimal road to weight loss AND better health.

    If you just want to lose weight, and don't actually care about lean muscle mass (if you're OK looking good only when clothed), you can eat at a larger deficit with no exercise and/or do lots and lots of cardio as your only source of exercise. Trust me on this one - I haven't been doing the weights like I should and that's part of the reason my body fat percent is not changing and still a tad high even though my BMI is rapidly approaching normal. I'm not unhealthy by any stretch, but if I had put more emphasis and time into lifting, I'd probably have burned off more fat and have a little more 6-pack, a little less keg.
    Absolutely spot on!
  • heybales
    heybales Posts: 18,842 Member
    Can you give me a rough break down of the kind of diet you would suggest for me? What percentage of carbohydrates, fats, and protein?

    I'm 24 years old
    5'7''
    33% body fat - I had this measured by a friend last night who is also a personal trainer
    workout 6 days a week, 3 strength training, 3 day cardio
    I work a desk job
    no medical problems

    Well, the one stat you failed to mention, current weight. So adding 22 goal loss to a ideal goal weight of 135 is 157.

    If that exercise is about 1 hr daily then.
    2036 daily calorie burn for everything, weekly avg taken to daily avg.
    15% deficit appropriate for so little to lose.
    Eat 1730 each day, workout or not.

    If you actually miss a planned workout, skip 200 cal's that day. if you make it up, eat 200 more that day.

    And for your exercise, make the lifting heavier by making the cardio easier. If you press the cardio too intense on the between days, you won't get full benefit from the lifting on the other days.
    Since the lifting will get best results, more focus on that.

    Macros, keep it simple at 40/30/30 popular ratio.