Skip to content
  • Register
    • We are pleased to announce that as of March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor has been introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

    Reese's Pieces Protein Shake

    Posts: 40 Member
    edited January 2 in Recipes
    Okay, so I know what you're thinking... "Reese's Pieces? This is going to be PACKED full of calories."

    On the contrary. It's only 160cals for a little more than 8oz and has 17g of protein!

    Here's what you need:

    2 tbsp of PB2 (powdered peanut butter)
    1/2 scoop of chocolate protein powder (I use MyoFusion Milk Chocolate)
    1 cup of milk (I use almond breeze - vanilla, unsweetened almond milk)

    I like to blend mine with ice so that it's more like a milk shake but it tastes just as great without ice!

    Enjoy, it's the most amazing protein shake I've ever tasted!

    Welcome!

    It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.
    Sign In
    Register
    «13456

    Replies

    • Posts: 148 Member
      Can't wait to try it. Sounds amazing.
    • Posts: 165
      Sounds good!
    • Posts: 7,739 Member
      Reese's Pieces are my weakness. Next time I need protein powder, I'll try some chocolate.

      You may just be my new hero. :bigsmile:
    • Posts: 40 Member
      Hahahaha they're mine too!

      And YAY! I love being a hero! :D
    • Posts: 54 Member
      This is one of my favorite drinks, thanks for sharing!
    • Posts: 589 Member
      Yumm that sounds good!! I've never looked for PB2 before. Where would I find it? Would WalMart have it, maybe with their protein powders, etc., or is it more of a specialty store thing?
    • Posts: 571 Member
      Bump - I am drooling and can't wait to try! :laugh: Thanks for sharing!
    • Posts: 4
      I wasn't sure if I wanted to try the powdered peanut butter, but you have just given me incentive to try it. Thanks!
    • Posts: 450
      Thanks for sharing... gonna have to buy pb2. A friend also told me about Walden Farms peanut butter which has no calories or carbs.
    • Posts: 40 Member
      Yumm that sounds good!! I've never looked for PB2 before. Where would I find it? Would WalMart have it, maybe with their protein powders, etc., or is it more of a specialty store thing?

      I got mine at a specialty supplement store called "HeavyWeights Training Center". They sell all protein powder and the likes. I live in a small provincial town in Canada though, so they might sell it at Wal-mart in other places :)

      I just have to say, as a peanut butter addict, the powdered peanut butter has helped me reduce my calories by a landslide amount and it tastes amazing! :)
    • Posts: 589 Member
      show previous quotes

      I got mine at a specialty supplement store called "HeavyWeights Training Center". They sell all protein powder and the likes. I live in a small provincial town in Canada though, so they might sell it at Wal-mart in other places :)

      I just have to say, as a peanut butter addict, the powdered peanut butter has helped me reduce my calories by a landslide amount and it tastes amazing! :)

      I really like and have been using Jif Natural peanut butter, it's a 2 Tablespoon serving instead of 1 and less calories...though not as few calories as the PB2. I found it online at the GNC store near here. I can't wait to try it!
    • Posts: 49 Member
      Thanks for sharing... gonna have to buy pb2. A friend also told me about Walden Farms peanut butter which has no calories or carbs.



      The Walden Farms "PB" is literally the worst thing I've ever eaten. I would not even spend the money on it if i were you. Take my word for it.
    • Posts: 336 Member
      I don't really know much about protien shakes and other assorted things so maybe you can help if you don't mind. Lol :)

      1. Do you actually taste the powder in the drinks or does it dissolve to be like candy flavoured milk? 2. When are you supposed to drink them?

      Thanls for the help <3
    • Posts: 40 Member
      I don't really know much about protien shakes and other assorted things so maybe you can help if you don't mind. Lol :)

      1. Do you actually taste the powder in the drinks or does it dissolve to be like candy flavoured milk? 2. When are you supposed to drink them?

      Thanls for the help <3

      Sometimes protein powder has an awful after taste and is really lumpy but I find MyoFusion amazing. Try asking around a supplement shop on which is their best seller!

      I drink protein shakes in the morning, for lunch, and for dinner hahaha. I use them as meal replacements most times, it depends on the day. It's excellent to drink them 20-60 minutes after a work out as well. They help you gain and maintain muscle and keep you full longer. It helps your body continue metabolizing as well.
    • Posts: 2,080 Member
      Adding peanut butter and even bananas and fruit to protein shakes is pretty much common...love me some PNB...mmmmm...
    • Posts: 13,274 Member
      Ok, I feel just as fooled with this as I did with the so-called "roasted peanuts" protein bar I had this morning without a single damn peanut in it! What a bad day I'm having today! :sad:


      :laugh: :flowerforyou:
    • Posts: 168 Member
      Thanks! Will try this!
    • Posts: 583 Member
      OH THANK YOU!!!! :love:
    • Posts: 105 Member
      bump
    • Posts: 82 Member
      Bump
    • Posts: 91 Member
      bump
    • Posts: 8 Member
      Sounds yummy!
    • Posts: 721 Member
      OOOOHHH MY GOSH! That sounds delicious!! Thank you....xx
    • Posts: 268
      nom nom nom!
    • Posts: 49
      OMG sounds delish and wonderfully low cal I am going to have to find a source of PB2 in the UK or get a USA colleague to bring some over for me!

      UPDATE YAY it is available on Amazon UK - guess what I am going to do next LOL
    • Posts: 95 Member
      There are some already flavored ones out there that are really good. I'm drinking a peanut butter cup one that is legit! They used to suck but they have come a long way.:drinker:
    • Posts: 128
      bump!
    • Posts: 2,080 Member
      Ok, I feel just as fooled with this as I did with the so-called "roasted peanuts" protein bar I had this morning without a single damn peanut in it! What a bad day I'm having today! :sad:


      :laugh: :flowerforyou:

      HA! Yep, just flavouring...have a teaspoon of it when you fancy, I eat it straight out of the jar usually...sorry OP, the recipe is fabby, just meandering a bit here ; )
    • Posts: 148 Member
      Looks great - I think I should track down some PB2 and bring protein shakes back into my diet...
    • Posts: 267 Member
      This sounds yummy!
    This discussion has been closed.

    Welcome!

    It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.
    Sign In
    Register

    Quick Links

    Categories