Knee Issues
WRXymama
Posts: 342 Member
My excercise of choice is running (C2 5k Week 7 day 3). While I'm running, my knees cause me no discomfort...in fact, I feel great! It's when I DON'T run, they ache. My left knee in particular feels as though it's going to give out when I go down the steps....a sever shooting pain through my knee. I'm having more knee issues than I did when 44+ lbs where on them. Has anyone else had something similar happen? I know it sounds a little crazy. Or would anyone recommend adding a brace to my knee while I'm running? Next step will be the Dr's, but would like to do a home fix/try prior to doing so. Thanks everyone!
0
Replies
-
My excercise of choice is running (C2 5k Week 7 day 3). While I'm running, my knees cause me no discomfort...in fact, I feel great! It's when I DON'T run, they ache. My left knee in particular feels as though it's going to give out when I go down the steps....a sever shooting pain through my knee. I'm having more knee issues than I did when 44+ lbs where on them. Has anyone else had something similar happen? I know it sounds a little crazy. Or would anyone recommend adding a brace to my knee while I'm running? Next step will be the Dr's, but would like to do a home fix/try prior to doing so. Thanks everyone!
SQUATS!0 -
I may have to youtube proper form on them. I had a knee injury while in roller derby, but my knee issues aren't even with THAT knee. I'm guessing they'll help my bootay too?0
-
Plus the crunching sounds in my knees are like nails on the chalkboard....getting old's a b*tch! LOL0
-
Plus the crunching sounds in my knees are like nails on the chalkboard....getting old's a b*tch! LOL
I have this crunching/grinding sound in my right knee! I thought it would get better as I lost weight, but it is getting louder! It isn't painful when it crunches, but I do have more soreness/tenderness during regular activities than I ever did when I wasn't exercising.
I'm looking forward to reading the responses you get here. I have read on MFP that Magnesium supplements are good for joint pain, but I haven't tried this.0 -
You could try Glucosamine I was very sceptical but it worked for me it is not an instant fix you need to take it for several weeks to get the benefit and then just keep taking it. recommended dose is 3 tablets a day but I am still only on 1.
This does not help with running but move over to cycling as it is none load bearing, helped me.0 -
I'll have to give suppliments as well as squats a go. Bike isn't an option, as I was given a treadmill, so that's my source of excercise...although Jillian Michaels and/or Heat Yoga will be added into the mix in the somewhat near-ish future.0
-
put an abs ball behind you and do squats that way - take it from someone who has bad knees and runs as well. right acl was replaced in 2000. yes squats will help strengthen your knees but incorrectly done and they will make your knees worse. make sure you haven't injured yourself first so visit your doctor.0
-
Where is the pain in your knee?
I am in the middle of physio treatments for what started out as a minor ache/disturbance just below my right knee, towards the inside. I took a couple of days off (I too am working through the C25K program) and my knee kept getting worse to the point that I could hardly walk.
Turns out I sprained my MCL. The physio said there was no tear, and has given me some exercises to start regaining strength and movement, and he told me to wear a slip on tensor "brace" anytime I'm on my feet. I started wearing it on Saturday and it helps immensly.
I would suggest talking to a doctor or physiotherapist about the joint first, and they will be able to give you some great exercises and support so that you can heal, strengthen and keep on running.0 -
I second the glucosamine and squats advice. I'll typically stretch a bit AFTER I run, but not before and it has made a difference for me.0
-
I would suggest talking to a doctor or physiotherapist about the joint first, and they will be able to give you some great exercises and support so that you can heal, strengthen and keep on running.
^^This.0 -
I have similar pain - but it is more along the muscle on the inside of my calf - and have been told squats and glucosamine.
I graduated c25k a few weeks back and have been running 3 miles a few times a week and just seems to be getting worse.
Hopefully all will feel well for my first official run on Thanksgiving morning. Would be a major bummer to do all of that training then miss the race.
Hope things start to improve for you!0 -
My left knee in particular feels as though it's going to give out when I go down the steps....a sever shooting pain through my knee.
<snip>
Next step will be the Dr's, but would like to do a home fix/try prior to doing so. Thanks everyone!
I wouldn't try the squats until you've seen the doctor. The shooting pain/giving out might possibly be a meniscus tear, among other possibilities, and squats could make it worse. The crunching sounds may indicate a problem with the articular cartilage under the kneecap.
If you want to do something at home, start with quad sets and straight leg raises. Those help strengthen the quadriceps muscles as well.0 -
omega 3 oil, glucosamine, blueberries & squats
0 -
My left knee in particular feels as though it's going to give out when I go down the steps....a sever shooting pain through my knee.
<snip>
Next step will be the Dr's, but would like to do a home fix/try prior to doing so. Thanks everyone!
I wouldn't try the squats until you've seen the doctor. The shooting pain/giving out might possibly be a meniscus tear, among other possibilities, and squats could make it worse. The crunching sounds may indicate a problem with the articular cartilage under the kneecap.
If you want to do something at home, start with quad sets and straight leg raises. Those help strengthen the quadriceps muscles as well.
most doctors will tell you not to do squats but my knees are 100% better since doing them - hardly a twinge now. you can always stop if you feel any pain.0 -
Thanks all so much!!!!0
-
Acupuncture and a less knee pounding exercise like elliptical training or rowing.0
-
There are certain knee injuries that will not heal on their own. If you don't see improvement in a few months you should go see the doctor.
I don't recommend doing squats with additional weight; just use your own body weight.
I can feel your pain though; I've had bad knees since highschool and I just had a flairup from going too hard too soon. It really sucks to be slowed down by knee injuries, but you don't want to do something that will make it worse. Another exercise recommended after knee surgury is to lay down and do sets of locking our your knee against the bed. I hope the whole thing clears up quickly for you. I personally dread another knee surgury.0 -
Someone else mentioned possible meniscus tear, and having read your description, I'm concerned. I also had one of those, and unless it's small and on the outer edge where there is bloodflow, it won't just heal. And no amount of strength training or supplements will fix the issue. If you don't want to see a doctor right now, at least google meniscus tears and look for some descriptions of tests you can do that are indicators that might be the issue.
Personally, i think it's worth the doctor visit given what you described.0 -
I had the same thing. On and off for months. Would appear, then go away. Get bad. Go away. One day I woke with my knee completely swollen, unable to put any pressure on it whatsoever. Went to the hospital with excruciating pain.
Turned out, I have a complex medial tear in my left meniscus. And I need surgery (happening next week).
DO NOT think that a simple ache that comes and goes is normal. I did and had I went to my dr. sooner, I wouldn't need surgery.0 -
I'd definitely say go to the doc. I avoided it for awhile and was so pumped when he gave me some practical tips to improve my knees/legs for running. It helps that he is a sports medicine doc as well as a distance runner. Thanks to him, I completely overhauled my running form, added excellent stretches and strength activities, dropped ALL knee pain, understood the pain of tendonitis in my shins/thighs, AND ran the half marathon faster than he did!!! LOL
In all seriousness, I'd say give the doctor a chance to help you improve before you are in a Lot of pain that may not be easily fixed!!0 -
Here are the basics of joint care:
- Strength such as squats, lunges and leg lifts. (If you have pain, wait until you are pain free)
- Stretching and warm ups are a must.
- For some it is hydration. Make sure you drink your water.
- Electrolytes. Most of us get plenty of sodium, but potassium is part of the muscular process. Bananas are top of the list, but there are others. You can Google "foods with potassium."
- Cartilage issues. As people age, the soft tissue gets less supple. I use Chondroitin/Glucosamine. I understand that it only works for about 30% of those the use it. Fish oil is also on the joint care list.
- Something that also helps me is a chiropractic technique called ART Active Release Technique. You can find a local practitioner by Googling "Active Release Technique".
That is what works for me. I will add that I also had surgery. I doubt that it could have been avoided. It was a meniscal tear.0 -
google or youtube IT Band stretches. it needs more stretching.0
-
I was told after my knee surgery years ago that the reason women have the grinding sound in their knees is because our knee caps are smaller than mens. But I do feel your pain on this subject, I want to run a marathon one day but my knees make it very difficult to do so. But I refuse to give up! I am just starting back to the gym after a year off again because of another knee injury, a torn meniscus this time. I am using the Couch to 5k app, so we'll see how I do this time around, good luck to you!0
-
I'd see a Dr. now, so you know what is going on first. Sooo many different things could be going on with it and you don't want to have an injury sideline you for a long time. They may have some ideas on how to keep from injuring it further.
I have had knee issues myself (pain and crunching) and took someone's advice to bike to make the muscles around my knee stronger to help support it. It def. worked because now that I'm just running and not biking anymore, the knee pain is back. I'm 51 and I don't want to run to the Dr. everytime I feel pain, but I may go if it doesn't let up.
Good luck and I pray you're pain free soon!0 -
I wouldnt put a brace on your knee until after you see a doctor - different braces are for different reasons, and can do way more harm than good. Plus, most doctors prefer you not wear a brace because it prevents building up and relying on your own muscles. I've had four knee surgeries, including a patella realignment, and I still run. The best thing you can do when you experience knee pain is to rest, ice, and see a doctor.0
-
There are certain knee injuries that will not heal on their own. If you don't see improvement in a few months you should go see the doctor.
^^THIS!!! (but I would not wait months...perhaps a week at most)
I have a meniscus tear in my left knee, and ACL in my right. Grinding noises, pain, and swelling is your body's way of saying STOP and go see a doctor!! You could make it worse if you don't. Meantime, wear a knee brace, ice it, and take glucosamine.0 -
Same issues - worn cartilage, arthritis - orthopedic Dr. and Physical Theraprist said no running!!!! Elliptical and swimming only. Will damage knees more with running0
-
Hi, I have slight pain as well in my knees but like you it seems to be fine when I jog. I make sure to always jog with braces on. I bought some Ace black 3 strap velcro ones at walmart and I find they help with supporting my knees when jogging. This works for me. My knees still have little pain when not jogging only when doing stairs and squats but they don't ache like they used to.
Just to let you know I am not an athlete or an expert but just thought I would tell you what has worked for me. I only jog max 2 miles 2-3 x a week at a somewhat slow pace. Good luck WRXYMOM (I love that name and cute Rexy. Been a Subaru fan for many years) :happy:0 -
run on the other side of the road if you run on the road or pavement0
-
Plus the crunching sounds in my knees are like nails on the chalkboard....getting old's a b*tch! LOL
I have this crunching/grinding sound in my right knee! I thought it would get better as I lost weight, but it is getting louder! It isn't painful when it crunches, but I do have more soreness/tenderness during regular activities than I ever did when I wasn't exercising.
I'm looking forward to reading the responses you get here. I have read on MFP that Magnesium supplements are good for joint pain, but I haven't tried this.
Its Called Crepitus - I have it
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crepitus0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions