Calorie Deficit and Getting Sick!
firstsip
Posts: 8,399 Member
So, I know it's that time of year where everyone and their mother is getting sick anyway...
But I've been sick THREE times since October, which is super unusual for me (years of working with kids has made my immune system that of a robot's).
I've read that extended periods of eating at a deficit contributes to lowered immunity, so I'm wondering... does anyone else find they're getting sicker more often?
I'll obviously eat more when I'm sick (if I can force it down/not throw it up), but boy, am I sick of getting sick.
But I've been sick THREE times since October, which is super unusual for me (years of working with kids has made my immune system that of a robot's).
I've read that extended periods of eating at a deficit contributes to lowered immunity, so I'm wondering... does anyone else find they're getting sicker more often?
I'll obviously eat more when I'm sick (if I can force it down/not throw it up), but boy, am I sick of getting sick.
0
Replies
-
I went through this during my first round of weight-loss. I was eating about 1,400-1,500 calories per day and I would get sick once every 5 weeks. It was crazy. I found that when I started eating at maintenance calories I didn't get sick as often. It was very strange....0
-
When I am sick which isn't often I usually up my water intake and make sure I get lots of rest.
Sometimes you just need to make sure you get complety rested and don't push to hard for a few days after.When you feel strong again get back at it. Rest is really important.
I hope you are feeling better soon.0 -
Are you exercising when you aren't sick? I had one truly heinous cold this year (it went around the office) but have been fine otherwise, despite taking public transportation and being around sick people. I read years ago that since your body temperature is raised a tiny bit during exercise, if you are regularly exercising then your immunity becomes better because the temperature raise kills germs during that time (but it has to be regular exercise). No clue if it's true but I think I get sick less when I exercise.0
-
Hi firstsip. Are you taking a multi-vitamin or other supplements like vitamin C or B complex? Also do you know if your vitamin D level is low - common this time of year when people stay inside a lot.
This can be a problem when reducing caloric intake because reduction in foods, and some types of foods, may be reducing the amount of vitamins and nutrients you are getting. Also if you are limiting some foods like red meat, this can get in the way of absorbing iron, which for women is very important to not become anemic.
Just some things to consider. I hope you get to feeling better very soon. :-)0 -
I found since I have been in school and not around people at work I have getting less sick in the year but I tried to get sick on my birthday which was the 22nd of nov what a bummer. I took some of walmarts equate cold and cough and it cleared me up the next day . I am sure what you are fighting is the weather changing periodically depending on where you are. Try taking some Echinacea & ginsing bottles from GNC.0
-
Maybe just a run of bad luck? I was at a deficit for three months to lose my 15 pounds and have never been healthier. I make sure to be getting all the stuff my body needs, lots of variety and nutrients and water and exercise.0
-
Haha, thanks guys! I guess I intended this thread to be more of a "YEAH THIS SUCKS," but I appreciate all the advice!
I take an iron pill, a B vitamin, AND Vitamin D/Omega 3 regularly, drink plenty of water, and have tried the "exercise even though you're starting to feel sick" thing (which has always backfired for me x_x).
It definitely makes sense you'd get sicker less often eating at maintenance calories, because your body's got much more fuel to fight off things (plus, eating at a prolonged deficit can raise cortisol, which definitely lowers your immune system)!
My deficit, however, has been since January, so... :X0 -
I had this at the beginning of the year, something like six colds in five months - it got so bad I lost count. It may have been due to eating at a deficit - I've also read that your immune system is weaker if eating at a deficit. It wasn't a huge deficit - I was eating around 1500 Cals including exercise Cals - which is fine for me as I'm very short. I couldn't see what to do about it though - I ate at maintenance when I was sick and dropped the Cals again each time I got better, but there was no way I was going to give up on counting my Calories, and working on shifting the weight so I battled on through and have been fine all all summer. I'll see what happens now that the cold and flu season is back again.0
-
Could it be that your getting sick because your body is (in effect) detoxifying? Once when I did a liquid detox program, my body detoxed alright - and all that crud being released from my blood and organs gave me a lovely little rash. Finally got me to the dermatologist, who basically told me to be kinder to my body in the future. LOL0
-
This could be just a coincidence. Here in WI due to the warmer weather it is like a breeding ground for germs. There is something running rampant through our office. I usually catch a cold but this year ended up with severe sinitus. Took two rounds of heavy duty antibiotics to get rid of it (just finished them on Thanksgiving) and I am still trying to get my exercise level back up.
FYI - If it is above the neck, they recommend you do not exercise. I was forbidden from exercising until I was better.0 -
you have to take your vitamins it will help you not get sick.
I have been sick a lot lately but I associate it with the ever changing warm to cold temperatures and my Doctor does as well.0 -
I've recently had a bad cold and struggled to stick to a 2lbs a week deficit so I've lessened it to 1.5lbs per week and I feel a lot healthier and less stressed on it. I did wonder whether I was doing the right thing but I have another year of this ahead of me and I lose calories whenever my weight drops and I've got to be able to do it healthily so I think it was the right thing for me.
I also suffer with patches of alopecia and was worried that may have been worsening so this way I can incorporate more fruit and protein to help keep my iron levels up.0 -
I take an iron pill, a B vitamin, AND Vitamin D/Omega 3 regularly, drink plenty of water, and have tried the "exercise even though you're starting to feel sick" thing (which has always backfired for me x_x).
Forget about the vitamins that have no proof or science they work for your immune system. How are you doing at eating 9-13 servings of raw fruits and vegetables each day?
Over 4000 clinical studies show that eating the daily recommended amount of raw fruits and vegetables will lower the risk of chronic illness (cancer, heart disease, diabetes etc...) and deliver the vitamins and minerals your body needs daily. Medical science reminds us every day that good nutrition and good health go hand in hand.0 -
I take an iron pill, a B vitamin, AND Vitamin D/Omega 3 regularly, drink plenty of water, and have tried the "exercise even though you're starting to feel sick" thing (which has always backfired for me x_x).
Forget about the vitamins that have no proof or science they work for your immune system. How are you doing at eating 9-13 servings of raw fruits and vegetables each day?
Over 4000 clinical studies show that eating the daily recommended amount of raw fruits and vegetables will lower the risk of chronic illness (cancer, heart disease, diabetes etc...) and deliver the vitamins and minerals your body needs daily. Medical science reminds us every day that good nutrition and good health go hand in hand.
You're right, my endocrinologist ordering me to take a vitamin D pill because I lack a thyroid, and my gynecologist recommending the iron pill that comes with my BC because I bleed out a week every month... I'll stop listening to them!0 -
I have only gotten really sick once since I started working out. I get a little sniffly here and there or maybe a 1 day bug but nothing serious. I got bronchitis in September but that's been it. I've been working out an hour or so 6 days a week since last spring. That may be helping. I did work in retail for 14 years before this job (2 years now). I got sick constantly there. Maybe my immune system was built up from that and just now started going down.0
-
I take an iron pill, a B vitamin, AND Vitamin D/Omega 3 regularly, drink plenty of water, and have tried the "exercise even though you're starting to feel sick" thing (which has always backfired for me x_x).
Forget about the vitamins that have no proof or science they work for your immune system. How are you doing at eating 9-13 servings of raw fruits and vegetables each day?
Over 4000 clinical studies show that eating the daily recommended amount of raw fruits and vegetables will lower the risk of chronic illness (cancer, heart disease, diabetes etc...) and deliver the vitamins and minerals your body needs daily. Medical science reminds us every day that good nutrition and good health go hand in hand.
You're right, my endocrinologist ordering me to take a vitamin D pill because I lack a thyroid, and my gynecologist recommending the iron pill that comes with my BC because I bleed out a week every month... I'll stop listening to them!
Ever thought about questioning that and doing your own research and not just taking the word of your endocrinologist and gynecologist who receive very little education on nutrition in their degree? Ever thought of consuming whole foods that provide those same vitamins, enzymes, and minerals your body needs to balance your immune system? By the way I too do not have a Thyroid.0 -
How big of a deficit are you eating at... and maybe you're not getting enough of your vitamins you need to support your immune system? Might want to look into some blood work to see if you are lacking in anything. Definietly get some veggies and fruits in your system (especially citrus fruits!) drink some hot green tea and honey too.
0 -
I take an iron pill, a B vitamin, AND Vitamin D/Omega 3 regularly, drink plenty of water, and have tried the "exercise even though you're starting to feel sick" thing (which has always backfired for me x_x).
Forget about the vitamins that have no proof or science they work for your immune system. How are you doing at eating 9-13 servings of raw fruits and vegetables each day?
Over 4000 clinical studies show that eating the daily recommended amount of raw fruits and vegetables will lower the risk of chronic illness (cancer, heart disease, diabetes etc...) and deliver the vitamins and minerals your body needs daily. Medical science reminds us every day that good nutrition and good health go hand in hand.
You're right, my endocrinologist ordering me to take a vitamin D pill because I lack a thyroid, and my gynecologist recommending the iron pill that comes with my BC because I bleed out a week every month... I'll stop listening to them!
Ever thought about questioning that and doing your own research and not just taking the word of your endocrinologist and gynecologist who receive very little education on nutrition in their degree? Ever thought of consuming whole foods that provide those same vitamins, enzymes, and minerals your body needs to balance your immune system? By the way I too do not have a Thyroid.
Lol you're funny.
Edit: To elaborate, since I don't feel like dealing with you again and am bummed you somehow found a way into this thread...
You are willfully ignoring countless studies to focus on others. You foolishly ask, "Ever thought about doing your own research" of someone who does research for a living. You say, "There's no evidence for vitamins" when there's TONS of verified and valid research for their benefit. I've read the tons of research that says micronutrients are better absorbed through eating actual foods... just like I've read the tons of research saying micronutrients are better absorbed cooked... or raw!
The thing about research is that there is always more and more of it, and science is always working towards a more precise understanding of why things are the way they are.
In the meantime, the studies saying, "Hey, if it's difficult to get a., b., and c. in your diet, taking certain vitamins is better than none at all" hold up, and your comments don't play any relevancy in a thread where, I've taken vitamins all along, but only with a recently low calorie diet have I had issues with immunity.
So, girl bai.0 -
I don't know how what your normally eat, but by the couple days I did see in your food diary it looks like you are not eating fruits and vegetables. Remember to be sure to get your vitamins and minerals every day, fruits and veggies are the best source, plus you can eat tons of veggies because they are low in calories, win/win situation. Good luck!0
-
I don't know how what your normally eat, but by the couple days I did see in your food diary it looks like you are not eating fruits and vegetables. Remember to be sure to get your vitamins and minerals every day, fruits and veggies are the best source, plus you can eat tons of veggies because they are low in calories, win/win situation. Good luck!
...You mean the days that nothing's tracked because I was out of town?
Lol, this thread has gone nowhere fast.0 -
Yes a lot of these threads never go the way the author intends them to. However I will answer your only question: No I never got sick while eating at a deficit because I was consuming mostly raw fruits and veggies which strenthened my immune system! ; )
I would also love to see where this "tons of" independent 3rd party clinical research studies published in peer reviewed journals on the product (vitamin or supplement) as a whole is.0 -
They have found most of us lack enough sunshine - thus the vitamin D
Bleeding out -- iron so you are not anemic -
Why would you stop doing what your physician suggests because of folks on a thread --
And if you have a thyroid condition you are probably also taking something for your thyroid -
Suggestion -- talk the illness thing over with your physician or non-physician practitioner --- or whatever practitioner you believe in - my guess they know more than those of us on the threads --
Good luck --- and have a wonderful day0 -
ure profile says beer. are u drinking when ure in your deficit? and if so how do u stay within your deficit when beer is full of calories? do u replace food with beer?0
-
No I have never been sick yet but I ate very healthfully, didn't drink and took a couple of vitamins.0
-
ure profile says beer. are u drinking when ure in your deficit? and if so how do u stay within your deficit when beer is full of calories? do u replace food with beer?
Looooooooooooooooooool. I attracted the worst people for this thread.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions