Ketogenic Diet
MizManda180
Posts: 68 Member
I have been hearing a lot about this ketogenic diet. How does it work and does it really help you burn fat quicker?
0
Replies
-
you cut your carbs to low levels i eat about 20-30 grams of carbs and more protein ,some people lose about 4 or 5 lbs a week0
-
F##K KETO its a fad!0
-
And exceedingly dangerous!0
-
F##K KETO its a fad!
yep.0 -
I have been hearing a lot about this ketogenic diet. How does it work and does it really help you burn fat quicker?
It works by changing your metabolism to primarily burn a fat/ketone mixture instead of dietary glucose (i.e. wot comes from carbohydrate).
WIll it burn fat *significantly* quicker in the long term? No.
Because the body will adjust to the new fuel mix so ...
Can you put weight on doing it? Yes, of course.
I've done it, took liberties with the calories and put weight on. I kind of bought into the whole carbs/insulin/fat thing ...
Going generally low carb helped me to recalibrate my sense of appetite and 'sweet tooth' but going into ketosis wasn't necessary or desirable for me. No metabolic advantage, might as well work an occasional mince pie into the plan eh?
Lyle McDonald's site is worth a read if your interested, he did a couple of books on ketogenic dieting but concedes they don't work any better for fat loss than other plans that restrict calories:
http://www.bodyrecomposition.com/
It was an interesting experiment but I'm back to moderation in all things right now.0 -
Big fan of Lyle McDonald.
I do not believe there is any reason for anyone who is not very lean already to go on something as extreme as a keto diet. (And the way Lyle plans it there are strategic refeeds based on BF% not indefinite low carb)
The primary reason a lot of people will do well on keto diets is that it forces them to stop eating a lot of processed foods which are very easy to overeat (and hence over consume cals) and forces them to rely more on protein intake. I haven't heard of too many people going on chicken/steak binges compared to donuts & icecream :laugh:0 -
I have been hearing a lot about this ketogenic diet. How does it work and does it really help you burn fat quicker?
It works as has been described above - typically no more than 20-30g of carbohydrates a day. It's just considered a very-low-carbohydrate diet. The good thing I find about ketosis is that you can cut calories without getting hungry... well... at all!
Whether it burns fat faster than other diets is not something I can answer - but I feel like it works for me quite well.
The only negative side effect I find is the smell of acetone on your breath! Carry some chewing gum!And exceedingly dangerous!
Not just dangerous, but *exceedingly* dangerous??
Would you care to tell us why it's dangerous?0 -
I've run a cyclical ketogenic diet a few different times for cutting. I like it because I don't feel as hungry with all of the fat in the diet. I have found it more convenient to count calories as well for two reasons. 1) More of my meals are simpler and easy to judge calorie content. 2) Because I fill up on fats, my meals tend to be smaller and more spread out.
A ketogenic diet is something you want to get right. If you don't have your macronutrients dialed in, you can suffer energy crashes and lathargy. If you venture down that road, pick up 'The ketogenic diet' by Lyle McDonald. There is also a group for keto dieters on this site. The 'keto' subsection on bodybuilding.com is also a very good resource.
Many people have different reasons for liking or disliking the keto diet. In the end, it still comes down to calories in vs. calories out. Keto isn't a 'magic pill' or anything.0 -
A ketogenic diet is something you want to get right.
I would agree with this statement. It doesn't require tonnes of forward planning, but it does require that you get your macros right and that you track them meticulously.
I use 5% carbs, 60% fats, 35% protein. I'm currently cutting and my first week has give me some real promising resultsIn the end, it still comes down to calories in vs. calories out. Keto isn't a 'magic pill' or anything.
This must be emphasised again - If it wasn't for counting calories, the promising results I got would not have been as pronounced.
As an aside, I must mention that if you like to drink alcohol, a ketogenic diet makes for a cheap night out! I don't know why (perhaps someone here knows?) - But ketogenic diets turn me into a drinking lightweight!0 -
OP, may I suggest doing research on your own and not asking for unqualified and way un-informed people to answer a serious question such as which lifestyle change is right for you.0
-
OP, may I suggest doing research on your own and not asking for unqualified and way un-informed people to answer a serious question such as which lifestyle change is right for you.
This is part of research isn't it?
Gather ideas, opinions and experiences from everyone then go off and find what is right for you?
What is your take on Keto after your research?0 -
I have been hearing a lot about this ketogenic diet. How does it work and does it really help you burn fat quicker?
It will not result in substantially better body-fat loss if we're comparing diets with matched protein intakes and matched calorie intakes.
That being said I do not think they're "dangerous" if done correctly.0 -
OP, may I suggest doing research on your own and not asking for unqualified and way un-informed people to answer a serious question such as which lifestyle change is right for you.
genius...please do not ask people on this forum for medical advice0 -
OP, may I suggest doing research on your own and not asking for unqualified and way un-informed people to answer a serious question such as which lifestyle change is right for you.
genius...please do not ask people on this forum for medical advice
Asking if a ketogenic diet results in faster weight loss is medical advice?0 -
I personally don't see anything wrong with this post The OP replied with something along the lines of 'I was misinformed and I need to learn more about carbs.' I would always hope people will consult their doctor before making a large lifestyle change, but we're all here to learn more. ô.o
Yah my carbs are at 170 and I'm insulin resistant, the kind of carbs I eat though have made all the difference in the world.
0 -
Big fan of Lyle McDonald.
I do not believe there is any reason for anyone who is not very lean already to go on something as extreme as a keto diet. (And the way Lyle plans it there are strategic refeeds based on BF% not indefinite low carb)
The primary reason a lot of people will do well on keto diets is that it forces them to stop eating a lot of processed foods which are very easy to overeat (and hence over consume cals) and forces them to rely more on protein intake. I haven't heard of too many people going on chicken/steak binges compared to donuts & icecream :laugh:
Yup never ever binged on my chicken!!! lol0 -
I use 5% carbs, 60% fats, 35% protein. I'm currently cutting and my first week has give me some real promising results
As an aside, I must mention that if you like to drink alcohol, a ketogenic diet makes for a cheap night out! I don't know why (perhaps someone here knows?) - But ketogenic diets turn me into a drinking lightweight!
Yup, it's really about the macros. Keto is a high fat, adequate protein, low carb diet. It's not hard to get right but still requires independent research to make sure you're a) hitting the right macros and b) not afraid of eating fat. Some people try to do low-far AND low-carb and up their protein at the same time. If you're going to do keto, do some research and do it right. Like I said on your wall, feel free to message me and I'll give you more info.
Also, true on the alcohol thing. Ketoers get drunk much easier.
You might get more informed answers in a keto-specific MFP forum. It's not a well-understood diet for the most part and you won't get a well-rounded answer from people that haven't researched it. It has numerous health benefits including but not limited to reducing/eliminating seizure activity in epileptics, reducing or eliminating diabetes, and stopping or preventing cancer (I know from experience that this will not cure stage 4 lung cancer, but studies have found it beneficial for the treatment of cancer). It certainly has its place and it's certainly not a fad.0 -
F##K KETO its a fad!
Explain and provide sources that proves it is a fad????????????
A ketogenic way of eating is in NO way a fad. Doctors are using ketogenic ways of eating more and more to treat kidney disease and epliepsy. It is also one of the best ways for people that have Metabolic issues to live a healthy lifestyle.
Given the fact that most of us go into a ketogenic state when we sleep (hence stronger smelling urine and funky morning breath) I would say it is a very normal body function and not some fad as you are trying to say.0 -
And exceedingly dangerous!
What a joke..............what is so dangerous about being in ketosis?0 -
Ketosis for the body means fat-burning (hip hip hooray!). For the brain, it means a lower seizure risk and a better environment for neuronal recovery and repair.0
-
Here's what Lyle McDonald (author of the book The Ketogenic Diet and several other books regarding ketogenic dieting) has to say about it:...does it really help you burn fat quicker?
http://www.bodyrecomposition.com/research-review/ketogenic-low-carbohydrate-diets-have-no-metabolic-advantage-over-nonketogenic-low-carbohydrate-diets-research-review.html0 -
OP, may I suggest doing research on your own and not asking for unqualified and way un-informed people to answer a serious question such as which lifestyle change is right for you.
genius...please do not ask people on this forum for medical advice
I'm not asking for medical advice, I was simply interested in the results of this diet from others who have done it. Please don't tell me what I can and can't ask.0 -
I appreciate all the feedback, both good and bad, and I will continue my research :-)0
-
i sliced my carbs because it was the only thing preventing me from losing weight. I have a carb addiction, no matter how active I was, how healthy i ate, i binged on carbs...so i read "carb nite solution" and realized that it wasn't a lifestyle, it's a cycle. i started with 30g of carbs a day, which almost forces you to up your protein and fats just to get your calories in. I am up to 100g of carbs a day and heavy lifting and cardio. It's working, I feel great, I eat properly, i just stopped with the white bread, white rice, white potatoes, white everything. Eating differently is difficult, but do your research and learn what to subsititute carbs with.0
-
Everyone has their own opinions, so just do what works for you. But my experience (Since late May) with eating HFLC boils down to one sentence:
It's the only way of eating I've tried that keeps me full.
Seriously, that's why I'm eating low carb. I now know what real hunger is (which is not munchies, I have learned) and can honestly stop eating when I'm satisfied. Low fat kept me munching all day on junk and constantly falling off the wagon. If I didn't eat regularly, I'd get shaky. Not anymore. I also have lots of energy and have since started being more active. All pros and cons aside, this has sold me on this lifestyle.
I agree how important hitting your macros are. If I find that I don't get enough fat each meal, I do get hungrier quicker. Once you get it down, though, it's easy to keep up.
Say what you want about ketosis (which is NOT ketoacidosis, by the way) but for me and my body, I've never felt better!0 -
I've been going round the cal counting, gym going merry go round for years and each time binge eating put me back on a downward spiral. Low carb, moderate protein, high fat eating has given me control over my weight and diet for the first time.
As someone said before this diet is used widely for conditions such as epilepsy and diabetes, maybe one of you brainiacs should let these doctors know they are killing their patients?
There is no way this diet poses more risk to my health than being obese....0 -
Just wondering - and my apologies if I am hijacking this thread - if the Ketogenic Diet referred to here (for weight loss) is the same as the Ketogenic Diet used for the treatment of uncontrollable epilepsy? Or is Ketogenic Diet (for weight loss) more akin to the Atkins Diet?
The reason I ask: my son was on the Ketogenic Diet for years for the treatment of his epilepsy (well over 100 seizures per day). But starting the diet required a 3-day hospitalization. Then he had monthly visits with a dietician and quarterly visits with a neurologist.
More importantly, we had to accurately weigh his food to the nearest tenth of a gram and everything he ate or drank had to be in perfect balance and at an exact ratio as determined by his neurologist and dietician. And his calories has to be spread evenly throughout his waking hours.
My point is that the Ketogenic Diet (as I am familiar with it) is *extremely* strict and is done under very close medical supervision.
I'm just wondering if maybe it's semantics: I'm thinking of the classic Keto Diet for seizure control, and MFPers are referring to a generalized high fat-low carb diet.0 -
Keto (at least how I'm referring to) is eating enough carbs that will keep you in ketosis. I do weigh everything and strive to hit the 65/30/5 f/p/c macro goal, but I eat differently each day (like today I will eat three times, some days I save all my calories for dinner). It didn't require a hospital stay for me to start, I just began one day on my own.
I have lots of non-epileptic keto friends on MFP who all do it a little differently.0 -
Check out the keto subforum on reddit. The FAQ there are really informative.0
-
Just wondering - and my apologies if I am hijacking this thread - if the Ketogenic Diet referred to here (for weight loss) is the same as the Ketogenic Diet used for the treatment of uncontrollable epilepsy? Or is Ketogenic Diet (for weight loss) more akin to the Atkins Diet?
The reason I ask: my son was on the Ketogenic Diet for years for the treatment of his epilepsy (well over 100 seizures per day). But starting the diet required a 3-day hospitalization. Then he had monthly visits with a dietician and quarterly visits with a neurologist.
More importantly, we had to accurately weigh his food to the nearest tenth of a gram and everything he ate or drank had to be in perfect balance and at an exact ratio as determined by his neurologist and dietician. And his calories has to be spread evenly throughout his waking hours.
My point is that the Ketogenic Diet (as I am familiar with it) is *extremely* strict and is done under very close medical supervision.
I'm just wondering if maybe it's semantics: I'm thinking of the classic Keto Diet for seizure control, and MFPers are referring to a generalized high fat-low carb diet.
It's a ketogenic diet that's adapted for weight loss - but essentially the principle is the same. There's less restriction when it comes to measuring things *so* exactly and visiting doctors.
The main difference (as far as I know) between epilectic treatment keto diets and weight-loss keto diets is the level of protein. I believe that weight-loss keto diets have far more protein - the objective being to preserve lean body mass whilst cutting calories.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions