Catabolic Diet ?
Grankakes
Posts: 128 Member
i heard about this yesterday - and it seems like a good idea - mostly fruits and veggies. kind of like the negative calorie diet. just wondering if anyone has done it
0
Replies
-
I have never heard of it. But I eat pretty much all fruits and veggies, and that is working spectacularly for me!0
-
Don't follow diets. Just count calories. You're better off in the long run.0
-
Sounds like a quick way to get skinny fat.0
-
Why would you want to make your body eat itself? If all you're eating is fruits and vegetables, your body is going to use your muscles as a protein source.0
-
Why would you want to make your body eat itself?
Cuz humans taste yummy?0 -
i heard about this yesterday - and it seems like a good idea - mostly fruits and veggies. kind of like the negative calorie diet. just wondering if anyone has done it
Sounds like a terrible idea0 -
You want to avoid going catabolic.0
-
negative calories?
I will take 20000 -
That has to be the scariest name for a diet that I've ever seen.0
-
LMAO
The Diet that works three times faster than starvation!
Diets based on catabolic foods result in staggering weight losses of pure fat from the body. The results are sensational. As the doctor said, "the diet works three times faster than starvation!"
While the average weight loss is one pound a day, one lady went from 395 lbs. to 156 lbs. in a matter of months. The loss of 239 lbs. was actually written up in the Journal of the American Medical Association.
http://www.catabolic.com/
0 -
0
-
absolutely terrible idea.
catabolic means you're losing tissue....fat and muscle.........
losing muscle isn't a good thing. and a "diet" that relies only on carbs (fruits and veggies) is awful. you need protein. and a diet should be sustainable.
please do some reading and research before putting your health at risk0 -
Why would you want to make your body eat itself?
Cuz humans taste yummy?0 -
Why would you want to make your body eat itself?
Cuz humans taste yummy?
Just a nibble?0 -
Sounds like a quick way to get skinny fat.0
-
Why would you want to make your body eat itself?0
-
Think about where you want to be in 5 years. Do you want to be eating only fruits and vegetables for the next 5 years, 3 years, 6 months? I think it's safe to say you wouldn't want this to be your permanent way of life. The problem with this diet, while you may lose a ton of weight initially, is that it is not sustainable. You will be starving your body of essential nutrients it needs, protein. So then when you realize you can't live like this anymore, you will go back to your normal way of eating, and all that weight you lost will come right back on, plus more.
While it's a much longer process to lose weight the right way, slowly, you have a better chance of keeping that weight off for the rest of your life. do you really want to be dieting for the rest of your life? Wouldn't you rather take the next year or so of your life, lose the body fat, but not muscle, then reach maintenance mode and not have to be dieting forever? This is what I want for my life.
I recommend checking out www.fat2fitradio.com There's a ton of really helpful, well-researched, information on there. I highly recommend their approach rather than starving yourself, which is what a diet of just fruits and vegetables is.0 -
i heard about this yesterday - and it seems like a good idea - mostly fruits and veggies. kind of like the negative calorie diet. just wondering if anyone has done it
Sounds like a terrible idea
i second this!0 -
zombie diet0
-
Sounds like a quick way to get skinny fat.
Oh man, SOOO tempted to post a picture of myself here...my "skinny" body is the result of sugary malnutrition and it will not lose any more. But if you think flabby cellulite is sexy then go for it.0 -
I knew that Jewish people ate differently, what with the kosher thing, but I didn't know that Catabolics did too. I wonder if this may have had an influence on the Protestant movement.0
-
i heard about this yesterday - and it seems like a good idea - mostly fruits and veggies. kind of like the negative calorie diet. just wondering if anyone has done it
You're aware that there's no such thing as negative calories, right? That's just a myth. Here's a really good article about why it's totally false, and my favorite excerpt from it below: http://www.answerfitness.com/269/negative-calorie-foods-fact-fiction/
Is Celery Really a Negative Calorie Food?
While the list of negative calorie foods has ballooned to include everything from beets to strawberries and mangoes (yes, I’m being serious here), celery is the most commonly cited negative calorie food.
From a nutritional standpoint, celery is pretty much empty. It’s basically made up of water, sodium, some trace minerals and something called cellulose — which is a form of vegetable fiber than the human body cannot digest. It contains no protein or fat and marginal carbohydrates. Any other nutrition in celery is in the form of vitamins, minerals and enzymes, which contain no calories.
In fact, aside from iceberg lettuce and cucumbers, you probably couldn’t find a less nutritious, lower-calorie vegetable to eat. These foods are already about as close as you can get to eating zero calories. Close, but not quite, as we’ll see in a moment.
A large, stalk of celery weighing in at 2.2 ounces contains only nine calories. Negative calorie diet advocates claim that the mere process of chewing and digesting celery requires an expenditure of energy that exceeds the 9 calories present in the celery. Therefore, the argument goes, celery has “negative calories.”
Again, this all sounds good in theory, but what about in practice?
Issues with the Negative Calorie Foods Theory
There are some flaws with the negative calorie food theory, however.
First, the reason that certain foods like celery are already low in calories is exactly because of their high-non-caloric nutritional content. The fact that cellulose, water and minerals like sodium contain no calories is already figured into the food’s caloric-content. That’s why it has minimal calories in the first place. Negative food advocates want to double-dip here, and have you believe that the non-caloric nutrients like cellulose lower its effective calorie levels even more, but that’s just not how it works. This is already baked-in.
Second, the whole argument that the body burns more calories chewing and digesting negative calorie foods like celery is also suspect.
Yes, the body does expend a certain amount of energy to digest food, but that expenditure — even with foods that contain a high-percentage of non-caloric nutrients like cellulose — is actually fairly minimal.
Typically, the body will expend 10 - 15 percent of the calories you consume each day to fuel digestion. Let’s just throw the negative calorie food gurus a bone and say that for foods that are rich in non-digestible nutrients like cellulose, that number is actually as high as 50 percent of calories consumed (I have no evidence for this claim — I’m just being generous to prove a point.)
In the case of celery — the poster child of all negative calorie foods – you would be burning an extra 4.5 calories per each 9 calorie, 2.2 oz serving of celery. That would put your effective net calories at 4.5 (9/50% = 4.5 calories) — hardly “negative calorie” territory.
And because the amount of energy expended on digestion of foods is always expressed as a percentage, to have a negative calorie effect, digestion would have to constitute at least 101% of the energy consumed in order to create a negative calorie environment — something which is physically impossible.
So it appears that the food that is the best candidate for qualifying as a negative calorie food — celery – can’t even hit the break-even point, let alone become “calorie-negative.”0 -
I knew that Jewish people ate differently, what with the kosher thing, but I didn't know that Catabolics did too. I wonder if this may have had an influence on the Protestant movement.
it makes sense, most people have movements after their Protestants are stimulated.0 -
0
-
Rofl this pic0 -
I don't subscribe to 'diets'. I just eat sensibly, watch my calories and get some exercise.0
-
like i said - i just heard about it yesterday. doing research today. looks like a no-go. just another fad
my main plan is to just eat healthy. fruits, veggies, lean meat.
and some of you - WOW - great jobs at weight loss. i hope i'm there with you one of these days!0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions