how early can you have soup?

it's never too early for soup.

i don't really give too much sway to the idea of 'breakfast foods' and 'lunch foods'.. there's good, nutritious food, and there's junky food.

if soup is going to keep you from surfing down the hallway on the tea trolley, trailing muffins and mars bars, have soup

'breakfast' as a type of food was invented by Kellogg.

Before that, there was just food.

soup anytime is good if that is what you want. and fluid first thing is probably a good thing.

I've had cake for breakfast lots of times. And cold pizza, wings, whatever is left over. Breakfast is breaking your fast, not an ad by a cereal company. Have whatever food you want to eat.

Many parts of Asia eat soup for breakfast all the time. You can eat any food whenever you want to! I ate pudding for breakfast at an island resort recently, it was wonderful and the chef thought it was a good idea so who was I to argue!

^Yes. A bowl of soup and grilled fish is a great way to start the day.

So its 9:33 am here and I am starving,
also feeling pretty cold, my options for food are instant soup or rice cakes.
My question is, is 9:40 too early for soup??

Yes. The soup police will arrest you if you eat it before 11 a.m.

That's not the only problem. Soup should not be eaten prior to 11:00AM as it is a lunch or dinner food. Your body will be confused and believe that it is later in the day than it really is. It can really mess up your TDEE and BMR. Eggs, toast, oatmeal, cereal, traditional breakfast foods are eaten in the morning in order to signal your metabolism to start going.

Many parts of Asia eat soup for breakfast all the time. You can eat any food whenever you want to! I atue pudding for breakfast at an island resort recently, it was wonderful and the chef thought it was a good idea so who was I to argue!

This sums it up. Who makes these rules, really? My wife & I have beans for breakfast every day. When we first started, I thought it would be weird, but it's not. And a friend who lived in New Mexico for a while said, "Out there, some communities would think you were weird if you DIDN'T have beans for breakfast!"

Funny story: We honeymooned in Hawaii at a hotel with a fair number of Japanese tourists. The hotel had a great breakfast buffet. My wife & I tended to eat the Japanese food on the buffet. So, one day at breakfast, we're sitting there with our rice bowls and miso soup, and we look over to the Japanese family at the next table and see their plates piled high with pancakes, hash browns, and donuts. They looked at our plates at the same time, and we all started laughing together.

never too early for me

You're an adult! You can have cake for lunch if you wanted!

Doing it. SHE SAID I COULD!!

I didn't realize there was a time to eat any kind of food... guy I have been breaking some kind of rule because I usually eat left overs for breakfast.

You're an adult! You can have cake for lunch if you wanted!

Doing it. SHE SAID I COULD!!

I ate soup at 10:05 yesterday morning and it was AWESOME:)

Too early for soup? I didn't realize there was such a thing to ingest something and it being too early.................except for Alcohol.............unless you are on Vacation......................unless thats a staycation then its too early but vacation anywhere else and its ok.......mmmm alcohol......crap what were we talking about?