Truth or Myth?
WinterGirl_101
Posts: 6 Member
`
0
Replies
-
1) 45 calories is a tiny drop in a large bucket and I wouldn't concern yourself with this.
But that's aside from your question so:
2) The differences are going to be somewhere between negligible and zero. You should work-out when you most enjoy working out. .
More importantly I'll include this tidibt that you should think about:
All that matters is where you land over the course of weeks or months in terms of net change in bodyfat. Change in fat is the difference between fat oxidation and fat storage. You're basically fluctuating between periods of fat storage and fat oxidation and all that you should care about is that you're oxidizing more fat than you are storing.
This will happen in a caloric deficit regardless of whether or not you're burning extra calories in your sleep, or during the day. This is also why it doesn't matter whether or not you eat a big meal at night vs at breakfast.
You need to create an energy deficit and you should exercise when you prefer to exercise.
Do this and you will lose fat. And you don't need to worry about the things you posted about, although I don't fault you for asking.0 -
If there's an afterburn from exercise it will happen regardless of what time it is. I find exercising right before bed makes it harder to get to sleep and your exercise doesn't burn off the food in your stomach so as long as you stay in your budget it really doesn't matter when you eat or exercise.0
-
-0
-
It doesn't matter when you eat or exercise.
I find exercising before bed negatively effects my sleep.0 -
It makes no difference as to when you do them, assuming the energy expended at the time is the same. Do them when you want and when makes sense based on your energy levels.0
-
Okay thanks for the help. My entire routine is based around calories eaten and burnt it helps me keep control over the matter so I will remain focused on that but thanks for the advise. And I agree with you on the getting to sleep, That's why I love my bedtime cup of tea and maybe a little tv it gets me out of workout mode and into a relaxed sleepy state. I like my nightime routine and i think I'll keep it but I do appreciate the advise and knowledge given
I'm not suggesting that you ignore calories. I'm suggesting that you don't need to micromanage the timing of nutrients with the timing of exercise to try and burn off things in the short term.
For example, if you eat a big breakfast you do not need to micromanage your activity to prevent acute fat storage.
Or you don't need to avoid eating a big dinner for fear of gaining fat in your sleep.
You just need to get in proper nutrition, eat at a caloric deficit, and do some exercise and ALL of that minutia will manage itself without you ever having to think about it.0 -
As your diary set for 700 cals a day, I really wouldn't bother worrying about 45 in a cup of tea.0
-
As your diary set for 700 cals a day, I really wouldn't bother worrying about 45 in a cup of tea.
Holy cr@p - your avi says it all.
OP: Hun - eat more and stop worrying about the small stuff.0 -
How tall are you, OP?0
-
As your diary set for 700 cals a day, I really wouldn't bother worrying about 45 in a cup of tea.
Holy cr@p - your avi says it all.
Hun - eat more and stop worrying about the small stuff.
This. Your base calorie level is 500. It should be much higher. 1200 at least.0 -
-0
-
As your diary set for 700 cals a day, I really wouldn't bother worrying about 45 in a cup of tea.
Holy cr@p - your avi says it all.
Hun - eat more and stop worrying about the small stuff.
This. Your base calorie level is 500. It should be much higher. 1200 at least.
-0 -
Wow. I seriously hope you are forgetting to log food because, when you do, you reportedly eat 99, 265, 397 calories....That is way too little for your present weight. I hope you haven't developed an eating disorder by eating this low for a long time.0
-
As your diary set for 700 cals a day, I really wouldn't bother worrying about 45 in a cup of tea.
Holy cr@p - your avi says it all.
Hun - eat more and stop worrying about the small stuff.
This. Your base calorie level is 500. It should be much higher. 1200 at least.
http://fattyfightsback.blogspot.com/2009/03/mtyhbusters-starvation-mode.html
1200 will not loose me weight especially since I can't burn that much in a day I don't have money to go to a gym I have to buy any supplies via xmas money and what little i get from my paychecks that do not cover bills, my house isn't big enough to hold any decent workout equipment ether. So i can't burn more than maybe 300 cals a day max. I eat less to make up for the lack of calories I can burn. I love this article because it exposes the fraud of the magic 1200 which does nothing. You need to eat what you can properly make up for by exorbitance and I simply don't have the means to make up for that many. There is nothing majoc about 1200 cals its just blowing smoke up our rears and I'm not wasting my time on that wives tale XD
The only part you are correct about is that there's nothing magical about the number 1200.
You are failing to consider the energy requirements of sustaining basic bodily functions. Even in the absence of all exercise, just sitting in a chair doing nothing, you are burning more than 300 calories. You are burning more than 300 calories if you slept all day.0 -
After reading your profile and looking at your user name more closely, seems to me that you are pro ana, which is not acceptable on this site. Also, the book you borrowed your user name from was not glorifying eating disorders, no matter how much you try to make it so.0
-
As your diary set for 700 cals a day, I really wouldn't bother worrying about 45 in a cup of tea.
Holy cr@p - your avi says it all.
Hun - eat more and stop worrying about the small stuff.
This. Your base calorie level is 500. It should be much higher. 1200 at least.
http://fattyfightsback.blogspot.com/2009/03/mtyhbusters-starvation-mode.html
1200 will not loose me weight especially since I can't burn that much in a day I don't have money to go to a gym I have to buy any supplies via xmas money and what little i get from my paychecks that do not cover bills, my house isn't big enough to hold any decent workout equipment ether. So i can't burn more than maybe 300 cals a day max. I eat less to make up for the lack of calories I can burn. I love this article because it exposes the fraud of the magic 1200 which does nothing. You need to eat what you can properly make up for by exercise and I simply don't have the means to make up for that many. There is nothing majoc about 1200 cals its just blowing smoke up our rears and I'm not wasting my time on that wives tale XD
There is definitely nothing magic about 700 cals per day either.
http://thefitgirls.com/tdee-calculator.aspx
After plugging in your current stats, to maintain your current weight in a coma you would need to be eating at least 1300 calories. If you exercise at a moderate level (3-5 times per week) you're looking at 2100 calories to maintain.
What are your goals, OP? A number? A certain physique? Being healthy?0 -
You are likely burning 1200 just by existing. You don't need to workout to burn every calorie you consume, your body burns calories the entire time it is alive. Only eating 500 calories a day is not enough to fuel what your body needs to do over the course of a day and you will end up with very serious health problems. There is no equipment necessary to eat properly.
I didn't read the article because it's likely either total bullsh!t or you have taken (out of context) the tidbits that are what you want to hear.0 -
As your diary set for 700 cals a day, I really wouldn't bother worrying about 45 in a cup of tea.
Holy cr@p - your avi says it all.
Hun - eat more and stop worrying about the small stuff.
This. Your base calorie level is 500. It should be much higher. 1200 at least.
http://fattyfightsback.blogspot.com/2009/03/mtyhbusters-starvation-mode.html
1200 will not loose me weight especially since I can't burn that much in a day I don't have money to go to a gym I have to buy any supplies via xmas money and what little i get from my paychecks that do not cover bills, my house isn't big enough to hold any decent workout equipment ether. So i can't burn more than maybe 300 cals a day max. I eat less to make up for the lack of calories I can burn. I love this article because it exposes the fraud of the magic 1200 which does nothing. You need to eat what you can properly make up for by exercise and I simply don't have the means to make up for that many. There is nothing majoc about 1200 cals its just blowing smoke up our rears and I'm not wasting my time on that wives tale XD
You need to do better research. VLCDs run the risk of malnutrition, excess loss of LBM, hormonal imbalance and metabolic adaptation among a bunch of other issues.
At 5 1 and 128 lb your BMR should be about 1,300 and your TDEE about 1,500 with no exercise. It seems as though you love that article because it justifies you eating a ridiculously low amount of calories - and btw, it is not even a proper article - its some persons blog.0 -
I know there's nothing magical about 1200, but even the smallest women I know need to eat at least that to be healthy. I'm not talking about "starvation mode" but simply eating enough calories to get all essential nutrients, protein, fat, etc and to have enough energy to make it through the day.0
-
OK obviously I can't ask a simple question without getting a lecture from people who I don't know and don't know me. All I wanted to know is if I burnt calories in my sleep if I worked out right before bed the 45 calorie thing was just an example I don't care if I burn off my tea or not like you all said its not important. This is my last post and I'm not going to respond to this thread anymore I got my answers I don't need a health class too.0
-
Myth.
Your body burns calories 'round the clock. You don't need to exercise before bed. Honestly, sounds like one of those things that gets spread around communities that promote starvation.0 -
OK obviously I can't ask a simple question without getting a lecture from people who I don't know and don't know me. All I wanted to know is if I burnt calories in my sleep if I worked out right before bed the 45 calorie thing was just an example I don't care if I burn off my tea or not like you all said its not important. This is my last post and I'm not going to respond to this thread anymore I got my answers I don't need a health class too.
45 calories doesn't matter no matter when you eat it especially when you're severely undereating like you are.
These responses were out of genuine concern and some from people who have been down similar paths as you before. But how dare they try to collect as much information about the situation as possible before they post an answer... such ignorant rude people, right?0 -
^^^^^^^Myth.
Your body burns calories 'round the clock. You don't need to exercise before bed. Honestly, sounds like one of those things that gets spread around communities that promote starvation.
THIS
And OP, don't be so thin skinned....we all are here to learn more and reach optimal health.
Good Luck to you:flowerforyou:0 -
OK obviously I can't ask a simple question without getting a lecture from people who I don't know and don't know me. All I wanted to know is if I burnt calories in my sleep if I worked out right before bed the 45 calorie thing was just an example I don't care if I burn off my tea or not like you all said its not important. This is my last post and I'm not going to respond to this thread anymore I got my answers I don't need a health class too.
You are getting a lecture from people who know more than you do about nutrition and fitness. Once your apparently hurt feelings subside about this, you would do well to listen to that lecture in the interest of your health.0 -
OK obviously I can't ask a simple question without getting a lecture from people who I don't know and don't know me. All I wanted to know is if I burnt calories in my sleep if I worked out right before bed the 45 calorie thing was just an example I don't care if I burn off my tea or not like you all said its not important. This is my last post and I'm not going to respond to this thread anymore I got my answers I don't need a health class too.
0 -
I got my answers I don't need a health class too.
Oh, but you do......0 -
OK obviously I can't ask a simple question without getting a lecture from people who I don't know and don't know me. All I wanted to know is if I burnt calories in my sleep if I worked out right before bed the 45 calorie thing was just an example I don't care if I burn off my tea or not like you all said its not important. This is my last post and I'm not going to respond to this thread anymore I got my answers I don't need a health class too.
They are simply giving you valuable advice which would really do you good to listen to.
Also, your username is awfully familiar with an eating disorder book...0 -
i'm sort of sorry i missed what the OP was before it was edited.0
-
This thread is sad.0
-
You've deleted most of your comments, so I'm probably not getting the whole picture. But from the bits that have been quoted, like this:
http://fattyfightsback.blogspot.com/2009/03/mtyhbusters-starvation-mode.html
1200 will not loose me weight especially since I can't burn that much in a day I don't have money to go to a gym I have to buy any supplies via xmas money and what little i get from my paychecks that do not cover bills, my house isn't big enough to hold any decent workout equipment ether. So i can't burn more than maybe 300 cals a day max. I eat less to make up for the lack of calories I can burn. I love this article because it exposes the fraud of the magic 1200 which does nothing. You need to eat what you can properly make up for by exorbitance and I simply don't have the means to make up for that many. There is nothing majoc about 1200 cals its just blowing smoke up our rears and I'm not wasting my time on that wives tale XD
Yeah. I've been there, and whatever's going on with you, you have my sympathy. This is what my mom taught me for my whole childhood. Burn off more than you take in. If you can't exercise much, eat less. Fat people like us need to eat less because we have plenty of stores to burn without eating. Etc etc etc. So I lived a life for decades where I ate 1000, and couldn't exercise enough to burn it off, so then I ate 800. And then 700. And then I started falling asleep all the time and couldn't summon the energy to even participate in phys ed, let alone go to the gym and work out on weekends. Never occurred to me as a kid, or a teen, or even a young adult, to question. Parents are always right, no? I was 25 or 26 before I realised that my mom had an eating disorder, and so did I. I thought life was normal, that things were just difficult because I was lazy.
People here are telling you to eat more because they're worried. If you're eating 800 you're damaging your health, but if you're eating 300 you're quite literally killing yourself. Of course nobody can force you to take advice. But if you decide you want to come back at any point and ask questions and listen, there'll never be a dearth of people with good advice to give. I hope you decide to return. One of the big emotional effects of starvation is fluctuating moods - anger, irritability, depression, a tendency to overreact and think that people are against you. They're not, but it's hard to remember that when your brain doesn't have enough energy to function properly. If you're really eating as little as 300, I'm guessing you feel pretty awful most of the time, emotionally as well as physically.
Life doesn't have to be like that.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions