Free or Cheat day? Chew on this

Options
From www.shapefit.com

I'm sure most of you have heard of this concept before, free food days. It's a dieting or lifestyle concept that some people find very helpful in maintaining or losing weight. You eat a strict diet and macronutrient ratio that is planned all week long and insert a free food day once every 7-10 days. This allows some people to never feel deprived and thus stay on track all week long with their food intake. It's a good plan for some people. I say its "good" because there are people who have lost tons of weight or who maintain their perfect weight doing this. I'm here to talk about the dark side of free food days.

Yesterday, I had a big garage sale so I was up at 2am and working hard all morning. I had friends coming over to assist me and that meant I needed something easy and quick to feed them all day. I made a healthier version of pigs in a blanket the night before so all I had to do was warm everything in the morning. This would set the stage for a FREE FOOD DAY for me. Here's how it went:

I started the day with low quality carbs (biscuits as the "blanket") which sent my blood sugar into high gear. The buzz was almost immediate. I ran around like a frantic rabbit! Soon my energy crashed and because the garage sale was well under way, I grabbed more pigs in a blanket. My normally low hunger levels became monstrous! With every hour I felt hungrier, more frantic, more light headed. I had no time to sit and eat a salad or even blend a high quality protein shake. Then I started on the diet sodas (which I have not had in months) and after 6 hours of this eating/crashing/eating/crashing pattern I was exhausted. The garage sale ended and someone said PIZZA (and more diet soda)! I immediately started craving pizza, so off we went. After eating 5-6 pieces of pizza I was well beyond "Thanksgiving meal" full.

I was so sleepy I couldn't keep my eyes open. I sat in the recliner watching a movie and was soon fast asleep. 60 minutes later I awoke, groggy, feeling sick to my stomach, with a terrible hangover type headache. The hormonal hot flashes started and I was literally sweating while in a non-moving vegetative state. This lasted several hours until I gave up on feeling like a normal person and went to bed. I woke up 7 hours later to greet the new day only to find my body feeling like lead. I felt like I had been slipped a drug yesterday, and of course I had been slipped a drug, a white flour and low protein drug which is one that had no traces of my usual abundant vegetables and high quality proteins and whole grains. I was experiencing the dark side of a free food day.

This was not a new experience for me. Years ago I actually lived by the free food day concept. I stayed with it for 2 years before realizing that every time I had a free food day I was re-awakening the monster. White flours, sugars and low quality foods in general are a drug. That's why people can't live without them. They are addictive and dangerous in large quantities. For me and many of my clients, eating more than a tiny bit of this drug sets off not only days of binges but also many hours (up to 36) where you feel hung-over, you lack any energy and your mood is dark. This happens for almost everyone to some extent, they just don't make the connection.

Obviously I no longer follow or advise my clients to follow the free food day theory. Some could handle it I'm sure but most could not. For many yo-yo dieters this is exactly the problem. Their bodies simply cannot handle a healthy eating plan with inserted days of the drug, the monster, the low quality foods. It sets us up for cycles where we feel horrid, make poor decisions and simply cannot work up the energy to exercise the next day. Does this mean we are all doomed to a life of never eating a favorite food or meal? Absolutely not, but we must have some rules.

Remember your trigger foods and steer clear of them. My trigger food is white flour. So if I want to have something "white" it must be in extremely low doses and I must immediately move away from the source. This way I won't sneak additional portions.

Have a plan for the coming cravings. If you have your free food that is known to trigger the irrational part of your brain, the binge center, then make darn sure there isn't a boat load of it available! This might mean buying small cups of ice cream instead of a half gallon or making 1 dozen pigs in a blanket instead of 3 dozen! Get a plan before the low quality free food takes over your brain center!

Drink extra large quantities of water. This not only helps flush out some of the drug but it also prevents you from adding to the problem! Diet sodas, regular sodas and anything with manmade ingredients is just more of the same drug but in a different form. Don't add insult to injury here! Limit your free food to what you actually want, what you planned for. The rest just isn't going to happen.

Re-think what FREE really means here. Is it "FREE" to feel like you are a food addict? Is it FREE to have your energy taken away from you so you can't enjoy the next 2-3 days of your life? Is it FREE to feel so angry at yourself for losing control? What price are you willing to pay for FREE FOOD? Sometimes FREE means a slice of your own birthday cake or a romantic dinner out with your favorite person. Sometimes FREE means having that glass of wine in the evening. Whatever FREE is to you, look at it. Really look at it and then decide, before you have consumed the drug, what is the price of FREE for this? Am I willing to pay that price? Is it going to be worth it? Sometime it will be worth it, GO FOR IT. Sometimes you'll simply say pass.

These days I am more likely to stay clear of FREE food choices unless I'm in a controlled environment. For me it's an act of self love. I much prefer zig zag calorie days where every 3-4 days I get more calories from my favorite healthy food choices. These days leave me feeling very satisfied, full of energy and a positive, upbeat outlook on life. These days never take me further away from my goals but take me closer to them. These types of days leave me feeling proud of myself and in control of my body.

As for today, I'll just have to get through it. I have another 24 hours of "detox" ahead. It won't be pretty, it won't be fun but it will serve as a reminder that I have done a great job at cleaning up my lifestyle. If I hadn't, I wouldn't feel so awful because of my free food day yesterday.

By Traci Breazeale

http://www.shapefit.com/diet/free-food-days.html?utm_source=MailingList&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=April+2010+-+Week+#3

Replies

  • gnme4243
    gnme4243 Posts: 120
    Options
    Wonderful post, thank you for sharing! I have also felt that drugged, disgusting feeling when I have eaten white flours, empty foods, and sugar. My husband and I were just discussing how we couldn't believe we lived in such a fog like that when we used to eat that way so often. And what's worse, once you started eating those types of things, your body craves more and more!

    If I don't eat anything with any type of wheat flour in it, especially white, and stay away from any refined sugars, I feel great- eating healthy feels so much better than any "free" or "cheat" day. I have finally started really listening to my own body and what triggers it, and find that I choose now to pass on the things that may taste good, but will make me sick- nope, just not worth it anymore. Not depriving myself, just choosing not to poison myself either.

    Again, thanks for your post!

    :flowerforyou:
  • bellinachuchina
    bellinachuchina Posts: 498 Member
    Options
    Love it :)

    Exactly how I feel on that subject. “Cheat days” are simply counterproductive, instead, I live by the rule "everything in moderation"!
  • acakeforawife
    Options
    Amazing article, thanks for posting it! Definitely gonna bookmark for re-reading!
  • lovelypen50
    lovelypen50 Posts: 192 Member
    Options
    Wonderful Post, I know that drugged feeling after over indulging in food. Everytime, even if it was only every two weeks, it took me a while to recover. Your post hit it right on target. I try not to over indulge, and I try to keep healthy snacks on hand. Wonderful Post.
  • hill242
    hill242 Posts: 412 Member
    Options
    "If you have your free food that is known to trigger the irrational part of your brain, the binge center, then make darn sure there isn't a boat load of it available! "

    So true. I know that if I start by eating one donut when people bring in a couple dozen to the office, that it will result in two, three, four, sometimes five donuts by the end of the day. And then I feel horrible both physically and emotionally. Therefore I don't eat even one, because as much I say I won't go back, once I eat that little indulgence, I cave.

    But I do like to treat myself weekly to a delicious bowl of ice cream. And I usually have one meal a week (occasionally two) where I don't restrict myself to 500 calories or less. It helps keep me feeling satisfied and happy. I've had good results with this approach.

    But a whole day? I really don't want to do that to myself ever again.
  • mandipandi2010
    Options
    It is CRAZY how close to home this post hit.

    Just last week after a 5 week strong and dedicated diet plan, we had a Bday at work, which ment cake. Since I had been so dedicated and successful I allowed myself a piece. I have been struggling ever since to get back in to the grind.

    Its like that one little piece of cake literally did awake the montster. This concerns me even more due to my Bday is next Tuesday. Needless to say, I have no interest in a cake for my Bday. I truely wish I would have never eaten it.

    Back on pace now....cant wait to weigh in tomorrow!
  • PJilly
    PJilly Posts: 21,734 Member
    Options
    LOVE that article! Thank you for posting it.
  • karabeara
    karabeara Posts: 19 Member
    Options
    Great post, thank you. I call that my "food hangover". When I eat processed or unhealthy foods in large quantities, the next day I CRAVE more of it.

    When I do a free day I try to think of it not as a total free for all, but more of just a day where I don't count calories. I still try to eat foods that fuel my body for the most part.
  • AllisonMS
    AllisonMS Posts: 104
    Options
    I'm still working off my "cheat" day on Saturday -- a bridal shower with champagne and wine and cake, and I gained 1.5 pounds -- and the sluggish feeling was horrible. And I'm fighting to get back to my weight of just the day before. And it pisses me off!

    So I'm right there with you -- cheat days are not worth it!
  • RentThisSpace
    RentThisSpace Posts: 96 Member
    Options
    Completely understand where the article is coming from. My finance' and I had fast food a few nights ago after not being a very good diet for the past several weeks, and it tore both of stomachs up. Not to the extent of the author, but we both had bad stomach aches and headaches, enough to be annoying but not put us down. We realized that the grease and processed foods was the culprit and realized we should not be eating like we were in college anymore (late night fast food).

    But on the positive side, we realized that our bodies had adjusted to the healthy lifestyle and was rejecting the unhealthy way. So that was a good lesson learned and another step towards a healthier life.
  • FabulousFifty
    FabulousFifty Posts: 1,575 Member
    Options
    I totally agree. I see it like this...it would be like telling a drug addict, 'You get to have a free drug day. Go ahead and splurge, then back on track tomorrow"...yeah right!!! Or would you tell an alcoholic..."Today is a free drinking day. Drink all you want then tomorrow it is back on the wagon for you!" No way!!!! I am a food-aholic with addictive behaviors when it comes to eating. I own it. There is no "free day" for me. Occasionally, I will cut myself a little slack, but it never works. Here's to detox and a lesson learned! Water, water, water!:drinker:
  • pfenixa
    pfenixa Posts: 194 Member
    Options
    I can't imagine leaving a whole day free to eat like that. What I've done for myself is actually to allow some of those bad foods into my regular diet. Before a month ago I regularly ate fast food and consuming next to no vegetables or fruit. What I decided to do instead of completely rehauling my foods was to fuse in healthier choices. I've been to McDonald's 3-4 times in the last month, but only on days that I've eaten well for other meals/snacks, and I always make sure to pick the "healthier" options and keep the portions small. So if a day comes up where I'm stressed or forgot to pack lunch, if I stop for fast food I don't have to worry about tearing up my insides. And I've still lost weight eating like I do (of course I exercise too). I've tried to be honest with myself: I know I don't want to just eat healthy all the time and I won't after I want to reach my goal weight either. Moderation really is the key; making the healthiest choice when it's not something necessarily healthy and knowing your limits.
  • Celestia
    Celestia Posts: 106 Member
    Options
    Its like a runaway train at times, especially if I have one cheat day...it becomes an issue that turns into a binge of 2-3 weeks. I realize I should practice more self control and more discipline to keep my health goals in check, but this article shed some light on my behavioral patterns towards eating and the processed foods like drugs analogy.

    I'm glad people enjoyed this post...