Low carb
cmeyers54
Posts: 16
Has anybody had as much success doing a low carb diet as they advertise?? Thinking about trying it. Any input??
0
Replies
-
I've lost weight going low carb in the past. The problem for me personally is that I can't stick to it, and I've always gained the weight back. Moderation and calorie counting is what's really worked for me this time. I've never lost this much weight or stuck to something this long.0
-
carbs are part of your diet. cut them out and lose, then introduce them and gain. I know no one who has kept it off :S0
-
Has anybody had as much success doing a low carb diet as they advertise?? Thinking about trying it. Any input??
The best diet is the one that is easiest for you to adhere to, barring any medical issues that require special diet practices. Low carbers as with other "special" diets like to make all sorts of fantastic claims about their diet that are more fantasy then reality0 -
Has anybody had as much success doing a low carb diet as they advertise?? Thinking about trying it. Any input??
The best diet is the one that is easiest for you to adhere to, barring any medical issues that require special diet practices. Low carbers as with other "special" diets like to make all sorts of fantastic claims about their diet that are more fantasy then reality
+1
You don't need to be so restrictive. People seem to think that losing weight must be as challenging as possible. It doesn't have to be like that at all. Just hit your calorie goal and exercise and the weight will come off. If you're in a calorie deficit, you will lose weight.0 -
Yes, I had some pretty good success with low carb diets. I was never hungry, I felt great and ate good food. Not bricks of cheese and mounds of bacon like some people envision. I didn’t follow Atkins, just my own common sense LC version. I did gain the weight back but not because I ate a carb but because I ate ALL the carbs! I went back to eating all the stuff that made me fat in the first place. I am very carb sensitive so bread, pasta, rice, etc trigger horrible cravings. So, I am not currently on a “low carb” regimen but I have cut out those items.0
-
Sorry to pile it on, but I also tried low-carbing and the results are great, but short-lived. I was doing pretty good for a while, but if you ever want to eat pizza or birthday cake again, it's really a bad diet, because the weight comes back as quickly as it went away. Plus, I plateaued after only six pounds lost. Additionally, I felt completely lethargic -- which should really be no surprise, since we get our energy from carbs, and I was limiting mine.
Bottom line, it's a great diet if you just want to lose a few pounds in time for your high school reunion or something. It's not a good diet in the long-run because it's hard to stick to and the weight only stays off as long as you're strict about it. Sorry... :-/0 -
Has anybody had as much success doing a low carb diet as they advertise?? Thinking about trying it. Any input??
The best diet is the one that is easiest for you to adhere to, barring any medical issues that require special diet practices. Low carbers as with other "special" diets like to make all sorts of fantastic claims about their diet that are more fantasy then reality
You don't need to be so restrictive. People seem to think that losing weight must be as challenging as possible. It doesn't have to be like that at all. Just hit your calorie goal and exercise and the weight will come off. If you're in a calorie deficit, you will lose weight.
I feel like I have done well. I started 1/7/13 and stayed within my calorie goal suggested by MFP and I have lost 12 pounds. But, I have over 100 pounds to lose and I feel like this week I am still within my calories but I'm just not eating very heatlthy. I have walked or done Zumba everyday and there are no results. It's just really frustrating since I have so much to lose. I try to tell myself it's not a race or a diet, this is my new life. I'm just not a very patient person.0 -
I am definitely not on a low carb diet by the standards of Atkins etc, ( I am aiming for 30 percent protein, 30 percent fat , 40 percent carb which actually means quite a lot of carbs for my quite high calorie limit) However by focusing on INCREASING protein I have found I don't want as many carbs, I am fuller for longer (most of the time!) and so my diet is healthier overall and my energy is better. Next I aim to improve the quality of the carbs I eat so they they are less processed/ refined.0
-
I'd like to add that I was not trying to go super-low-carb. I was doing about 30 grams per meal, mostly from fruit and veggies as opposed to processed carbs (pastas/breads/etc.). I read somewhere that 40-60 grams of carbs per meal is considered average, so I wasn't that far off; I was just eating less of the "bad" stuff (like cake). Even that didn't last, although your willpower is undoubtedly better than mine; it certainly couldn't be worse!
You may also want to check out "eating clean" and the paleo diet. I don't know that much about them, but if you're willing to give up carbs or just generally make better choices, you might prefer these.0 -
Has anybody had as much success doing a low carb diet as they advertise?? Thinking about trying it. Any input??
The best diet is the one that is easiest for you to adhere to, barring any medical issues that require special diet practices. Low carbers as with other "special" diets like to make all sorts of fantastic claims about their diet that are more fantasy then reality
Exactly. I am one of those people who HAVE to eat low carbs because my blood glucose is too high and if I continue down that path I will most likely get diabetes. I noticed when I eat low carb, my sugar stays normal and doesn't spike unhealthily. If you are just someone who wants to lose weight by watching carb its very possible, but its also a lot harder to keep for a long period of time. I think the best diet is moderation and trying to incoroporate things that you know are good for you. I wish I could just do that but every time I have anything over 30g of carb per meal, my sugar goes up. Best of luck to you!0 -
Too restrictive and in the end, when you reintroduce some, the weight comes back. Better to adjust your carbs to the healthier ones and just cut back a bit. I get huge cravings if I try to cut back too much. Balanced is better.0
-
I went on the Dukan Diet, all 4 stages. it reintroduces carbs and eventually you eat what you want in moderation. However, I felt so much better without rice, potatoes, bread and pasta I only eat them when I visit my mom and she cooks and puts them in front of me. (in small amounts, I am might add)...
I counted calories and still log like crazy. I added back an apple or banana or avocado daily and I am on month 15. I think the combination of Dukan and Logging my calories and exercise AND weighing daily will all play into a successful healthy lifestyle.0 -
Low carb works for me. But then again I'm pretty sure I can happily eat steak every day for the rest of my life.0
-
It seems to me that people don't truly understand what low carb means. It's not all carbs, it's the type of carbs that are often the issue. I choose to be low carb, and the carbs I cut out are the ones found in wheat products and other grains, i.e. bread, pasta, cereals, corn, etc. I throw soy in there as well, because like wheat and corn, it's starting to crop up in all kinds of things, and unfermented soy is really bad for you. Other legumes, such as peas and beans, are carby as well, but I like them, so I eat them in moderation. Same with rice and potatoes. Fruit is carby, and so is raw milk, but since they are natural whole foods, and untampered with (usually; I buy organic when I can, or grow my own, or buy from a local supplier), I don't feel bad having a piece of fruit or a glass of milk during the day. I also try to avoid sugars (heavily refined with morally poor growing practices) and artificial sweeteners (hello cancer!) and anything that might contain these.
Anything that says it's "enriched", "fortified", "refined", has had anything added to it to make it "better for you", or, generally, anything that says "healthy", "low fat", "no fat", or "low carb friendly" even is generally extremely bad for you. Read the ingredients lists of the things you buy. If you can't pronounce the ingredients, don't eat it. If you still insist on buying it, research the ingredients. I do this with everything I put in, on, or near my body, and you'll be surprised what it turns up.
Know your food. Know what you eat. Eat low carb if you think it's what will be good for you. Try eating less bread, pasta, rice, potatoes and sugar, cut out processed foods, and eat your fruits, vegetables, free range eggs, pastured meat and chicken, fresh wild caught fish, quality dairy products and milk, and grass-fed butter. Shop only in the fresh food sections of the store (usually around the perimeter) and stay away from the aisles unless you need foil, paper towels, or other non-consumables.
If there's one thing I can say about the traditional food pyramid, it is what has destroyed my health.0 -
I do lowER carb - 15%, but I also stay within my calorie goal - it's not a protein buffett all day! LOL
It's working well for me.0 -
im a low carb nut
i have great sites for yu...and some real good tricks
i am doing it because im a type 2 diabetic
would love to talk0 -
There is no magical advantage. It still comes down to calories in vs calories out.0
-
As far as calories in vs calories out go, I advise you read the book Why We get Fat and What To Do About It, by Gary Taubes.0
-
I've mostly elimated simple carbs (processed food) and eat complex carbs- fruits, vegetables, lean protien, eggs, skim milk, a little cheese and have lost 64 lbs in a year. I have no problem eating this way and plan to the rest of my life. It is calories in and calories out, the difference is that eliminating all the simple carbs have taken my cravings away and allowed me to be in control. I eat because I need to to live, not because an insulin spike is compelling me to. I can (and do) pass up sweets, junk, all of it. If I choose to indulge once in awhile, I know how to quickly gain control again. I feel better than I've ever felt.0
-
I'm gonna be honest - I did extremely low carb (20 net carbs/day), combined with exercise, and lost 90lbs in about six months. Now I was also only eating around 1200-1500 calories per day, I was also 320lbs and I was only 22 years old when I started. When you first start it is REALLY hard but after about two weeks you start to feel better and actually I gained more energy.
The object is to do really low carb until you get down to your goal weight and then slowly start to add back whole grains. You can expect to gain a little weight back but you have to find the right amount of carbs so that you may maintain.
I didn't make it to my goal weight (because I got pregnant) and now that I'm eating normal I do find it hard to lose weight as fast. The problem for me is mental because I was so used to dropping 6-8lbs per week that only seeing 2lbs today kinda sucks.
BEFORE you try anything please consult with your physician. Also, the key to a healthy lifestyle is to find something that works for you. You will always have people that disagree but in the end you are the only one that matters.0 -
I was doing low carb and it was working fine, until I started adding back in real exercise (running and 30 Day Shred). I was dizzy and shaky, but it cleared up immediately once I bumped my carbs back up. I'm at between 30-40% carbs per day now. Like others have said, it is still calories in, calories out.0
-
I've lost 207 pounds doing low carb for the last 2 years. I had to decide that i would never eat the "bad carbs" good carbs yes veggies etc.. It can be done its hard yes and people do gain it back because it is very very very hard to go anywhere and not have carbs stuck in your face. I buy my groceries and cook totally different meals than my family.. going out to eat is pretty much impossible but ive figured ways around it. DONT DO IT JUST TO LOSE A FEW POUNDS ITS A COMPLETE LIFESTYLE CHANGE
BTW IT WAS THE ONLY THING THAT WORKED FOR ME. I WAS 420 LBS AND A DIABETIC.0 -
I would definitely not jump into Atkins etc unprepared, do a bit of research first. I like Gary Taubes 'Why we get fat and what to do about it' but my favourite is Jenny Ruhl's 'Diet 101: The truth about low carb diets'. She provides a very balanced view which you don't really get in any of the Atkins books (or Gary Taubes' book), she has a website as well. What I took away from Jenny's book; if your blood glucose is fine there is really no compelling reason to go on a low carb diet as you will lose weight on the classic low fat, moderate carb diet. If you do have Type II Diabetes (or are pre-diabetic), lowering your carbs will benefit you but there is no need to go very low (ie go on a ketogenic diet), sticking to about 100 grams of carbs a day will yield similar benefits as a very low carb diet of 20 grams a day.
I agree with what others have said, the best diet is the one that works for you and that you can stick with. If that's not the case it will just be a short term solution and there's a large chance that you will quickly gain what you lost.
Good luck with whatever you decide to do.0 -
Too low carb = low energy for me. A healthy balance of good carbs is all you need. All boils down to the calorie in vs. calorie out anyway.0
-
As far as calories in vs calories out go, I advise you read the book Why We get Fat and What To Do About It, by Gary Taubes.
LoLTaubes your advice is invalid.0 -
Has anybody had as much success doing a low carb diet as they advertise?? Thinking about trying it. Any input??
The best diet is the one that is easiest for you to adhere to, barring any medical issues that require special diet practices. Low carbers as with other "special" diets like to make all sorts of fantastic claims about their diet that are more fantasy then reality
Yes, this. I have had success, but I have hypertriglyceridemia that responds best to lower carb.0 -
I get such a kick out of the mindless people who say " low carb is too restrictive, or you cant maintian it..." Like their knowledge is vastly superior to everyone elses.
You can have a good healthy diet while moderating your carbs and lose weight, and its not hard, you dont have to deny yourself indulgences.. just make smart choices, track your macros and excercise. If it works for you, then thats excellent, if not, you have to find another approcach. But dont listend to the fitness bozos who make broad based comments that it cant and wont work.... like they speak for the entire population.
BTW... been doing primal since 1 Jan, down 17 lbs.. I still drink Diet coke, have a cookie once in a while etc and for excercise I only walk a mile a day. I'm not deprived, I'm not hungry, I dont get spikes or lows. And all this by maintiaining 50-100 grams of carbs a day. It IS doable.0 -
I've lost 207 pounds doing low carb for the last 2 years. I had to decide that i would never eat the "bad carbs" good carbs yes veggies etc.. It can be done its hard yes and people do gain it back because it is very very very hard to go anywhere and not have carbs stuck in your face. I buy my groceries and cook totally different meals than my family.. going out to eat is pretty much impossible but ive figured ways around it. DONT DO IT JUST TO LOSE A FEW POUNDS ITS A COMPLETE LIFESTYLE CHANGE
BTW IT WAS THE ONLY THING THAT WORKED FOR ME. I WAS 420 LBS AND A DIABETIC.
Congrats!0 -
I've lost 207 pounds doing low carb for the last 2 years. I had to decide that i would never eat the "bad carbs" good carbs yes veggies etc.. It can be done its hard yes and people do gain it back because it is very very very hard to go anywhere and not have carbs stuck in your face. I buy my groceries and cook totally different meals than my family.. going out to eat is pretty much impossible but ive figured ways around it. DONT DO IT JUST TO LOSE A FEW POUNDS ITS A COMPLETE LIFESTYLE CHANGE
BTW IT WAS THE ONLY THING THAT WORKED FOR ME. I WAS 420 LBS AND A DIABETIC.
Congrats!
Thank you0 -
If you're not getting enough energy from your food, you're not getting enough fat in your diet. This low fat/no fat bull**** is the most destructive advice I've ever seen advocated. You need fat to fuel your body and oh, maybe do a few repairs here and there too. Just because you're an adult doesn't mean your body isn't constantly repairing and replacing itself, and fat is an efficient, slow burning substance that leaves you feeling full and satisfied for longer.
Your brain is 66% fat. Whether you like it or not, you are all fat heads. So don't be afraid of butter, egg yolks, coconut oil, or clean animal fats, especially for your children. (If you are feeding your children low fat/no fat, then I have no respect for you. It's child abuse in my book, because guess what they need to build bones, organs, and most importantly, their brains? That's right: FAT.)0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions