Visible ribs, but I still have a belly. What's going on?
ibvitale
Posts: 11
Hi FitnessPal people! Thanks in advance for your help. I'm a 21 year old female, 5'6, just in case that is helpful.
Okay, so my problem is, I'm at the point where my bones are showing more than I'd like (very visible ribs in front & back, jutting hips, etc), but my stomach still looks pudgy! How do I fix this? Do I need to carry on losing weight? I don't want to gain, because obviously I've been losing for about a year (a slow process!), & my stomach was even bigger & less fit when I weighed more.
Anyone else in the same boat?
Okay, so my problem is, I'm at the point where my bones are showing more than I'd like (very visible ribs in front & back, jutting hips, etc), but my stomach still looks pudgy! How do I fix this? Do I need to carry on losing weight? I don't want to gain, because obviously I've been losing for about a year (a slow process!), & my stomach was even bigger & less fit when I weighed more.
Anyone else in the same boat?
0
Replies
-
You don't say what you do for exercise but probably you need to focus more on strength training. Build some muscles instead of just trying to lose weight. I hate the term skinny fat but if you just lose weight without exercise you can still have a high proportion of fat that gives that pudgy look.0
-
You don't say what you do for exercise but probably you need to focus more on strength training. Build some muscles instead of just trying to lose weight. I hate the term skinny fat but if you just lose weight without exercise you can still have a high proportion of fat that gives that pudgy look.
DITTO0 -
I've just recently started a workout video with some crunches included, so hopefully that will help. Wayyyy too poor to afford a gym membership, unfortunately. Do I just need to workout & build muscle?0
-
Holding fat in your belly is also the result of simply being a woman. Estrogen dominance causes us to store fat around the middle and in your thighs. A low glycemic "diet" (or rather food choices- i.e., low carb and sugar) can help with that. Also, strength training will tone your body. You might not lose weight, but you'll be firmer and less jiggly.0
-
Start eating to maintain weight instead of losing it. Then focus on strength training. Since muscle weighs more than fat, this may cause you to gain weight, but you will actually look thinner and more toned. it's worth it.0
-
I'm in the exact same boat. My hips can protrude out, m spine is too visible for my liking when i bend over, and my ribs are showing. But I am anything but skinny-mini (still a size 10 pant and 25% BF). I still have a large amount of fat to lose in my belly and thighs. I am hoping that more strength training will help this, I want to start lowering BF% now instead of lowering the number on the scale. I'm interested in hearing what others, possibly more educated, have to say.0
-
You don't need cardio you need muscles! You do not have to go to a gym for it but Google "using body weight for exercise", or this book is 9 bucks http://www.amazon.com/You-Are-Your-Own-Gym/dp/03455285810
-
How are losing weight? Diet only? Diet and Exercise?
Your nutrition has a lot to do with belly fat. Eating well and eating the right food is important.
A good mix of cardio and strength training, with nutrition, is the best way to lose fat all over, including your stomach.
Good way to look at it, ever see those guys with huge biceps and huge legs at the gym that still have a big tummy?
Not to say that's what your issue is but remember you can't spot train your tummy, so overall cardiovascular exercise is important to lose fat all over and again, eating the right foods. : ) 0 -
. Since muscle weighs more than fat, this may cause you to gain weight
Muscle does not weigh more then fat it just takes up less space..If you build bigger muscles you then will notice the scale move a bit. but to do that you need to eat at a surplus.0 -
I've been losing through diet & cardio, pretty much stopped the cardio now that I'm thin everywhere else except my stomach.... Trying to eat more protein, but I feel like maybe that's made me consume more fat as well.
Seems like the overall consensus I'm getting is, tone up!0 -
I'm a size 1-2, so I wouldn't say I'm fat, but I just feel that I don't look properly fit. I feel like you guys probably got the gist of that anyway, but just in case it helps, I'm pretty small.0
-
Strength train, you need to use those ab muscles to get them less "pudgy" looking. I have the same problem.0
-
You don't need cardio you need muscles! You do not have to go to a gym for it but Google "using body weight for exercise", or this book is 9 bucks http://www.amazon.com/You-Are-Your-Own-Gym/dp/0345528581
I have this book and the APP. I can really feel a difference in my body composition! Hope to soon schedule time to lift heavier, but the Bodyweight (with added dumbbells) is working well for now.0 -
I've been losing through diet & cardio, pretty much stopped the cardio now that I'm thin everywhere else except my stomach.... Trying to eat more protein, but I feel like maybe that's made me consume more fat as well.
Seems like the overall consensus I'm getting is, tone up!
Add weight lifting. Start small and light at first if you need to.0 -
I agree with the posts that suggest strength training, you probably need to add some core work to start if you are not already doing this.
but.....a flat stomach/abs happen in the kitchen. What are you eating regularly? Are you eating clean? try to cut out some of the processed foods, white flour, sugar, sugar substitutes, etc and see if that helps at all0 -
Yep it is another website that is free is nerd fitness the creator is a big proponent of body weight exercise also that you do not need a gym to work out and has some neat exercises that you can do in your home to tone up:bigsmile: .0
-
I agree with the posts that suggest strength training, you probably need to add some core work to start if you are not already doing this.
but.....a flat stomach/abs happen in the kitchen. What are you eating regularly? Are you eating clean? try to cut out some of the processed foods, white flour, sugar, sugar substitutes, etc and see if that helps at all
Unfortunately, as a broke university student, I'm definitely not eating clean. Though I don't really overeat (occasionally, but seldom), I do eat a lot of chocolate/coffee/whatever is around. I love healthy food like fruits & veg, as well as yogurt, it's just hard to come by.0 -
How much do you weigh? Generally, its poor body composition that prevents some from getting a flat stomach.0
-
Hi FitnessPal people! Thanks in advance for your help. I'm a 21 year old female, 5'6, just in case that is helpful.
Okay, so my problem is, I'm at the point where my bones are showing more than I'd like (very visible ribs in front & back, jutting hips, etc), but my stomach still looks pudgy! How do I fix this? Do I need to carry on losing weight? I don't want to gain, because obviously I've been losing for about a year (a slow process!), & my stomach was even bigger & less fit when I weighed more.
Anyone else in the same boat?
Honestly if your hip bones are jutting out, you are probably just noticing the contrast of your stomach with the surrounding bony area, versus your stomach ACTUALLY sticking out! At how bony you sound, I highly doubt that your stomach actually "looks pudgy". Sounds like a bit of body dysmorphia to me
0 -
Your not the only one, i've gained 2 stone over the last few years and i'm still ribby and bony up top but have a rather large belly. Just starting to try and get the weight back off again. Planning on doing some pilates core body exercise routines as I diet.0
-
I've just recently started a workout video with some crunches included, so hopefully that will help. Wayyyy too poor to afford a gym membership, unfortunately. Do I just need to workout & build muscle?
Crunches will do absolutely nothing for reducing the fat on your belly, I'm sorry to say. You body will lose weight wherever you are genetically predisposed to lose fat from. Some people are just prone to holding onto fat in one specific are while the rest of the body leans out. For me, it's the inner thighs.
Look up Convict Conditioning, or You Are Your Own Gym, to build strength and retain muscle mass just by using your own body weight, if you can't afford a gym.
1 -
This content has been removed.
-
-
My ribs show and I still have a belly. It's very frustrating, but I am resolved to lift more heavy weights to develop upper body muscle and hopefully still eat at a deficit to get rid of the belly.0
-
It could also be fat packed around your organs. Read wheat belly by dr davis, and grain brain by dr perlmutter, for more explanation.0
-
Old post, people, I imagine the Op found her solution or did not.0
-
Something weird is going on and not because I got necro pwnd... I found this at the top of the General Fitness when I replied..
0 -
Something weird is going on and not because I got necro pwnd... I found this at the top of the General Fitness when I replied..
Maybe it is a haunted thread.
0 -
IDK OP but hopefully since February 2013 you found your answer.0
Truth
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions