Message for those asking for help

Very true! but i think many are afraid of sharing that intimate part of their lives, so it is hard.

Very true! but i think many are afraid of sharing that intimate part of their lives, so it is hard.

I agree. Sadly, while some of us like to look at diaries to give genuine, friendly advice... I have seen some be brutally torn apart. I certainly would not want to be on the receiving end of that.

I whole-heartedly agree with making one's food diary public. Not only does it help other members by giving good ideas, but it has also made me more accountable knowing that my friends are going to look at what I ate. And, as Dan says, if you are not sure why your meal plans aren't working for you, there are a lot of knowledgeable people here that want to help and can do so by looking at what you are eating.

Very true! but i think many are afraid of sharing that intimate part of their lives, so it is hard.

I agree. Sadly, while some of us like to look at diaries to give genuine, friendly advice... I have seen some be brutally torn apart. I certainly would not want to be on the receiving end of that.

We learn from out mistakes. How can you offer proper help if you can not see where there may be a possible problem. If someone wants to make their Diary private later they are welcome to. And those that are going to be unfriendly about giving help will be unfriendly even if they don't see someones diary. I just want to be able to help someone the best I can.

I partly agree with what you say... I would certainly never see a patient without taking a diet history. That said, you can certainly give basic nutrition advice without seeing what somebody is eating. I agree that people may be unkind anyway but somehow there seems to be so much difference between for example this:

No diary - 'Eating a lot of packaged food is bad and they are often high in calories/sugar/fat'
Diary - 'You are eating so much processed crap, it's no wonder you aren't losing weight'

I can just see why people wouldn't want it to be too personal.

Absolutely, and in general I have seen people take quite personal advice very well when it is given in that manner... we can only hope more people learn to keep it that way!! :happy:

I guess I feel that I can still be honest and offer advice without being rude. I didn't say that you should tell everyone that everything they are doing is great, obviously they have asked for advice. But adding mean remarks about the knowledge/personality/attitude/motivation of the person isn't really necessary to getting your point across, that's all.

And I agree with you that there are too many people that are being way to blunt and not give advise but scolding the person asking for help. We need to offer our help by suggesting ideas ("You might want to try doing...) instead of telling people they're wrong ("Well no wonder you're not loosing weight you're...) :-)

This thread is probably in regards to a post I made earlier telling the OP that it wasn't necessary to open her diary for all to see. I do agree with you, that it is easier to give advice to others when we can see their eating habits. But, as I've went onto threads to post and give feedback I've noticed a LOT of really harsh criticism and very rude people. Some people have good intentions, but the way it comes out sounds horrible. Quite honestly, the reason I don't think its necessary sometimes for people to open their Diary is because if they aren't being honest with themselves in a forum discussion, its likely they aren't recording everything they are eating anyways. But, if they are truly trying to find out "what more they can do" (my favorite 5 words) then I think its necessary for them to open the Diary to allow us to help them sort out the good from bad. And help them realize that some foods they eat may not be as good for them as they thought. (Or at least help them make their own opinions on what is considered "clean" eating for them)

I do agree that if someone wants to ask personal questions such as "What should I be eating" then they should be prepared to share what they are eating with their Diary so we can help. My approach to getting answers that I am looking for is to ask what YOU eat rather than ask what I SHOULD eat. That way I don't feel obligated to share my diary to some of the trolls out there who are looking to tear me down. I didn't come here for that. Typically, if someone isn't willing to share specifics in their original post (such as their weight, height, current exercise, current food patterns) then I'll give them general answers. If they want personal things, they're gonna have to share personal specifics, including their Diary. They're gonna have to have some thick skin because if they are eating crap and not exercising I be giving them some tough love. Sometimes we need to be blunt- especially when I hear "I can't seem to lose any weight!" and then their diary shows they've been eating at Wendy's all week and no exercise. They've asked, so I will answer. So, in conclusion, I agree with you. Those of you who want advice, REALLY want advice, get real with yourself, and share your Diary so we can help you. And if the trolls come around, just brush them off, don't feed them! Some people may be mean, but in the end, I think you'll find that many more people were offering good advice that you can learn from.

In the early beginnings I had my Diary open so that I could get good advice on what to change. It was very helpful and I had some great constructive criticism. At this point where I'm at now, I don't need the advice and therefore do not share my Diary with the public.

Edited: because once again I get a little too long winded. I could still edit more and take out my blah-blah-blahs, (I am SO like my mother) but I'm too lazy.

I do know what you mean! I have posted topics that said the tiniest thing about a way of eating e.g. a single comment about one certain dietary restriction within a whole article and people have replied saying I have bashed them personally for saying that about the way they eat (even though they had nothing to do with the post and I didn't even know them). So I do appreciate your frustration! :flowerforyou:

I love when people have theirs able to view..I like getting ideas! I think mine is friends only, but I've been wanting to share it with everyone. I don't always reach my calories, so I also don't want to be *****ed at haha. I'm always really busy, and have a hard time fitting all my calories into my day. Especially lately. I'll be glad to undo mine, if anyone wants to look at it for ideas. I eat clean. I use nothing processed, boxed, etc.

I have to say that if someone asks for an opinion in an open forum, you are inviting everyones view. I have done this before, mostly in the first 6 months. I did not like all of what was posted, but I took it into consideration.

One such remark has stuck with me since early on. He was a rather blunt person and when I posted a thread stating I had no time to cook things fresh,he pointed out I had been on MFP posting why I could NOT do things for a few hours:laugh:

To this day when I think about skipping an exercise session, or opening a can of peas, his AV comes to mind.

The problem with always being ultra supportive is that we lose the honest feedback that can bring positive results.

IMHO:flowerforyou:

:drinker: I couldn't have said it better!

If I ask a question here about my individual situation I fully understand I'm going to probably be ridiculed along with getting some really bad advice. If I'm lucky I may get some good relevant information mixed in, too. I take a lot of factors into consideration when reading responses here: who seems to know what they're talking about and what personal experience they have with the topic and what information they've provided to support their viewpoint and THEN I draw my conclusions from there.I believe the vast majority of MFP users are very well intentioned. But a lot of us are ignorant and/or tactless, too. :laugh: I have seen some horribly irresponsible advice being given on MFP. However, there is a lot of what I believe to be very good and helpful information here in the archives, you just have to know how to sort it out.

I very rarely post topics here. If I'm looking for comments on a specific topic, I search the post archives first. That way I don't put myself out there and I still get some good opinions and information about the subject.