running shoes?

I'm getting ready for my first 5k, what are your favorite running shoes for women? I've been through so many pairs of running shoes, and can't find the perfect one!
«1

Replies

  • nexangelus
    nexangelus Posts: 2,080 Member
    Minimalist here - vibrams all the way. : )
  • kgalea
    kgalea Posts: 156 Member
    Brooks, then Saucony then Asics
  • meerkat70
    meerkat70 Posts: 4,605 Member
    Brooks.

    Have you been to a good shop, and been properly fitted? Might be cheaper, long term, than working through lots of failed pairs?
  • AllonsYtotheTardis
    AllonsYtotheTardis Posts: 16,947 Member
    Get to a running store, and have them analyse your gait - it's the best way to get good recommendations, as everyone moves differently. What's the best shoe for me, might be the absolute worst shoe for you.
  • jdp9130
    jdp9130 Posts: 18 Member
    Get to a running store, and have them analyse your gait - it's the best way to get good recommendations, as everyone moves differently. What's the best shoe for me, might be the absolute worst shoe for you.
    This for sure. We just bought my wife a new pair at the local running store and they spent all the time we needed to get the right shoes for her, Saucony for her and me too.
  • moodyshannon15
    moodyshannon15 Posts: 39 Member
    Brooks..for walking and running
  • nexangelus
    nexangelus Posts: 2,080 Member
    Yes, we all know the running shop/store story, I was gait measured and plonked in the most stupid stability shoes for overpronation (used to wear new balance and saucony). I suffered shin splints, achilles tendonitis, all sorts of injuries on and off for many years. Also had to have sports massage to straighten out the horrible aches and pains in my calves. I then tried to run with no stability, strengthen my feet, ankles and calves by running "barefoot". I have had no injuries this whole year of running this way. I also run faster and longer too : )

    So....you need to experiment a little and don't necessarily take what the running shops/stores to heart or as truth. Running free of injury is what made the decision for me. I know this is probably a costly way to do things...

    Just my story, there may be many who are happy/injury free with their running shop recommended footwear ; )
  • MsBobLoblaw
    MsBobLoblaw Posts: 171 Member
    I took up running when rehabbing from ACL surgery. My PT, along with the local running store Fleet Feet, recommended Asics Gel-Nimbus because of the cushioning, as well as it fit whatever my foot type/running style was (I can't remember). I've gone through several pair now, and I love them.
  • Otterluv
    Otterluv Posts: 9,083 Member
    Brooks for running, Asics for walkabout shoes.

    Prior to hurting my foot, I was fine running in Asics. But my injury made shoes with more aggressive support necessary.
  • Chris99mu
    Chris99mu Posts: 352 Member
    I'm a Pearl Izumi fan all the way. But recently got Mizuno Wave Rider 16s. So far, not bad :-)
  • Chris99mu
    Chris99mu Posts: 352 Member
    Yes, we all know the running shop/store story, I was gait measured and plonked in the most stupid stability shoes for overpronation (used to wear new balance and saucony). I suffered shin splints, achilles tendonitis, all sorts of injuries on and off for many years. Also had to have sports massage to straighten out the horrible aches and pains in my calves. I then tried to run with no stability, strengthen my feet, ankles and calves by running "barefoot". I have had no injuries this whole year of running this way. I also run faster and longer too : )

    So....you need to experiment a little and don't necessarily take what the running shops/stores to heart or as truth. Running free of injury is what made the decision for me. I know this is probably a costly way to do things...

    Just my story, there may be many who are happy/injury free with their running shop recommended footwear ; )

    FYI, another MFPer turned me onto Roadrunner Sports (.com). 10% off list, free shipping and *90* days to try and return. I was sold :-).
  • Zekela
    Zekela Posts: 634 Member
    New Balance. I'm flat footed and need the support.
  • dcander2
    dcander2 Posts: 19
    I used to buy Nikes but now I LOVE my Asics and buy a new pair every year. But don't get the cheaper ones, it's the ones closer to $100 with the thick gel in the heel that are great. I also have been itching for the new balance minimus shoes but haven't quite gotten myself to buy them because I'm nervous of switching to a more barefoot type shoe.

    Just make sure to break them in before your 5k! :)
  • 3laine75
    3laine75 Posts: 3,069 Member
    Yes, we all know the running shop/store story, I was gait measured and plonked in the most stupid stability shoes for overpronation (used to wear new balance and saucony). I suffered shin splints, achilles tendonitis, all sorts of injuries on and off for many years. Also had to have sports massage to straighten out the horrible aches and pains in my calves. I then tried to run with no stability, strengthen my feet, ankles and calves by running "barefoot". I have had no injuries this whole year of running this way. I also run faster and longer too : )

    So....you need to experiment a little and don't necessarily take what the running shops/stores to heart or as truth. Running free of injury is what made the decision for me. I know this is probably a costly way to do things...

    Just my story, there may be many who are happy/injury free with their running shop recommended footwear ; )

    This^
    I went for gait analysis as I get shin splints - the ones the girl sold me have made it ten times worse - my £11 jjb ones weren't half as bad :S
  • meerkat70
    meerkat70 Posts: 4,605 Member
    The poster did say a *good* running shop. I've never been 'plonked' in anything at the shop I go to. I try several shoes, on the mill, and they have a fair returns policy.



    And more importantly, Shin splints are far more likely caused by overuse, than by bad shoes....
  • nexangelus
    nexangelus Posts: 2,080 Member
    The poster did say a *good* running shop. I've never been 'plonked' in anything at the shop I go to. I try several shoes, on the mill, and they have a fair returns policy.



    And more importantly, Shin splints are far more likely caused by overuse, than by bad shoes....

    I went to the best running shop in my city. And I have never overused my shoes or my legs...the injuries were caused by the good stability shoes recommended by the best running shop in my city after having gait measured by running on a treadmill. I could not return the shoes as fair use was well done by the time I had recurring shin splints. Heel strike running is not suited to my legs or body as I found out and with stability shoes there is no way you can run on your forefoot...

    I said this was my story...not everyone does well in even the best shoe shop recommendations... ; )
  • ToughMudderAddict
    ToughMudderAddict Posts: 290 Member
    Minimalist here - vibrams all the way. : )

    Absolutely, love my Vibrams!

    I used to get really bad knee and hip pain when I ran and after I switched to my Vibrams the pain disappeared and my running times improved. Win/Win!
  • Sieden76
    Sieden76 Posts: 127 Member
    Asics Kanao
  • casuzyq
    casuzyq Posts: 6 Member
    Definately recommend a GOOD running store such as Fleet Feet. They will analyze your gait, etc., but as pointed out they don't always get it right. A GOOD running store will typically allow you to exchange the shoes within a certain of days. I used to wear support shoes, but now with custom orthotics I need a neutral shoe. The Mizunos felt great in the store, but on the road, not so much. Was able to exchange for another shoe that is working great. The proper shoe will depend upon your biomechanics. Once you find the right shoe, then buying on line is a breeze.
  • ze_hombre
    ze_hombre Posts: 377 Member
    Brooks PURE minimalists. Love them as does my wife.
  • Brooks
  • eep223
    eep223 Posts: 624 Member
    You need to get to a running specialty shop and have them analyze your gait. Everyone has their favorites, but different brands work for different shaped feet. I finally went to a specialty shop after running for a year in my old shoes, and it truly makes all the difference in the world! Just make sure you give yourself enough time to get used to the new shoes before your race, though.
  • coacherik
    coacherik Posts: 73
    FInd a good running shoe store... I went in, they sized me up and I am in Brooks Beasts... No more ankle pain, Knee Pain, or back pain. A good Running Shoe Store will size you up correctly. FYI... they are not cheap... I use to pay $40-50 for Asics and wore by them... now I pay $140... but they are SOOOOO worth every penny!!!
  • EricV440
    EricV440 Posts: 11 Member
    Saucony is the only shoe that I can run in.
    Go to two or three running stores and get a gait analysis done. Hopefully, they will all agree on what type of runner you are. Also, get your feet measured. You may be surprised at the size! I wore a 9.5 standard, off the shelf shoe for most of my adult life. The size I wear now is 10.5 4E! In some instances, a size 11 shoe.
    Try on a bunch of shoes and write down the ones you like. Tell the shop that you need to think about it.

    Go online to Zappos and order the shoes you want. Zappos has free, fast shipping both ways, and a 365 day return policy. Sign up for the VIP club and you get preferred shipping. I don't know how they do it, but I order a pair of shoes on Thursday and they are here in SoFla by Friday!

    They also have a good selection and large sizes. I wear a 10.5 4E shoe, which isn't the easiest size to find.

    The other thing you may want to try is inserts. There are a whole bunch out there and you can try those with your shoes to get the most comfort.
  • Asics, Brooks, Mizuno. In that order.
  • Doodlewhopper
    Doodlewhopper Posts: 1,018 Member
    I used to buy Nikes but now I LOVE my Asics and buy a new pair every year. But don't get the cheaper ones, it's the ones closer to $100 with the thick gel in the heel that are great. I also have been itching for the new balance minimus shoes but haven't quite gotten myself to buy them because I'm nervous of switching to a more barefoot type shoe.

    Just make sure to break them in before your 5k! :)

    I now have 3 pair of Asics Kayano collecting dust since I got the NB Minimus. My experience with the shoe has been A+. Durability is disappointing (I got the trail shoe though Im a road runner)

    I might try the Minimus Road shoe next or probably the Merrell Road Glove. http://www.merrell.com/US/en-US/Product.mvc.aspx/26342M/69118/Mens/Barefoot-Run-Road-Glove
  • Doodlewhopper
    Doodlewhopper Posts: 1,018 Member
    The poster did say a *good* running shop. I've never been 'plonked' in anything at the shop I go to. I try several shoes, on the mill, and they have a fair returns policy.



    And more importantly, Shin splints are far more likely caused by overuse, than by bad shoes....

    Sorta right. Shin splints are generally caused by the "Terrible Toos" - Too far, Too soon, Too hard....but engineered shoes can & do contribute.
  • LissaK1981
    LissaK1981 Posts: 219 Member
    Go get fitted. I got Brooks and will be getting another pair after I eat through these ones :)
  • LoosingMyLast15
    LoosingMyLast15 Posts: 1,457 Member
    brooks then new balance. right now my fav pair is brooks glycerin 9. if you're going to continue with your running get fitted for a good pair. HUGE DIFFERENCE.
  • LoraF83
    LoraF83 Posts: 15,694 Member
    Get to a running store, and have them analyse your gait - it's the best way to get good recommendations, as everyone moves differently. What's the best shoe for me, might be the absolute worst shoe for you.

    Agreed.