We are pleased to announce that on March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor will be introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the upcoming changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

Is it ok to be under my calorie goal (1,200) on some days?

LibbyFelicity
LibbyFelicity Posts: 16
edited January 21 in Food and Nutrition
Is it ok to be under my calorie goal (1,200) on some days to make up for days when I go over it by a large amount?
Basically on some weekends I drink alcohol and eat junk food, I don't log these days but I can imagine that the calories are probably 2,000-3,000 on those days. I'm just wondering if it's ok if in the days following these cheat days I eat under my goal of 1,200 calories? For example I had a bit of a cheat weekend last weekend and this week my calories have ranged from 800-1,175. Is this ok?

Replies

  • Laurelthequeen
    Laurelthequeen Posts: 78
    If you're losing, yes. If you're not, no.
  • jansiemoo
    jansiemoo Posts: 5 Member
    If you're losing, yes. If you're not, no.
    This.
    Due to my profession, my hours are erratic.
    I commonly eat 30-50% below my goal one day and over by 30% the next.
    But! My overall weekly goal is met or below, resulting in a net loss for the week.
    This is working very well for me, and I see it as similar to not weighing yourself everyday and fretting over
    one half pound lost/gained from day to day.
    Big picture, lifetime changes. :)
  • lindsayk324
    lindsayk324 Posts: 54 Member
    This actually a recognized form of caloric restriction called "calorie cycling" by laymen and "alternate-day fasting (ADF)" by nutritionists. Legitimate peer-reviewed scientific journals have published studies on ADF. This is a good summary of findings using animal and human subjects: http://ajcn.nutrition.org/content/86/1/7.full

    One study (http://ajcn.nutrition.org/content/81/1/69.abstract?ijkey=8244a073f4e997f5ecbc96499d98eaccdf3bbca2&keytype2=tf_ipsecsha) confirms body weight and body fat loss in their study on the effects of ADF on life-span. Following an ADF (or intermittent fasting) regime may work for some people better than strict same-calories-every-day restriction, and you'll get the same benefits as long as your weekly average turns out "correct".

    That said, my personal (unpublished :p) opinion is that 800 is a little too low. Also, make sure that those low days are as packed full of nutritional quality as possible! One big factor with ADF -- and all diets, really -- is that, to do it right, you've got to be mindful of not just the quantity of calories but the quality of them, as well.

    TL;DR - what you're doing is called calorie cycling or alternate-day fasting (ADF) and it's a scientifically recognized way to lose fat, but keep making sure you stay properly nourished in terms of food diversity, weekly macro breakdowns, and vitamin/minerals!
  • LibbyFelicity
    LibbyFelicity Posts: 16
    Thanks so much!
  • snowmanluv
    snowmanluv Posts: 200 Member
    Probably as long as not too low. Save up a few for the weekend days or special events.
  • minivegrunner
    minivegrunner Posts: 45
    I have the same calorie goal and am under on some days. I'm also over on some days too! I think it evens out. I'm loosing, but not at an alarming rate, just a slow, steady, HEALTHY one :)

    If that souds like you, I doubt there's reason to worry ;)
This discussion has been closed.

Categories