Started running, putting on weight..
sa1712
Posts: 11
I started running 3x a week the last 2 weeks and my weight loss stopped after week 1 and now after week 2 i've put on a half a kilogram.
I'm using the a running app which allows me an extra 300 calories on the running days. Is it better just to focus more on my diet? or not add the running calories?
I'm using the a running app which allows me an extra 300 calories on the running days. Is it better just to focus more on my diet? or not add the running calories?
0
Replies
-
One of this things that is often said on here is Patience! 2 weeks is not a long time to see a long term difference. There are lots of reasons why you are showing an increase on the scales but you just have to keep in mind that your body needs time to adjust to a new routine. You know that you are doing something right by running. You are eating good food - not too much, logging all that you eat? Then it's just time (and a Zen attitude that's needed :-P)
Come back here in two months and give us an update. In fact I'm off to my post that I made a few weeks ago (on exactly this topic!) to say that I'm now seeing more weigh coming off and a leaner looking body emerging.0 -
Ditto!
I have gained a pound in the last 1 week. I am not sure where I am going wrong. I eat clean, workout 3 times a week (cardio & wts).
My theory - may be muscles are building and they are holding water. (I am not sure if I am fooling myself!)
Will give it another 1-2 weeks and try again.0 -
Is it better just to focus more on my diet?
yes.or not add the running calories?
You might be overestimating the calorie burn, perhaps try eating back only 50% of the calories for a few weeks and see what happens. Although your first statement kind of implies you haven't been very on point with your diet, which would be the bigger issue.
(and it's not going to be muscle, I know that's going to get posted)0 -
How many calories are you eating? I'm a runner as well and I can't say as though I've ever gained weight from running but that doesn't mean it's not possible. Make sure your drinking lots of water to make up for what your sweating off. I would suggest getting a heart rate monitor if you don't have one as my running app extremely overestimates my calories burned.0
-
You just have started a new exercise...Let your body adjust to your new regime....Give it at least 2 months before making any decisions...continue with the great workout..:drinker:0
-
It's been two weeks. That's not long enough to tell anything, and half a kilo is negligible in the grand scheme of things. It's possible you are overestimating your burn, but it's unlikely that you've overestimated it by 3,500 calories in the past week (the rough amount you'd need to gain half a kilo of fat.) Even if you'd burned no calories at all running (likely?) and were eating over your goal by 300 calories each time, you'd probably still be eating within the deficit given to you by MFP.
One thing that happens when you start a new exercise programme, or increase intensity, is that your muscles retain water as they repair themselves, which can affect the numbers you see on the scale. I would relax, carry on, and give it a few more weeks before you start seeing real progress.0 -
How many calories are you eating? I'm a runner as well and I can't say as though I've ever gained weight from running but that doesn't mean it's not possible. Make sure your drinking lots of water to make up for what your sweating off. I would suggest getting a heart rate monitor if you don't have one as my running app extremely overestimates my calories burned.
im eating 1600 on days off, 1900 on running days. my carb and fat levels always stay in the green.
think i need to try a different exercise, as running only seems to let me eat more that day, i dont see it having many other benefits
im not really overweight (154 pounds/11 stone, 5ft 10) but feel very out of shape, skinny in some places/fat in others.0 -
im eating 1600 on days off, 1900 on running days. my carb and fat levels always stay in the green.
think i need to try a different exercise, as running only seems to let me eat more that day, i dont see it having many other benefits
im not really overweight (154 pounds/11 stone, 5ft 10) but feel very out of shape, skinny in some places/fat in others.
If you're wanting to change your body composition, then look into resistance training of some sort - body weight exercises or lifting weights. They will have a much more dramatic effect on how you look than cardio alone. I personally like a mix of cardio and strength - cardio for heart & lung fitness, endurance, and keeping my head in a good place. Strength for getting stronger, for maintaining muscle mass and bone density, and looking firmer.0 -
first of all... why are you eating extra calories? Exercise is supposed to burn calories.... you eat your basic cals per day, not eat extra to make up for the exercise, and someone else said, you may be overcalculating how much you are burning.
I can tell you right now... MFP is NOT accurate for exercise cals, ridiculously over generous.
I can see plain as day why you are gaining.... STOP eating your exercise cals. End of story.
AND congrats on starting to run, its awesome!!!!!!0 -
first of all... why are you eating extra calories? Exercise is supposed to burn calories.... you eat your basic cals per day, not eat extra to make up for the exercise, and someone else said, you may be overcalculating how much you are burning.
I can tell you right now... MFP is NOT accurate for exercise cals, ridiculously over generous.
I can see plain as day why you are gaining.... STOP eating your exercise cals. End of story.
AND congrats on starting to run, its awesome!!!!!!
On MFP plan you are suppose to eat your exercise calories back BUT you are right the exercise calories are probably way over. I would try and either get a HRM and track your calories that way or only eat back half of your exercise calories. You don't wanna eat to little and you don't wanna eat to much.0 -
first of all... why are you eating extra calories? Exercise is supposed to burn calories.... you eat your basic cals per day, not eat extra to make up for the exercise, and someone else said, you may be overcalculating how much you are burning.
I can tell you right now... MFP is NOT accurate for exercise cals, ridiculously over generous.
I can see plain as day why you are gaining.... STOP eating your exercise cals. End of story.
AND congrats on starting to run, its awesome!!!!!!
She is not actually gaining....as someone else mentioned, she'd have to be overeating by 3500 calories in a week for that weight loss! Plus, when MFP gives us calorie counts you are SUPPOSED to eat back any exercise calories because of the already generous deficit. I eat 1500 calories if I don't work out and between 1600-2600 if I do...depending on the workout and I still lose.
Your muscles are probably retaining water from the new regimen. When I started running, I didn't lose for 3-4 weeks and then I dropped 17 pounds over the next 9 weeks. Now I just started lifting because the scale is stalled again but I'm not expecting to see a drop for a few more weeks because my muscles are very sore. Keep at it, stay focused, and if you're worried about an inaccurate calorie burn, buy a heart rate monitor....you can get a really good one for about 60$. I know MFP actually UNDERESTIMATED my burns meaning I wasn't eating ENOUGH when I started running (I was eating 200-400 calories less than what I should be).0 -
first of all... why are you eating extra calories? Exercise is supposed to burn calories.... you eat your basic cals per day, not eat extra to make up for the exercise, and someone else said, you may be overcalculating how much you are burning.
I can tell you right now... MFP is NOT accurate for exercise cals, ridiculously over generous.
I can see plain as day why you are gaining.... STOP eating your exercise cals. End of story.
AND congrats on starting to run, its awesome!!!!!!
I'd be careful chucking around advice like that...there are far too many people on here who do not understand how MFP works as it is, they will see advice like yours about not eating back exercise calories and think they are doing something wrong if they eat back exercise calories. If you are following MFP calories guidelines your deficit is built into your allotted calories already. Exercise calories are added so you can eat more. Agreed, they may not be 100% accurate but I don't agree with anyone eating 1200 calories baseline unless medical reasons dictate.
OP, I would give it more time personally. If you enjoy running, then run. If you don't then stop. Cardio is good for the heart but you don't need it to lose weight. You only need to eat less than you burn to lose weight.0 -
Water retention.0
-
I never eat the calories I burn during exercise! I hate that they add them on there. I consider those my weight loss calories. I always hear that you have to burn more than your eat to lose weight. If I eat my exercise calories, how can I loss weight? That's just how I see it. I know a lot of people do eat them. It's a personal thing.
I would say do your measurements. Sometimes you see more inches lost than weight lost! Good luck!!0 -
I have gained 3 pounds from running, its all muscle in my calves and hamstrings. My legs look freaking awesome. I have a spectacular diet and I exercise so I put the scale away, it was freaking me out.0
-
I have gained 3 pounds from running, its all muscle in my calves and hamstrings. My legs look freaking awesome. I have a spectacular diet and I exercise so I put the scale away, it was freaking me out.
You think you gained 3 lbs of muscle from running? Like seriously?0 -
I gained loads of weight the first time I ever trained for a marathon- and completed it!
The problem was, I was over estimating the calorie burn.. I was thinking that when the treadmill said I'd burned 600+ calories, I could eat this back, but alas, when I invested in a really good heart rate monitor I found the calorie burn was around half of what the treadmill or cross trainer was telling me, grrr.
Also, I was seriously over doing it on the carbs- healthy carbs, but just far too many, I was constantly snacking on bowls of porridge, dried fruit, bananas, wholemeal bread.. Since Ive started strength training with a bit of cardio in the mornings, and changed the ratio of carbs and protein I've dropped over 15pounds, phew!!0 -
Running is good for you...nuff said.0
-
I have gained 3 pounds from running, its all muscle in my calves and hamstrings. My legs look freaking awesome. I have a spectacular diet and I exercise so I put the scale away, it was freaking me out.
Um...I seriously doubt that. You can definately tone up those muscles and gain strength (at first) as they are put to use, but I seriously doubt the muscle gain as you say. You might have gained -some- stength in your legs as a result from running (I have) but not 3 lbs of muscle.0 -
I have gained 3 pounds from running, its all muscle in my calves and hamstrings. My legs look freaking awesome. I have a spectacular diet and I exercise so I put the scale away, it was freaking me out.0
-
first of all... why are you eating extra calories? Exercise is supposed to burn calories.... you eat your basic cals per day, not eat extra to make up for the exercise, and someone else said, you may be overcalculating how much you are burning.
I can tell you right now... MFP is NOT accurate for exercise cals, ridiculously over generous.
I can see plain as day why you are gaining.... STOP eating your exercise cals. End of story.I never eat the calories I burn during exercise! I hate that they add them on there. I consider those my weight loss calories. I always hear that you have to burn more than your eat to lose weight. If I eat my exercise calories, how can I loss weight? That's just how I see it. I know a lot of people do eat them. It's a personal thing.
With respect, it sounds like you are both misunderstanding how Myfitnesspal works. It gives a calorie goal with a calorie deficit already built into it, based on the information you entered when you signed up. MFP asks about your daily activity level, but does not include planned exercise or workouts like going to the gym, or running. It includes the activity from your normal day to day activities like your job, or household chores, or shopping etc. How active you are in general. That forms the basis of the calorie goal you get, and it is based on the assumption that any workouts you do, you log those and eat back the extra calories. Otherwise, MFP would have included all planned exercise and would have given you a higher calorie goal to start with. With the calorie goal MFP gives you, you can lose weight with no formal exercise. Of course, exercise is beneficial for lots of reasons, but that's besides the point. The vast majority of your daily calorie burn comes from your body's normal processes that keep you alive, and your normal daily activities. Those are really your "weight loss calories".
If, for example, you tell MFP you are sedentary, and then you go running 3 times a week, MFP will have given you a goal based on you being sedentary, and any additional exercise will be making your calorie deficit bigger. Sounds good, but having too large of a calorie deficit can be unhealthy and counter-productive over time. You risk losing far more lean mass than you would do otherwise, and you also risk messing up your hormones. This is especially true the closer you are to a healthy weight.
Now, a lot of people on MFP choose to customise their calorie goal to include all the activity and exercise they do. They don't "eat back" their exercise calories, but they end up with a larger calorie goal to start with.
It is a "personal thing" how big a calorie deficit you ultimately choose to have, some people decide to eat 500 calories a day and that's their choice. Doesn't mean it's a good idea. Understanding how MFP works is a good start, and giving blanket advice to stop eating exercise calories back is a really bad idea. In general, people who are obese and have larger amounts of fat stored can "get away with" large calorie deficits more than people who are closer to a healthy weight.0 -
Well, running and eating all my calories back. And yes, the three pounds is in my legs.
I should mention that I was underweight and when I thought was eating maintenance, I was still under eating. I started actually eating what my fitbit said I should be instead of what I calculated my TDEE to be. My legs looked like sticks. My massage therapist just commented recently about how toned and muscular my legs have gotten lately.
I have gone from 112 to 115 and the ONLY thing that has changed is the size of my calves and hamstrings. Still a size 2 and a XS.0 -
I started running 3x a week the last 2 weeks and my weight loss stopped after week 1 and now after week 2 i've put on a half a kilogram.
I'm using the a running app which allows me an extra 300 calories on the running days. Is it better just to focus more on my diet? or not add the running calories?
why, do you think you're not focusing enough on your diet?
are you running on an incline? I put on a little muscle weight when I run but there are hills where I am ...0 -
I was in the same situation as you about 2 years ago. I was eating 2500 calories and spent about 1 hour a day running. On top of that I was lifting weights. I decided to go to the doctor and check my cortisol level which is the stress hormones level and they were three times as high as they should be, both morning and night. I did a bit more research and backed down on exercise levels while increasing my calories. After dong that I got down to my goal weight. Also my cortisol levels returned to normal. I may be the exception but I did what worked for me lol.0
-
From what I've heard a lot of the weight you lose in the first week is often water weight and the loss slows a bit for a couple of weeks and then picks up and you start to lose a little more steadily. I don't eat my calories back on days that I run, and eat back most of what I do on the days (mostly just extra protein) on days that I strength train.0
-
Your muscles are probably retaining water from the new regimen.
^^^This. Your muscles retain water when you start new exercise. I'm a runner and I recently started commuting to work by bike. I gained about 2 lbs for a week before I went back to my previous weight. Just let you body get used to it.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions