Lost 49lbs...gained back 13lbs.....what's going on?
Ducati58
Posts: 20 Member
If anyone can give me some help in this, I would appreciate it!! I am 55, walk 4 miles six days a week, Spin class once a week, trying to keep my carbs under 150 grams....did really great keeping the weight off up until December and have since started gaining...have been taking CLA supplements recently....but not any other big changes....diet is pretty much the same as last year....went through blood tests a couple of months ago and my thyroid is ok....I am thinking maybe it's because I am in menopause and need hormone replacement....I am stumped..... 
0
Replies
-
When I was young I could eat anything, or under eat, and I'd spring back to healthy looking with little effort and time. Now i'm 51 and it's different. It's slower progress, but the best progress still happens and I believe i'm in better shape than when I was in my 30's. Maybe even my 20's. You have to eat your exercise calories with the big burn exercises you do. Under eating, or eating crappy undercuts my goals at this age. My body will hang on to every scrap of energy if it can. It only lets go if I'm eating well, and enough. I even have month long stalls, but it always eventually works if I follow the plan.
You eat well, you exercise a lot, which is good, but you aren't eating enough according to your diary.0 -
I'm sorry, I don't have any advice for you. I don't know the secret to lasting success. But I will support you and encourage you in your :flowerforyou:0
-
tell me what u are eating and what you are doing to have gained 13!0
-
My mom has had great luck with hormone therapy - you're on the right track guessing that hormones are making a difference. She takes troches (spelling? I don't know) and they totally make a difference in how she feels, her energy level, and her whole body, including weight! Ask your doctor.
Good luck! 0 -
I don't know how menopause affects weight loss...but I am in perimenopause (pre-menopause) and have not noticed a difference in that respect.
Are you sure you are logging everything you eat at the correct amounts (weighing everything)?
Are you sure your caloire target is correct (based on a deficit from TDEE)?0 -
I am 59 and I did the same thing. Gained 13 lbs over the holidays, got scared I would gain all my weight back, found this site and logged everything I ate and have lost it. I was overeating healthy stuff, going back and getting apples and stuff but too many calories,had to weigh everything and be vigilant. I was eating a little here and there and had WW mentality to eat all fruit and veg I wanted and I gained weight. I upped my exercise, zumba and ripped, very energetic stuff 4-6 times a week!0
-
I agree with brenn24179. I think a calorie journal is a good idea. Once you have a few weeks worth of data you can see what's going on for sure. Good luck!0
-
Well, the answer is easy. You are no longer in a calorie deficit. You cannot gain weight (except for temporary water weight) if you expend more calories than you consume. I would suggest you re-evaluate your diet and exercise to insure you are logging all your food, and also entering accurate caloric burns. Something changed...hormonal changes can affect weight but only by slowing metabolism...I bet something else changed...reflect on that and I bet you find it.0
-
Congratulations on your weight loss!
Did you reevaluate your caloric needs at your lower weight?0 -
I read on someone's MFP blog that you should only eat half of your exercise calories back because it is not always spot on with calories....?? and then someone else wrote "don't eat any of them back"....I am confused.....0
-
Yes I did change my calorie changes based on weight changes....0
-
I have been going back over my records last year and the thing I noticed is that I was pretty low on calories most days and I don't think I accurately recorded alot of what I put down LAST year....I was putting less calories down for exercise and keeping under that so that is why I have been only eating back half of what I have been putting down this year.....0
-
I'm thinking it's sugar somewhere in your diet... and/or the consumption of useless carbohydrates! Try google.com for: Top 10 Foods Highest in Carbohydrates (To Limit or Avoid).... You may discover something of value to you. Good luck. 0
-
I did my TDEE and it was 2243 so minusing 20%, I should be eating 1795 and not eating back exercise calories....0
-
Could be hormones / but probably not recording right , weighing everything, Adjusting your goals , You've lost almost 50 lbs be proud of that, and just reevaluate your goals and stay on track.0
-
MFP works because keeping a food diary helps you realise and be accountable for exactly what you are eating. Record EVERYTHING you eat. Weight and measure all your portions as until you can see what for example 100 g or 1 tablespoon of something looks like it is surprising how far off we can be.
Also keeping a journal of how you are feeling when you want to eat can help some people. There is a notes section in the food diary on MFP or you can keep a paper diary with you for this. This may help you to associate certain feelings with food and help you identify any triggers that may cause you to excessively eat.
Regarding exercise calories, it's a difficult question here because everyone will give you a different response. I would recommend calculating your TDEE (total daily energy expenditure) here: http://scoobysworkshop.com/calorie-calculator/
Be honest in the online form with the amount of exercise do and aim for a maximum 20% deficit. Then eat this amount every day. In this circumstane you do not eat back your exercise calories as you have already counted them in your calculation.
Recalculate for every 5lbs change in weight.
Good luck to you.0 -
I read on someone's MFP blog that you should only eat half of your exercise calories back because it is not always spot on with calories....?? and then someone else wrote "don't eat any of them back"....I am confused.....
I feel your pain, there are various opinions and advice on this forum and it gets confusing. As for me, I've found a comfort zone that is adding up to 1 - 2 lbs lost per week so I'm sticking with it. I do think eating too little can be a problem, so I eat back most, if not all, of my exercise calories. I exercise 4 - 6 times per week as well.
Good luck to you!0 -
I did my TDEE and it was 2243 so minusing 20%, I should be eating 1795 and not eating back exercise calories....
You are not doing this now. Your diary is set to @1300. If you are using the TDEE method then you need to go and manually set your calorie goal to 1795. Otherwise you need to eat back exercise calories.0 -
I had been on WW a couple of years ago and it did nothing for me as they did not limit carbs...that is how I lost on MFP....keeping my carbs under 150 carbs....but does not seem to be working right now for some reason......0
-
I think you need to ease up on the sodium, some days your sodium in way over. Give the pickles a break, instead of having 4 have one, store bough food is also very high in sodium.0
-
Unless you are 6' tall and well over 200 pounds, I *seriously* doubt you could eat almost 1800 calories a day at age 55 and be in a deficit. If you are gaining weight, you are eating too much. It's that simple. Weigh and log everything that goes in your mouth, and if you insist on counting your exercise calories as extra food you can eat, then get a heart rate monitor. The cardio machines at the gym are giving you a calorie burn for a 200 pound man. (For example, I was on the eliptical last week for 42 minutes, and the machine told me I burned 480 calories. My actual burn -- from my Polar watch/HRM -- was 310 calories).0
-
Unless you are 6' tall and well over 200 pounds, I *seriously* doubt you could eat almost 1800 calories a day at age 55 and be in a deficit. If you are gaining weight, you are eating too much. It's that simple. Weigh and log everything that goes in your mouth, and if you insist on counting your exercise calories as extra food you can eat, then get a heart rate monitor. The cardio machines at the gym are giving you a calorie burn for a 200 pound man. (For example, I was on the eliptical last week for 42 minutes, and the machine told me I burned 480 calories. My actual burn -- from my Polar watch/HRM -- was 310 calories).0
-
I agree with what you are saying about 1800 calories...I need to go back to what was successful for me last year and staying away from the excessive sodium...nixing the pickles and cashews for a while...I think the extra eating snuck up on me after losing my weight last year ......0
-
I agree with what you are saying about 1800 calories...I need to go back to what was successful for me last year and staying away from the excessive sodium...nixing the pickles and cashews for a while...I think the extra eating snuck up on me after losing my weight last year ......
YOU are so diligent about your exercise ... I hate to see that you aren't losing! I agree about the 1800 calories also. At my weight, 166lbs now, I wouldn't lose at 1800 - I keep my calories around 1200. It's not that I am depriving myself to hit the 1200 calorie goal, that's just where I end up daily after eating what I want ... high protein, no visible fat (but I don't limit/cut out fats), and low carb. When I look at MY carbs, I am currently keeping them between 30-70 (I am a low carber for reasons other than, and in addition to, weight loss) ... again, it's resulting in weight coming off (slowly). Good carbs, as in not processed foods, but veggies. I have heard, from several sources to keep your carbs below 100g ... but different sources will tell you different amounts. I do allow myself Splenda (useless carbs) in my coffee and I won't give up my coffee lol! My husband and I both cook, so there is always freshly cooked meat to eat ... I have a roast in the crockpot right now. You may have hit on a very common problem about menopause though ... it's worth checking into if the other strategies mentioned don't work for you. I hope things turn around for you very very soon.0 -
I agree with what you are saying about 1800 calories...I need to go back to what was successful for me last year and staying away from the excessive sodium...nixing the pickles and cashews for a while...I think the extra eating snuck up on me after losing my weight last year ......
YOU are so diligent about your exercise ... I hate to see that you aren't losing! I agree about the 1800 calories also. At my weight, 166lbs now, I wouldn't lose at 1800 - I keep my calories around 1200. It's not that I am depriving myself to hit the 1200 calorie goal, that's just where I end up daily after eating what I want ... high protein, no visible fat (but I don't limit/cut out fats), and low carb. When I look at MY carbs, I am currently keeping them between 30-70 (I am a low carber for reasons other than, and in addition to, weight loss) ... again, it's resulting in weight coming off (slowly). Good carbs, as in not processed foods, but veggies. I have heard, from several sources to keep your carbs below 100g ... but different sources will tell you different amounts. I do allow myself Splenda (useless carbs) in my coffee and I won't give up my coffee lol! My husband and I both cook, so there is always freshly cooked meat to eat ... I have a roast in the crockpot right now. You may have hit on a very common problem about menopause though ... it's worth checking into if the other strategies mentioned don't work for you. I hope things turn around for you very very soon.0 -
Thanks - I hope they turn around soon too....I am going to try to keep my carbs under 150, reduce the sodium and try to not go over 1700 cal.....also backing away from cashews that I would have in the afternoon and pickles!.....those are two things that I started eating lately that I wasn't last year....so we'll see..... 0
-
I did my TDEE and it was 2243 so minusing 20%, I should be eating 1795 and not eating back exercise calories....
You are not doing this now. Your diary is set to @1300. If you are using the TDEE method then you need to go and manually set your calorie goal to 1795. Otherwise you need to eat back exercise calories.
You are not eating even what you said you need to eat according to your diary. Get a heart rate monitor and then assume that you are recording your more accurate exercise calories if that's what is worrying you. Eat 1795 and then your exercise calories, or at least what you MFP goal says.0 -
Your calorie intake seems high. I would try a 250 to 500 calorie cut per day depending on what you are comfortable with. Cashews won't make you fat if they fit into your calorie goals. Sodium from pickles doesn't cause a person to get fat and any extra pounds on the scale would be temporary. You have done an awesome job so far and I am sure you will reach your goals.0
-
Your calorie intake seems high. I would try a 250 to 500 calorie cut per day depending on what you are comfortable with. Cashews won't make you fat if they fit into your calorie goals. Sodium from pickles doesn't cause a person to get fat and any extra pounds on the scale would be temporary. You have done an awesome job so far and I am sure you will reach your goals.0
-
Thanks for the encouraging words....I think it's more of a sodium issue with me and the cashews and pickles....plus it's hard for me to put the breaks on when I am eating cashews.... I am trying this week to keep the calories down and the carbs down (getting back to where I started last year)....I am happy that I kept the majority of weight off but it is disconcerting when you gain even a couple pounds of it back....I looked at your diary and you don't seem to eat much fruit....carbs?? 0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 430 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions