We are pleased to announce that as of March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor has been introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

Stationary Bike?

misssalley
misssalley Posts: 12
edited January 23 in Fitness and Exercise
SO. People keep telling me that theres no real point in using a stationary bike because it doesnt burn as many calories and doesnt "work"

My theory is that I want nice legs and since my legs are moving on the bike, thats good lol

Opinions? Success stories with it maybe?

Replies

  • rygma2010
    rygma2010 Posts: 7
    I don't know why someone would say that. I ride 30-45 minutes a day.. I feel it all the way up to my lower stomach..and yes it tones legs:smile:
  • WhosThirsty
    WhosThirsty Posts: 28 Member
    The key is to keep your heart rate at a number above 90 and below 150 (for most).

    Personally, I keep mine above 140, but it takes me about 3-4 minutes to work up to it.

    I stay riding at that rate for 15-25 minutes. There is a good formula for calculating your calories burned using your BPM, age, sex, and time on the bike. Let me look it up and I'll share it.
  • WhosThirsty
    WhosThirsty Posts: 28 Member
    I'm fairly certain this is applicable to most anything:

    Calculate the calories that you burned if you're male.

    This is given by the equation C = (0.6309 x H + 0.2017 x A + 0.09036 x W - 55.0969) x time / 4.184.

    C = Calories burned
    H = average heart rate in bpm,
    A = age in years,
    W = weight in pounds
    T = length of the exercise session in minutes.


    Step 4
    If you're FEMALE C = (0.4472 x H - 0.05741 x W + 0.074 x A - 20.4022) x time / 4.184.

    Assume you're a 31-year-old female weighing 124 pounds.
    Your exercise session was 30 minutes long
    Your average heart rate during the exercise session was 132 bpm.

    You burned C = (0.4472 x 132 - 0.05741 x 124 + 0.074 x 31 - 20.4022) x 30 / 4.184 = 242 calories during your exercise session.


    http://www.livestrong.com/article/73386-convert-heart-rate-calories-burned/#ixzz2SRPsh0QR
  • WhosThirsty
    WhosThirsty Posts: 28 Member
    I have made a quick spreadsheet in Excel where all you have to do is plug in C, H, A, W, & T and it will automatically calculate it for you. If you want, I can e-mail it to you, just message me your e-mail. This is helpful for calculating the calories burned for different exercises over the course of time and not having to look up the formula/calculate it each time.
  • 1Kristine1
    1Kristine1 Posts: 697 Member
    I go to spin class and I burn 450+ calories in an hour, from what the bike tells me. I find it is a good workout.
  • WDEvy
    WDEvy Posts: 814 Member
    It doesn't burn a lot of calories but it's definitely better than sitting your butt on the couch. I use an interval timer app and it does burn a bit more cals than just pedaling away.
  • misssalley
    misssalley Posts: 12
    Thats really helpful of you! Thanks but no need to email. I think I got it.
  • taunto
    taunto Posts: 6,420 Member
    SO. People keep telling me that theres no real point in using a stationary bike because it doesnt burn as many calories and doesnt "work"

    My theory is that I want nice legs and since my legs are moving on the bike, thats good lol

    Opinions? Success stories with it maybe?

    I don't know if stationary bike will give you nice legs but I liked my bike and I used to burn decent cals on it. Specially with higher resistance. I was very sad when I had to sell it before I moved.

    Anytime you're working, no matter how, you're burning cals and thats all that matters. Be it biking, walking, running, boxing, weight lifting. It all adds up!
  • misssalley
    misssalley Posts: 12
    Thanks everyone for all the responses and advice! I really appreciate it and Im going to keep on the bike :)
  • MzzFaith
    MzzFaith Posts: 337 Member
    This really helps thanks
  • Lysander666
    Lysander666 Posts: 275 Member
    For me it's 75% as efficient as running.

    I can do 400 kcal running in 30 mins, and 300 kcal doing stationary bike in 30 mins.

    Tonight I did 66 minutes on stationary bike which gave me 700 kcals. That's still fine in my book. It just depends what mood I'm in.
  • bonniecarbtoo
    bonniecarbtoo Posts: 29
    Some time ago I was inactive except for chair exercise, because of morton's neuroma. When it started healing, I started taking slow strolls for 30 minutes a day. I was told by a "nut" that I was wasting my time.
  • rheinrich17
    rheinrich17 Posts: 8 Member
    I love my bike ... and, since it's in my house and always available, I can't use the excuse of the weather or not wanting to go to a gym to skip exercising. Yes, there may be more efficient ways to burn calories, but I figure anything that keeps me moving almost every day is better than a gym membership that I would probably not use.
  • jlfoster0427
    jlfoster0427 Posts: 86
    I have a stationary bike at my house and use it just about every day. I try to pair it with a Jilian Michaels workout or my own weight lifting. I feel if your moving your burning calories so it doesn't matter how :)
  • okcat4
    okcat4 Posts: 224 Member
    Yep, no excuses when you have one at home, better than no exercise and gives you good legs, but and good a cardio! Who ever said that was wrong.Like saying a treadmill is no good at all since you are not "really" walking. Keep it up, enjoy and remember you are lapping the person on the couch!
  • brian1383
    brian1383 Posts: 39 Member
    I have made a quick spreadsheet in Excel where all you have to do is plug in C, H, A, W, & T and it will automatically calculate it for you. If you want, I can e-mail it to you, just message me your e-mail. This is helpful for calculating the calories burned for different exercises over the course of time and not having to look up the formula/calculate it each time.

    LOL! I'm no spreadsheet wizard, so it took me about 30 mins to get this right ... then I read this post! Could have just asked for the e-mail

    Thanks for the formula. though!
  • tammymusic1
    tammymusic1 Posts: 243 Member
    so I have a question is a stationary bike as good as going out and riding on a real bike? I go out at least 2 days a week for 10-12miles but would love a stationary bike at home as well is it worth it
  • Tw1zzler
    Tw1zzler Posts: 583
    so I have a question is a stationary bike as good as going out and riding on a real bike? I go out at least 2 days a week for 10-12miles but would love a stationary bike at home as well is it worth it

    I wear my HRM while riding and find I get a much higher burn riding on the road than on the stationary bike. However the stationary bike is a great alternative when the weather is bad. I also mix in sprint intervals and 'climbs' indoors - it adds to the burn and breaks up the monotony.
  • WhosThirsty
    WhosThirsty Posts: 28 Member
    The stationary bike I use lets me pretty much lean forward and rest my head and not really have to look up. Really helps when you're pushing 155BPM and you're struggling.

    On a bike, if I rested my head and didn't look up, I'd have a lot more problems than keeping my heart rate at 155BPM!
This discussion has been closed.

Categories