excercise..is it really necessary to do EVERY DAY?

Options
2

Replies

  • smanning1982
    smanning1982 Posts: 210 Member
    Options
    I HATE HATE HATE EXERCISE AS WELL! I can't stand it, seriously LOL I can tolerate going to zumba and used to do that once a week but I've stopped that too, but I have 4 children and can't seem to get out to go.

    Anyways, you only need to be eating at a calorie deficit to actually lose weight, exercise is more about toning from what I've read.

    I finally 5 weeks ago got in gear with eating right and sticking to 1200-1300 calories a day and I have lost 15 pounds in the last 5 weeks with NO exercise at all.

    In the past, I would always lose more weight on the weeks I would do no exercise as apposed to stalling on the weeks I did exersice!
  • GrabacrPD
    GrabacrPD Posts: 94 Member
    Options
    If i dont exercise daily then all I want to do is go to bed at 7pm, exercise for me stops me from feeling lethargic.
  • lkcuts
    lkcuts Posts: 224
    Options
    While there are many benefits to exercise, the only real necessity to losing weight is to burn more calories than you consume. I had a health issue and couldn't work out for the 1st two months of my weight loss effort. I still lost weight. So, cut your calories, do whatever exercise doesn't cause you to hate life, and lose weight. The end.

    Love your little "The end" story. Gave me a nudge thanks!
  • onwarddownward
    onwarddownward Posts: 1,683 Member
    Options
    For me personally, I must do it daily. "Make no provision for the flesh." Romans 13:14. I don't quote the bible often, but this one gets me.

    If I stop for a day, it derails my habit of swimming every day, first thing in the morning.

    Some people drink coffee, I go off the deep end ----> literally!
  • mazdauk
    mazdauk Posts: 1,380 Member
    Options
    I never believed PE teachers at school who used to ay "the more exercise, the more energy" and "the more effort you put in the more you will enjoy it". I hereby apologise to all PE teachers for not beieving.

    My knees and feet used to hurt a lot, but as the weight has come off and my muscles have got stronger that has stopped (unless I do something silly!). I have to exercise every day because a) once I start using the "fat girl" excuses I'll give up and b) because it gives me extra calories for "naughty" things.

    I have a fitness DVD which breaks into small sections - 20-25 mins - and I do one EVERY morning before breakfast. Its not high impact - they even show you the way to do it if you're unfit - so I'm not pouring with sweat, but it gets me moving for the day (even if I feel a bit stiff). I walk to and from work, and unless its pouring do a walk at lunchtime - only 15-25 mins, again nothing sweaty. That gives me an hour to an hour 20 every day without having to do anything drastic. Then when I get home out comes another exercsie DVD, and I might mix a bit of aerobic and toning exercises (25-45 mins), otherwise I get out Wii Zumba (now that IS sweaty!), then have a nice bath and I'm ready for dinner and a relaxing evening.

    I'm looking out longing for my walk, and planning what I'll do when I get home tonight. And my Zumba class is an absolute highlight -I get excited the night before! Find something you enjoy doing and build up - as you lose weight and become more flexible there may be other things you can try which you enjoy.

    If you eat at a deficit you will lose. If you eat at a deficit and exercise your body will look better for it at the end.:happy:
  • foleyshirley
    foleyshirley Posts: 1,043 Member
    Options
    Maybe try some swimming for a change if possible? It might be less painful without putting your weight on your hip, and help you relax instead while still burning decent calories. I find it a lot more enjoyable than standing on a treadmill anyway.
    Best of luck!
    Tom

    Great idea. Or maybe a water aerobics class to take pressure off the joints.
  • Gail3260
    Gail3260 Posts: 354 Member
    Options
    Maybe try some swimming for a change if possible? It might be less painful without putting your weight on your hip, and help you relax instead while still burning decent calories. I find it a lot more enjoyable than standing on a treadmill anyway.
    Best of luck!
    Tom

    Great idea. Or maybe a water aerobics class to take pressure off the joints.

    ^^^ This. I have a bad knee so virtually all my exercise is in the pool. I do an aquafit once a week and it is great fun. We are all mature ladies and have a good laugh as well as a good workout.
  • AbnormalYak
    AbnormalYak Posts: 55 Member
    Options
    It is absolutely necessary to try to be more active but that doesn't have to mean "The Dreaded EXERCISE!!!" Just move more. Walking is fantastic exercise. Watch this 10-minute video that convinced me walking isn't a poor second-best to running:
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=aUaInS6HIGo
    And don't walk for "the Dreaded EXERCISE!!!", walk for a purpose. Qalk to the shops. Walk to the cafe to meet a friend. Walk the dog. Drive to a park and walk around it with someone you love, enjoying the trees and flowers and birds. Walk around a museum or art gallery. Walk around a zoo. Walk around an outdoor flea market hunting for bargains. Walk around a craft fair shopping for charming knick-knacks.
    There has to be something you enjoy that is more active than sitting still. Walking, swimming, bicycling, dancing, gardening, golf - anything that is an inherently fun activity that gets you off the couch.
    You don't have to do "The Dreaded EXERCISE!!!" but you do have to get off the couch.
  • lkcuts
    lkcuts Posts: 224
    Options
    Thanks so much for the replies.. looks like you all answered the question I hoped there was another answer for...I have to excercise. Thanks for the encouragement and ideas I will certainly try these..maybe someday I will actually just not mind it as much..for now, its out to the ole' eliptical for me..might try singing during it this time.
    Chumbawamba"s..."I get knocked down but I get up again, you ain't never gonna get me down!" Thanks.. also I have had a few friends but none are really truely supporting me. Even when I am bad they say "Good Job" in the mean time they are making the same excuses I do to NOT do what they are supposed to. Maybe I need some encouragement from other people I have 2 non active friends right now.. again thanks. This actually gave me the kick in the butt I needed.
  • 3foldchord
    3foldchord Posts: 2,918 Member
    Options
    I am 41 with chronic fatigue syndrome. I workout 3 times a week and maybe 1-2 other days I do something as simple as a 30 minute walk or bike ride. Nothing too vigorous. (On good weeks, on 'flair up' weeks, I am often lucky to get just one workout, usually a wal, all week.)
    This has seemed to work well for me.

    My 'rest days' really are TEST DAYs. Spending most the day in bed or lounging round the house.
  • Reeceybaby1988
    Options
    excercise is NOT!!! needed to lose weight, you will not lose any quicker safely excercising more, unless you are not eating back excercise calories.

    a calorie defacit is what makes you lose weight, and excercise can be used to make it easier to attain this. what i mean is if you are going by MFP, and you need to NET 1500 calories a day, adding a 500 calorie burn will allow you to eat 2000 calories TOTAL for that day while still only NETting 1500. BONUS! to maintain, you need to eat 2500 calories, this translates into a 1000 calorie deficit every day, for a week, this will allow you to loose 2lbs a week SAFELY.

    ^this is just an example.

    if you are following TDEE -20% -15% or whatever, excercise is already included in the calculation, you eat a FLAT amount of calories a day acording to your activity level and dont track your excercise.

    excercise has the added benifit of increasing overall health, fitness strength and body composition.

    each to there own, if you dont want to excercise, fine, but alot of people would still recommend lifting to retain muscle mass.
  • 3foldchord
    3foldchord Posts: 2,918 Member
    Options


    if you are following TDEE -20% -15% or whatever, excercise is already included in the calculation, you eat a FLAT amount of calories a day acording to your activity level and dont track your excercise.

    While very true, I and others I know who use this method still track time. I like to make sure I really have gotten that 3-5 hours I used as my activity setting.
  • paulperryman
    paulperryman Posts: 839 Member
    Options
    absolutely not, totally upto you. Doctors just suggest 30mins a day at a minimum cause alot of people are completely imobile alot of the day and thats the opposite end of the scale, aslong as you are moving going about daily activities that still counts as some exercise and has an effect on your body

    It's not necessary to exercise at all provided you control your food intake.
    Exercise enhances the burns, improves cardiovascular, builds muscle and tones. Not exercising at best just loses weight if you under-eat what your body needs to maintain itself, however you'd lose weight at a very reduced rate and you can't gain muscle

    I do 6 days a week but thats cause it's habit now and i love the feeling at the end of a good workout. It's also paying off big time in toning my body and improved fitness 100 fold. But as you lose weight and improve fitness (not including gaining muscle) the same workouts don't contribute as much so either gotta increase the workout or just make do with a lower result at the end.

    on my rest day i try do little so the body can recover and i eat just enough to not be starving.
    If i have more then 1 rest day i feel guilty but the body responds positively when i next train. just last week had to miss 3 days due to the flu and blocked sinuses so couldn't breathe anyway or i woulda toughed it out. on the 4th day i went back to the gym and my body has totally recovered from the niggling aches and pains and i had my best workout in over a month despite a migrane.
  • momzeeee
    momzeeee Posts: 475 Member
    Options
    I lost all my extra weight, around 4olbs, without doing any exercise at all. I did this on purpose, after reading over and over again how exercise is not related to weight loss, and sometimes can even cause weight loss to stall. After transitioning into maintenance a couple months ago I started walking a couple times a week. Now I walk ten miles a week and have also started Mark Lauren's strength training program. But, I did this after being in maintenance and not actively trying to lose weight anymore. Losing weight really is all about what/how you eat.
  • wigglingalltheway
    Options
    In terms of general weight loss (i.e.. from a medically obese or overweight state) exercise (though important) is highly overrated.

    The only reason someone would "need" to exercise in order to loose weight is if they are eating too many calories and need to burn some off to create their deficit. From personal experience if this were the case I would seriously consider looking at the foods we are eating as it should be easily possible to eat well under a persons calorie count without feeling hungry or deprived.

    The figures change depending on the quote but the usual one is something like weight loss is 70-80% diet. And by diet it means eating the right foods, not starving yourself. I lost 32 pounds in three months without exercise. Now I exercise but because I enjoy sport not to lose weight.

    disclaimer - I am not anti-exercise I just think people have been conned into believing its a prerequisite for weight loss which it in no way is!
  • paulperryman
    paulperryman Posts: 839 Member
    Options


    if you are following TDEE -20% -15% or whatever, excercise is already included in the calculation, you eat a FLAT amount of calories a day acording to your activity level and dont track your excercise.

    While very true, I and others I know who use this method still track time. I like to make sure I really have gotten that 3-5 hours I used as my activity setting.

    I don't count that as "exercise" for one thing you can't track exactly how much you specifically are burning thats just a rough guide of what an average person of your age, height and weight would burn going about your normal daily activity (ie walking and going to work) , i'd say most people would only count that area as normal activity including work but excluding intentional exercise which you log seperately

    So for isntance if your job was on your feet all day long you'd put that in there but if you sat in your *kitten* most of the day that would be sedentary. Now ontop of that you log Intentional exercise like "going for a walk" "doing specific exercises"
  • lilbearzmom
    lilbearzmom Posts: 600 Member
    Options
    Have you tried taking classes? Or taken up strength training? Cycling? There has to be something that you find fun that is also exercise. And no, you don't have to do it EVERYDAY to improve your health. I really dislike going to the gym just to get on the elliptical. It BORES me to death, even when I have music to listen to. So I go to Zumba, and during the break in classes, I am adding lap swimming/water walking during the break in classes & then the 30 DS. You can do it- good luck!!!

    -Kendra
  • viragoeap
    viragoeap Posts: 107
    Options
    I find it helps to find some form of exercise that is enjoyable, pain free and remembering the reason for doing it! I run and walk most days, cycle and dance about 1-2 times a week. I enjoy it most of the time and when I get bored, mix up the routine a bit. Doing stuff with others helps,particularly if it's done at a pace when you can chat. A bit of interesting gossip can help you forget just how hard you're working. I have 3 bulging discs, so I know what discomfort when exercising means, so I just change it around and do something different. It's also key to know when to take a day or 2 off and give the body a chance to recover. My osteopath tells me that 'mobility is your friend' so just do something that raises the heart rate, help keeps you supple and enjoy. I'm 52 and am well aware of the saying 'use it or lose it'!
  • TorrizzleWillSizzle
    TorrizzleWillSizzle Posts: 119 Member
    Options
    I don't exercise everyday... Im lazy honestly, I walk when I feel like it (or when my child is restless and needs a change of scenery). Im on about 1535 calories and I've lost 27lbs so far :) Loss will probably happen faster if you walk or something daily but as long as there is a deficit in your calories you will be ok. At least thats what everyone says lol
  • Nutella91
    Nutella91 Posts: 624 Member
    Options
    absolutely not, i do it three times a week.