MYTH: Constant Grazing Boosts Your Metabolism

This is an article I just read. While I'm at work at a desk job, I've taken to always bringing a container full of raw vegetables that I can munch on at any time as well as a piece of fruit or two. Some days I eat them and other days not so much. Can that be a bad thing?

Opinions?

http://www.jillianmichaels.com/fit/lose-weight/myth-small-meals?xid=nl_LosingItWithJillianMichaels_20130617


MYTH: Constant Grazing Boosts Your Metabolism

Are six small meals really better for your metabolism, than a healthy three-meals-a-day diet? It's time to get to the bottom of this popular weight-loss myth.

The Truth: The exact opposite is true: If you keep eating small amounts of food throughout the day, you’ll never burn any fat.

This myth is an easy one to buy into, because at face value, it seems like it makes sense. By eating frequent, small meals, you’re continuously stimulating your metabolism, and thus burning more calories, right? WRONG. Here’s why:

By grazing around the clock, you’re preventing your body from burning fat. When you’re constantly eating, you’re consistently releasing insulin, which puts your body into its “absorptive phase.” Basically what this means is that the insulin in your body is storing sugar — and not letting other enzymes in your body release sugar to break down fat. The goal is for your body to be in “postabsorptive phase,” where it uses your energy stores for sustenance, and burns more fat.

Grazing can cause you to lose track of your calories consumed. When you have three, well-balanced meals a day, it’s easy to keep count of all of the calories you’re consuming and it’s much easier to nutritionally balance your meals. Conversely, when you have six, small meals — it becomes harder to count and remember how many calories you’ve eaten in a particular day. It also becomes more difficult to ensure that each time you’re eating, you’re consuming the appropriate combination of macronutrients like healthy proteins, fats, and carbs.

You’re left feeling unsatisfied. Studies have shown that many people don’t feel satiated following a small meal, which can then cause them to overeat later, to make up for it. Psychologically, grazing can leave you wanting more because you never sit down to have a full meal. Instead, I want you to eat every four hours — three meals per day with one snack between lunch and dinner. Eating every four hours stabilizes your blood sugar, optimizes insulin production and manages hunger.

The Bottom Line: Three balanced meals, spaced out every four hours — with a snack between lunch and dinner is the ideal meal plan for weight loss. Your body will use your energy stores and burn more fat!
«1

Replies

  • jwdieter
    jwdieter Posts: 2,582 Member
    When broscience battles broscience, does anyone win?
  • SideSteel
    SideSteel Posts: 11,068 Member
    I think saying:

    The Truth: The exact opposite is true: If you keep eating small amounts of food throughout the day, you’ll never burn any fat.


    Is just replacing one crappy myth with another crappy myth.


    Making an assertion about meal frequency or meal timing and trying to apply it in a universal sense without regard to energy balance and without considering individual preferences is pretty much laughable and wrong.

    EDIT: (The Bottom Line: Three balanced meals, spaced out every four hours — with a snack between lunch and dinner is the ideal meal plan for weight loss. Your body will use your energy stores and burn more fat! ) ^^^ this is just a bunch of nonsense.

    That being said, evidence would point to the subject of the article being correct. It is a myth that constant eating boosts metabolism.
  • ssteinbring677
    ssteinbring677 Posts: 158 Member
    Grazing can cause you to lose track of your calories consumed. When you have three, well-balanced meals a day, it’s easy to keep count of all of the calories you’re consuming and it’s much easier to nutritionally balance your meals. Conversely, when you have six, small meals — it becomes harder to count and remember how many calories you’ve eaten in a particular day.

    Enter, MFP. If you count your calories, how can you lose track? Eat whatever you want, whenever you want. Log it and stay within your calorie limit. It's simple, really.
  • eileenm777
    eileenm777 Posts: 31 Member
    I think eating repetitively through the day makes me get into a 'snacking habit' and I end up eating more. So whether this is true or not, I do better when I don't graze.
    In Italy and France (where the food is amazing), my family members are all fairly thin and healthy - they don't snack!
  • nomeejerome
    nomeejerome Posts: 2,616 Member
    There is a lot of wrong in that article.......
  • Sarauk2sf
    Sarauk2sf Posts: 28,072 Member
    This is replacing one myth with another.
  • magerum
    magerum Posts: 12,589 Member
    In for potential ludicrous claims
  • barbaratrollman
    barbaratrollman Posts: 317 Member
    If that was true, I wouldn't have been able to lower my BF% so dramatically, and I wouldn't have lost the 43 pounds I've lost since Jan. this year.
    I eat constantly!
  • barbaratrollman
    barbaratrollman Posts: 317 Member
    It does matter, if you're a diabetic. Diabetics benefit from eating smaller amounts more often. I don't believe it benefits weight or fat loss, I just prefer to graze.
  • Sunitagt
    Sunitagt Posts: 486 Member
    Meal timing and number of meals doesn't matter

    I was going to say the same thing. I've read so many for both sides, and then ready quite a few detailing why its really just personal preference. I prefer small meals throughout the day because then I don't feel so insatiably hungry later on or at a meal.
  • RobynMWilson
    RobynMWilson Posts: 1,540 Member
    Bull...besides an intermittent fast in the morning b/c i just can't eat that early, I graze all thoughout the day, have 18% body fat, am 40 yrs old and can eat 2000 cals per day. PHOOOEY!
  • TLWallperson
    TLWallperson Posts: 125
    I would def have to disagree with this article. I eat 4-5 times a day and I have lost 80lbs and I have no problem tracking my calorie intake at all. The reason I do eat several small meals a day is not because I think it keeps my metabolism burning, but because it helps to keep my blood sugar stable throughout the day (no I am not diabetic) and because of this I DON'T binge. This has worked for me, but it may not work so well for someone else, but I think it's wrong for her to say that it doesn't work for anyone.
    When are people going to realize that we are all created different and what works for one person may not work for someone else.
  • cwolfman13
    cwolfman13 Posts: 41,865 Member
    Wow....double mything. That takes talent.

    OP...if you're at a calorie deficit, you're burning fat...no matter how often or when you eat. 'cuz laws of thermodynamics.
  • Annette_rose
    Annette_rose Posts: 427 Member
    I think eating repetitively through the day makes me get into a 'snacking habit' and I end up eating more. So whether this is true or not, I do better when I don't graze.
    In Italy and France (where the food is amazing), my family members are all fairly thin and healthy - they don't snack!

    I was thinking the same thing! I got to visit France a few years back and my host family ate three meals a day and did not snack at all! They joked about how they see Americans eating all the time. We went to a restaurant and I asked for a "to go" box and they all looked at me like I was crazy. My host mom said "That is why you Americans get hungry, because you don't eat all your food at one sitting", lol. It was so funny but I could not imagine wasting the food that was not eaten. But, I rarely saw any overweight people there. It was pretty amazing!!
  • jennifershoo
    jennifershoo Posts: 3,198 Member
    That's stupid. I munch all the time and lost 20 lbs in the last 3 months.
    Jillian Michaels is not a good reference.
  • Yanicka1
    Yanicka1 Posts: 4,564 Member
    I weep for insuline
  • Myxalplyx
    Myxalplyx Posts: 129 Member
    Instead of saying this or that is the truth or a lie, test it for yourself and report the results. We have all the tools in the world to do this. You can post up a link to an article and try it, then get back and report your results.

    What works for one may not work for another.
  • CarmenSRT
    CarmenSRT Posts: 843 Member
    Grazing throughout the day may keep you from gnawing off someone's face in a hunger induced craze. Or is that just me?
  • seanezekiel
    seanezekiel Posts: 228 Member
    I switched from 3 meals a day to 6 and have lost over 90. Ill take personal experience over any study.
  • bumblebums
    bumblebums Posts: 2,181 Member
    When broscience battles broscience, does anyone win?

    ^^^^^^
  • greenmonstergirl
    greenmonstergirl Posts: 619 Member
    Instead of saying this or that is the truth or a lie, test it for yourself and report the results. We have all the tools in the world to do this. You can post up a link to an article and try it, then get back and report your results.

    What works for one may not work for another.
    THIS^^
    I have lost 54 by grazing...mooooooo
  • myrealname
    myrealname Posts: 90 Member
    I certainly don't agree with her article, I was surprised that she or her team would put it out there. Since I've started this journey, I've lost 25 pounds and the grazing on healthy snacks helps to keep me away from all the treats that are brought into the office.

    I am not surprised at all at any of the opinions here and agree. I believe we are all different.
  • Deipneus
    Deipneus Posts: 1,861 Member
    Thank you. I'll at least read and consider sources such as this (National Institute of Health) but not the various and sundry bloggers and online magazines that usually get cited.
  • bumblebums
    bumblebums Posts: 2,181 Member
    I certainly don't agree with her article, I was surprised that she or her team would put it out there. Since I've started this journey, I've lost 25 pounds and the grazing on healthy snacks helps to keep me away from all the treats that are brought into the office.

    I am not surprised at all at any of the opinions here and agree. I believe we are all different.

    This comes from people who make entertainment out of crash dieting and marathon workouts with injuries. I don't think they are exactly scientifically minded, unless The Biggest Loser is some secret experiment with America's TV watching public as the subject population. I don't think it is, though, because I never signed a consent form and I'm pretty sure it's required for human subjects studies these days.
  • MrGonzo05
    MrGonzo05 Posts: 1,120 Member
    Six small meals a day will not offer a metabolic advantage. Also, skip breakfast if you like.
  • fiberartist219
    fiberartist219 Posts: 1,865 Member
    I eat when I'm hungry... If I don't, I turn into a monster. Sometimes I am only hungry three times a day and sometimes I'm just hungry all day long. Sometimes I get tired after eating... and sometimes I just get hungry again.
  • chrisdavey
    chrisdavey Posts: 9,834 Member
    This coming from the lady that has her 12 week challenge people "refeed" with the exact same amount of calories once per week... :huh:
  • rosemaryhon
    rosemaryhon Posts: 507 Member
    I think eating repetitively through the day makes me get into a 'snacking habit' and I end up eating more. So whether this is true or not, I do better when I don't graze.
    In Italy and France (where the food is amazing), my family members are all fairly thin and healthy - they don't snack!

    I was thinking the same thing! I got to visit France a few years back and my host family ate three meals a day and did not snack at all! They joked about how they see Americans eating all the time. We went to a restaurant and I asked for a "to go" box and they all looked at me like I was crazy. My host mom said "That is why you Americans get hungry, because you don't eat all your food at one sitting", lol. It was so funny but I could not imagine wasting the food that was not eaten. But, I rarely saw any overweight people there. It was pretty amazing!!

    Off-topic but it just bugs me to hear about other's joking about Americans. I don't know, it just seems rude to me. ~ end vent ;)