I want to Cardio but.......
mckellipgirl
Posts: 63 Member
I can't breathe!
I can walk at a slow/moderate pace all day long but if I try to push myself, at all, I can't breathe. I have an elliptical machine that I thought I'd love but can't use it for extended periods of time. I'm talking more than 8 minutes. It's so frustrating. My body isn't tired but I just can't breathe. The last time I went 12 minutes on the elliptical I almost passed out. I was extremely short of breath, started getting dizzy and was coughing for hours afterwards. I'm willing to bet this isn't normal... Any advice, tips or have experienced this yourself?
Just so you don't have to ask, I smoked for 12 years but have been smoke free for 1 year and 3 months. Besides being obese, I have no other medical ailments. This is after any extended exertion; walking fast, jogging, bicycling or elliptical.
I can walk at a slow/moderate pace all day long but if I try to push myself, at all, I can't breathe. I have an elliptical machine that I thought I'd love but can't use it for extended periods of time. I'm talking more than 8 minutes. It's so frustrating. My body isn't tired but I just can't breathe. The last time I went 12 minutes on the elliptical I almost passed out. I was extremely short of breath, started getting dizzy and was coughing for hours afterwards. I'm willing to bet this isn't normal... Any advice, tips or have experienced this yourself?
Just so you don't have to ask, I smoked for 12 years but have been smoke free for 1 year and 3 months. Besides being obese, I have no other medical ailments. This is after any extended exertion; walking fast, jogging, bicycling or elliptical.
0
Replies
-
If you have no other medical ailments then you are simply out of shape and need to work at it.
I remember when I'd get winded walking up small hills. I finally got tired of that, and solved it by walking more and then learning to run.0 -
Agreed if there are no other ailments then its likely just a time issue. Just be patient and take it slow and you will find every day will get a little easier and less hard on the breathing part. Glad to hear you are committed to making yourself healthy and good luck!0
-
I don't know, if you were already at a place of being able to walk all day long, feeling like you are going to pass out on the elliptical (even slowly?) or anything faster doesn't sound normal to me. I'm 45, obese, with a sedentary job and when I started doing things again, I never once felt like i was going to pass out, just winded, and when I stopped after a few minutes everything was back to normal. You should go to the doc and get checked out..maybe you've got some asthma going on or something.0
-
I can't breathe!
I can walk at a slow/moderate pace all day long but if I try to push myself, at all, I can't breathe. I have an elliptical machine that I thought I'd love but can't use it for extended periods of time. I'm talking more than 8 minutes. It's so frustrating. My body isn't tired but I just can't breathe. The last time I went 12 minutes on the elliptical I almost passed out. I was extremely short of breath, started getting dizzy and was coughing for hours afterwards. I'm willing to bet this isn't normal... Any advice, tips or have experienced this yourself?
Just so you don't have to ask, I smoked for 12 years but have been smoke free for 1 year and 3 months. Besides being obese, I have no other medical ailments. This is after any extended exertion; walking fast, jogging, bicycling or elliptical.
So you've been tested for asthma and COPD?
I ask because I have asthma and humidity plays a huge roll in how my breathing is on some days.
I'm obese, also. I walk for at least an hour at 2.5 mph. I've noticed it's gotten easier, so I'll up my speed for part of that hour. I'm building up my endurance.
So you can go 8 minutes on your elliptical, that's great! Instead of going for 12 minutes, could you build up the time gradually? Then once you get to a time you're happy with, be it 12 minutes or 60, or somewhere in between could you increase your difficulty level?
So maybe this week you go for 9 minutes, then ten, etc.0 -
I agree, sounds like asthma. I've had it. You should be checked out. Yes, your out of shape but that doesn't make you feel like your gonna pass out.You should go to the doc and get checked out..maybe you've got some asthma going on or something.0 -
If you have no other medical ailments then you are simply out of shape and need to work at it.
I remember when I'd get winded walking up small hills. I finally got tired of that, and solved it by walking more and then learning to run.
QFT..... When I first started I could not stand for 30 seconds at a stretch let alone walk..... I spent 17 months in a therapy pool using weight displacement to allow me to stand long enough to be able to walk. and lose 170 lbs. before I could get out of the pool and continue my exercising. You just need to start and the next workout do a little more and continue this process... You will continue to get stronger and will be able to do more.... Best of Luck0 -
How long have you been using the elliptical? Because the first month after I got mine I had only gotten up to 10 mins (and that was with a break about halfway through to "fix" the music on my ipod
) Any minute of exercise you do is a GOOD minute and the longer you do it the longer you'll be able to keep it up! Just keep pushing! 0 -
I agree you may want to check with your doctor about the possibility of exercise induced asthma or some other lung issue just to be sure.
If that checks out, then you'll just need to keep at it slowly but surely. The very first time I got on an elliptical, I was huffing & puffing and could only do about it for about 3-4 minutes. I just kept at it and increased it bit by bit til I could do it for longer periods of time. Same idea with walking or any other activity you tackle. Just keep trying and don't quit!0 -
This may be a silly question, but are you holding your breath? Some people get so into their exercise that they subconsciously hold their breath because they are concentrating on their movement. You could try focusing on breathing, trying to breathe in for four counts and out for four counts (or whatever count is appropriate for you) so that you're not either holding it or hyperventilating. Otherwise it's like the others have said, the more you do it the easier it gets.0
-
I can't breathe!
I can walk at a slow/moderate pace all day long but if I try to push myself, at all, I can't breathe. I have an elliptical machine that I thought I'd love but can't use it for extended periods of time. I'm talking more than 8 minutes. It's so frustrating. My body isn't tired but I just can't breathe. The last time I went 12 minutes on the elliptical I almost passed out. I was extremely short of breath, started getting dizzy and was coughing for hours afterwards. I'm willing to bet this isn't normal... Any advice, tips or have experienced this yourself?
Just so you don't have to ask, I smoked for 12 years but have been smoke free for 1 year and 3 months. Besides being obese, I have no other medical ailments. This is after any extended exertion; walking fast, jogging, bicycling or elliptical.
I feel the exact same way when my asthma acts up. I also cough a lot when it is bad.0 -
I can't breathe!
I can walk at a slow/moderate pace all day long but if I try to push myself, at all, I can't breathe. I have an elliptical machine that I thought I'd love but can't use it for extended periods of time. I'm talking more than 8 minutes. It's so frustrating. My body isn't tired but I just can't breathe. The last time I went 12 minutes on the elliptical I almost passed out. I was extremely short of breath, started getting dizzy and was coughing for hours afterwards. I'm willing to bet this isn't normal... Any advice, tips or have experienced this yourself?
Just so you don't have to ask, I smoked for 12 years but have been smoke free for 1 year and 3 months. Besides being obese, I have no other medical ailments. This is after any extended exertion; walking fast, jogging, bicycling or elliptical.
So you've been tested for asthma and COPD?
I ask because I have asthma and humidity plays a huge roll in how my breathing is on some days.
I'm obese, also. I walk for at least an hour at 2.5 mph. I've noticed it's gotten easier, so I'll up my speed for part of that hour. I'm building up my endurance.
So you can go 8 minutes on your elliptical, that's great! Instead of going for 12 minutes, could you build up the time gradually? Then once you get to a time you're happy with, be it 12 minutes or 60, or somewhere in between could you increase your difficulty level?
So maybe this week you go for 9 minutes, then ten, etc.
This. I was diagnosed with COPD at the age of 28, after 10 years of smoking. I found that I was getting bad coughs and bronchitis whenever I got a cold, which was my warning signal. I stopped smoking before it went beyond what is classified as mild, but I am still working with just 68% as opposed to the usual 84% for my age lung function.
I got horribly breathless when I first started cycling 3 years ago and thought I was going to die.
Now I can cycle for 3 hours, probably longer and I can run. I still get breathless, but not to a degree that I can't or wont push through it.
Definitely worth checking out if your lungs are impaired now as a result of the smoking.0 -
The first time I did an elliptical I couldn't go more than 5 minutes and I was thinking to myself "no way", I thought I was going to die. I kept at it and 5 went to 10 and 10 went to 30 and before long I was at 60 minutes. You are in the privacy of your own home, I was at the gym and I held my head high has I would do my 5 minutes and get off and go onto another machine while everyone else was doing their hour or so on them.
Edit- At that time I had just quit smoking.0 -
I weighed over 300lbs when I first started. I couldn't do anything for more than a minute or two.But guess what , throughout the did I did my little minute or two. They add up. I still can't do more than 5 minutes of low impact aerobics. But if I do it more than once a day, it adds up and I get stronger and stronger until I can do a little more each week or so. You do what you can do, eventually your tolerance builds up and you get stronger. Good luck!0
-
I understand where you're coming from. I work a hospital job, standing and walking 8 hrs a day. When I started this journey, I tried Walk Away the Pounds video for newbies. I couldn't even walk the mile (25 min) without being totally out of breath and feeling like passing out. I thought because I stood and walked all day at work, I was obese but in ok shape - so totally not true !!! But, I kept at it, slowly over the past 6 months, and now sometimes my walks with the dogs turn into a spontaneous 5k! Good luck0
-
Sounds like exercise induced asthma. Happens to me too but only when I push myself super hard. You CAN work through it and it will get better. If you keep it up and just push but not too hard. It will slowly start get to where you can work harder and harder without the symptoms flaring up and eventually they will likely subside all together. The only thing I can't handle is running for long distances. I never really run more than a mile anyway. I can even do very intense interval stuff and circuit training, sprints, running for about a mile, etc without any problem. It's just running over a mile or so that gets me. Good luck!0
-
I had the same thing happening. I've never smoked or worked in a hazardous profession.After being tested for asthma, copd, and interstitial lung disease ,my dr discovered that I have scar tissue in my left lung and further testing says I'm only at 59% lung capacity. I'm on oxygen 24/7. I didn't need it while using the therapy pool though and did really well. Now that I have an exercise bike at home, I just leave the oxygen on. You definitely should have your dr look into this! Mine won't reverse, even with exercise and weight loss, but knowing what it is and adjusting how I exercise, I haven't been derailed on my journey to get healthy!0
-
You need to see a physician this could be excercise induced asthma among other things such as heart issues,especially if you smoked. the lungs and heart can be affected and not even know it. DO NOT push yourself until you get a thorough exam and tell the Dr. what you wrote here. Good luck!0
-
I would check with my doctor and tell him what exactly is going on. That sounds scary to me. I never had this problem even at 272 pounds. If he clears you then I would just attempt to gain more endurance but until you know what's going on, i wouldn't push a thing.0
-
I have not seen a doctor about asthma or COPD because it's only when I over exert, and honestly because I don't want it. Lol
I guess I'll have to bite the bullet and get checked out to make sure.
This isn't stopping me at all, it's just slowing it down. Instead of working really hard and pushing harder, it's much slower. I can do Zumba but have to sit after 2 songs and relax then start back up because of the burning. I'm walking every day 20 minutes to 1.5 hours, depending on time allotments but I want to push, I want to get better, more endurance. It's a goal, something to achieve, something to work towards so I don't get bored... I guess I'll cave and get checked out.
0 -
The solution here may be as simple as just getting an inhaler and taking a hit or two before exercise. Open those airways!0
-
I was the exact same way on the elliptical when I first started working out. You basically described me to a T. I would go for about 8 minutes, and felt like I was literally dying. The coughing afterwards especially sucked. I kept at it every day, upped how long I was on the elliptical by 1 minute every few days. Eventually, it got easier, and the coughing stopped. For me, it was just being extremely out of shape.
I have no medical conditions, no asthma, never smoked a day in my life. I think it's normal, or at least it was for me. Once I got in better shape, it all improved. Hope that helps 0 -
I would see the doc just to be sure. Congrats on a healthy future! wishing you the best0
-
Have you tried intervals? I'm not talking high intensity, but basically take a program like C25K, and instead of doing walk-run intervals, do walk-fast walk intervals. That should gradually build you up, and when you think you're ready you can try it with running.
Little story onthe side: I tried to run a fast kilometer today, and I went way too fast in the beginning, and thought my lungs would seize halfway through. Point is, I could have got the same time, going overall a bit slower, and not trying too hard.
Intervals will push you, but also teach you to pace yourself properly. Works on the elliptical too :happy:0 -
I have not seen a doctor about asthma or COPD because it's only when I over exert, and honestly because I don't want it. Lol
I guess I'll have to bite the bullet and get checked out to make sure.
This isn't stopping me at all, it's just slowing it down. Instead of working really hard and pushing harder, it's much slower. I can do Zumba but have to sit after 2 songs and relax then start back up because of the burning. I'm walking every day 20 minutes to 1.5 hours, depending on time allotments but I want to push, I want to get better, more endurance. It's a goal, something to achieve, something to work towards so I don't get bored... I guess I'll cave and get checked out.
Yes you need to go to the doctor. You need your heart and lungs checked out, even if it's only when you are doing what you consider to be over exerting. I hope you get the clearance and can just push on after, but you do need to get checked out. Good luck!0 -
If the doctor gives you the all-clear, then it's a combination of getting in shape and thinking about your breathing. When people first start to do cardio, there is a tendency to breathe quickly and shallowly. This deprives the body of oxygen and can leave you feeling light headed, dizzy or out of breath. When you walk, focus on your breathing and make sure you continue to take deep, even breaths while you exert yourself. I had the same problem when I first started running, but deliberate breathing helped a great deal.0
-
I understand people trying to err on the side of caution, but exercising isn't supposed to be easy. It's damn hard, and if you're out of shape, it will be hard to breathe, you won't be able to go for a long time. I think the constant doctor suggestions are a little out of place. Like I said in my other post, I had the EXACT same symptoms/ailments, and it does go away/get better as you get in better shape.0
-
I understand people trying to err on the side of caution, but exercising isn't supposed to be easy. It's damn hard, and if you're out of shape, it will be hard to breathe, you won't be able to go for a long time. I think the constant doctor suggestions are a little out of place. Like I said in my other post, I had the EXACT same symptoms/ailments, and it does go away/get better as you get in better shape.
You are WAY off base. It is always a smart idea to get checked out by a doctor before beginning ANY new exercise program, especially if you are experiencing discomfort such as she suggests. She should be screened to make sure there is no underlying concern. You are giving irresponsible advice based on your own experience, not based on prevailing medical recommendations. There is no down side to getting checked out, so I am unsure why you would tell someone not to do it.0 -
See a MD maybe you have exercise induced Asthma. Nothing a inhaler won't cure.0
-
I would go to the Dr and get checked out for asthma or allergies maybe also cuz this time of yr there is alot of allergy stuff in the air going on. I have mild asthma and I know way bk in highschool I had a hard time breathing after running the track and stuff but I've been using an inhaler ever since and now my asthma is very mild and I only need it pretty much 2 puffs twice a day. I would start either with something you enjoy alot maybe dancing or something like that or maybe even just walking and walking a little bit further every day. when your body gets used to it and a bit stronger than try the machines and stuff again and you might be surprised how much longer you can go just with an inhaler and working your way up to it.0
-
I understand people trying to err on the side of caution, but exercising isn't supposed to be easy. It's damn hard, and if you're out of shape, it will be hard to breathe, you won't be able to go for a long time. I think the constant doctor suggestions are a little out of place. Like I said in my other post, I had the EXACT same symptoms/ailments, and it does go away/get better as you get in better shape.
You are WAY off base. It is always a smart idea to get checked out by a doctor before beginning ANY new exercise program, especially if you are experiencing discomfort such as she suggests. She should be screened to make sure there is no underlying concern. You are giving irresponsible advice based on your own experience, not based on prevailing medical recommendations. There is no down side to getting checked out, so I am unsure why you would tell someone not to do it.
Agreed. It can't hurt anything to get it checked, and you don't want to find out you do have a problem by falling off some equipment or passing out. There is a difference between feeling winded and feeling like you are going to pass out.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions