Good carbs...bad carbs...protein???

melissaka7
melissaka7 Posts: 277 Member
edited January 30 in Food and Nutrition
I need some advice on my food choices (fair warning) if you look at my food diary the passed few days it is not a good indicator of what I normall eat (there has been a death in the family & cooking hasn't been much of an option).

According to MFP my highest percentage of what I eat is CARBS & I'm not getting enough protein. My typical day included honey nut cheerios & skim milk or whole wheat toast, natural peanut butter, & fruit for breakfast, a turkey wrap with romaine lettuce & italian salad dressing for lunch (I use the Flat Out wraps), I usually have string cheese, fruit, almonds/walnuts, greek yogurt, or veggies as a snack (2 snacks a day), & my dinners, well they aren't "clean eating", but they aren't fast food & I do portion control.

Are there "better carbs" I could be eating? Where can I get more protein. I know I can look it up, but I'm curious what other people have found works for them or tastes good.

Replies

  • ngyoung
    ngyoung Posts: 311 Member
    Your sources of carbs seem fine aside from the cheerios which relative to other cold cereal aren't too bad. Everything else seems to be from sources that are not devoid of fiber. Easiest way to get more protein is to eat more meat. Also try eggs for breakfast a few times a week. You can also pre-cook some grilled chicken and chop it up to portion out for things like your wraps instead of using deli sliced meat or throw a slice or two of bacon in with it.

    Fiber content is usually the biggest factor in what makes "good" or "bad" carbs. Refined carbs are typically devoid of any fiber to slow the absorption of glucose.
  • This content has been removed.
  • magerum
    magerum Posts: 12,589 Member
    There are no good or bad carbs. Just carbs.

    My ice cream is not a bad carb while my strawberries are good carbs. Track your calories, eat at a deficit and target your macros.

    There are many options for adding protein to your daily regimen. Mix and match and experiment until you're happy.
    Top sirloin
    95/5 ground beef
    Hanger or flank steak
    Chicken breasts
    Drumsticks
    Pork tenderloin
    Assorted seafood
    Quest bars
    Greek yogurt
    And much much more

    ^ This.
  • AJ_G
    AJ_G Posts: 4,158 Member
    There are no good or bad carbs. Just carbs.

    My ice cream is not a bad carb while my strawberries are good carbs. Track your calories, eat at a deficit and target your macros.

    There are many options for adding protein to your daily regimen. Mix and match and experiment until you're happy.
    Top sirloin
    95/5 ground beef
    Hanger or flank steak
    Chicken breasts
    Drumsticks
    Pork tenderloin
    Assorted seafood
    Quest bars
    Greek yogurt
    And much much more

    ^ This. Carbs are carbs, track your carbs and don't go over your macro, doesn't matter if you get 100% of your carbs from granulated sugar, or 100% of your carbs from whole wheat pasta, they'll have the same effect on your body composition. I get most of my protein from chicken thighs, chicken breasts, lean beef, fatty beef, cheese, milk, etc. If you can't hit your protein macro by eating whole foods, you can use Whey powder if you need to, but whole foods are preferable.
  • CyberEd312
    CyberEd312 Posts: 3,536 Member
    There are no good or bad carbs. Just carbs.

    My ice cream is not a bad carb while my strawberries are good carbs. Track your calories, eat at a deficit and target your macros.

    There are many options for adding protein to your daily regimen. Mix and match and experiment until you're happy.
    Top sirloin
    95/5 ground beef
    Hanger or flank steak
    Chicken breasts
    Drumsticks
    Pork tenderloin
    Assorted seafood
    Quest bars
    Greek yogurt
    And much much more

    Yup This!!
  • mbucchieri
    mbucchieri Posts: 44 Member
    Although a carb is a carb, certian carbs fall higher or lower on the G.I. and this effects your blood sugar.If there was no difference in the way carbs effect your body, then there wouldn't be specific diets for diabettic people. my opinion is that anything in moderation is ok as long as you don't have health issues that require specific diets.Is ice cream or a cookie going to kill you,, no..but if you eat tons of it every day, then thats a different story.
  • AJ_G
    AJ_G Posts: 4,158 Member
    Although a carb is a carb, certian carbs fall higher or lower on the G.I. and this effects your blood sugar.If there was no difference in the way carbs effect your body, then there wouldn't be specific diets for diabettic people. my opinion is that anything in moderation is ok as long as you don't have health issues that require specific diets.Is ice cream or a cookie going to kill you,, no..but if you eat tons of it every day, then thats a different story.

    Lol, gonna bring up the glycemic index? You obviously haven't done much research on it then. The glycemic index was originally developed for diabetics. The way they tested foods for the glycemic index is they would feed someone a meal consisting of only that one food, and they would be fed that food in a fasted state and their blood glucose was monitored. How often do you eat a meal consisting of one single type of food, in a fasted state? For me, it's never. Research has shown that when you eat high glycemic index foods in a regular meal consisting of carbs, fats and protein, the glycemic index is basically washed out by the protein and fat, and this is true in a fasted state, and especially true in a fed state. Most people eat 1 meal a day in a fasted state, their first meal, and it's usually not consisting of a bunch of carbohydrates by themselves. The glycemic index is very misleading. Also, if you're eating at a deficit, the glycemic index is completely irrelevant because you won't be storing any fat at the end of the day anyway...
  • kmbweber2014
    kmbweber2014 Posts: 680 Member
    I have been going through the same thing. I have slowly started to lower by carbs and increase my fats and protein. So I started eating more fruit vegetables and salads and realized that I am more over on my carbs now than I was. I don't feel as worried about it now because most of my carbs are coming from fruits and vegetables but they are still higher than I want. Any suggestions would be appreciated.

    Also when logging my food sometimes for ease of logging, I will make a kale salad or smoothie and when logging it I will use something similar but usually made by a restaurant. I figure the calorie count is probably higher than what I actually ate.
  • AJ_G
    AJ_G Posts: 4,158 Member
    I have been going through the same thing. I have slowly started to lower by carbs and increase my fats and protein. So I started eating more fruit vegetables and salads and realized that I am more over on my carbs now than I was. I don't feel as worried about it now because most of my carbs are coming from fruits and vegetables but they are still higher than I want. Any suggestions would be appreciated.

    Also when logging my food sometimes for ease of logging, I will make a kale salad or smoothie and when logging it I will use something similar but usually made by a restaurant. I figure the calorie count is probably higher than what I actually ate.

    I suggest taking the time to input all the ingredients of the salad or smoothie that you make at home to be more accurate, could give you some extra calories to eat. Just a suggestion. As for going over on carbs from fruits and vegetables, a lot of people will tell you "don't worry about it, fruits and veggies are good for you, eat as much of them as you want". While they are good for you because of the nutrient content, you still shouldn't go over your macro goal for carbs, because that means that you're not hitting your macro goal for fat or protein, or both, and carbs are the least important macronutrient for your body.
  • whierd
    whierd Posts: 14,025 Member
    Try subbing your Cheerios for Kashi GoLean cereal. A cup of that with a cup of milk is 23g of protein and high in fiber.

    Boiled eggs are another easy one.

    There really is no good or bad carb, though some food is more nutrionally dense than others. Just focus on your macros+fiber.
  • mbucchieri
    mbucchieri Posts: 44 Member
    Although a carb is a carb, certian carbs fall higher or lower on the G.I. and this effects your blood sugar.If there was no difference in the way carbs effect your body, then there wouldn't be specific diets for diabettic people. my opinion is that anything in moderation is ok as long as you don't have health issues that require specific diets.Is ice cream or a cookie going to kill you,, no..but if you eat tons of it every day, then thats a different story.

    Lol, gonna bring up the glycemic index? You obviously haven't done much research on it then. The glycemic index was originally developed for diabetics. The way they tested foods for the glycemic index is they would feed someone a meal consisting of only that one food, and they would be fed that food in a fasted state and their blood glucose was monitored. How often do you eat a meal consisting of one single type of food, in a fasted state? For me, it's never. Research has shown that when you eat high glycemic index foods in a regular meal consisting of carbs, fats and protein, the glycemic index is basically washed out by the protein and fat, and this is true in a fasted state, and especially true in a fed state. Most people eat 1 meal a day in a fasted state, their first meal, and it's usually not consisting of a bunch of carbohydrates by themselves. The glycemic index is very misleading. Also, if you're eating at a deficit, the glycemic index is completely irrelevant because you won't be storing any fat at the end of the day anyway...



    Maybe I am not as knoweldgeable as I should be,,but my point was , unless you have health issues, then don'y worry about it..carbs won't kill you..
  • melissaka7
    melissaka7 Posts: 277 Member
    KASHI cereals make me sick. I've tried. :(
This discussion has been closed.