Do you plan on logging forever?
ze_hombre
Posts: 377 Member
I have been in maintenance mode for a couple weeks now and have been debating with myself over whether or not I will continue logging indefinitely. I will certainly log for a few more months as I learn how to maintain and what foods work for me in which portions in maintenance (if for no other reason than to get the 365 of logging in streak), but will I be logging two, three, five, ten years from now? I have made the major lifestyle changes so I am not really worried about regressing. I know much, much more about food now than I did six months ago and I have a decent understanding of macro nutrient content in food without using MFP.
I am curious how others have approached (or plan on approaching) this?
This may also be a stupid question since the people who quit logging will presumably not be logged into read this, so if you have a friend of a friend situation and can offer some anecdotal insight I welcome it (as long as you note it accordingly, please).
I am curious how others have approached (or plan on approaching) this?
This may also be a stupid question since the people who quit logging will presumably not be logged into read this, so if you have a friend of a friend situation and can offer some anecdotal insight I welcome it (as long as you note it accordingly, please).
0
Replies
-
i am over 400;
i am GOD.0 -
I'm not at my goal yet, but in 2005 I lost 35 pounds by counting my calories. I kept it off for probably 3 years, but I slowly began to gain it back, and started this summer at only 10 pounds lighter than my HW. I thought I was making healthy choices, so I didn't need to log my foods, but I wasn't eating the correct portions and was taking in more calories than I needed. So long story short, this time around I feel like I've been at it long enough that I've made the lifestyle change, but I do still think I'll continue to log my calories to keep me accountable when I get to maintenance mode. Can I say I'll be doing it 10 years from now? Who knows if MFP will still be a thing then? Haha. But I don't see myself stopping anytime soon.0
-
I think what I'm trying to do is cultivate a new normal for me so that I can maintain a healthy weight by eating normally and doing normal activity, and I want to be able to do this without actively keeping a log of everything I eat or do.
That said, if I had to I think I could log my intake indefinitely. It hasn't been that difficult or invasive, for me. But I don't want to rely on it.0 -
I stopped counting a while back and I discovered that the amount I naturally eat when not logging is enough to maintain with minimal exercise. So if I want to see more loss I need to only exercise a little bit more.0
-
I'm not at my goal yet, but in 2005 I lost 35 pounds by counting my calories. I kept it off for probably 3 years, but I slowly began to gain it back, and started this summer at only 10 pounds lighter than my HW. I thought I was making healthy choices, so I didn't need to log my foods, but I wasn't eating the correct portions and was taking in more calories than I needed. So long story short, this time around I feel like I've been at it long enough that I've made the lifestyle change, but I do still think I'll continue to log my calories to keep me accountable when I get to maintenance mode. Can I say I'll be doing it 10 years from now? Who knows if MFP will still be a thing then? Haha. But I don't see myself stopping anytime soon.
This was a fear I had a few months ago so I started a pretty extensive exercise regimen with a group of people here in town who triathlons regularly. I am burning way more calories in a week than I could possibly eat. Well, not really, but its much easier to keep things in perspective and control when you are running 20-25 miles a week and biking at least 40.0 -
I have been around for about 2 years, reached my goal weight Xmas 2011, and don't log every day, but I like to track my exercise reports and log my food if I start to put on a couple of pounds. Call me obsessive, but it seems to work for me.0
-
Once I have maintained my goal weight for a while, I will probably only log when I need to get back in line or just check in to make sure I am still on track. I don't want to think about calories every day for the rest of my life.0
-
Because I can't exercise (and likely will not be able to), I plan on keeping a semblance of counting for a long, long time.
If I got to a point where I was satisfied enough to go into maintenance, I'd count at maintenance for probably 6+ months. I have no will power, and while counting doesn't stop me from binging most of the time, it does make me think twice.
Once I feel "safe" enough to move past that, I will likely portion out my food according to packages, but perhaps not track the calories as vigilantly.0 -
Between here and I use to do weight watchers I have recorded for Seven years now. Some times I would go a month without and holly smokes I gained weight because you really need to see what you put in your body. I will record for life I have lost over 40pds.0
-
Between here and I use to do weight watchers I have recorded for Seven years now. Some times I would go a month without and holly smokes I gained weight because you really need to see what you put in your body. I will record for life I have lost over 40pds.
I stopped logging for about 3 months and gained back some. So, maybe forever.0 -
I'm at maintenance and not logging. I really made a point when I was logging and counting to really learn how to eat, what to eat, portion control, etc so that I could go into maintenance knowing how to get my nutrition on and being able to listen to my body and know what I need.
I eat the same way as I did when I was losing...just more calories. Food wise though, it's pretty much the same stuff save for a few extra treats here and there. In my experience, the really crucial thing has been keeping up with my training and exercise. I think this is where many go wrong...they associate training and exercise with the desire to lose weight...so they go to maintenance and they stop exercising or become more inconsistent, etc.
When I went to maintenance I made sure I had new goals...nutrition goals and fitness goals to keep me motivated and paying attention.
Also keep in mind that you'll likely put on a few pounds upping to maintenance due to your glycogen stores being replenished. Don't worry about it or drop an extra few pounds now to compensate. Also realize that, just as your weight loss wasn't linear, nor is maintenance static. You have a floor and a ceiling and I personally fluctuate a good 3 Lbs floor to ceiling on a daily basis...it can be more if I've had a really high sodium day, intense workout, or having a little beer bloat.0 -
My plan is to log still. I've regained weight in the past and it seems like a small price to pay to keep myself accountable.0
-
I was planning to gradually phase it out once I reached my goal weight. Hopefully, I could get along without it. If I were to notice a considerable weight gain, though (like, 10 pounds,) I think I would probably start up again. My intent is to train myself to be able to get along without it, but if logging is what's gonna keep me healthy, then so be it.0
-
According to findings from the National Weight Loss Registry, you have to continue to journal and exercise if you want to keep the weight off. You should not wait until you gain 10 pounds before doing something about it, but takes steps at no more than 2 pounds.0
-
According to findings from the National Weight Loss Registry, you have to continue to journal and exercise if you want to keep the weight off. You should not wait until you gain 10 pounds before doing something about it, but takes steps at no more than 2 pounds.
Makes total sense IMO. By the time you gained 10 lbs back, you're more likely to have changed your habits back for a while, which makes it much harder to get back in the bandwagon.0 -
Yes, I do plan on logging forever.
Though I've never been this low in my adult life (I weighed over 200 lbs in 6th grade) I have lost & regained quite a bit and what I've learned is that bad habits creep back up on you slowly and stealthily. For me, a few minutes a day logging and planning my eating gives me confidence that I'm still in control. Small price to pay.
But that's me, and how my mind works. I was obese for almost 50 years. I don't trust myself to stay slim without diligent accountability.0 -
I have a ways to go but my plan is to log for a month or so @ maintenance and then stop logging but continue to weigh often and log it just as I do now. I plan to pick a number maybe 10 pounds over my goal and if I ever see that number then back to logging.0
-
If i. Want to stay fit i will log i eat healthly most of the time but portion get out of wack .it really helps to see .so yes i will log as long as i can .0
-
Yes!!!0
-
I just see logging my food as part of my new lifestyle along with my exercising, making healthy and tasty dishes, and moving more. I've never been able to do so over the weekends and I probably never will, but it keeps me honest and in check. Even when I don't log my calories over the weekend because I do it every other day I know when I'm overdoing it or not making the right choices and will change my mind. I've gone from a size 16 to a size 6. I've tried to not use a food diary and that doesn't work for me.0
-
I'll probably have to yes. When I leave it up to myself I gain. I don't seem to be able to judge it accurately without MFP or another calorie counter. And MFP is easiest to use.0
-
I hit my goal about 6 months ago but like someone else mentioned I just keep after it to make sure I'm eating right and enough 'good' food. plus if I do have some days of overdoing it I can catch myself quicker. I do it first thing in the morning and adjust as needed through the day. and Sunday was 820 days in a row for me. :happy:0
-
I am hypothyroid and may continue to log even when I hit a safe maintenance level. I would like to be 10% body fat. For me, that would be 190-192 lbs. I am at 13% right now. I feel like I am monitoring my thyroid level and will try to keep up with as much as I can.0
-
I do plan on logging forever, I don't trust myself and my instincts.0
-
No. I have this amazing ability to maintain the same weight no matter what I do so long as I keep track of my weight and reign it in a little if needed. However, that also means I have lost 10lbs in 6 months because my body LOVES to maintain so getting to the goal weight in the first place could very well take forever...0
-
Yes... I am like the Stepford Husband of MFP....
Join us... forever and ever...0 -
I log every now and then as a sanity check and sometimes for a stint of a few days, but I don't want to depend on it. I do pay attention to meals as units of my diet and think about the rough numbers, so I know about where I am. I will pay attention to the scale and weigh often even when I have maintained for a while. I think it may be more important during the first big loss (assuming you have one) where you get from unhealthy back to healthy. For me that was over 50 pounds and I still want to lose a little more even though I am back in the healthy zone now. I have pretty much given up weekday daytime snacking and I think that will be permanent. That does make keeping rough numbers a lot easier.0
-
Yes I do. Maybe not religiously, but my plan is to keep logging indefinitely. I lost weight before, stopped logging and gained everything back and then some.
It's not that big a deal... just anothe one of the silly, mundane things I do online every day. I notice when I stop logging it's because I'm not eating very well and don't want to have concrete proof of that in my face.0 -
I view weight like debt: once you get your debt paid off, does that mean it's time to stop budgeting and logging your money? Nope. Gotta keep on keeping on. So when I get my weight off, I absolutely plan to continue logging for as long as I'm able, because every time I stop logging my food, my weight creeps up & up & up, slowly but surely. I don't want it to get ahead of me, I want to stay accountable and responsible, and logging my food & exercise has been the only think keeping me grounded.0
-
My hope is that I will log for a few months on maintenance to make sure I have a good understanding of how it works, what I can eat, how much I can eat, etc. And then I plan on testing myself for a few weeks to make sure I'm comfortable. If it's too scary (logging it is a security blanket, ya know) or if I start gaining/slacking, then I will start back up. But I honestly dream of the day when I won't have to log every single thing. I have learned how to cook, weigh, and pack my food as habits for the rest of my life, not just while I'm trying to lose. I have considered closing my account and saying farewell to my friends, but I think I've decided against that so that I can be a success story and inspire others. Also, my fitness goals won't ever stop, so it will be a good way to keep me accountable for my exercise.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions