Question; only for serious people. No judging.
Options
77TiffanyIrene77
Posts: 16 Member
A few years ago I was watching a show; Intervention, and it was about eating disorders.
Now; I would rather drink any day than eat. Rather it's water, juice, milk anything... I would rather drink than eat. Well I'm finally off soda and onto water and 0 to low calorie drinks.
My issue is;
I sometime's get this horrid craving for something salty and/or crunchy. Or even just something sweet that I know I shouldn't eat. Well on Intervention I seen a girl who was anorexic and she would chew it and then spit it out into a cup... Just for the taste, to help with the craving so she wasn't getting all the calories.
My question is wouldn't she still be getting the calories?
If not, if I'm maintaining my calories under what my DV should be, is it bad to use the Chew & Spit method to get rid of the cravings?
Please honest answers. No judging...
Now; I would rather drink any day than eat. Rather it's water, juice, milk anything... I would rather drink than eat. Well I'm finally off soda and onto water and 0 to low calorie drinks.
My issue is;
I sometime's get this horrid craving for something salty and/or crunchy. Or even just something sweet that I know I shouldn't eat. Well on Intervention I seen a girl who was anorexic and she would chew it and then spit it out into a cup... Just for the taste, to help with the craving so she wasn't getting all the calories.
My question is wouldn't she still be getting the calories?
If not, if I'm maintaining my calories under what my DV should be, is it bad to use the Chew & Spit method to get rid of the cravings?
Please honest answers. No judging...
0
Replies
-
That is an extremely bad idea unless you are working on having an eating disorder. Plan your calories for the day so you can have a little treat, completely chewed and swallowed. Losing weight isn't about depriving yourself of everything, it's about learning to eat in a sensible way that you can live with the rest of your life.0
-
Yes, you shouldn't chew/spit. A big reason is that it can contribute to other, more dangerous disordered behaviors. I believe there are some physical side effects that have to do with effects on the teeth and glands, but emotional side effects in addition to encouraging other ED behaviors would include a negative change in how you view yourself and food.0
-
If you just chew something and none of it goes down your throat into your stomach...I would have to assume you're not getting any calories from that. I could be wrong though. I think the hard part would be to actually pull that off. I've had the same thought in the past but once I get something tasty it's going in my belly lol.0
-
Could you find a healthy alternative instead? I buy Twistos instead of chips and granola bars instead of chocolate bars.....I think that would be better for you.
I would be afraid that the chew and spit method would be scary because what if it goes too far? As far as the calorie count goes, I'm not sure...0 -
Just plan for some salty snacks in your day. I have pretzels, Cheez-it's, chips, and other salty snack pretty much every day and just make sure it fits in my macros.
Chewing and spitting is an early step towards an eating disorder. It's best to just not head down that road at all.0 -
By the way, if you are drinking fluids more than eating, your salt cravings could be valid. We need a certain amount of sodium and it can be thrown off by overconsumption of beverages without enough salt to offset it. Don't take risks with your electrolytes. (I have no idea if imbalance is a problem for you, but based on the limited info in your post, thought it might be worth a mention.)0
-
I do not think it is a good idea, personally.
Part of this process is learning that you don't have to be eating/tasting/chewing all the time. Also, if you find yourself craving those things, the best thing to do is to fit them in your day.
If I am having a lot of cravings, I will plan my day early and include a dessert or a snack that I KNOW I won't be able to turn down. That way, its already in my diary and fits into my goals.
Chewing/spitting is an eating disorder of its own. It is not something I would recommend anyone start. It will send you on an unhealthy path with food. That is just my opinion :flowerforyou:0 -
Think about this for a minute, are the habits of a girl who needed an intervention because of an eating disorder the habits that you want to copy? That doesn't sound like a good idea.0
-
Carbohydrate digestion begins in the oral cavity. There is an enzyme known as Amylase found in saliva that starts the process of breaking down carbs for energy. So yes, you can start getting calories from food that contains carbohydrates. Protein and fats have to enter the stomach to have calories absorbed.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amylase0 -
Think about this for a minute, are the habits of a girl who needed an intervention because of an eating disorder the habits that you want to copy? That doesn't sound like a good idea.
If it helps at all, I have figured out a way to satisfy my one craving weakness: coffee. Of course black coffee itself isn't all that bad, but I like espresso, with milk, with sugar. I made myself a deal: if I want starbucks, I walk there. For me that means a 3.5 mile round trip on some mildly hilly roads. So, I end up burning more calories than I take in, but I still get my treat. This is, of course, in addition to the normal exercise I'm doing. Perhaps it's possible for you to do something similar?0 -
That girl was VERY sick. Not a good idea to do ANYTHING she was doing.0
-
Bad behavior to "learn" or try......I have battled with food my whole life......I am 32 and now I finally understand that you can eat (for the most part) ANYTHING you want....as long as it is done in MODERATION....Yesterday I woke up craving a Cadbury chocolate bar, so I ate that day knowing I was going to eat that chocolate bar later on. I still stayed within my calorie goal and didn't feel any guilt or shame after eating half of it.
To deny yourself the pleasure of eating something you crave is very unrealistic, just eat it in moderation and/or try to find a lighter/healthier alternative.
Cheers!0 -
If you have horrid cravings for stuff from time to time, why not indulge? Fit it into your daily goal and go from there. Total restriction is the road to failure, period. No one eats perfectly all of the time. Or even close to it. NO ONE.0
-
Horrible idea, it's better to just scratch the itch, as long as it fits your calories, eat or drink it. Otherwise you're just setting yourself up for a fall.
Rigger0 -
hit your calories. eat a sustainable diet. don't spit, swallow. if you're not planning to swallow then don't put it in your mouth.0
-
Think about this for a minute, are the habits of a girl who needed an intervention because of an eating disorder the habits that you want to copy? That doesn't sound like a good idea.
& ^^^THIS!^^^0 -
There are NO foods that you cannot indulge in once in a while. Chewing and spitting is a symptomatic behavious or disordered eating (hence a girl needing an intervention doing it). It's also gross.
Your diary is closed, and your comment about preferring to eat than drink is ambiguous. How many cals are you on a day that you don't think you can spare some for a treat?0 -
I would change my diet up to allow some salty snacks instead of trying to emulate bad habits. I agree with some other posts. If you are drinking alot and exercising. Your body maybe signalling you need some added salt. There are alot of health salty snacks.0
-
Enough said on the spit/swallow idea. Hopefully you won't find anybody on here that would encouraging this kind of dangerous behaviour. I find that if I want to treat myself to something I just promise myself to have it as a treat/dessert after my next main meal. By the time I have eaten the healthy main meal I often find I am satisfied with just half of what it was that I was hankering for and sometimes not want it at all. Its only a small exercise of will to delay your treat to the next meal time but I find it to be a really successful strategy. Good luck on your weight loss journey.0
-
Not judging but this is one pretty good way to continue to develop an eating disorder.
Would not recommend.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 391.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.4K Getting Started
- 259.6K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.6K Food and Nutrition
- 47.3K Recipes
- 232.3K Fitness and Exercise
- 387 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.4K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 152.7K Motivation and Support
- 7.8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.2K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.2K MyFitnessPal Information
- 22 News and Announcements
- 911 Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.3K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions