TEA WARS: white, black, red, green

Which do you prefer ? Which is healthier ?
«1

Replies

  • mockchoc
    mockchoc Posts: 6,573 Member
    My guess is green tea is healthiest but that's just a guess. I just keep some of all of them and have what the mood calls for at the time. I especially have a big variety of herbal teas so I don't have to worry about caffine and can drink it instead of water since I don't add sugar or milk.
  • enchantedgardener
    enchantedgardener Posts: 214 Member
    I prefer black teas myself. I like the flavour of a strong cup of black tea, the bitterness, the tannins.

    All teas are healthy. They all contain antioxidants and polyphenols. Now, the green and white teas have more of those than do black tea. But, on their own, all teas contain these health-promoting compounds.

    That being said, when you load up tea with sugar, honey, and/or high fat dairy products: not so healthy.
    Hot water plus tea leaves, maybe add some low-fat milk or a slice of lemon if you wish: perfectly healthy.
  • I've never met a tea I don't like! In addition to the ones you listed, I also love corn, barley, and dandelion teas.

    The healthiest tea is whichever one replaces soda in a person's diet. :smile:
  • Orient_Charm
    Orient_Charm Posts: 385 Member
    Black for sure
  • jenilla1
    jenilla1 Posts: 11,118 Member
    I've never had red tea. I like white the best - it's the mildest. I also like green tea. Black tea is a bit bitter and has more caffeine than I'd like. I'm extra sensitive to it and it gives me palpitations. I will look into the red tea. Sounds intriguing...:drinker:
  • BunBun85
    BunBun85 Posts: 246 Member
    Tea, Earl Grey, hot. =)
  • marvybells
    marvybells Posts: 1,984 Member
    see below.....

    (my edit failure resulted in a double post haha)
  • marvybells
    marvybells Posts: 1,984 Member
    Black > Green > White

    My all-time favorite is a black tea, Pu-erh....but i also LOVE Matcha which is green powdered

    By red tea do you mean Rooibos? if so then i'm not a fan of the red but that is not actually a true tea. It's an herbal variety. I do like some other herbal "teas" for energy, like Tulsi, Ginkgo & Ginseng. I have also tried Yerba Mate which did give me energy but also a throbbing headache.
  • mushroomsontoast
    mushroomsontoast Posts: 118 Member
    Black tea, has to be Yorkshire Gold, nice and strong :smile:
  • laurabini
    laurabini Posts: 257 Member
    I like both green and black tea. I guess all of them are healthy if you don't add sugar and don't drink too much of course :)
  • Noor13
    Noor13 Posts: 964 Member
    I love Oolong Tea
    If I have green tea, it is a green matcha
  • Noor13
    Noor13 Posts: 964 Member
    I love Oolong Tea
    If I have green tea, it is a green matcha
  • SadFaerie
    SadFaerie Posts: 243 Member
    I don't know which is healthiest, but I love red. I drink huge amounts of unsweetened flavoured rooibos, strawberry vanilla makes my day.
  • Many tend to think of green as the healthiest one I think, or even say it helps with weightloss (which, personally, I don't believe, as much as I love green tea).

    If you find it hard not to add sugar, milk etc, invest in nice loose leaf tea (and brew it in the right temperature), they taste much nicer. They might be a bit more expensive than your average black tea in bags, but a 100g bag of tea will last you AGES and is SO much better in quality (what non-loose leaf tea bags have in them: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fannings#Fannings).

    You could also change sugar to honey, which is sweeter and thus you need less of it. When I changed to honey years ago, after just weeks I found that if I put sugar in the tea, it would actually taste bitter and unpleasant to me! I've since moved to having my tea without any sweeteners or milk and thoroughly enjoy both the delicious flavours and the "health benefits".
  • agressre
    agressre Posts: 24 Member
    I drink them all and love them all.

    Rooibos (Red) has no caffeine and the most anti-oxidants. Technically, it would be the healthiest.

    All the others are really very yummy and it depends on your personal taste.

    Personally, I drink loose leaf teas. The prep time is not that bad (put loose leaf tea in infuser basket, place in mug, pour water) and the health benefits are so much better. Most mass produced bag teas (Lipton, Bigilow ect...) use tea rementants that are not purchased by quality tea bags (Mighty Leaf) and loose leaf sellers. That means you are getting the broken bits that are not good enough for loose leaf. Also, most tea bags do not allow the tea to open up and expand to its natural size. This means that you do not get all the tea oils and are missing out on the full flaovr and health benefits. Finally, a recent article in the NY Times pointed to the fact that many of the mass produced green teas out of China have a problem with lead being found in them. They think it is the way the tea bags are produced.

    Loose leaf tea in a proper infuser (not a tea ball, no room to open up) lets you enjoy the full flavor of the tea and get all the health benefits. I shop at Tea Gschwendner and Gong Fu Tea for mine. I know a ton of people who enjoy Teavana. I prfere tea with little flavoring, so I don't spend time at Teavana but if you like infused teas, Teavana is a good source of loose leaf.

    The other benefit to loose leaf tea is that it can be resteeped. I steep the same leaves three times and get good flavor out of the third steeping. If you resteeep, you should save money using a good loose leaf over a tea bag.

    Finally, pay attention to the packaging. One problem with tea in the US is that most people assume you use boiling water and steep for 5 minutes for all teas. You don't. Most Japanese Greens (Bancha, Sencha, and others) require water in the 165-195 range and you only steep for a minute. Oolongs can use water from 195-208 and steep for about three minutes. Most people who put milk and sugar in their tea find that they don't need it when they steep their tea properly. The milk and sugar tend to cover up the bitter taste that comes from over steeped tea. Kind of like adding crap to spinach that has been over cooked.

    ummm I like tea.
  • agressre
    agressre Posts: 24 Member
    Black > Green > White

    My all-time favorite is a black tea, Pu-erh....but i also LOVE Matcha which is green powdered

    By red tea do you mean Rooibos? if so then i'm not a fan of the red but that is not actually a true tea. It's an herbal variety. I do like some other herbal "teas" for energy, like Tulsi, Ginkgo & Ginseng. I have also tried Yerba Mate which did give me energy but also a throbbing headache.

    Pu Erh is my favorite as well but it is not a black tea. It has a totally different production process. There are black/cooked pu erhs and green/uncooked pu erhs. Pu Erhs are different because the fermentation process in the tea is slowed not stopped. So people buy pu erhs like they do wines knowing that the flavor is going to change over time. It is the only tea where the oxidation process is not totally stopped.

    Oolongs are another great tea that is produced differently then a black, green, or white tea. There are Oolongs that are closer to a black tea and Oolongs closer to a green tea.
  • 55in13
    55in13 Posts: 1,091 Member
    I think the differences from a health perspective are vastly overblown. None are bad for you and all have some benefits. Drink the one you like best. I drink more black than green, but enjoy both. White is too subtle for my tastes.
  • aerochic42
    aerochic42 Posts: 843 Member
    Just for additional interest; black green and white teas are all from the same plant, it's just a matter of how much fermentation and drying occurs.

    Personally I like balck tea, especially English breakfast
  • agressre
    agressre Posts: 24 Member
    Yup, black, green, and white teas are all from the same plant. The differences are based on how they are processed. White teas are mininally processed, green teas are in between, and black teas are more processed. Japanese and Chinese greens are also a bit different. Japanese Green's are steamed and Chinese Greens are pan fired to stop the oxidation. So they taste very different. I prefer the Japanese Greens to the Chinese.

    Red, Rooibos, is not a tea at all, it is an herbal from the rooibos plant. Technically, it falls into the herbal tea catagory since it does not come from the tea plant (scinetific name is failing me).
  • obrientp
    obrientp Posts: 546 Member
    Black tea addict. Love it hot or cold.
  • jen_zz
    jen_zz Posts: 1,011 Member
    I love Oolong Tea
    If I have green tea, it is a green matcha

    same!!
  • cadaverousbones
    cadaverousbones Posts: 421 Member
    All teas have different health benefits, so it just depends what you are looking for in your tea. I love all kinds and have a whole cupboard dedicated to teas.
  • agressre
    agressre Posts: 24 Member
    Teas come from the same plant so they have the same health benefits. The amount of processing can effect the nutrients and antioxidant level but not by that much. So white teas should have more antioxadents then green and green more then black but that is about it.

    I don't drink tea for the nutrients, there really are not that many in them. I drink tea because I enjoy the taste and it has 0 calories, I don't use milk or sugar in my tea. It helps with hydration and it makes me happy. It is a lot better then soda.

    No tea is really going to help you with weight loss on its own. If you use it as a substitute for juice or soda or some other caloric beverage it will help only because you are cutting out those calories. I see teas advertised as weight loss teas and I chuckle. You will lose weight if you replace your soda with a cup of tea but not because of some magical property in the tea.

    Drink what you like. I have been on a Pu Erh kick for the last year. I love Oolongs. I have three or four Japanese green teas. I rarely drink black tea, but I do get in the mood for a good cup of Keemun from time to time.
  • caspergirl7
    caspergirl7 Posts: 590 Member
    I like white tea : )
  • DMicheleC
    DMicheleC Posts: 171 Member
    I only drink rooibos tea or herbal/fruit teas. Super healthy, no caffeine, also you don't have to add milk to these so technically no calories. Just so much better for you. I stopped drinking black tea about a year ago, and couldn't believe how ill it made me for about three days after I stopped drinking it, that has put me off for life. If it can make you ill for three days that's not a good thing.
  • agressre
    agressre Posts: 24 Member
    How much were you drinking and what kind? I drink about 64 ounces of tea a day (black, green, Oolong, or Pu Erh) and had no problem giving it up when I found out I was pregnant. Granted, I am ADHD so stimulants effect me differently then most folks.

    I didn't like giving it up. I love my tea, but I had no physical response to it.

    That said, Rooibos teas are yummy. They have a good strong flavor that I like. Most herbal teas are far too weak to satisfy my tastes.
  • KeriA
    KeriA Posts: 3,338 Member
    There are more studies on the healthy benefits of green tea than on white tea but those on white show the same health benefits. Red is probably healthy but I haven't looked into it and black is healthy too. I usually go for white then green. Love English (Seattle) Breakfast Tea.
  • agressre
    agressre Posts: 24 Member
    White, green, and black teas all come from the same plant so will carry most of the same health benefits. Red comes from the Rooibos plant, it is technically not a tea, and has more antioxadents and no caffeine so could be thought of as better for you.
  • Shellz31
    Shellz31 Posts: 214 Member
    How can one possibly choose a favorite? I say drink them all! :drinker:

    Stash Teas makes a green/white mix that I LOVE. I'm not a huge fan of green tea, but mix it with white tea and it's delicious. Great with some ginger and lemon added.

    Rooibos (red) tea was my first love. Discovered it in college and it started me drinking hot tea. I buy a blend called African Autumn that I love so much I never go a day without it. :love:

    Black tea is my cup of morning joe. I prefer Earl Grey because it's so flavorful. And it kind of smells like fruit loops when you are brewing it :bigsmile:
  • I stopped drinking coffee since Februrary and replaced it with tea & herbal tea. I love David's Tea. They have a great variety and some nice flavors. I never add milk or sugar. If the tea is too bitter, I had some stevia which is sugar free & calorie free!