Why am I gaining weight?
debi_f
Posts: 330 Member
Okay, let me get this out of the way. I thought it was water weight when it first started happening, but since I've been steadily gaining since Feb, I don't think it's all water.
I hit my goal (and then some) in Jan, then decided to try upping my cals a bit to maintain. I started gaining weight. I lowered the cals, and kept gaining weight. I upped my exercise and gained more weight.. In total, I've gained back 20 pounds! (And 4 of them just in the last week!)
I eat at a deficit, mostly staying below 1000 cals per day. I exercise 7 days a week. I've only gone over on cals twice in the past 8 months. I log 99 percent of what goes in my mouth (I figure trying to keep the logged foods under 1000 cals makes up for the odd taste of dinner while I'm cooking, since I'm sure I'm not tasting 400+ cals). My carbs are usually under 35 g/day, though I have an occasional carb binge (I even managed more than 100 g/carbs one day this week... sheesh).
I've gained 2 inches in each thigh (though I have to admit that my thighs are pretty rock solid -- I run, ride bikes and do Pilates) and and inch in each area: chest, waist and hips. I know it can't be muscle, because you can't build muscle eating at a deficit.
Major confession: I drink Diet Pepsi. In fact, way too much of the stuff, but that can't be why I've suddenly gained 20 pounds. I drank the same amounts while losing 70!
What in the world am I doing wrong?
I hit my goal (and then some) in Jan, then decided to try upping my cals a bit to maintain. I started gaining weight. I lowered the cals, and kept gaining weight. I upped my exercise and gained more weight.. In total, I've gained back 20 pounds! (And 4 of them just in the last week!)
I eat at a deficit, mostly staying below 1000 cals per day. I exercise 7 days a week. I've only gone over on cals twice in the past 8 months. I log 99 percent of what goes in my mouth (I figure trying to keep the logged foods under 1000 cals makes up for the odd taste of dinner while I'm cooking, since I'm sure I'm not tasting 400+ cals). My carbs are usually under 35 g/day, though I have an occasional carb binge (I even managed more than 100 g/carbs one day this week... sheesh).
I've gained 2 inches in each thigh (though I have to admit that my thighs are pretty rock solid -- I run, ride bikes and do Pilates) and and inch in each area: chest, waist and hips. I know it can't be muscle, because you can't build muscle eating at a deficit.
Major confession: I drink Diet Pepsi. In fact, way too much of the stuff, but that can't be why I've suddenly gained 20 pounds. I drank the same amounts while losing 70!
What in the world am I doing wrong?
0
Replies
-
If I had to guess, I'd say that you trained your body very well to run on very few kcalories. You may have to start over with a metabolic reset (an initial gain), lose it again slower and then level off into maintenance.
More helpful info here
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/groups/home/10118-eat-train-progress0 -
Are you eating enough calories and are you eating your exercise calories back??
Maybe ask a nutritionist to help you out.
Good luck x0 -
If you are steadily gaining weight over a period of months you are in surplus and not in deficit....0
-
If I had to guess, I'd say that you trained your body very well to run on very few kcalories. You may have to start over with a metabolic reset (an initial gain), lose it again slower and then level off into maintenance.
More helpful info here
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/groups/home/10118-eat-train-progress
^This. If you logging honestly, it would seem impossible to gain weight from eating so few calories - but it isn't. Eating less than 1000 calories for a significant amount of time, limiting carbs, while also exercising by doing endless amounts of steady state cardio, you most likely have caused metabolic damage. Your body has gotten increasingly efficient at running on so few calories by slowing down its metabolism. The answer isn't to cut out more calories, because you are already at a dangerously low level. The above link from tryclyn should provide more help. I also recommend searching YouTube for Layne Norton and metabolic damage. You basically have to do a reset by reverse dieting. Increasing your calories by slowly upping carbs and slowing decreasing cardio and training. You will most likely gain more weight, and it isn't an overnight fix. Seek professional help if need be.
The goal is to eat as many calories as possible and manintain weight, not as few calories as possible. In the long run, such a large restriction, coupled with intense training, causes more harm than good. Good luck.0 -
If I had to guess, I'd say that you trained your body very well to run on very few kcalories. You may have to start over with a metabolic reset (an initial gain), lose it again slower and then level off into maintenance.
More helpful info here
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/groups/home/10118-eat-train-progress
This is my guess. < 1k cals long-term teaches your body to adapt to VLCD way of eating.0 -
If I had to guess, I'd say that you trained your body very well to run on very few kcalories. You may have to start over with a metabolic reset (an initial gain), lose it again slower and then level off into maintenance.
More helpful info here
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/groups/home/10118-eat-train-progress
Thank you, I'll check them out!If you are steadily gaining weight over a period of months you are in surplus and not in deficit....
Wow, how low do I have to go to be in a deficit then?
Granted, I'm not a perfect logger, but I do weigh 99% of what I eat, and I log everything except the odd tastes here and there (this is not a daily practice, mind you). Sometimes my salad will have 3 rather than 2 cherry tomatoes or 5 snap peas rather than 4, but would that really put me that far over?0 -
How much were you eating when you were actively losing weight?
You are gaining on 1000 calories because your body doesn't know what to do with all the glorious food!!
Are you exercising/eating back the cals?0 -
I actually implemented a rule, no taste testing, I have my husband taste for seasoning. Also Diet Pepsi is poison.
Good luck!0 -
When I said you are in suplus it certainly wasn't meant to suggest dropping calories - just stating the fact that you can't be creating something (additonal weight over a period of time) out of nothing (a calorie deficit).
If your food and exercise logging is accurate (and by implication your metabolism has adjusted downwards to such an extent) then I would urge you to accept that a temporary weight gain is necessary for your long term health.0 -
When I said you are in suplus it certainly wasn't meant to suggest dropping calories - just stating the fact that you can't be creating something (additonal weight over a period of time) out of nothing (a calorie deficit).
If your food and exercise logging is accurate (and by implication your metabolism has adjusted downwards to such an extent) then I would urge you to accept that a temporary weight gain is necessary for your long term health.
Sorry, my reply sounds snarkier than it was meant to be. I'm just really confused.
Thanks for the suggestions. I followed the link, and I think I'll do a bit more reading there this afternoon! I'll also check out the YouTube suggestion.
As for the Diet Pepsi, yes, I know it's poison. I've read all the horrible articles... but I just can't help myself! I think they make it with crack... ;-)0 -
I actually implemented a rule, no taste testing, I have my husband taste for seasoning. Also Diet Pepsi is poison.
Good luck!
Taste testing and Diet Pepsi has nothing to do with the OP's weight gain.0 -
Just a few guesses to start trouble shooting the issue...
1) you tanked your metabolism eating so few calories when dieting...you probably lost a lot of LBM along the way, thus your metabolism is much slower than someone of similar stats. You could try for a metabolic repair...I'd also advise making resistance training a substantial element of your fitness regimen. Make your body build muscle to help repair the metabolic damage.
2) you are underestimating your intake and thus eating at a surplus. A lot of people who claim to have been eating 1000 calories or less when they were dieting actually underestimated their intake and they're eating for more. This carries over into maintenance because they've never actually learned for real how many calories they are consuming.
People neglect to weigh and measure things...they just eyeball portions...they pick generic items from the database like "Homemade Chicken Soup 100 calories" rather than creating their own recipe or adding the ingredients individually to their diary...'cuz in reality, the chicken soup they're eating is more like 500 calories and 2 servings.
3) you're cheating yourself and not accounting for everything that goes into your body0 -
Not sure if you checked, but you may want to check your sodium intake. I once went crazy with eating soups because it was so low calorie and I could eat many cans a day and be way below my daily caloric intake, however I kept gaining weight. Luckily a friend asked me what I ate and then showed me the sodium content in most soups. For the next couple weeks I lowered my salt to 50-60% of daily intake, and weight dropped.0
-
1000 calories per day is WAY too low, plus you are working out 7 days per week. Your body is in starvation mode.0
-
omgggg! reading this made me sooo scared!! wtheck?? metabolic damage?? sometimes I eat aroun 1200, sometimes 700...so according to you guys, if I reach my goal and then start eating at maintenance calorie, im going o blow up??? I feel sooooo hopeless!0
-
Have you had your thyroid level checked recently? It's not unusual for women over 40 to have decreasing levels. Just a longshot.0
-
OMG I would die if I had to eat only 1,000 cals a day! Especially for how much you work out! I still get hungry eating 1800!
You probably hurt your metabolism doing this for so long.....0 -
This is why, when you want to take off the pounds, that you do it in a SUSTAINABLE way, so that it's a way of life that you can live with.
I KNOW I can't live happily on 1200 + exercise calories per day for the rest of my life. I love my family and friends too much to do that to us, LOL...0 -
Just a few guesses to start trouble shooting the issue...
1) you tanked your metabolism eating so few calories when dieting...you probably lost a lot of LBM along the way, thus your metabolism is much slower than someone of similar stats. You could try for a metabolic repair...I'd also advise making resistance training a substantial element of your fitness regimen. Make your body build muscle to help repair the metabolic damage.
2) you are underestimating your intake and thus eating at a surplus. A lot of people who claim to have been eating 1000 calories or less when they were dieting actually underestimated their intake and they're eating for more. This carries over into maintenance because they've never actually learned for real how many calories they are consuming.
People neglect to weigh and measure things...they just eyeball portions...they pick generic items from the database like "Homemade Chicken Soup 100 calories" rather than creating their own recipe or adding the ingredients individually to their diary...'cuz in reality, the chicken soup they're eating is more like 500 calories and 2 servings.
3) you're cheating yourself and not accounting for everything that goes into your body
Thanks, everyone for replying.
I do measure out everything that doesn't come pre-weighed. For instance, if I use a package of 400 grams of chicken, then eat a quarter of it, I don't measure to make sure I get exactly 100 g if I make it into a stir-fry, but I will weigh a chunk of breast if I eat it separately.
I eat a lot of salads for lunch (because I LOVE them!), and I don't weigh the ingredients. Because I make them basically the same, I count out what I put in (3 cherry tomatoes, 6 snap beans, 1 green onion, etc.). If I'm out of tomatoes, I may add in an extra slice of cucumber (or not), but don't go crazy trying to change my recipe to show such an insignificant change.
If I do add something extra (i.e., tonight I made a salad and added homemade bacon bits and Parmesan "croutons"), I list those separately. I don't like salad dressing, and the seasoning I use is low-cal/low-sodium. In fact, in the amount I use, it doesn't register as having any calories or sodium.
I don't have soups at all, because of the high carb and sodium counts. I love them, don't get me wrong, but I love French Bread and fries, too, and manage to live without them.
Sure, it's possible that I'm not accounting for everything correctly. I guess on some things when I'm in a hurry or just trying to get something in front of the restless natives demanding to be fed. Maybe I am totally fooling myself about the amounts I eat. But I try to be thorough.0 -
Go get a physical.0
-
I actually implemented a rule, no taste testing, I have my husband taste for seasoning. Also Diet Pepsi is poison.
Good luck!
Taste testing and Diet Pepsi has nothing to do with the OP's weight gain.
This.0 -
omgggg! reading this made me sooo scared!! wtheck?? metabolic damage?? sometimes I eat aroun 1200, sometimes 700...so according to you guys, if I reach my goal and then start eating at maintenance calorie, im going o blow up??? I feel sooooo hopeless!
That is exactly what happened to me! My advice would be to read up on the things these folks are saying now, so you don't run into this problem. It stinks big time! I feel like I'm trying so hard and losing ground everyday.0 -
omgggg! reading this made me sooo scared!! wtheck?? metabolic damage?? sometimes I eat aroun 1200, sometimes 700...so according to you guys, if I reach my goal and then start eating at maintenance calorie, im going o blow up??? I feel sooooo hopeless!
From the looks of your picture, yes, you're very likely eating way too few calories. The recommended calorie allotment for 1lb/week loss that MFP give you is generally about right, barring pre-existing conditions that would affect your metabolism, and has the deficit built in.
So, for the love of all that is good and healthy in this world eat the number of calories that MFP tells you to.0 -
Yes, It probably is time to have a full work up. Consider also the hormonal changes that come around at this time for us women. It has played havoc on me, too. I also concur with other posters-- that your intake has been calorically too low for too long, and you likely have some metabolic resetting to do.0
-
I think you are eating too many calories and are not at a deficit. Your body may need to have a certain amount of calories because your body is not burning them like before..
Reset your goals and let MFP set them. See if it changes and if you follow those numbers, and see if it works.. then you will find out whether you are eating the right amount of calories.0 -
Do any of you have good sights or books or blogs or vlogs (etc., etc., etc.) that you would recommend for resetting one's metabolism.
I've done google searches and such, but there's so much out there, and it's oftentimes so contradictory. Has anyone done one of these that has worked?
And any of you who have accomplished a metabolic reset, how much weight did you regain before you knew it was working? I mean, I've already gained back 20 pounds. I don't want to gain another 20 (or even another 10!) before finding out I'm doing it wrong and just getting fat again.0 -
Not to be a downer, but maybe your goal weight is too low for your body to healthily maintain? Our set point for optimum health usually creeps up as we age, and what was a maintainable weight at one year may not be as we get older. I would love to be 110 again, but I'm thinking 140 might be more realistic....0
-
^^^This^^^ The professional help to also run blood tests and set you up specifically to fix the problem... Clearly you know how to count calories after dropping 70 pounds the problem is the metabolism! Thyroid issues and other metabolic problems need to be addressed by a professional using blood tests to find the exact issue, put you on a dietary plan and meds to fix the exact issue that is going on.If I had to guess, I'd say that you trained your body very well to run on very few kcalories. You may have to start over with a metabolic reset (an initial gain), lose it again slower and then level off into maintenance.
More helpful info here
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/groups/home/10118-eat-train-progress
^This. If you logging honestly, it would seem impossible to gain weight from eating so few calories - but it isn't. Eating less than 1000 calories for a significant amount of time, limiting carbs, while also exercising by doing endless amounts of steady state cardio, you most likely have caused metabolic damage. Your body has gotten increasingly efficient at running on so few calories by slowing down its metabolism. The answer isn't to cut out more calories, because you are already at a dangerously low level. The above link from tryclyn should provide more help. I also recommend searching YouTube for Layne Norton and metabolic damage. You basically have to do a reset by reverse dieting. Increasing your calories by slowly upping carbs and slowing decreasing cardio and training. You will most likely gain more weight, and it isn't an overnight fix. Seek professional help if need be.
The goal is to eat as many calories as possible and manintain weight, not as few calories as possible. In the long run, such a large restriction, coupled with intense training, causes more harm than good. Good luck.0 -
You still need to go back over your food plans and see where your holes are. If everything is the same then you would not be gaining. I quit sodas because of the high sodium content in them. Something is not right. I maintain myself after each 20 lbs so that I learn HOW to maintain. Then after 2 weeks I start again. My trainer is pretty strict about learning to maintain yourself correctly.0
-
Eating below 1,000 calories and exercising 7 days a week is dangerous. When I first started here I was eating at 1200 (exercising 3-5 times per week, but still it wasn't enough) and while I was still doing that I ended up gaining weight. My body just stored anything I put into my mouth because it needed the energy. I now eat at 1700 calories, feel much more satisfied, and am losing faster than I had.
Your body sees the more calories as a surplus even though it's really not. It is just storing all the extra food because it didn't get to before.
Calculate your TDEE. That is how many calories you would eat to mantain.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions