Can someone tell me how many calories I should be eating?

I really need help figuring this out...

MFP has me eating 1200 I burn around 200 a day, I always eat my exercise calories back!

I am 5'2"
a 20 year old female
117.4lbs

I workout 5-6 times a week for 30 mins (Jillian Micheals) and then on weekend I work at a wedding banquet hall as a server.

can someone tell me how many calories I am suppose to be eating? I really don't want to eat 1200

thanks X

Replies

  • or atleast help me with my activity level :(
  • kiwitechgirl
    kiwitechgirl Posts: 145 Member
    When you say you don't want to eat 1200, do you feel that is too many or not enough?
  • SmileCozYouCan
    SmileCozYouCan Posts: 315 Member
    Like Kiwi said. If you think 1200 is too little for you, then you can try to eat a little more and see how that works. Or you can try the opposite. For your age, height, and weight, about 1350 calories would be the ideal amount for you. But checking in with a doctor or asking a professional person is much better.
  • I'm in the same boat actually. I am 24, 230lb, 5'6, mix between lazy and moving (the first two options haha but lately working on being more moving and walking), my profile has my diary (some stuff I messed up on but I'm learning). I would like to know if 1200 is right for me, trying to lose 15-30 pounds (more would be great, but one thing at a time).
  • FlaxMilk
    FlaxMilk Posts: 3,452 Member
    Since you are already light, you will lose at a slower rate. Go ahead and eat more as you aren't happy with your intake. You will just lose slightly more slowly. Try 1500-1700 as a general range on days you do more activity or exercise.

    How much are you trying to lose? You seem like you are at a great place to begin thinking about maintenance.
  • wild_wild_life
    wild_wild_life Posts: 1,334 Member
    According to a TDEE calculator like this one

    http://www.fitnessfrog.com/calculators/tdee-calculator.html

    Your maintenance requirement is somewhere between 1900-2100. If you're eating around 1400, your deficit is 500-700 cals a day. This would put you on target to lose around 1 lb a week if you had any significant amount of weight to lose. What is your goal weight? I would guess you are approaching it, if not at it.

    If you want to lose more you will have to do it at a slower rate -- so 1700 per day or for a 1/2 lb loss per week (total intake, no exercise calories). I think that's the best you can hope for. Continuing to have a high deficit at a healthy rate will not be good for your metabolism in the long run.

    Adjust upwards slowly -- there might be an initial gain but it will even out.
  • My goal weight Is 110lbs, so I'm pretty close.
  • Any ideas on my question @jsl_mfp? thanks
  • foleyshirley
    foleyshirley Posts: 1,043 Member
    I really need help figuring this out...

    MFP has me eating 1200 I burn around 200 a day, I always eat my exercise calories back!

    I am 5'2"
    a 20 year old female
    117.4lbs

    I workout 5-6 times a week for 30 mins (Jillian Micheals) and then on weekend I work at a wedding banquet hall as a server.

    can someone tell me how many calories I am suppose to be eating? I really don't want to eat 1200

    thanks X

    You should not be eating 1200 calories a day. You have very little, if any, to lose. You should focus on strength training. At most, you should be eating just below maintenance. 1200 is too low for you.
  • FlaxMilk
    FlaxMilk Posts: 3,452 Member
    I'm in the same boat actually. I am 24, 230lb, 5'6, mix between lazy and moving (the first two options haha but lately working on being more moving and walking), my profile has my diary (some stuff I messed up on but I'm learning). I would like to know if 1200 is right for me, trying to lose 15-30 pounds (more would be great, but one thing at a time).

    I don't think 1200 is right for you in the slightest. You have more to lose, and while you may lose quickly at 1200 calories, I'm not sure you would be happy or fulfilled long enough to make it worth it. Set your activity to lightly active and then follow MFP's settings. Eat at least half of your exercise calories back (half to account for overestimation.)
  • the 1200 was what the system recommended, thought it was a bit weird:| I don't EAT 1200, I end up with more like 1500 due to exercise. Please see my diary for more info.


    I'm in the same boat actually. I am 24, 230lb, 5'6, mix between lazy and moving (the first two options haha but lately working on being more moving and walking), my profile has my diary (some stuff I messed up on but I'm learning). I would like to know if 1200 is right for me, trying to lose 15-30 pounds (more would be great, but one thing at a time).

    I don't think 1200 is right for you in the slightest. You have more to lose, and while you may lose quickly at 1200 calories, I'm not sure you would be happy or fulfilled long enough to make it worth it. Set your activity to lightly active and then follow MFP's settings. Eat at least half of your exercise calories back (half to account for overestimation.)
  • wild_wild_life
    wild_wild_life Posts: 1,334 Member
    Any ideas on my question @jsl_mfp? thanks

    Sure, I'm really not an expert, I just know the math. If you plug your numbers into the TDEE calculator above, at "little to no exercise" your maintenance is 2600. At light exercise, it's 3000. So maybe just pick something in between according to your schedule -- say 2700. It's all an estimate anyway (and calorie counting isn't exact either).

    The chart below is what I have seen recommended as far as the rate of loss to shoot for depending on how much you have to lose.

    75+ to lose = 2lbs 
    50-75 to lose = 1.5-2lbs 
    25-50 to lose = 1-1.5lbs 
    15-25 to lose = 1lbs 
    0-15 to lose = 0.5lbs 

    So you would be good at 1-1.5 lbs per week, which is a 500-750 daily deficit. Taking that off 2700, I'd say 2000 is the minimum you should be eating (approximately).

    If you're set at 1200 but are eating 800 extra cals in from exercise each day, that's fine. That's how MFP is set up. But 2000 gives you an appropriate deficit IMO.

    ETA -- this is a good post that should answer all your questions
    http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/819055-setting-your-calorie-and-macro-targets
  • FlaxMilk
    FlaxMilk Posts: 3,452 Member
    the 1200 was what the system recommended, thought it was a bit weird:|

    My guess is that you put in 2 lbs a week as your loss goal? See what it gives you at 1 lb a week. Being male and young, you'll almost certainly be miserable at 1200 calories a week. (I'm not anti-1200 for all-it's the right number for me to lose weight. But to put that in perspective, I'm 10 years older than you, female, half a foot shorter, and more than 100 lbs lighter. We should not be eating the same number of calories!)

    *Just saw your edit-I think 1500 calories is too little for you as well. I agree with the person who suggested trying around 2000 calories.
  • helpfit101
    helpfit101 Posts: 347 Member
    I think 1200 may be too little.

    You can try starting at 1600. And eat back your exercise. Then monitor the scale for at least three weeks. Then depending on whether you are losing/gaining adjust up/down by 200 calories.
  • foleyshirley
    foleyshirley Posts: 1,043 Member
    the 1200 was what the system recommended, thought it was a bit weird:|

    My guess is that you put in 2 lbs a week as your loss goal? See what it gives you at 1 lb a week. Being male and young, you'll almost certainly be miserable at 1200 calories a week. (I'm not anti-1200 for all-it's the right number for me to lose weight. But to put that in perspective, I'm 10 years older than you, female, half a foot shorter, and more than 100 lbs lighter. We should not be eating the same number of calories!)

    *Just saw your edit-I think 1500 calories is too little for you as well. I agree with the person who suggested trying around 2000 calories.

    This is a female. But she still needs to eat more.
  • Biggest issue is, actually getting that many...I don't really have enough to eat 2k haha...Would 1500-1600 minus exercise be a good starting point?
    the 1200 was what the system recommended, thought it was a bit weird:|

    My guess is that you put in 2 lbs a week as your loss goal? See what it gives you at 1 lb a week. Being male and young, you'll almost certainly be miserable at 1200 calories a week. (I'm not anti-1200 for all-it's the right number for me to lose weight. But to put that in perspective, I'm 10 years older than you, female, half a foot shorter, and more than 100 lbs lighter. We should not be eating the same number of calories!)

    *Just saw your edit-I think 1500 calories is too little for you as well. I agree with the person who suggested trying around 2000 calories.
  • FlaxMilk
    FlaxMilk Posts: 3,452 Member

    This is a female. But she still needs to eat more.

    I responded to the OP earlier, but the person I was responding to in the post you quoted was male.
  • FlaxMilk
    FlaxMilk Posts: 3,452 Member
    Biggest issue is, actually getting that many...I don't really have enough to eat 2k haha...Would 1500-1600 minus exercise be a good starting point?

    Do you mean 1600 total then or 1600 net? I think 1600 net could be ok, depending on how you feel. When you say you don't have enough to get to 2000, do you mean money or room in your belly? I would suggest going to Eat, Train, Progress group for help on setting your macros. I think the recommendations on MFP should be thought of as minimums, but the actual goal should be a bit higher on protein. The ETP group has a lot of links to setting your numbers.
  • My girlfriend is having an even harder time eating here intake due to exercise...she right now is like 900 under...http://www.myfitnesspal.com/lonilee please help us:( - she is 22, 5'2, 165lb with light activity.

    1600 as in base 1200 - exercise + exercise difference. So If exercise was 400, that's 400 additional i'd eat.

    I mean actual food to fill that quota...I don't eat junk food anymore since I get addicted when I do.
  • foleyshirley
    foleyshirley Posts: 1,043 Member

    This is a female. But she still needs to eat more.

    I responded to the OP earlier, but the person I was responding to in the post you quoted was male.

    Oops. Sorry.
  • FlaxMilk
    FlaxMilk Posts: 3,452 Member

    I responded to the OP earlier, but the person I was responding to in the post you quoted was male.

    Oops. Sorry.

    No big-gets confusing with more than one person posting stats in a thread.
  • FlaxMilk
    FlaxMilk Posts: 3,452 Member
    My girlfriend is having an even harder time eating here intake due to exercise...she right now is like 900 under...http://www.myfitnesspal.com/lonilee please help us:( - she is 22, 5'2, 165lb with light activity.

    1600 as in base 1200 - exercise + exercise difference. So If exercise was 400, that's 400 additional i'd eat.

    I mean actual food to fill that quota...I don't eat junk food anymore since I get addicted when I do.

    I don't think 1600 calories will hurt you, it just doesn't seem optimal to me. I too do better eliminating certain foods, but you may want to look into incorporating some more higher calorie food items if you are struggling to get enough to eat. Your appetite may be off from the changes, but my bet is that it will normalize if you allow it to. (I don't eat gluten and I'm vegan, and I can easily put away 2000 calories without having junk food in.) Remember that veggies absorb better with some fat.
  • Could you recommend some foods to eat? It's hard to eat healthy and get the caleries. Like I said, my girlfriend is having a huge issue with that right now haha. We're having to search for some food and get ready to goto sleep, we hate eating before bed.

    ANY tips would be awesome! What should we NOT be afraid of (sugar, fat, etc). Things we are avoiding now: sodium and sugar mainly.
  • janupshaw
    janupshaw Posts: 205 Member
    I eat peanut butter before bed when I'm under, or a PBJ if I'm WAY under goal. Other calorie dense foods I like are cashews, almonds, and an apple with peanut butter.
  • FlaxMilk
    FlaxMilk Posts: 3,452 Member
    You don't need to be afraid of any foods. Of course, you have to manage your own trigger foods by what will work best for you. I'm not sure what your trigger foods are, so just discard anything that doesn't fit.

    Did your doctor tell you to avoid sodium? There is no reason to be afraid of it unless you have particular medical needs. Of course, eat it in moderation, as with everything, but your body actually needs some sodium. I would say the same for sugar-unless you have particular medical needs, you don't really need to avoid it. I personally do my best when I do avoid added sugar, but there are times it's just not a priority. Don't worry about trying to meet MFP's sugar limit-if you have fruit, you'll go over.

    An easy high calorie smoothie:

    Peanut Butter (200) + banana (100) + milk of choice (100) + strawberries (50) = 450. If you are willing to get adventurous, add some chia seeds (70-150), protein powder (120ish), and spinach or kale (minimal calories). That could add an easy 200 calories, using a small serving of chia.

    Keep in mind that my recommendations will be based off of my own lifestyle, so I'm sure I'm missing some easy ones that other people could contribute.

    Hummus with veggies or pita chips. 2 TBSP of hummus has 70-80 calories if you don't get low fat. Hummus also works great in sandwiches or as a salad topper. You could also substitute guacamole for the hummus.

    Nuts and seeds, high calorie fruits for snacks (dates, bananas), don't fear the potatoes (sweet or otherwise).

    Rice and pasta.

    Cereal-to me, it isn't filling at all, which makes it a treat food for me. Add milk or cream to your coffee.

    Don't buy the diet or low fat version of foods unless you have specific medical conditions that require you to.

    Good luck! I think you two will be successful. It's obvious you care, and you are doing this together.
  • wild_wild_life
    wild_wild_life Posts: 1,334 Member
    ^^ Agree! Thanks, Flax!
  • In general, I typically tell women that are your height to aim for 1200 calories. You could likely consume 1300 to maintain your weight.

    Get an exclusive look at Lisa's new book STOP THE DIET, I WANT TO GET OFF! at www.stopthediet.com and visit Lisa Tillinger Johansen at www.consultthedietitian.com on Facebook at Lisa Tillinger Johansen and on Twitter @LisaTJohansen