Should I treat myself a little everyday?
fangmouse
Posts: 119
Lately I've been pretty restrictive with my diet, eating just mainly vegetables and fruits and one serving of dairy for breakfast. I've been craving some foods daily (not desserts, just foods that aren't really all that great for me like noodles, frozen yogurt, chocolate, etc).
For the past few days since Saturday, ive been eating unhealthy food here and there like half a cup of chocolate milkshake and a slice of pizza on Saturday, a slice of pizza again on Sunday with a few bites of tiramisu and 1tbsp of chocolate covered raisins and today, Monday, I had 120g of frozen yogurt. I feel really guilty, because I'm not supposed to be eating so much junk.
However, apart from the junky foods I've eaten, ive been having salads, broths and fruit for lunch and dinner with Greek yogurt for breakfast.
Should I allow myself a small treat daily or will that hamper my progress?
For the past few days since Saturday, ive been eating unhealthy food here and there like half a cup of chocolate milkshake and a slice of pizza on Saturday, a slice of pizza again on Sunday with a few bites of tiramisu and 1tbsp of chocolate covered raisins and today, Monday, I had 120g of frozen yogurt. I feel really guilty, because I'm not supposed to be eating so much junk.
However, apart from the junky foods I've eaten, ive been having salads, broths and fruit for lunch and dinner with Greek yogurt for breakfast.
Should I allow myself a small treat daily or will that hamper my progress?
0
Replies
-
Allow the treat. Do you eat no protein?0
-
Well In my case I take small treat every time lose a pound.Gives me something to look forward to0
-
What's wrong with frozen yoghurt? I eat enough of that per day that I'm good for protein.
BTW freeze the greek yoghurt & you HAVE your frozen yoghurt. Chobani 2% is best for that.0 -
Lately I've been pretty restrictive with my diet, eating just mainly vegetables and fruits and one serving of dairy for breakfast. I've been craving some foods daily (not desserts, just foods that aren't really all that great for me like noodles, frozen yogurt, chocolate, etc).
For the past few days since Saturday, ive been eating unhealthy food here and there like half a cup of chocolate milkshake and a slice of pizza on Saturday, a slice of pizza again on Sunday with a few bites of tiramisu and 1tbsp of chocolate covered raisins and today, Monday, I had 120g of frozen yogurt. I feel really guilty, because I'm not supposed to be eating so much junk.
However, apart from the junky foods I've eaten, ive been having salads, broths and fruit for lunch and dinner with Greek yogurt for breakfast.
Should I allow myself a small treat daily or will that hamper my progress?
IIFYM eat it!0 -
the daily treat isn't going to make or break your diet. eating very little food and almost no protein will.0
-
Everything in moderation is fine IMO, I have a little high quality dark chocolate everyday
0 -
I stay away from treats as much as i can as i find i binge on it, but hey if you can get away with it why not. Only you can see if know if its effecting you goals.0
-
I think it's better to have a treat now and then, as long as you can fit it into your calories. If you are too restrictive with your diet, you are more likely to go on a binge. Besides, the way you eat now should be something that is sustainable. It's not a quick fix diet but a whole way of eating.0
-
If any foods are 100% off limits, they become 'forbidden fruit' and you crave them so much more. I am a total sweet tooth and love my chocolate so, instead of buying a large block of regular chocolate I buy a smaller block of good quality dark chocolate and allow myself a couple of squares any day I exercise. That way I don't tend to fixate on it because I know I can 'earn' my treat any day I want to.0
-
If you restrict it will ultimately lead to binging and the end of your diet.
This should be a sustainable lifestyle change. If it fits in your daily allowance eat anything you want!
You want extra pizza or some chocolate? Go work for it to earn extra calories! 0 -
I think it's better to use moderation instead of complete restriction of certain foods, but I also think it's a bad idea to conceptualize food as a reward.0
-
I dont treat myself. I totally agree with a pp that you shouldnt use food as a reward. It belies a very unhealthy relationship with food, much like your very restrictive diet.
I've lost 9kg (20 lbs) and I've done so eating and drinking what I please, within moderation.0 -
I don't agree with some post that suggest using a food treat as a reward. If you can enjoy a small amount t during the day and stay in your calorie goal go for it! I on the other hand have found those small treats keep adding up and turn into full blown binges!0
-
I suggest not grouping foods into categories of good or bad and learn to eat in moderation. Overall this approach will prove to be one that is sustainable for the long run. As long as you are eating in a calorie deficit regardless to what foods you are eating you will lose weight and on that note as long as you are hitting your macro and micro nutrient needs as well than there are no bad points for enjoying the things you like daily.... Get a food scale if you all ready do not have one and measure your portions, I have practice this approach from the beginning and I do not think it has hampered my weight loss.... Best of Luck0
-
Who says you can't have frozen yogurt or chocolate???????? They are good. A lot of people have the idea that you are NO LONGER a loud to eat--they would be wrong. Skinny people eat, they just don't eat great amounts of food. You need to rethink this--my trainer told me people FAIL at diets and I have failed at a lot of them---BUT---this is a" lifestyle change" for the rest of our life. Look at it that way and you won't fail anymore. Modify your foods to fit who and what you do. Never deny yourself anything, just don't binge on it. Have faith--you will do it, I have and I am not failing anymore. THIS IS THE REST OF OUR LIFE.................0
-
staying away from things you love to eat is like contemplating suicide........one day you will do it and go completely overboard.
Eat what you love in portions NOW when you can........binging is killing your self.0 -
The treats will only hamper your progress if they take you massively over your daily calories every day - but then, they wouldn't be treats if you were eating that much.
I have a biscuit or chocolate bar most days but I budget for it in my daily calorie allowance - and on days where I earn a lot of calories back, I usually end up treating myself too.
You have to be able to maintain your new way of eating, so you'll find it easier if you allow yourself treats and teach yourself moderation and restraint.0 -
You shouldn't feel guilty, especially if it fits into your cal goals for the day. I eat chocolate almost everyday but I limit myself to a serving size.0
-
Fruit. It's nature's candy.0
-
I'm going to disagree with most of the advice here but only becuase this is what I found works for me. It very well might not work for you so please do what you will. For me a little treat everyday hampers my progress or adds weight even when I am under my calorie goals. That's because I'm very sensitive to sugar. If I have a little sugar everyday it pretty much stops my weight loss or has me start gaining.
However what I've found that if I do a "cheat" day when I am really craving this stops the cravings and makes it easy for me to return to healty eating. I only do this when I find myself craving for several days. Usually it's once every 3 to 4 weeks.
This is what has worked for me but totally get it if it's not for everyone.
Good Luck!0 -
I have to have a dessert with dinner, like every night. When we try keeping desserts out of the house, I end up making something terrible from scratch and binging.
Best for me is to eat well throughout the day and leave myself with enough calories for dessert. No reason to keep it out as long as I am still within my daily goal. Plus, it keeps you on the road to success when you aren't struggling to fight certain cravings..0 -
Cut down not out and eventually you'll cut out altogether because you see no reason to eat crap.
I used to eat about 12-15 bags of crisps a day. I eat about that a year now!! I'll wander down the crisps aisle and look at the multipacks, consider a purchase then automatically think "what a load of ****e" before walking off.0 -
No!!!0
-
I'm going to disagree with most of the advice here but only becuase this is what I found works for me. It very well might not work for you so please do what you will. For me a little treat everyday hampers my progress or adds weight even when I am under my calorie goals. That's because I'm very sensitive to sugar. If I have a little sugar everyday it pretty much stops my weight loss or has me start gaining.
However what I've found that if I do a "cheat" day when I am really craving this stops the cravings and makes it easy for me to return to healty eating. I only do this when I find myself craving for several days. Usually it's once every 3 to 4 weeks.
This is what has worked for me but totally get it if it's not for everyone.
Good Luck!
Quantity of calories is all that matters, not quality. 1200 = 1200. So either you have some sort of metabolic disorder or you are going over your calories with the sugar.0 -
I keep a large bar of Godiva's Dark Chocolate with Sea Salt in my freezer. When I pack my lunches I take one square of it and put it in my lunch. It's only 50 calories per square and it takes care of that chocolate craving and the salt in it helps with my desire for chips.
I also will sometimes pack a bag of light popcorn so that between classes or I head to work I can have something that will hit my salty, munchy craving without ruining my plan and being completely devoid of calories. Just be wise when shopping and look at the sodium content on the box, some can be pretty steep. I can get away with higher sodium because a medication I'm on depletes sodium in my body, but for others it is a great way to pack on the water pounds.0 -
Enjoy a treat every day if you can fit it into your calorie goals. I just bought some dark chocolate-covered almonds with sea salt at Trader Joe's and I weigh out a few grams of them to fit my goal for the day. I find small things like jelly beans or little bits of chocolate, etc. are easy to measure out in small amounts to fit into a little bit of room in the calorie budget.0
-
No, I rarely treat myself. To me a treat involved something in addition to what I would normally eat. On holidays, or if i see some friends I haven't. Sure why not, then I treat myself.
That being said. What are you doing?? I'd go insane if I only was eating that. I eat any foods that I want. nothing is off limits. I don't crave anything, because its all available to me. I'm in this for life.
0 -
I eat what I want and am losing weight. It's about moderation NOT deprivation. When you deprive yourself that's what happens, you start eating it and then eating more of it. Whatever you do you have to make it fit into your lifestyle. It has to be something you'll do the rest of your life if you want to keep the weight off. If I want a ice cream sandwich, I have one, I don't have 10 of them. I refuse to tell myself anything is off limits. If I go over my calories one day, I either workout harder/longer or go under the next day.
I truly believe that setting foods off limits or calling foods bad is setting ones self up for failure. It's about moderation. There are no bad foods, only bad eating habits/patterns.0 -
I do that sometimes too!When we try keeping desserts out of the house, I end up making something terrible from scratch
I dont' need a treat every day. I think that's excessive, but once a week, a few times a week? Fine. Just try to pick something satisfying. Like, a small piece of dark chocolate works really well when I have a chocolate craving (or if I'm going really crazy, dark chocolate pot de creme or moose).
You're forgetting the importance of nutrients and satiation. Is the OP eating any fat or protein? That might be the problem right there. Add in some protein and fat and the occasional bit of dark chocolate or the really occasional croissant or donut or what have you and you'll probably feel better.Quantity of calories is all that matters, not quality. 1200 = 1200. So either you have some sort of metabolic disorder or you are going over your calories with the sugar.0 -
If all your eating is veg and fruit and have doubt that other foods will make you fat, begs the question, how many calories are you eating?0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 423 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions