Am I too heavy for running?

Options
I am 5 ft 6 and weigh 211 lbs (15 st 1). God it hurts to write that!

Anyway, I have previously incorporated running into my exercise routine - even did a 10k race once without stopping (a proud moment!).

About 2 years ago I got Plantar Fasciitis which meant I could hardly walk, let alone run. After a very long recovery I am now at the stage where I don't think running will damage my foot.

However, at the weight I am, I worry that the stress on my joints will be too much and I should stick to lower impact activities?

I'd love to hear your advice / experiences.
«1

Replies

  • nytrifisoul
    nytrifisoul Posts: 500 Member
    Options
    I am 5'8 and was 210 when i started exercise while eating at a deficit. At first I rode exercise bike till i dropped 20lb then went right into running. It was hard on my feet at first but my knee's actually didnt start to bother me until i had already lost 50lb and was running everyday. I bought new running shoes and performance insole's and my knee's have been much better since. So whatever you choose to do, make the first choice to buy yourself a good pair of shoes.
  • iplayoutside19
    iplayoutside19 Posts: 2,304 Member
    Options
    I weighd 320 lbs when I started running. If you're concerned about it. Walk for a few weeks. Then ease into it so your joints have time to adapt. I recomend a program like Couch-to-5K even if yo think your cardio fitness can do better. I will say, my knees and ankles got stronger after I started running regularly.
  • seltzermint555
    seltzermint555 Posts: 10,742 Member
    Options
    Start slow!

    I don't run, and I'm at 209, but I know a lot of people much heavier who run.

    In fact I'm in awe of them!

    I'll admit though I have noticed in the past 10-20 lb I have an easier time going along at a moderate jog...so maybe!
  • akdollie
    akdollie Posts: 69 Member
    Options
    I started "running" when I was about 260 ish (that was about 5 years ago)- about 2 years ago I developed issues with plantar fas.in my right foot only. I did some reseach into shoes and got some designed more for my issue. Since then it's pretty much gone. I started slow and I'm still not super fast but I enjoy it and just do as much as I can without aggravating my foot or my knee issues. There is no magic number to tell you that you can or can't be a runner. Just look into good shoes (I prefer Asics) and go your own speed. You will do great!
  • LoraF83
    LoraF83 Posts: 15,694 Member
    Options
    I started running at about 210lbs (I'm also 5'6"). It's not impossible but I do have some advice:

    1. Strength train to stay strong
    2. Go slow - don't push yourself for too much speed too soon.
    3. Take a form clinic - bad form will cause injury and you want to avoid that
    4. Get fitted for shoes - especially since you've dealt with pf before
    5. Foam rolling does wonders for sore muscles
    6. Do some yoga at least once a week to stay limber.
  • tesha_chandler
    tesha_chandler Posts: 378 Member
    Options
    I asked my doctor because I was concerned about the same thing. He told me that being heavy and doing high impact exercises can end up causing injuries to my knees, and/or back. He said I should swim, bike or work out on the elliptical until i'm at a lower weight. If you do decide to starting jogging anyway, make sure that you buy great support shoes.
  • daniellemm1
    daniellemm1 Posts: 465 Member
    Options
    I am only 5' and started running when I was 230lbs. I had never been a runner and did not think I could even do it. I used a C25K app and thought I was going to die just running for 30seconds. Each week I thought for sure I would not be able to progress but each week I surprised myself. I now regularly run an "easy" 5K. I have to tell you that running makes me feel strong and powerful. You can do it!!!
  • jeepyj93
    jeepyj93 Posts: 392 Member
    Options
    Go slow do the C25K program, get fitted at a running store for shoes not a sports store.
    Do a walk run and no you are not to heavy to run.
    Check with your Dr before starting any exercise program.
    I watched a gentleman this past year run by my house the progression has been amazing.
    He was a very big guy and would run about 30 seconds and walk a minute, I would see him daily now he looks at least 100 lbs less and runs all the way down my street. Not going very fast but still getting there.
  • JUDDDing
    JUDDDing Posts: 1,367 Member
    Options
    I started c25k at 282 lbs and survived. :-)

    I kind of think that if you've been heavy for awhile, your body probably gets used to carrying around that weight.

    If I tried to run holding 2 45lb plates today, I'd probably die.
  • janicebinva
    janicebinva Posts: 99 Member
    Options
    I had a very painful and persistent case of plantar fasciitis that is just now back under control. Have you been to see a good podiatrist or perhaps an MD foot specialist? I went through over a year of bad pain in both feet. After shots, physical therapy and custom shoe inserts, and continuing to stretch every day, it's now under control. I wish you the best with that. I know what it's like when you have pain every time you stand up, and pain with almost every step. It is a horrible way to live and really messes with your outlook and mood. So I know how you feel. If you're getting it under control, I would think you would want to be careful-- don't do anything too fast, or you could jeopardize your progress. Since you said you're heavy, I think it's important to realize that it will take time for your joints and muscles to build up to the point where running won't hurt something. Of course if you're in your 20s or 30s, you may have an easier time than someone like me who's pushing 50.

    I used to jog about once a week for five miles, along with other exercise a few days a week. Personally if I were getting back into it now (which I can't yet because my shoulder is still in a sling from surgery), I'd start with a few decent length walks, and make sure to keep stretching the feet, calves, hamstrings and Achilles tendons. Then, assuming your feet do okay, maybe do a run-walk-run-walk kind of thing. Take it slowly. Then as you progress and build up strength in your feet, joints and muscles, then take it further. This is what I intend to do next year. And my custom inserts get put into my running shoes when I go. They really do help.

    I hope you write again and let us know how it goes!
  • bondgirl129
    Options
    I've been thinking about running too. I had torn meniscus surgery a year ago, bunion and hammer toe surgery two years before that, and have dealt with plantar fascitis off and on for years. I also wore leg braces as a kid. I am going to talk to my doctor at my next appointment and get his two cents worth but I'm thinking if I start with walking/running intervals on a treadmill or softer track, instead of immediately going to pavement or asphalt, then it might be better. I still haven't been cleared to do anything besides walking which I've been doing whenever the weather cooperates.

    I'm hoping that starting slow and easy and not pushing too hard will be the key to success.
  • petechiae
    petechiae Posts: 147 Member
    Options
    I do not think you are too heavy. Just listen to your body, build your speed and mileage gradually.
    I started running when I was 210 pounds. I'm 5'4 short. I was slow and it was hard, I've had to deal with a lot of shin splints and take breaks, but now I can "comfortably" run a 5k. My time is not the best, but I'm working on it. If I did it, I am 100% sure you can too. Just take it one day at a time and pay attention to your form. A good tip that someone told me when I started running is "If you can slow down, you are running too fast". When you begin, run as slow as you can without it having an impact on your form.

    Like a few persons mentioned, I highly suggest the C25K. It's a good program that will help you go from the state of couch potato to 5k runner. The fact that it's a plan really helps you stay motivated.

    If you ever feel like it hurts too much, stop. Attempt an exercise that's low impact like the elliptical. It's really easy on your joints and is a great workout.

    You can do this! Take care. xo
  • BrianSharpe
    BrianSharpe Posts: 9,248 Member
    Options
    I was pushing 50 years old and 235lbs when I started running.

    Keep the runs slow and short to start with and build gradually. Most running injuries are a result of trying to do too much, too fast, too soon.

    The myth about running being bad for your knees is grossly exaggerated, if you have pre-existing joint problems or are morbidly obese running is definitely contraindicated,

    Check runnersworld.com or other sites for exercises to strengthen hips and glutes, weaknesses in these muscles often presents as knee pain.
  • edwardrz
    Options
    Heard a doctor say that every pound above your knee adds 5 pounds of pressure on the knees. So if a person loses 10 pounds, they lose 50 pounds of pressure on the knees.

    Go slow and easy while listening to your body is good advice.

    After several running injuries, calf tear and knee issues, I'm doing low impact exercise (walking, elliptical, swimming and weights) until I get closer to 200 pounds.
  • Daisy471
    Daisy471 Posts: 409 Member
    Options
    No, you are not too heavy. I have been running off and on for a long time, but started running consistently this past spring when I was at my heaviest. I am also 5'6", and was 215 lbs. This was just before I found mfp. Today I weighed in at 194.8 lbs, and I ran a 10k race on Sunday.

    Go to a running store to get fitted for shoes. Make sure they know that you have had problems with plantar fasciitis. C25K is a great program, repeat weeks if you have to. Go slow - you're going too fast if you can't carry on a conversation. Make sure that you have rest days, especially when you're still getting used to running, and remember to stretch too!

    You can add me if you want (so can anyone else). I love reading about other people's runs, I find it very motivating!
  • ModernNerd
    ModernNerd Posts: 336 Member
    Options
    Just rolling off what other folks are saying, but no you're not! Start small. Good running shoes are everything. I managed to get a stress fracture in my foot this summer because I was toodling around in ones that were falling apart.

    On a slightly more scientific note, biologically it's important that you lose the weight if you want to build back that bone strength. I was a lab assistant for a few semesters where we focused on in vivo musculoskeletal biomechanics and skeletal adaptation to load and disuse. We used mice but the principle remains the same. Stop using those bones and muscles, lose bone strength. Obviously don't go sprinting out the door now and run 30 miles, but start getting in the habit of running a little bit. If absolutely nothing else, I find it very enjoyable:)

    Best of luck OP!
  • endoftheside
    endoftheside Posts: 568 Member
    Options
    I had plantar fasciitis at some point over ten year ago, and had sort of forgotten about it because it hadn't bothered me in a long time. Until I started running again a couple of months ago. :grumble: I started slow and managed to avoid the other issues I had previously had with running but the PF (right foot only) was just getting worse. In my case, excess weight surely does not help, but I think there might be more to it that since I didn't start back until I was only about 10 pounds over being in the normal range for BMI.
  • NathanFronk
    NathanFronk Posts: 137 Member
    Options
    Go running.

    The longest journey begins with a single... Run.

    Look for the silver lining... and run to it.

    Roses are red, violets are... nope, poetry is for runners. Go running.

    :)

    Hope that helped!
  • dreamer12151
    dreamer12151 Posts: 1,031 Member
    Options
    I started running at 5'41/2" (yes, that 1/2 inch IS important! lol) and 224.8 lbs. I'm 44 years old and have fought plantar fasciitis in the past as well. I'm also not a doctor, nor do I play one on TV.

    My personal opinion? Run. Make sure you have good shoes & good socks and are getting good stretches in. Please start slow & build up, like has been said before, injuries occur when you start off too soon and too quick, you have to pace yourself.

    If you start & it feels good - no, great! - then keep going!! Good luck!
  • meshashesha2012
    meshashesha2012 Posts: 8,326 Member
    Options
    go to a running store and have them observe your gait to know which shoes are best for you.

    you're not too heavy