"Soup Can Make You Thin" Diet?

2»

Replies

  • PikaKnight
    PikaKnight Posts: 34,971 Member
    OK so I googled it. Says soup is fat burning and you lose 10lbs in 10 days. Wow great idea .. not :laugh:

    Soup Diet - Soup can make you thin!
    - Soup Diet - Soup can make you thin!
    Want to lose 10lbs in 10 days? According to a newly launched diet plan, all you need to do is eat more soup.

    Sounds pretty easy doesn't it? But what does it involve?

    Fiona Kirk, author of 'So What the F**K Should I Eat?" and "Eat, Live & Lose the Flab", says in her new book 'Soup Can Make You Thin' that a healthy diet of soup can make you lose a significant amount of weight in only 10 days.

    Kirk's theory is simple. Eat more soup, weigh less.

    Kirk's research into weight loss and nutrition has led to her believe that soup is where the secret to weight loss lies.

    She says: "When it comes to getting our waistlines in order, is nothing short of a miracle in a bowl."

    For 10 days dieters must eat nothing but soup (with a few exceptions here and there) and as a result will see a serious shrinking to their waistline.

    However the fact that soup is a diet-friendly food source is no secret. For those of you wondering if this is the Cabbage Soup Diet in disguise, Kirk says otherwise.

    She believes the main things that prohibit weight loss and keeping those pounds off are boredom, lack of variety, and one thing that the 'Soup Can Make You Thin' regime has, is a huge variety of foods you can eat.

    So let's find out how it actually works...

    How it works:

    The diet is based around the fat burning qualities of soup where dieters eat a variation of soups for 10 days straight, for breakfast lunch and dinner (and the opportunity for two snacks in between).

    This is a relatively flexible approach to the soups you eat but the only fixed thing that Kirk recommends is that you include a good selection of the 'SuperSkinny' soups that she outlines in the book in those first 10 days.

    Kirk says that soup is the perfect fat buster: "The combination of water and solid fills you up more effectively and for longer than if you eat exactly the same food but drink the water separately". Makes sense right?

    As well as this a combination of the fact that soup satisfies hunger, fights water retention, helps cholesterol, encourages better digestion, is a natural energy booster and is nutritionally a God-send makes it the perfect weight-loss tool.

    However Kirk emphasises that this is not a crash diet but a way of life and her book ensures that with her guidance you will be able to keep off the weight by incorporating of all your new found soupy knowledge in your day-to-day!

    She even includes a selection of recipes and guidelines of exactly which soups you should go for, for maximum effects - all you could ever need really.

    A Typical day:

    Breakfast: This doesn't necessarily have to be soup but if you really want to see results then opt for a variation of either:

    • Gazpacho-Style Soup
    • Very Quick Tomato Soup
    • Light Chicken Soup
    • Chinese Little Gem & Chicken/Tofu Soup

    Mid morning/ Early-lunch snack: Have a bowl or mug of one of the following:

    • Thai Curry Sweet Potato Soup
    • Spinach & Watercress Soup
    • Beef Broth with Pearl Barley

    Lunch: This is the time of day that Kirk says soup is essential to fat-loss. So choose from:

    • Thai Curry Sweet Potato Soup
    • Spinach & Watercress Soup
    • Beef Broth with Pearl Barley
    Add a small mixed salad if needed. Lots of green leaves, lots of colour and dress with a good splash of olive oil and a little lemon juice.

    Early Evening: This is the point where you will be most likely to snack so it is important to boost those energy levels with a high-protein soup. Choose from:

    • Gazpacho-Style Soup
    • Very Quick Tomato Soup
    • Light Chicken Soup
    • Chinese Little Gem & Chicken/Tofu Soup
    • Miso Soup

    Evening: This depends on what you have eaten in the day but the last meal should include a decent portion of protein and a load of vegetables.

    Soups include:
    • Pea, Mint & Lettuce Soup
    • Spicy Meatball Soup
    • Gazpacho-Style Soup

    Kirk also states that you should never go to sleep hungry so if you get a little peckish before your head is about to touch the pillow then have a small portion of Turkey/Tofu & Spinach Soup.
    Plus points:
    One of the major plus points for this diet is that the food that you'll be eating will actually taste good.

    You also get much more choice than most diets as well as hopefully never having to go hungry.

    You're also given the choice to give your own spin on the soups you are making or follow the recipes in the book, so you can pick and choose (within reason) what you are eating.

    Downsides:
    Making soup can take some time but there are also ready-made options to choose from.

    *from the website sofeminine.com.uk

    Wait. OP I thought you said this was long term? 10 days isn't long term.
  • SherryTeach
    SherryTeach Posts: 2,836 Member
    I just went to the author's website. He makes all kinds of claims about soup boosting your metabolism and other hocus pocus. It also supposedly balances your hormones.
  • vjohn04
    vjohn04 Posts: 2,276 Member
    Wow... Talk about the opposite of a friendly, helpful forum.

    I think you're getting extremely helpful advice. Yes, it's not cheery and 'friendly', but it is cut and dry and quite accurate.

    If you want to soup it up, go for it. But for me..... I'm having steak for dinner.


    cac.png
  • BeachIron
    BeachIron Posts: 6,490 Member
    Wow... Talk about the opposite of a friendly, helpful forum.

    Asks what people think about a silly fad diet, claims its not a fad, and gets butt hurt. Happy Sunday on MFP . . .
  • OP deactivated. :laugh:
  • ladymiseryali
    ladymiseryali Posts: 2,555 Member
    Wow... Talk about the opposite of a friendly, helpful forum.

    We don't support foolish fad diets. We also don't support dangerous ways of losing weight. Sorry.
  • I drive a semi for a living, and I'll eat a can of campbell's soup for dinner and then a regular meal for supper. I don't consider myself on a soup diet. The soups are low in calories so it helps me stay under my allotted calories.

    When I'm home I'll also fix a lot of different soups to eat, they are normally pretty easy, and like I mentioned before low in calories.
  • WalkingAlong
    WalkingAlong Posts: 4,926 Member
    Soup can be a big help in getting full on low calories. Read any of the Volumetrics books by Barbara Rolls, PhD, or google the Volumetrics diet.
  • Mr_Knight
    Mr_Knight Posts: 9,532 Member
    Have any of you tried the "Soup Can Make You Thin" diet?

    There are numerous studies showing that highly-liquid diets have lower satiety levels than solid-food diets. I love soups, but would go insane if that were my primary food type.
  • Mr_Knight
    Mr_Knight Posts: 9,532 Member
    Wow... Talk about the opposite of a friendly, helpful forum.

    How are these posts unhelpful? They nailed the topic pretty much perfectly.
  • WalkingAlong
    WalkingAlong Posts: 4,926 Member
    Have any of you tried the "Soup Can Make You Thin" diet?

    There are numerous studies showing that highly-liquid diets have lower satiety levels than solid-food diets. I love soups, but would go insane if that were my primary food type.

    Studies on soup, like that you eat with a spoon and that has chunks of food that you chew? Beverages, I can see.

    http://www.indiana.edu/~abcwest/pmwiki/CAFE/Soup and satiety.pdf
    http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15639159
    http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23093339
    http://communities.deakin.edu.au/deakin-speaking/node/438
    http://www.bbc.co.uk/sn/humanbody/truthaboutfood/slim/soup.shtml
  • Mr_Knight
    Mr_Knight Posts: 9,532 Member
    The Indiana study which lies at the root of much of that did 300 calories of soup in an otherwise normal diet. That's a long way from being a primarily-liquid diet.

    In addition, the chicken "soup" wasn't soup - it was solid chicken thrown into a blender. That too is quite a bit different than a chicken soup that is primarily broth.
  • WalkingAlong
    WalkingAlong Posts: 4,926 Member
    Right, I'm not advocating "all soup, all the time" like I imagine the OP was thinking. I think as a frequent meal or better yet, an appetizer, it's terrific. All soup, all the time would get very dull, I agree.
  • Mr_Knight
    Mr_Knight Posts: 9,532 Member
    Oh, hey, I agree, much LOVE LOVE LOVE for soup. Make it and eat it regularly.