The best gym equipment for weight loss?

2

Replies

  • cwolfman13
    cwolfman13 Posts: 41,865 Member
    Fork put downs and table push aways. Srsly...your weight loss is 99.9% about what you are putting into your mouth. Exercise simply increases your body's calorie requirements which in turn allows you to eat more and still lose weight...plus you look more fit in the end. Example...

    Lets say without much of any exercise whatsoever that you maintain on 2000 calories per day (average female). Theoretically you would lose about 1 lb per week eating 1500 calories per day...as you would have a 500 calorie per day deficit from your maintenance = 3,500 calorie deficit for the week.

    Now let's say you exercise and on average burn around 300 calories per workout. Your new maintenance would now be 2300 calories (2000 + 300 = 2300)...so to achieve the same 500 calorie deficit you could now eat 1,800 calories per day (2300 - 500 = 1,800)

    Any exercise you do is going to increase your activity and thus increase your calorie requirements. This is why I always tell everybody and anybody to sit down and think of some actual fitness goals that go beyond burning calories...it's all going to burn extra calories...so set some goals that go beyond that and prosper.

    Any good fitness regimen is going to have components of both cardiovascular fitness and strength/resistance work. Your priorities for either one will be determined by your fitness goals.

    Diet for weight control; exercise for fitness.
  • DavPul
    DavPul Posts: 61,406 Member
    I don't know. Nothing looked the same. And why should I have to google what's IN A BOOK that's supposed to explain it all? It had photos and descriptions, but it was not helpful at all once I tried to incorporate it in reality.

    I should have just googled in the first place and saved the money I spent on the useless book.

    this guy figured it out
    I took each exercise, googled them, watched some videos, saved some pictures and hit the gym as soon as I could. It's fun, and works really well. I also googled alternatives, because I can't get my fat *kitten* to do a jackknife to save my life, so I found alternatives. It's a good place to start, and the book is cheap.

    As I said, the book was supposed to tell me what and how. It didn't. Why buy the book in the first place, which I bought at the recommendation of people on this site.

    If you still have to google everything after reading the book, there's no point in buying the book ...

    the point is that it gives you a program complete with exercises and progression so that a complete noob has a place to start. sorry, but the $14 you pay for the book doesn't cover having someone come to the gym with you and hold your hand while guiding you to the various pieces of equipment and showing you each move in person. The gym has someone that will do that.....for $75 an hour.

    Either your expectations are too high for $14 or you're waiting to play the victim card, not sure which.
  • I burn more calories per hour on the treadmill than anything else if that's what you're asking
  • rml_16
    rml_16 Posts: 16,414 Member
    I don't know. Nothing looked the same. And why should I have to google what's IN A BOOK that's supposed to explain it all? It had photos and descriptions, but it was not helpful at all once I tried to incorporate it in reality.

    I should have just googled in the first place and saved the money I spent on the useless book.

    this guy figured it out
    I took each exercise, googled them, watched some videos, saved some pictures and hit the gym as soon as I could. It's fun, and works really well. I also googled alternatives, because I can't get my fat *kitten* to do a jackknife to save my life, so I found alternatives. It's a good place to start, and the book is cheap.

    As I said, the book was supposed to tell me what and how. It didn't. Why buy the book in the first place, which I bought at the recommendation of people on this site.

    If you still have to google everything after reading the book, there's no point in buying the book ...
    Ugh- You're completely missing the point.
    I'm in a training class for work. The open book/take home quiz is given at the end of every day.....

    guess what I'm googling that stuff because IT"S NOT IN MY HANDBOOK.

    it's a program. You don't have to come up with a program. That's what you bought. A program. That being said- you could have googled that up to. But the thing is there is so much stuff there you have no idea to start. Having a manual and a program gives you a jumping off point- a reference- something for which to google with out getting lost in the sauce.

    Just because you buy a program doesn't mean the information will be spoon fed to you- sometimes you have to get off your duff and do more work on your own.
    Pretty sure the book is marketed as a how-to guide. If I'm paying for a how-to guide, it better tell me HOW TO. It was confusing as hell for a beginner and more than one person recently has told me it is NOT the best book to start with. Heck, you even just said so in this thread.

    So my point stands that it is probably not a good recommendation for the OP.
  • rml_16
    rml_16 Posts: 16,414 Member
    I don't know. Nothing looked the same. And why should I have to google what's IN A BOOK that's supposed to explain it all? It had photos and descriptions, but it was not helpful at all once I tried to incorporate it in reality.

    I should have just googled in the first place and saved the money I spent on the useless book.

    this guy figured it out
    I took each exercise, googled them, watched some videos, saved some pictures and hit the gym as soon as I could. It's fun, and works really well. I also googled alternatives, because I can't get my fat *kitten* to do a jackknife to save my life, so I found alternatives. It's a good place to start, and the book is cheap.

    As I said, the book was supposed to tell me what and how. It didn't. Why buy the book in the first place, which I bought at the recommendation of people on this site.

    If you still have to google everything after reading the book, there's no point in buying the book ...

    the point is that it gives you a program complete with exercises and progression so that a complete noob has a place to start. sorry, but the $14 you pay for the book doesn't cover having someone come to the gym with you and hold your hand while guiding you to the various pieces of equipment and showing you each move in person. The gym has someone that will do that.....for $75 an hour.

    Either your expectations are too high for $14 or you're waiting to play the victim card, not sure which.
    "Victim card"? Seriously?

    I expected the book to be at least somewhat helpful. It was not even slightly helpful. I read it, thought I had a good idea of what I was doing, walked into the gym and found that it was a waste of money and time. And as I said, others have since backed me up on that -- people who actually lift regularly and know their stuff.

    I'm not asking for my money back. I'm not going to sue the writer or publisher. I'm simply stating it isn't what it's touted to be and trying to save someone else the trouble.
  • CallMeCupcakeDammit
    CallMeCupcakeDammit Posts: 9,377 Member
    Eat at a deficit and look for this machine in your gym.


    squat_rack.jpg

    And do StrongLifts of NROL in it

    QFT. I'm kinda sad we don't have this machine, but I'm making do for now.
  • sweetpea03b
    sweetpea03b Posts: 1,123 Member
    Free weights. Buy the book "New Rules of Lifting for Women" and follow the plan. :-)

    Yep. I do NROLFW from home. I have an all-in-one rack with the pulley system, knee lift chair, pull up bar, bench etc and what do I use most? My trusty dumbbells. Just about to a weight where the dumbbells won't do the job so I'm hoping to add a barbell when I get my next check :)
  • CTcutie
    CTcutie Posts: 649 Member
    Please check and see if you can get a free session with a trainer to get you started, so you don't feel overwhelmed!!:smile:

    I would also suggest if you are interested in any of the classes at your gym to not be shy, and just get there a few minutes before the class to touch base with the instructor, letting them know you are new! That way they can give extra instruction to you if you get "lost" during class.

    Cardio machines (elliptical, treadmill, bikes, rowing) are good for beginners, in my opinion, but if you want to do strong lifts, anything with weights you NEED to seek out assistance. (I don't think it's wise to tell a newbie to just go do this!)

    And you may want tot invest in a heart rate monitor if you don't already have one (that has a strap around your chest; Polar is what I use, for example)- I find it adds motivation to see and be able to log your burns more accurately.

    Have FUN!!! :flowerforyou:
  • Fentyman
    Fentyman Posts: 58 Member
    Cardio! I love the eliptical.
  • lizziebeth1028
    lizziebeth1028 Posts: 3,602 Member
    I think it's a mix of cardio and weights. Find which ever cardio equipment you enjoy and go for it :)

    Pretty much this!
  • PikaKnight
    PikaKnight Posts: 34,971 Member
    Free weights. Buy the book "New Rules of Lifting for Women" and follow the plan. :-)


    THIS

    Not only is it a progressive weight lifting plan, it prevents you from wandering around the gym looking lost. I made a chart for each exercise, pictures if you don't remember what the exercise is. Mark down the weights you're using so you can GRADUALLY increase them throught the weeks. I also do 15 minutes of cardio before and after I lift.
    I read that book. Then I went to the gym, walked to the free weights section and realized nothing looked like in the book and I had no idea where to start.

    So ....

    you're gym doesn't have a squat rack or power cage?

    and you don't know how to google.

    okay got it.
    I don't know. Nothing looked the same. And why should I have to google what's IN A BOOK that's supposed to explain it all? It had photos and descriptions, but it was not helpful at all once I tried to incorporate it in reality.

    I should have just googled in the first place and saved the money I spent on the useless book.

    So you took nothing away from it? Nothing at all? No tips on form, nothing on progression, why weight train, etc?

    I don't know if you realize, but gym equipment isn't created by just one company. So that means there will be different looks to the same "type" of machine or even racks/plates, etc. Maybe you could have asked which machine was which; or what something was; or where a specific thing was? Or was there no one available to help you at your gym?
  • My_Own_Worst_Enemy
    My_Own_Worst_Enemy Posts: 218 Member
    I don't know. Nothing looked the same. And why should I have to google what's IN A BOOK that's supposed to explain it all? It had photos and descriptions, but it was not helpful at all once I tried to incorporate it in reality.

    I should have just googled in the first place and saved the money I spent on the useless book.

    this guy figured it out
    I took each exercise, googled them, watched some videos, saved some pictures and hit the gym as soon as I could. It's fun, and works really well. I also googled alternatives, because I can't get my fat *kitten* to do a jackknife to save my life, so I found alternatives. It's a good place to start, and the book is cheap.

    As I said, the book was supposed to tell me what and how. It didn't. Why buy the book in the first place, which I bought at the recommendation of people on this site.

    If you still have to google everything after reading the book, there's no point in buying the book ...
    Ugh- You're completely missing the point.
    I'm in a training class for work. The open book/take home quiz is given at the end of every day.....

    guess what I'm googling that stuff because IT"S NOT IN MY HANDBOOK.

    it's a program. You don't have to come up with a program. That's what you bought. A program. That being said- you could have googled that up to. But the thing is there is so much stuff there you have no idea to start. Having a manual and a program gives you a jumping off point- a reference- something for which to google with out getting lost in the sauce.

    Just because you buy a program doesn't mean the information will be spoon fed to you- sometimes you have to get off your duff and do more work on your own.
    Pretty sure the book is marketed as a how-to guide. If I'm paying for a how-to guide, it better tell me HOW TO. It was confusing as hell for a beginner and more than one person recently has told me it is NOT the best book to start with. Heck, you even just said so in this thread.

    So my point stands that it is probably not a good recommendation for the OP.

    Sorry you had a bad experience. Maybe you should have tried this book instead?

    9780471768456_p0_v1_s260x420.JPG
  • This content has been removed.
  • This content has been removed.
  • _SABOTEUR_
    _SABOTEUR_ Posts: 6,833 Member
    I don't know. Nothing looked the same. And why should I have to google what's IN A BOOK that's supposed to explain it all? It had photos and descriptions, but it was not helpful at all once I tried to incorporate it in reality.

    I should have just googled in the first place and saved the money I spent on the useless book.

    this guy figured it out
    I took each exercise, googled them, watched some videos, saved some pictures and hit the gym as soon as I could. It's fun, and works really well. I also googled alternatives, because I can't get my fat *kitten* to do a jackknife to save my life, so I found alternatives. It's a good place to start, and the book is cheap.

    As I said, the book was supposed to tell me what and how. It didn't. Why buy the book in the first place, which I bought at the recommendation of people on this site.

    If you still have to google everything after reading the book, there's no point in buying the book ...

    the point is that it gives you a program complete with exercises and progression so that a complete noob has a place to start. sorry, but the $14 you pay for the book doesn't cover having someone come to the gym with you and hold your hand while guiding you to the various pieces of equipment and showing you each move in person. The gym has someone that will do that.....for $75 an hour.

    Either your expectations are too high for $14 or you're waiting to play the victim card, not sure which.
    "Victim card"? Seriously?

    I expected the book to be at least somewhat helpful. It was not even slightly helpful. I read it, thought I had a good idea of what I was doing, walked into the gym and found that it was a waste of money and time. And as I said, others have since backed me up on that -- people who actually lift regularly and know their stuff.

    I'm not asking for my money back. I'm not going to sue the writer or publisher. I'm simply stating it isn't what it's touted to be and trying to save someone else the trouble.

    You said it was recommended to you on here? By how many people? Does your one experience negate all of their positive ones? The book didn't change only the person reading it. Just saying.
  • My_Own_Worst_Enemy
    My_Own_Worst_Enemy Posts: 218 Member
    Eat at a deficit and look for this machine in your gym.


    squat_rack.jpg

    And do StrongLifts of NROL in it

    QFT. I'm kinda sad we don't have this machine, but I'm making do for now.

    I wish I had this in my house. I wouldn't have to ever wait for a squat rack at the gym again.

    Just wait, in a couple weeks you should start seeing these popup for sale on Craigslist and eBay everywhere.
  • This content has been removed.
  • PikaKnight
    PikaKnight Posts: 34,971 Member
    Eat at a deficit and look for this machine in your gym.


    squat_rack.jpg

    And do StrongLifts of NROL in it

    QFT. I'm kinda sad we don't have this machine, but I'm making do for now.

    I wish I had this in my house. I wouldn't have to ever wait for a squat rack at the gym again.

    Just wait, in a couple weeks you should start seeing these popup for sale on Craigslist and eBay everywhere.

    LOL. True.
    If I had the room, I'd want one.
  • TR0berts
    TR0berts Posts: 7,739 Member

    As I said, the book was supposed to tell me what and how. It didn't.


    Yes, it did.

    My wife and I bought this. I've read it twice - some sections more. The only thing it doesn't tell you is exactly where to start. But it does tell you how to figure that part out for yourself.

    If you had a problem walking into the gym and implementing this program, the problem wasn't with the book - it was either you or your gym. It sounds like it was your gym that was the problem.
  • BeachGingerOnTheRocks
    BeachGingerOnTheRocks Posts: 3,927 Member
    ....is the equipment you're going to use.

    That simple. Do what works for you. Start with where you want to start, give it a few weeks. If you like it stick with it.

    What works for me may not make you happy.

    I lift free weights, ride the stationary bike sometimes, use weight machines, run, use the elliptical, ride my bike, swim, play with my kids, do lots of yard work.....

    I honestly don't think there is one right answer.
  • JoRocka
    JoRocka Posts: 17,525 Member
    Whenever I'm into something new that I find interesting and I want to learn more about it, I google it.

    All of those programs are online. You just have to look. But, they are there. You dont' HAVE to buy the book, but you always should.

    Anyways, I can't believe that someone on the internet is arguing about having to search on the internet for something. LOL

    Even if I have a book on how to do something, that is very detailed, I'll do a couple things. I'll google the legitimacy of the book. I'll google other books that are similar. I'll look for fun facts about the topic. I'll search for other possible forums that are on that subject. And, I'll ask questions.

    So, just because a book says something, doesn't mean thats the end of that whole issue, even if its supposed to be the end all.

    I'm in love with the people who ask "what's planking"

    or what's "NROLW"

    or what's XXXXX

    when you say it.... in a post.... on a forum. Like really? you're a on a FORUM. That means at some point somewhere- you googled that ****. I would expect the simple things you don't know- instead of posting stupid easily re-searchable questions....you'd search.

    So get to get googling.

    sigh. oh well- I guess we can't all have high standards for ourselves.
  • geebusuk
    geebusuk Posts: 3,348 Member
    Another vote for weight lifting with big compound movements.
    ^^^ Oh, SO MUCH this! ^^^^

    I want one of those so badly for the house I can't stand it! :)
    I made my own for pennies - ok, I already had the wood and metal around, but it wouldn't have cost THAT much to make it from scratch.
    Mine isn't nearly as pretty as a lot of the DIY efforts out there (some of the wood still has nail in for instance, that I've just beaten flat), but it's stopped >300lb squishing my back, which is all I care about :).
    (I've tested it statically with a lot more than that and the bars hold fine.)
  • Always_Smiling_D
    Always_Smiling_D Posts: 118 Member
    All depends on what you are looking to do... for cardio, I love love love the Arc Trainer... strength free weights.
  • dbmata
    dbmata Posts: 12,950 Member
    Could anyone tell me what the best gym equipment is for weight loss? I've joined the gym and am off there tomorrow morning for a workout, but i have absolutely no idea what im doing! HELP!?

    The stuff you use consistently is the "best".
  • b_ray_73
    b_ray_73 Posts: 110 Member
    Eat at a deficit and look for this machine in your gym.


    squat_rack.jpg

    And do StrongLifts of NROL in it

    ^^Best piece of equipment I ever bought. Starting Strength is a great read to go along with it.
  • DavPul
    DavPul Posts: 61,406 Member

    "Victim card"? Seriously?

    I expected the book to be at least somewhat helpful. It was not even slightly helpful. I read it, thought I had a good idea of what I was doing, walked into the gym and found that it was a waste of money and time. And as I said, others have since backed me up on that -- people who actually lift regularly and know their stuff.

    I'm not asking for my money back. I'm not going to sue the writer or publisher. I'm simply stating it isn't what it's touted to be and trying to save someone else the trouble.

    and yet here we stand with a bunch of other people, some of them complete beginners, who were able to read the book and figure out how to implement the program even tho they had no prior knowledge of free weight and exercises.
  • BlueBombers
    BlueBombers Posts: 4,064 Member
    Free weights
  • CallMeCupcakeDammit
    CallMeCupcakeDammit Posts: 9,377 Member
    OP, if you do get NROLFW, join this group. http://www.myfitnesspal.com/groups/home/102-new-rules-of-lifting-for-women-nrol4w There's a link to worksheets that are already filled out with the exercises you do and make it a lot less complicated. They were a huge help to me when I did it. You really don't have to join to get the link, but it's good if you still have questions.
  • Hauntinglyfit
    Hauntinglyfit Posts: 5,537 Member
    I don't know. Nothing looked the same. And why should I have to google what's IN A BOOK that's supposed to explain it all? It had photos and descriptions, but it was not helpful at all once I tried to incorporate it in reality.

    I should have just googled in the first place and saved the money I spent on the useless book.

    this guy figured it out
    I took each exercise, googled them, watched some videos, saved some pictures and hit the gym as soon as I could. It's fun, and works really well. I also googled alternatives, because I can't get my fat *kitten* to do a jackknife to save my life, so I found alternatives. It's a good place to start, and the book is cheap.

    As I said, the book was supposed to tell me what and how. It didn't. Why buy the book in the first place, which I bought at the recommendation of people on this site.

    If you still have to google everything after reading the book, there's no point in buying the book ...

    the point is that it gives you a program complete with exercises and progression so that a complete noob has a place to start. sorry, but the $14 you pay for the book doesn't cover having someone come to the gym with you and hold your hand while guiding you to the various pieces of equipment and showing you each move in person. The gym has someone that will do that.....for $75 an hour.

    Either your expectations are too high for $14 or you're waiting to play the victim card, not sure which.
    "Victim card"? Seriously?

    I expected the book to be at least somewhat helpful. It was not even slightly helpful. I read it, thought I had a good idea of what I was doing, walked into the gym and found that it was a waste of money and time. And as I said, others have since backed me up on that -- people who actually lift regularly and know their stuff.

    I'm not asking for my money back. I'm not going to sue the writer or publisher. I'm simply stating it isn't what it's touted to be and trying to save someone else the trouble.

    It helped me when i was a complete begginer. Didn't even have to google the exercises because the pictures and descriptions ARE detailed and helpful. Please don't dismiss the quality of the book, or program just because you needed extra help following simple instructions.
  • MoreBean13
    MoreBean13 Posts: 8,701 Member
    FWIW I like Starting Strength better for explaining the nitty gritty of the big lifts.