Does melatonin work?
Replies
-
I've been suffering from insomnia for months now. I either cant fall asleep, or I cant stay asleep and I wake up every hour and toss and turn. My sister uses melatonin at 5mg and it works for her. I'm always a bit wary of pills, but I think I should take it tonight if I cant sleep. Who else uses it? is it safe? is 5 mg to much or to little?
Melatonin does not appear to be helpful in most people who have insomnia, except in people with delayed sleep phase syndrome (i.e. people who take a long time to fall asleep).
Judging by the fact that you've had difficulty STAYING asleep due to frequent wakening for months, I'd recommend you go see your doctor. While your insomnia could be easily remedied by practicing good sleep hygiene, it could also be due to an underlying medical condition, in which case you'd need to take care of that first.
Considering that chronic insomnia can have serious consequences in your physical and mental health, I strongly urge you not to self-medicate with dietary supplements like melatonin and to go see someone who knows what they're talking about.0 -
I used to take up to 6mg per night when I had insomnia. It would help me fall asleep, but I would still wake up during the night. I couldn't turn my brain off. I suffered for many months, and the melatonin slowly stopped working.
The thing that finally worked for me... ear plugs. I started to notice my brain would focus on anything it could, even quiet ambient noises like the heat/air switching on, cars passing, even my significant other's breathing pattern. Earplugs completely blocked out everything, and would allow me to sleep through the night. I've been wearing them every night for about 3 years now. I've become so used to them, I basically black out as soon as I put them in lol. The only downside is that I have a lot of trouble falling asleep without them (if I forget to pack them while traveling for example)
Good luck!0 -
Bad Side Effects of Melatonin Supplements:
http://www.livestrong.com/article/115717-bad-side-effects-melatonin-supplements/0 -
I have been using Melatonin for 2 years now and have always split my 5 mg. in half. When I used the larger dose I felt groggy in the morning. Of course everyone is different. I did see an excerpt on Dr. Oz once and apparently the doctor said that Melatonin is a hormone and anything above 2mg. is of no value anyway and will leave you with feeling like you have a hangover the next morning.
The doctor said that the only people that would benefit from a slightly larger dose would be seniors because they do not produce as much Melatonin as they get older and individuals with Autism/ADD etc. that have significant sleep issues.
I take mine about half hour before bed and turn the TV off etc.
Good luck!:0 -
It works but sometimes you wake up groggy. :yawn:0
-
This content has been removed.
-
Yes, and with no side effects. I only use it once every couple of months.0
-
Ooh, those are some well-researched, peer-reviewed studies...not.
Since you asked for it, here are the results of a meta-analysis comparing melatonin (2mg to 5mg with placebo):
Results
Nineteen studies involving 1683 subjects were included in this meta-analysis. Melatonin demonstrated significant efficacy in reducing sleep latency (weighted mean difference (WMD) = 7.06 minutes [95% CI 4.37 to 9.75], Z = 5.15, p<0.001) and increasing total sleep time (WMD = 8.25 minutes [95% CI 1.74 to 14.75], Z = 2.48, p = 0.013).
The Efficacy and Safety of Exogenous Melatonin for Primary Sleep Disorders: A Meta-Analysis
J Gen Intern Med. 2005 December; 20(12): 1151–1158. doi: 10.1111/j.1525-1497.2005.0243.x
While these findings were statistically significant, I wouldn't consider them clinically significant. Adding 8 minutes on average to your total sleep time isn't going to do diddly-squat for most people with insomnia. You are basically better off with just about any other FDA approved drug with an indication for insomnia.0 -
I lived with insomnia since I was a little kid, and I only finally addressed it a few years ago. I highly recommend the professional and objective attention of a mental health counselor, not necessarily a medical doctor. A counselor will dig into the reasons behind why your sleep is disturbed, and what you can change in your daily routine to improve your "sleep hygene." Melatonin was one of the things I tried, and I don't know if it is placebo effect or not, but it helped. Funny I've seen studies that show that placebo effect works even if you know/believe that you are getting the placebo. The mind loves to trick itself
Some of the things recommended for me:
30-60 minutes before bedtime:
Melatonin, if you want to try it
Brief/easy/relaxing stretches
A warm, non-caffeinated beverage (tea, chamomile, just warm water, etc.)
Write a list of the things you are worrying about, or the things you need to do in the morning (gets it out of your head, so you aren't worrying all night that you will forget it)
Turn off all electronics and overhead lights
At bedtime:
As quiet and dark as you can manage in your sleeping area
A glass of water by the bedside, so you aren't forced to get up and go to the kitchen in the middle of the night
15 minute meditation. I use the Mountain Cabin audio found at http://www.excelatlife.com/downloads.htm
My insomnia was a symptom of a deeper problem, but sleep hygiene is important for everyone. I also recommend tracking your sleep on a daily basis, as this helps me realize when my bedtime is drifting too late, or when I am sacrificing sleep for schoolwork, etc. I use a phone app called SleepBot.
**EDIT**
Also, of course, I was recommended to continue exercising, because it improves mood and general health, and both of these are good for sleep. No mention of some magical lifting routine, just good regular exercise that you enjoy.0 -
I use it and it is very safe. Melatonin is a hormone that your body already produces to regulate your "internal clock". However, studies have shown that it does not work with someone with insomnia from anxiety. It will work for delayed sleep onset caused by disrupted sleep patterns (such as shift workers). It can help you program your body to sleep when you want to, if you take it every night at the same time. It could take up to 3 months for your body to begin to get tired at that designated time.0
-
I lift and occasionally have insomnia.0
-
I use melatonin, I use 5mg melt tabs, they just help you feel sleepier and relaxed, but aren't strong
My daughter swears by valerian root either tea or pills, also a natural supplement, but I have never tried that.
try one and drink some chamomile tea about an hour before bed.
Also turn off all electronics a good hour before too, no computer, tv or phone since they stimulate to stay awake.0 -
Grehlin is the hormone that your brain produces to tell you when to eat. Melatonin is the hormone that your brain produces to tell you when to sleep. It is completely safe and already exists in your body. The levels of melatonin vary with your sleep patterns. If you try to sleep when the melatonin in your brain is low, then you will have trouble falling asleep. Taking melatonin at a certain time will cause your brain to recognize that melatonin should be produced at that time. Eventually, your brain will automatically produce the correct amount of melatonin at that time.
It does work if your issues are related to sleep patterns. It does not work if you are not sleeping due to anxiety.0 -
I lived with insomnia since I was a little kid, and I only finally addressed it a few years ago. I highly recommend the professional and objective attention of a mental health counselor, not necessarily a medical doctor. A counselor will dig into the reasons behind why your sleep is disturbed, and what you can change in your daily routine to improve your "sleep hygene."
There are many of reasons why she could have chronic insomnia that have nothing to do with mental health. If the reason for her insomnia is related to sleep hygiene then she can find all the info she needs on the internet without paying a dime. If her insomnia is secondary to an underlying medical condition, she needs to see a doctor and get medical treatment.
Please stop advising someone with chronic insomnia to self-medicate with supplements or talk to a counselor. If sleep hygiene isn't an issue here, and she hasn't seen a doctor, then she should see one.0 -
It's worked for me as far as getting asleep. I still wake up in the middle of the night, but it's easier to get back to sleep. 5mg is okay. See how it works for you. It works for me, but not for my dad, so you can't know until you try it, if you feel that's what you need.0
-
It personally worked wonders for me, I am a huge insomniac going like 30hours without sleep, it was killing me!
I used to take 2mg and that worked fine!
My brother also used to take it, he has ADHD and wouldnt sleep so the doctor gave it to him... He was out like a light after! and He also only took 2-3mg a night....
I think it might be mostly if not all natural too so its better
I hope that helps!0 -
I use melatonin very rarely. But when I do, it knocks me out. I wake up the next day feeling great!0
-
That is a natural vitamin supplement that DOES work.....0
-
Great to know! I'm going to split the 5mg pill in half soon and take it. I'll update everyone tomorrow. :bigsmile:0
-
My doctor recently put me on Metatonin 5mg and it's been working great. I had trouble falling asleep and staying asleep. Now I get to sleep quickly most nights and don't have alot of trouble failing back asleep if I do wake up. Sometimes I even sleep all the way through now. And the melatonin doesn't keep me from waking up on time and alert.
Since it's a fairly cheap OTC supplement, I would suggest just giving it a try.0 -
OP: Melatonin works for me if I take 9 mg. Melatonin is naturally produced by the body. Don't listen to Nutellabrah- you CANNOT get addicted to Melatonin.0
-
Melatonin definitely works. If you take it you won't argue while in your underwear.0
-
I use melatonin very rarely. But when I do, it knocks me out. I wake up the next day feeling great!
Great to know! I'm going to split the 5mg pill in half soon and take it. I'll update everyone tomorrow. :bigsmile:0 -
OP - I lived in Alaska for two years, which is where I learned about melatonin. It was widely used where I lived to help deal with insomnia, SAD (seasonal affective disorder), and to help keep regular sleep patterns in the winter. I've taken it on and off for many years with no adverse affects. Lots of folks say to take it an hour before bed (and that works for them!) but for me I have about a 20 minute window before my body seems to shake it off. If I take it and go directly to bed I can fall asleep pretty quickly, but if I wait any longer than 20 minutes or am doing something busy before bed it doesn't work at all.
I generally take 5 mg. I've taken higher dosages (with doctor approval), but get really wacky, unsettling dreams from high dosages (which I don't like). Even at 1 mg & 3 mg I still have really vivid dreams. Whatever dose, though, I've never woken up groggy the next day.
If it's your first time trying it make sure you don't have to go anywhere in the morning (work or school). Like all the commercials say - don't drive until you know how it will affect you. I have a few friends who ARE groggy from melatonin even on low dosages.
Hope that helps!0 -
Melatonin has been shown to be fairly safe, and its low incidence of side effects is why many doctors are quick to recommend it. It's not very effective for insomnia compared to other options though.0
-
OP. I would suggest checking with a Dr as there might be a bigger issue at play.0
-
I have been taking it for months, and it works so well. I take 3mg. I have trouble falling asleep and when i take it, I fall asleep, and if i happen to wake up, i fall back to sleep right away.i have to make sure to get enough sleep otherwise I cant function at work. I never saw any side effects of taking it. Makes me feel well rested.0
-
I've taken melatonin (as suggested by my doctor) probably a dozen times and it has worked every time. But I don't take it unless I have already had some insomnia so I'm not sure how reliable my stats are. I find reliably that if I have had lots of exercise I sleep eight hours and when I have had zero exercise I am likely to have insomnia.
But I also want to say that insomnia can exacerbate and be exacerbated by psychological disorders (depression, anxiety etc). I have a couple friends that can attest to that. One is now on an antidepression medication and the other is on a GAD medication.
Not sure how reliable this is but I've read that if you are experiencing sleepiness during the day, you are more likely to have a sleep disorder and should consider visiting a sleep clinic. If you are experiencing fatigue but not sleepiness, you should see your doctor.
Good luck!0 -
It works for me, I usually take one on Sundays and maybe one other time per week. I get them from Costco, pretty inexpensive0
-
I use it occasionally. Sometimes it seems to work, other times it doesn't. Get some you can dissolve under your tongue if you can, it works better (apparently).
ETA: It is generally considered safe, but should not be used for extended periods of time.
I am currently using it (dissolvable) and it does SEEM to be helping. It's supposed to trigger your own body's natural sleep mechanisms (melatonin), from what I understand. I have read data suggesting amounts much smaller than they sell at the store can actually be MORE effective than larger amounts, but I take 3mg and it seems to do okay. I still don't sleep through the night, but I also have IC to complicate the issue, so there's that...0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 430 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions