What Should I be eating to lose weight?

You don't have a lot of weight to lose. I suggest plugging your numbers into MFP, set the goal weight loss to 0.5 or 1 lbs per week.

The important thing is to accurately and consistently log the food you eat. Don't skip days. Weigh your food, so you know for sure that it's 100g or 5 ounces, or whatever. You don't have to eat low carb or high fat or anything you don't want to do. The key is to eat less calories than you use by moving around.

The calorie goal MFP gives you already has a deficit built in. So don't be afraid to eat all the calories it tells you to. Good luck!

Eat whatever allows you to achieve your desired caloric deficit and be happy. If that's an Atkins diet, then eat foods that are consistent with Atkins-friendly macros. If you find you need to save some of your daily calories for chocolate and ice cream in order to be happy, then that's what you should be eating. There is no one-size-fits-all answer to this question.

Foods to eat - after you've been logging a few days - you will notice that some of the foods you are currently eating are great (serving sizes make sense or have a lot of nutrition). Other foods may shock you a bit (servings are tiny or calories are terribly high). That's all part of learning a new lifestyle.

I find that non-processed foods give me more......more protein, more fiber, larger serving size, for fewer calories. But I won't give up any food completely, I just have to "manage" them better.

Yep, it doesn't have to be about what you eat, but more of how much you eat. A diet full of takeaways and chocolate can still yield weight loss if you do a good job of tracking calories and stay under your goal. The down side of that is that food like those are often calorie dense (have lots of calories for little volume of food) and you will potentially find yourself hungry often. Foods that are light on the calories and nutrient dense can help you eat less because the overall volume will be more. Many people find success changing one or two things at a time. Instead of takeaways every day, start packing a lunch or making a healthy meal at home 2-3 nights a week. If you drink full sugar soda, drop back to diet soda. Small things can add up, but you will want to also track calories so you can keep at goal. Soon you will start to see what things you are more willing to cut for better choices. One meal that comes in at your calories for the day will be a big wake up call (usually is for me) and helps me make the better choices. Healthy food doesn't need to taste bad.

My diary is always open, I haven't logged much the past few weeks, but I have a few weeks in January and Feb filled out. Also a whole lot from a year ago. I've gone between 1500 and 1900 calories depending on my goals at the time.