We are pleased to announce that as of March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor has been introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

Can you use Pam (spray oil) as substitute for butter

Posts: 122
edited February 15 in Chit-Chat
in recipe? Recipe calls for 150g of butter. Can I just spray pam for a minute or two into the other ingredients as a replacement for butter?

Welcome!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.
«13

Replies

  • Posts: 3,908 Member
    No
  • Posts: 5,609 Member
    in recipe? Recipe calls for 150g of butter. Can I just spray pam for a minute or two into the other ingredients as a replacement for butter?

    Why would you want to replace butter - just make it fit into your calories (butter tastes better). :smile:
  • Posts: 122

    Why would you want to replace butter - just make it fit into your calories (butter tastes better). :smile:

    Don't have any butter and i also plan on eating the entire batch
  • Posts: 3,536 Member
    I'm am going with the no crowd.......... :sick:
  • Posts: 5,609 Member

    Don't have any butter and i also plan on eating the entire batch

    :smile: - why not try it and see how it turns out. There's nothing better than experimental cooking (except of course when it doesn't work).

    I remember once spending 3 hours preparing and cooking a spinach and potato dish - what a waste of 3 hours (time I will never get back). In the end I threw it in the bin and fried up a packet bubble and squeak.

    Good luck.
  • Posts: 151 Member
    No, you can't. Butter is used in baked goods, not only for flavor, but often to provide a little moisture.
  • Posts: 3,908 Member
    I doubt whatever you're making that's supposed to have 150g of butter in it has the butter as a flavour enhancer.

    My money is on that it is in there for essential, structural reasons.
  • Posts: 211 Member

    Don't have any butter and i also plan on eating the entire batch
    And you think Pam tastes better? Please don't say you think it is low cal.
  • Posts: 122
    And you think Pam tastes better? Please don't say you think it is low cal.

    label046791.gif

    1minute spray = 37.8g of fat = 340calories

    much less than

    150g of butter which is 121.5g of fat and 1094 calories
  • Posts: 211 Member
    Thing is you need 150g of Pam. Time it as you spray it on a scale and then to the cal math.
  • Posts: 122
    Thing is you need 150g of Pam. Time it as you spray it on a scale and then to the cal math.

    im not going to waste an entire can of it right now

    since its in gas form wont it just evaporate?
  • Posts: 3,908 Member
    The calories in an average McDonald's meal is infinitesimal compared to the calories of China's entire vegetable production per year.

    Using your figures, butter is lower in calories...
  • Posts: 322 Member
    Ew.
  • Posts: 218 Member
    No. You can replace butter with applesauce, coconut oil, plain Greek yogurt.
  • Posts: 211 Member

    im not going to waste an entire can of it right now

    since its in gas form wont it just evaporate?
    Thanks for the smile.
  • Posts: 122
    Thanks for the smile.

    tumblr_m5410opBZS1rr66wko1_500.gif
  • Posts: 612 Member

    label046791.gif

    1minute spray = 37.8g of fat = 340calories

    much less than

    150g of butter which is 121.5g of fat and 1094 calories

    Get a timer, spray for 166 seconds.
  • Posts: 122

    Get a timer, spray for 166 seconds.

    How do i convert grams into seconds?
  • Posts: 5,609 Member
    Have you not made it yet. It would have been quicker to pop to the shops and buy some butter!!

    And if you had walked then screw the extra calories - you're just eating them back. :laugh:
  • Posts: 122
    Have you not made it yet. It would have been quicker to pop to the shops and buy some butter!!

    And if you had walked then screw the extra calories - you're just eating them back. :laugh:

    I live 120km from the nearest supermarket and i can't drive my car right now because i put the wrong octane gas in it, so im going to use the pam and i will report back and post my results.

    :smile:
  • Posts: 5,609 Member

    I live 120km from the nearest supermarket and i can't drive my car right now because i put the wrong octane gas in it, so im going to use the pam and i will report back and post my results.

    :smile:

    'i put the wrong octane gas in it'

    Have you not learnt your lesson already? :smile:

    Maybe make something else for lunch?
  • Posts: 391
    NO.

    Pam contains "propellant", which is food-grade alcohol, nitrous oxide, carbon dioxide, and/or propane.

    Do you really want to ingest that as a substitute for butter just so you can eat a ton of crap??? :noway:
  • Posts: 122

    'i put the wrong octane gas in it'

    Have you not learnt your lesson already? :smile:

    Maybe make something else for lunch?

    learnt is not a word

    have you learned your lesson kind sir?
  • Posts: 3,908 Member

    learnt is not a word

    have you learned your lesson kind sir?

    In England, where the English speak English it is a word.
  • Posts: 122

    In England, where the English speak English it is a word.

    Pretty sure its called great britain and they speak british english
  • Posts: 9,003 Member
    Herp Derp.
  • Posts: 612 Member

    How do i convert grams into seconds?

    To get the 121.5g of fat you'd need 166 seconds of Pam Spray.

    Make the recipe without the butter.
    Divide it into 10 servings.
    Eat it in 1/4 serving bites.
    That would equate to 4 seconds of Pam Spray Per bite.

    Take a bite followed by 4 seconds of Pam Spray in your mouth.
  • Posts: 122
    To get the 121.5g of fat you'd need 166 seconds of Pam Spray.

    Make the recipe without the butter.
    Divide it into 10 servings.
    Eat it in 1/4 serving bites.
    That would equate to 4 seconds of Pam Spray Per bite.

    Take a bite followed by 4 seconds of Pam Spray in your mouth.

    Profit??

    XdXVG.gif
  • Posts: 13,274 Member
    Pam is just for creating a no-stick surface. It is not for replacing butter or margarine or oil in recipes.
  • Posts: 16,414 Member

    Don't have any butter and i also plan on eating the entire batch
    I suspect that replacing the butter with Pam will solve your problem of eating the entire batch.
This discussion has been closed.