Anybody else given up artificial sweeteners?
MandaJean83
Posts: 675 Member
Hey everyone
So I had a lot of success this past year in losing over 20 lbs, just by faithfully logging my food and upping my exercise. I'm a nurse, so my health is actually very important to me after seeing what years of abuse and neglect will do to a person's body. I work on an oncology floor, and have seen so much cancer in younger people lately. Super scary. It really got me thinking about whether or not it may be related to all the diet drinks and foods our generation tends to consume. I haven't read the research myself, but I've been told there has been a link. Either way, I feel like MAYBE 4 cans of diet coke a day, and two or three coffees with splenda is probably not benefitting me any.
So last month, I totally gave up all the splenda, sweet and low, stevia, etc. It has been super hard for me, and I've had to resort to putting sugar in my tea/coffee because I cannot drink them black to save my fricking life. LOL Not only is the urge to sip a diet coke hard to overcome, but I also felt extremely sluggish the first few weeks without consuming them. And some withdrawl headaches as well. LOL
Just wondering what other's experiences have been! Anyone else made the leap and given them up?
So I had a lot of success this past year in losing over 20 lbs, just by faithfully logging my food and upping my exercise. I'm a nurse, so my health is actually very important to me after seeing what years of abuse and neglect will do to a person's body. I work on an oncology floor, and have seen so much cancer in younger people lately. Super scary. It really got me thinking about whether or not it may be related to all the diet drinks and foods our generation tends to consume. I haven't read the research myself, but I've been told there has been a link. Either way, I feel like MAYBE 4 cans of diet coke a day, and two or three coffees with splenda is probably not benefitting me any.
So last month, I totally gave up all the splenda, sweet and low, stevia, etc. It has been super hard for me, and I've had to resort to putting sugar in my tea/coffee because I cannot drink them black to save my fricking life. LOL Not only is the urge to sip a diet coke hard to overcome, but I also felt extremely sluggish the first few weeks without consuming them. And some withdrawl headaches as well. LOL
Just wondering what other's experiences have been! Anyone else made the leap and given them up?
0
Replies
-
Awww, no one!? I guess it's just me! haha0
-
I personally gave up all artificial sweeteners years ago. Aspartame really screws with my anxiety. It took me a long time to figure that out, but I started doing some experimenting after reading a bunch about it and found a definite link for me. Splenda does not agree with my body at all... I can't digest it. Best case scenario, bloating. Worst case scenario, massive intestinal cramping and having to run to the bathroom.
It's also been shown that artificial sweeteners can trigger an insulin release. Not good for those of us who have insulin issues.
This isn't the exact study I was looking for to link to, but this is one shared to me by the veterinary specialist I consult with on my horse's insulin resistance. There have been more recent ones covering other sweeteners.
http://ajpendo.physiology.org/content/238/4/E336.abstract0 -
I eliminated them too. I do admit to sneaking a small glass of diet coke every few days, but way less than I did before. At first I put a tsp of honey in my coffee, but now I got used to drinking it unsweetened, and I prefer it that way now. I sometimes put about 1/2 tsp coconut manna in my coffee. It gives it a barely there nutty almost sweet taste and with my full fat cream makes a yummy coffee. Once I cut out all the added sugars, it makes my fruit and dark chocolate taste much sweeter and more satisfying. I don't feel guilty for enjoying them because I have so little sugar elsewhere in my daily diet. Bye bye sweeteners. Nice to have known you.0
-
I never really drank them... They taste funny. Hang in there, it'll get better after awhile.0
-
This is a good idea. I use stevia at home in coffee every day, but to be honest at work they only have sweet n low, out and about they usually only have splenda. So I know I have one of these almost every day and I am going to try stopping and see how I feel.0
-
Hey - Another reason to give up artificial sweetners is new research that says they make you hungrier! I gave them up when I lost 20 pounds a few years ago. At first I missed diet coke - now not at all! I try to use honey in my tea. My mantra is "eat real food"! If I can give up diet coke - anyone can - good luck!0
-
I used to be a queen of artificial sweeteners! LOL, I would put artificially sweetened flavored coffee syrups into my artificially sweetened pepsi! Oh man... Talk about SWEET! I used to love it though. I would chew sugar free gum on top of that, multiple pieces a day, and drink Snapple (the sugar free, artificially sweetened!) as well.
I quit cold turkey about a year ago. No withdrawal symptoms, although it was hard for me to stop chewing gum. I feel SO MUCH BETTER now though. It's amazing how sluggish just consuming that type of junk makes you!
I did, however, drink a HUGE Snapple about a week ago. LOL, guilty pleasure, but yes, I did have it. Feels good to have them every once in a while as a TREAT though, instead of regular every day occurrence.0 -
I've been really struggling with diet coke, usually four cans a day. I don't like the taste of coffee, so it's my only source of caffeine. It's a real struggle on days I wake up tired.
A friend suggested I keep a jar and plop in money I save on days I drink less than four cans. This was genius, I've banked over $200 in no time, My goal is zero (four dollars a day!) - carbonated drinks have been implicated in osteoporosis0 -
I'd like to cut them out completely also. I am convinced that artificial sweeteners give me headaches and an overall icky feeling.0
-
I use splenda years ago and said what am I doing... I am better off with real sugar and limiting that...at least I know what it is....people will say its real sugar...if its real sugar it wouldnt be called splenda...there is a chemical in there somewhere... I really only drink water and coffee....at home no sugar in coffee and out and about 1/2 tsp of sugar.... good luck . just remember every day is a new day and you are doing fine.0
-
I gave up Splenda about 2 weeks ago. I don't feel any different, but I have noticed I'm using about 100 calories a day in sugar for my tea and coffee. So I need to cut that down.0
-
Just to be clear, Stevia isn't artificial - it doesn't raise your blood insulin levels and work on your body the way some others do.
I have shifted to Xylitol - natural as well and has quite a few benefits (and has been around since the 1800s).
Most of the time though, it's unsweetened for me. I have PCOS and so I have to be careful of the insulin rollercoaster. Once I get on, it's very tough for me to lose weight.0 -
Nursing is usually a very busy, high stress work environment, and oncology can be particularly so. You have my admiration. I'm also a nurse (public health now, but I worked for a long time at the hospital), and I've used coffee, tea, and soda to stay alert and energetic, not to mention hydrated. I used to drink from 3-5 diet sodas a day, but I read some scary things about the possible safety artificial sweeteners, and cut them out of my diet about 3 years ago. (I know there are many that would argue that they are safe, but I'd rather not take the chance.) I'm still a bit of a caffeine fiend, so drink a lot of tea, and I use about a teaspoon of sugar per 10 oz cup. I don't eat a whole lot of sugar otherwise, and I log in the calories. When I want something sweet, I try to choose foods that are sweetened with sugar, molasses, honey, or occasionally stevia.0
-
Yes, I have read that carbonated sodas basically sap all of the calcium out of your bones, leading to osteoporosis. I will occasionally have a glass of regular coke, but otherwise NO soda for me.
I am hoping that I am less hungry as a result of giving it up, but so far I feel like the hunger level is just about the same. I am curious about how artificial sweeteners will taste to me if I ever go back...maybe I'll find them gross after a while! I can only hope so!0 -
I gave up artificial sweeteners 4 days ago. I've used them since I was 16, so this is quite a change. I have had headaches and some brain fog. I'm using raw sugar and coconut Palm sugar instead. My understanding is that artificial sweeteners cause inflammation which may block my body from assimilating and disposing nutrition properly. Have you heard anything like that before?0
-
i give up nothing…
but I actually prefer real sugar over stevia, artificial stuff, etc...0 -
Hey - Another reason to give up artificial sweetners is new research that says they make you hungrier! I gave them up when I lost 20 pounds a few years ago. At first I missed diet coke - now not at all! I try to use honey in my tea. My mantra is "eat real food"! If I can give up diet coke - anyone can - good luck!
links to said research?0 -
I gave up artificial sweeteners in 2010. The withdraw I went through was worse than when I quite smoking. Headaches. Nausea. Mood swings. The whole bit.
PS. Stevia is not artificial, no need to give that up.0 -
i give up nothing…
but I actually prefer real sugar over stevia, artificial stuff, etc...
Likewise. I avoid them but only because sugar tastes better0 -
Hey - Another reason to give up artificial sweetners is new research that says they make you hungrier! I gave them up when I lost 20 pounds a few years ago. At first I missed diet coke - now not at all! I try to use honey in my tea. My mantra is "eat real food"! If I can give up diet coke - anyone can - good luck!
links to said research?
Here is what I found about artificial sweeteners and weight gain/loss.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2892765/0 -
The weight of the evidence that I've seen indicates that they're safe. If you really want to be safer then don't get a motor vehicle, make sure that you maintain a healthy body fat percentage, don't drink alcohol to excess, and if you have children under 4 make sure they know how to swim.0
-
Hey - Another reason to give up artificial sweetners is new research that says they make you hungrier! I gave them up when I lost 20 pounds a few years ago. At first I missed diet coke - now not at all! I try to use honey in my tea. My mantra is "eat real food"! If I can give up diet coke - anyone can - good luck!
links to said research?
Here is what I found about artificial sweeteners and weight gain/loss.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2892765/
thanks, I will take a look ..
skimmed it and it appears to be a study of studies so not sure how relevant it would be…
Also, they compared BMI, which IMO is a garbage stat…My BMI says I am "obese" but am 12% body fat…LOL0 -
I too gave up artificial sweetners a year ago when I started MFP. They were something I used alot, and have always had my doubts about long term effects. I didn't want to add alot of regular white sugar, so I try to do without. When I can't, I use honey. I have a cappucino or mug of coffee with skim milk twice a day. That I can usually enjoy without sweetening. I've switched to fruit teas because I can drink them plain. I cannot say I noticed a difference cutting out artificial sweetners---good or bad. It just gives me peace of mind. I've never been a diet soda guzzler. You don't want to touch that on here--people get defensive.0
-
The weight of the evidence that I've seen indicates that they're safe. If you really want to be safer then don't get a motor vehicle, make sure that you maintain a healthy body fat percentage, don't drink alcohol to excess, and if you have children under 4 make sure they know how to swim.
Done all this. Surprised?0 -
I've never used them. I hate the after-taste. I swore off sodas altogether, rather than going to diet sodas. :noway:0
-
the only artifical sweetener I have is in my diet coke but that is cause I prefer it to reg coke...
When I don't use sugar I use xylatol..naturally occuring sugar from trees...same as sugar just let calories.0 -
I personally gave up all artificial sweeteners years ago because they made me hungry.
I am one of those people that find artificial sweeteners seriously make me more hungry. I was gaining weight year after year and switched to artificial sweeteners in an effort to stop gaining weight. Instead my weight started going up even faster! So during the next six months i kept track of what i ate in a log book and also noted when i was hungry (this was days before smart phones so it was much more difficult). I found during those weeks i was using artificial sweeteners I was a lot more ravenous. I snacked more and always seemed to go back for seconds.
So I just decided to quit Soda and sweet drinks altogether. In the next year after I slowly lost 20 lbs and stayed at that weight for years. Though now i am working on getting back to a more healthy weight.
The good thing is after a few months my craving for constant sweets went away.
I should have also known better. In my youth when I worked as a bartender at a Pizza place, I always thought it odd that the fat folks would always order huge pizzas with lots of toppings... with large diet sodas. And the fit folk would order smaller pizzas with fewer topping and order small sodas (with sugar).
...and in response to some of the others comments.... as for aspartame I have a few friends with horror stories. Yes i had a one friend that had seizures, others had some other reactions but harder to prove, but the worse was a friend who reacted with a change to his personality. He went from a mild mannered introvert to a foul mouthed angry jerk. Luckily it was caught in time before it completely destroyed his life.0 -
Up until very recently (last month) I've been a 5-6 can per day diet Pepsi addict. For over 20 years I've been downing the horrible crap that is aspartame. It gave me headaches, carb cravings, and sore joints. Since cutting down to one can per day all those symptoms have disappeared. I hope to get down to 2 cans per week, moderation is OK, but drinking it all the time was taking a horrible toll on my body. A few of the others in flavoured yogurt and such, don't seem to have the same effect on me as aspartame. And I had a food intolerance test done last year. Guess what one of my severe intolerances was... yep, aspartame.0
-
I have been a coca cola/pepsi addict for years, particularly the diet stuff. recently made the switch to flavoured waters to ween myself off. I had a glass of regular pepsi the other day as the boyfriend had bought some and i really didn't enjoy it as much as i thought, I prefer the flavoured waters. massive victory for me there. have real sugar in my tea/coffee rather than sweeteners.0
-
I recently gave up my one 16 oz Diet Sprite a day, due to reading a lot about aspartame. It was the one year anniversary of my giving up my regular Coke/Pepsi habit due to the excessive amounts I was drinking (4-5 16 oz bottles/day, then had cut down to 1-2). I'm slowly acclimating to seltzers that just have natural flavoring. I also have a Soda Stream so I use that to make the same seltzers. Can't honestly say I notice a difference after no aspartame for the past three weeks or so, but I'm not craving the Diet Sprites so it's fine with me.
I never used artificial sweeteners in my coffee, I was using excessive amounts of sugar but gradually decreased it and stopped altogether almost two years ago. Now it's just with almond or skim milk. I'd rather have all those extra calories to use in real food.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions