Do you believe in food addiction?
Replies
-
I know some people think that you cannot be addicted to food because it is essential for survival and not something you can quit , but I 100% believe that sugary, fatty, and salty junk foods are addictive.
What do you think?
It doesn't matter what anyone here thinks. This isn't a matter of opinion; "addiction" is a medical term with a specific meaning.
Medically, you can be addicted to absolutely anything that gives you pleasure. This of course can include food.
Addiction is defined by continued use in the face of adverse consequences. This of course can include food.
Google can find you a mountain of good, well-sources information on all this. Begin here: http://www.helpguide.org/harvard/addiction_hijacks_brain.htmAlcoholics are able to control their addiction by NEVER taking another drink. That's the only thing that's found to work. Same with drug addicts.
This is a childish view of addiction, and is both incorrect and dangerous. I'm an alcoholic. I drink frequently. I just have to be careful about it. Not all alcoholics are as lucky as me.
^This gives me the sads.
Alcoholism is a progressive disease, and unless it's arrested (by abstaining) it is more often than not- terminal.0 -
Bottom line, addictions aside. If you want to see hot boys with no shirts... this is the thread!
do you have an addiction to boys with their shirts off??0 -
Alcoholics are able to control their addiction by NEVER taking another drink. That's the only thing that's found to work. Same with drug addicts.This is a childish view of addiction, and is both incorrect and dangerous. I'm an alcoholic. I drink frequently. I just have to be careful about it. Not all alcoholics are as lucky as me.
I apologize. Before I wrote this, I looked up ways to control alcoholic behavior and alcoholism. The only literature I found referred to complete abstinence. :flowerforyou:0 -
Alcoholics are able to control their addiction by NEVER taking another drink. That's the only thing that's found to work. Same with drug addicts.This is a childish view of addiction, and is both incorrect and dangerous. I'm an alcoholic. I drink frequently. I just have to be careful about it. Not all alcoholics are as lucky as me.
I apologize. Before I wrote this, I looked up ways to control alcoholic behavior and alcoholism. The only literature I found referred to complete abstinence. :flowerforyou:
that is the only method that I am aware of too …0 -
Psychologically, yes. Physically, maybe. But don't believe sugar, fat, or salty is addictive. It's highly palatable, but not addictive based on that physically we ingest these everyday. Unlike an alcoholic, drug user, or gambler, we can habitually learn to moderate these, while it's practically impossible to do it with others with any success.I know some people think that you cannot be addicted to food because it is essential for survival and not something you can quit , but I 100% believe that sugary, fatty, and salty junk foods are addictive.
What do you think?
A.C.E. Certified Personal/Group FitnessTrainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition0 -
Bottom line, addictions aside. If you want to see hot boys with no shirts... this is the thread!
do you have an addiction to boys with their shirts off??
more like an enthusiasm.... it is easily controlled, and I can live and function without it, so it doesn't qualify as an addiction.
0 -
Bottom line, addictions aside. If you want to see hot boys with no shirts... this is the thread!
do you have an addiction to boys with their shirts off??
more like a passion or enthusiasm.... it is easily controlled, and I can live and function without it, so it doesn't qualify as an addiction.
Hmmm interesting .
I have an addiction to woman which their shirts off ..and it is not easily controlled….0 -
Bottom line, addictions aside. If you want to see hot boys with no shirts... this is the thread!
do you have an addiction to boys with their shirts off??
more like a passion or enthusiasm.... it is easily controlled, and I can live and function without it, so it doesn't qualify as an addiction.
Hmmm interesting .
I have an addiction to woman which their shirts off ..and it is not easily controlled….
Haha! you win!0 -
Here is a link to an article that explains how some of the additives in food, trigger the same site in the brain that causes euphoria, and the same response that is triggered by meth and heroin... Interesting.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/10/16/junk-food_n_4043980.html0 -
Anything that boosts your dopamine response past that of what is found in nature can be addicting, and that includes drugs as well as un-naturally concentrated calorie dense foods like we eat in this country. Foods can also have other addictive components, too.I know some people think that you cannot be addicted to food because it is essential for survival and not something you can quit , but I 100% believe that sugary, fatty, and salty junk foods are addictive.
What do you think?
Food addiction is a very real thing, and it is very much manufactured into many processed foods. Whole natural plant foods are not addicting.
Ask a room full of people to speak up when they spot an addictive food, then flash images of food on a screen. No one speaks up for strawberries, cantaloupe, kale, broccoli or melons, but as soon as you flash chocolate, cheese or pastries on the screen, EVERY mouth in the room speaks up simultaneously. We all know intuitively that food addiction is very real.0 -
in to read later 0
-
i will always be addicted to food always. i think about food all the time. i love how food tastes,smells, looks. i overeat because i love food. i was deprived as a child. i was grossly underweight til i got a job at 16 and could buy my own food. of course it is an addiction but it is the hardest addiction beat as you need food to live. learning self control and better eating habits is the only way you are going to get this demon in control. i will always have the urge to overeat. it is the hardest thing i have put my mind to overcome.0
-
For sure, because I am.0
-
Again, I think people can have issues here and very real problems...but "problem" doesn't necessarily equate to "addiction."
[/quote]
HA, very well put, I agree with this statement. About food addictions.... well, I don't know. What I do know is that it takes work and perserverance and determination to break the habits that got us into that situation in the first place. It doesn't really matter if it's an addiction or just a really bad habit. The cure is the same. Change the bad habit into a good habit. Yes, it might hurt some to change our behavior and our wants and desires, but isn't the reward worth it? Notice I am putting myself into the equation here - I am by no means above or beyond this problem. I have MANY bad habits that must be changed, and my health and well-being depend on me stepping up and putting in the work to make those changes. So to those of you on either side of the fence, what say we shake hands and agree to disagree on the definition of the problem, and work on a solution to it instead.0 -
these threads always turn to discussions of sugar…so before it even happens don't come in here and say you cut out all sugar but still eat fruit and honey ….please for the love of god do not do this!!!!!!!!!!!!
I thought they always turned into discussions about drug and alcohol addictions :huh:0 -
Here is a link to an article that explains how some of the additives in food, trigger the same site in the brain that causes euphoria, and the same response that is triggered by meth and heroin... Interesting.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/10/16/junk-food_n_4043980.html
That is a statement so misleading it should be a criminal offense. Practically everything activates those areas.0 -
But the same can be said for dancing, skydiving, driving fast, etc. and I doubt those would be considered addictions.Here is a link to an article that explains how some of the additives in food, trigger the same site in the brain that causes euphoria, and the same response that is triggered by meth and heroin... Interesting.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/10/16/junk-food_n_4043980.html
A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness industry for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition0 -
NO
If a drug addict stops using drugs, are they cured of the addiction? What if they just do less of the drug or just do the drugs occasionally, are they still considered an addict?
Can someone addicted to food quit eating, will they be cured of their addiction? What if they eat less or just eat occasionally, are they still considered an addict? How can a food addiction be broken?
loved this way of putting it.0 -
This content has been removed.
-
I know some people think that you cannot be addicted to food because it is essential for survival and not something you can quit , but I 100% believe that sugary, fatty, and salty junk foods are addictive.
What do you think?
I think any behavior can become compulsive, eating included. I think that eating can become people's main coping mechanism, too. Are some foods more likely to draw compulsive overeaters? Probably. I never crave broccoli, after a break up.
I've been in recovery from alcoholism and drug addiction for 26 years. My 2nd sponsor told me that she "never woke up next to someone she didn't know, because she ate too many chocolate chip cookies", minimizing eating as a coping mechanism or compulsive behavior. At the time, I laughed, because I was probably 120 pounds. Now that I'm morbidly obese, I have a different perspective. I think that for me, overeating sugar, fat & salt, is a big problem. I'm now in recovery from using these substances to cope with life's difficulties. Will I slip or relapse? I don't know. Some people say relapse is a normal part of recovery. Whatever happens, I'm not giving up, as I have in the past. I have to face the fact that for the past 13 years, my relationship with food has been very unhealthy and my lifespan will probably be much shorter if I don't change my behavior.
Thanks for asking the question. It made me think and I'll enjoy reading other people's respectful posts.0 -
I believe in food addiction as an excuse for being overweight. 'It's not me, it's the addiction'.
As a medical status, however, this is make-believe.0 -
i will always be addicted to food always. i think about food all the time. i love how food tastes,smells, looks. i overeat because i love food. i was deprived as a child. i was grossly underweight til i got a job at 16 and could buy my own food. of course it is an addiction but it is the hardest addiction beat as you need food to live. learning self control and better eating habits is the only way you are going to get this demon in control. i will always have the urge to overeat. it is the hardest thing i have put my mind to overcome.
That is a gluttonous attitude issue, not an addiction.0 -
Yes, I do.
I have posted the first review article before. It examines both human and animal studies. The co-author, Koob now heads the National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism
The dark side of food addiction. Parylak SL Koob GF, Zorrilla EP. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3304465/#!po=55.7143
"In drug addiction, the transition from casual drug use to dependence has been linked to a shift away from positive reinforcement and towards negative reinforcement. That is, drugs ultimately are relied on to prevent or relieve negative states that otherwise result from abstinence (e.g., withdrawal) or from adverse environmental circumstances (e.g., stress). Recent work has suggested that this “dark side” shift also is key in the development of food addiction. Initially, palatable food consumption has both positive reinforcing, pleasurable effects and negative reinforcing, “comforting” effects that can acutely normalize organism responses to stress. Repeated, intermittent intake of palatable food may instead amplify brain stress circuitry and downregulate brain reward pathways such that continued intake becomes obligatory to prevent negative emotional states via negative reinforcement. Stress, anxiety and depressed mood have shown high comorbidity with and the potential to trigger bouts of addiction-like eating behavior in humans"
Another review article http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20042860
Food addiction: true or false? Corsica JA1, Pelchat ML.
"Recent findings have strengthened the case for food addiction. These findings may serve to validate the perception of food addiction in patients and inform psychoeducational, cognitive-behavioral, and/or pharmacological treatment for chronic food cravings, compulsive overeating, and binge eating that may represent a phenotype of obesity. Screening for food addiction has the potential to identify people with eating difficulties that seriously compromise weight management efforts. Future research should include a focus on human food addiction research; evaluating the impact of treatment on underlying neurochemistry; and prevention or reversal of food addiction in humans."
There is also a validated Yale Food addiction Scale. Article here. http://www.yaleruddcenter.org/resources/upload/docs/what/addiction/FoodAddictionScaleArticle09.pdf
It's a controversial hypothesis though...0 -
Physically, not really.
Emotionally, yes, absolutely.
I think emotions fuel the desire to eat (to soothe, to cope, distract, defense mechanism, etc)
But over time I think people become more addicted to the binge, the over-eating, the emotional fulfillment they get from the food, not an actual physical addiction to a cookie or chips, for example.
I do not think many people over-eat/binge because they *truly* enjoy it. Most have extreme guilt and shame over these actions. I think a lot of addicts feel guilt or shame over their (drugs, alcohol, etc) addiction. I think the emotional turmoil might be same no matter the addiction.
Just my 2 cents ...0 -
I do not believe in food addiction. While I -may- be proven wrong some day, I believe that most people who think they have a food addiction just have behavioral issues or emotional issues that they are masking with food intake.
Which is exactly how most addictions start and progress.0 -
Interesting link. It concludes that food addiction could exist as a type of behavioral addiction.0 -
A thread about definitions.
If one considers behavioral addictions like gambling, lying, collecting, internet, etc then eating certainly may fall into behaviors that are difficult to control and result in conditions that are essentially harmful.
Is there a biochemical addiction equivalent to that of hard drugs? No. Not even close.
The answer depends on which bucket you want to use.0 -
Yes, I do.
I have posted the first review article before. It examines both human and animal studies. The co-author, Koob now heads the National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism
The dark side of food addiction. Parylak SL Koob GF, Zorrilla EP. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3304465/#!po=55.7143
"In drug addiction, the transition from casual drug use to dependence has been linked to a shift away from positive reinforcement and towards negative reinforcement. That is, drugs ultimately are relied on to prevent or relieve negative states that otherwise result from abstinence (e.g., withdrawal) or from adverse environmental circumstances (e.g., stress). Recent work has suggested that this “dark side” shift also is key in the development of food addiction. Initially, palatable food consumption has both positive reinforcing, pleasurable effects and negative reinforcing, “comforting” effects that can acutely normalize organism responses to stress. Repeated, intermittent intake of palatable food may instead amplify brain stress circuitry and downregulate brain reward pathways such that continued intake becomes obligatory to prevent negative emotional states via negative reinforcement. Stress, anxiety and depressed mood have shown high comorbidity with and the potential to trigger bouts of addiction-like eating behavior in humans"
Another review article http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20042860
Food addiction: true or false? Corsica JA1, Pelchat ML.
"Recent findings have strengthened the case for food addiction. These findings may serve to validate the perception of food addiction in patients and inform psychoeducational, cognitive-behavioral, and/or pharmacological treatment for chronic food cravings, compulsive overeating, and binge eating that may represent a phenotype of obesity. Screening for food addiction has the potential to identify people with eating difficulties that seriously compromise weight management efforts. Future research should include a focus on human food addiction research; evaluating the impact of treatment on underlying neurochemistry; and prevention or reversal of food addiction in humans."
There is also a validated Yale Food addiction Scale. Article here. http://www.yaleruddcenter.org/resources/upload/docs/what/addiction/FoodAddictionScaleArticle09.pdf
It's a controversial hypothesis though...
I have yet to see a center treating opiate path related addiction for food with methadone....0 -
Anything that boosts your dopamine response past that of what is found in nature can be addicting, and that includes drugs as well as un-naturally concentrated calorie dense foods like we eat in this country. Foods can also have other addictive components, too.I know some people think that you cannot be addicted to food because it is essential for survival and not something you can quit , but I 100% believe that sugary, fatty, and salty junk foods are addictive.
What do you think?
Food addiction is a very real thing, and it is very much manufactured into many processed foods. Whole natural plant foods are not addicting.
Ask a room full of people to speak up when they spot an addictive food, then flash images of food on a screen. No one speaks up for strawberries, cantaloupe, kale, broccoli or melons, but as soon as you flash chocolate, cheese or pastries on the screen, EVERY mouth in the room speaks up simultaneously. We all know intuitively that food addiction is very real.
Well said.0 -
Absolutely and I think that the food companies use that to their advantage and to keep us coming back. I don't think food in its natural form is addicting. Processed, chemical laden, sugary foods however, are.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 430 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions