Ridiculous amount of calories to eat after exercise.
alicekelli
Posts: 11 Member
I am exercising at a rate that i feel necessary to build my strength, lose weight, and boost metabolism... but my calorie goal for weight loss is 1200... and after burning 1000 exercising, that means a 2200 calorie day. I ate a jumbo bowl of popcorn at the end of the day to make up those extra few hundred calories... but it just seems like too much food. leaving me feel heavy. concerned also that the more i eat, the more i will want or need to eat every day... i love food, but would love to just be able to eat about 1700 to 1800 and feel content and healthy. don't want to drop below 1200 net... and 2200 seems way too much... would less exercise be the best option?
0
Replies
-
Honestly...when I burn that much I just eat until I am full and take the extra calorie deficit as a bonus. While not dropping below 1200 net is ideal, if you aren't hungry enough to hit 2200 then don't worry about it so much. As long as you are eating enough to keep yourself feeling full and healthy.
But....if it does worry you, start buying full fat versions of stuff, cook with oils, etc...that will bump calories up pretty easily.0 -
Get an HRM to get a more accurate calorie burnt, MFP and cardio machines can give you an inflated number.0
-
Listen to your body. Honestly if I eat 1750, and burn 1000 at the gym. All I do is have a 170 calorie protein shake, and go to bed at times. That may net just 920, but honestly I ate near 2,000 calories, and I know I'll make it up later in the week.0
-
I see you have a small amount to lose, which makes me think you aren't obese (you would burn tons of calories if you were). If MFP gives you 1000 extra calories every day from exercise you may be overestimating your burn or overexercising.
What kind of exercise are you doing? MFP and cardio machines tend to overestimate the burn for everything except running and walking IMHO.0 -
Just consuming calories alone won't get you the results you want, if you are not paying attention to the kinds of food that those calories are coming from. Having a proper balance of Protein/Carbs/Good fats is Key. the ratio of those however will flux a bit depending on the kind of working out you are doing.
1000 Calories from working out is pretty huge so i have to commend you for that. If you are burning most of your calories from strong resistance training, then you will want to make sure your proteins are the main part of your nutrition as the body will need those proteins to help rebuild muscle, and recover. If you are burning most of your calories from cardio/HIIT style training then you probably want to lower the protien % a bit and increase carbs (for energy). Example for heavy resistance training: 60% protein, 30% carbs, 10% fats. Those percents would change depending on the type of working out you are doing. The amount of calories per day that you need also does depend on the kind of regular activity you get from Non working out (i..e a desk Job vs a construction worker). The kind of fitness you are doing as well also has an effect on if you will plateau or not.
Finally, the types of food you consume make a real difference. Obviously consuming calories from something of very little nutritional value will just have an opposite effect of achieve proper fat loss and fitness goals.
Give us an idea of the kind of working out you are doing. There really is a no one size fits all approach and the kind of working out + food intake, is what will ultimately determine the right amount of calories you need. Calorie numbers can be played around with and tweaked.0 -
that was with a heart rate monitor...but in my settings, i said i was sedentary... though i logged my power walk / jog today, which with hills was 400 calories... not sure i should log walks, even if intense?0
-
i did an hour of cardio and later took a 45 min intensity walk (fast and hills).. then tonight i did 20 min hatha yoga to stretch my legs and relax. i appreciate all the comments!0
-
To be quiet honest, I was fearful of the same thing months ago. But it's always good to maintain a deficient calorie in take when losing weight. For example my diary yesterday contained +14360 in food and exercise of -1019 leaving me a net of 417. My daily calorie goal is 1,530. It's not that I didn't eat enough because I did, but I was so active today, which isn't bad. If your hungry eat healthy and right. If your just eating to make calories back I would stop. Plus you never eat all your calories back from exercising anyways. Hope this helps, enjoy your day!0
-
You could log only half the calories you actually worked out. Even if you decide to eat every single workout calorie back, 1 cup of walnuts is close to 800 calories! A fistful of walnuts could fill in any gaps and it doesn't feel overwhelming. Personally I would go by my gut and not worry too much unless it's cutting in too low.0
-
That sounds really high...0
-
I highly doubt all that exercise is 1000 calories. Maybe 800. Even then, a bowl of ice cream with some fudge and whipped cream and you're set.0
-
I bank my extra calories for the days I feel like sitting on my *kitten* and eating all the calories. I watch a weekly deficit because I am unable to do a daily one. If you have this large of a deficit everyday, you may wish to re-evaluate your fitness or nutritional goals. Also, try to make sure your calories on any given day at least do not dip below your BMR.0
-
A 15Km run is about 1000cals (with HRM) and so the data in the Op is not outrageous.
My go to food after a good run like that us mostly Protein based.0 -
Honestly...when I burn that much I just eat until I am full and take the extra calorie deficit as a bonus. While not dropping below 1200 net is ideal, if you aren't hungry enough to hit 2200 then don't worry about it so much. As long as you are eating enough to keep yourself feeling full and healthy.
But....if it does worry you, start buying full fat versions of stuff, cook with oils, etc...that will bump calories up pretty easily.
+10 -
I do that much cardio, sometimes more (when training for a marathon) and do find I can eat back most of my exercise calories, unless I've run 18-22 miles (which is a LOT of calories), but it doesn't make me want to over-eat on non-running days because I'm just not as hungry if I haven't worked out. So I really wouldn't worry about getting into bad habits.
I originally joined MFP to make sure I didn't lose too much while training intensively and what I noticed is I was eating a lot less at lunchtime than I thought I was. So rather than trying to make up a massive deficit at the end of the day, maybe consider just having slightly larger meals throughout the day? e.g. add some nuts or toasted pumpkin seeds to a salad at lunch, eat full fat yoghurt for breakfast etc.0 -
If you plan on doing that much exercise most days, you'll want to plan your meals better. Eat a bit more at each meal, especially protein. Also, pick foods that offer a lot of calories for the volume; cheese, nuts, peanut butter, oil, etc. I don't think you need to eat all of the calories back every day, but definitely eat some since your daily goal is so low. My favorite go to if I have lots of calories left is 2 slices of bread, 90 cal each, toasted, with 2-3 T peanut butter and 2 cups of 1% milk.
A delicious way to spend 600+ calories.0 -
If your exercise burns are accurate, and you can't eat enough cals to keep up with it, then I'd cut back on the exercise, because proper fuel and nutrition is important.
Personally, I have no problem eating 2000+ cals a day.
I've also never burned 1000 cals through exercise in a day, so it's never a problem. 
0 -
If your exercise burns are accurate, and you can't eat enough cals to keep up with it, then I'd cut back on the exercise, because proper fuel and nutrition is important.
Personally, I have no problem eating 2000+ cals a day. I've also never burned 1000 cals through exercise in a day, so it's never a problem.
I'm gonna agree with this. Assuming you're going to keep up the exercise once you get to your goal weight... your maintenance calories are gonna be pretty high. So you need to look into finding a better balance between the calories you're eating and the calories you're burning.0 -
I am exercising at a rate that i feel necessary to build my strength, lose weight, and boost metabolism... but my calorie goal for weight loss is 1200... and after burning 1000 exercising, that means a 2200 calorie day. I ate a jumbo bowl of popcorn at the end of the day to make up those extra few hundred calories... but it just seems like too much food. leaving me feel heavy. concerned also that the more i eat, the more i will want or need to eat every day... i love food, but would love to just be able to eat about 1700 to 1800 and feel content and healthy. don't want to drop below 1200 net... and 2200 seems way too much... would less exercise be the best option?
If you don't know how to eat like an athlete, maybe you shouldn't be training like one.
You don't need to burn 1000 calories in exercise every day...not really sustainable for most, particularly if you don't know how to properly fuel that activity.
Your calorie deficit for weight loss is built into your calorie goal before exercise...meaning you would lose your weight just eating to that calorie goal. You exercise for fitness and if you aren't a reasonably fit individual, doing that much exercise is likely overtrain. I'm very fit and active and the only days I have burns like that are on my long ride days where I'm out on my bike for 3 hours plus and covering a good 30-40 miles....I know I'm going to burn a lot so I eat a lot...I don't wait until the evening to get my calories in, I plan them into my day.
I would add to that, if indeed you are training like that and burning that many calories on a regular basis, 2200 calories is nothing....on a long ride day I eat around 3500 calories to maintain...I would still lose about 1 Lb per week eating around 3000 calories.0 -
This content has been removed.
-
Listen to your body. That goes for eating when you're hungry as well as stopping when you're full. Any time I try to force an extra pound of loss by limiting my intake of calories (My "allowance is 1430 and I have tried to go only 1200), I don't see any significant benefit from it.
I started my weight loss journey in January of this year - like many other people - but for a slightly different reason. My average weight loss has been 1/2 per day (MFP has me at about 10 pounds more lost than actual because it is going back to 2011 when I first tried it). That may seem extreme for some, but it is comfortable and easily maintainable for me. But that's ME, not you. If you feel sluggish or sapped for energy, eat more protein rich foods. If you feel bloated and 'blah', reduce your fats, gluten and carbs. If these things don't have the desired effect, find something that works for you.
I try to only eat to my food goal and not 'eat back' my workout calories. That keeps me between two and three pounds or weight loss per week because some weeks are better than others at hitting my goals.0 -
1000 calories? What on earth are you doing? Most I can burn in an hour is 500?0
-
1000 calories? What on earth are you doing? Most I can burn in an hour is 500?
What if you exercised for two hours?0 -
You don't have to eat them ALL back, eat anywhere between 1/3 and 3/4. But 1200 cals is pretty low, what is your weight loss goal set at?0
-
I don't know your body stats but a lot f times calorie burn is overestimated and food under estimated. As other have mentioned listen to your body, but know that if you are not properly fueling your body and trying to sustain these high levels of calorie burn the injury/burnout is not pretty. Been there. Plus look into calorie dense foods.0
-
That advice can be very flawed. Hopefully in due time you will realize that.Listen to your body. Honestly if I eat 1750, and burn 1000 at the gym. All I do is have a 170 calorie protein shake, and go to bed at times. That may net just 920, but honestly I ate near 2,000 calories, and I know I'll make it up later in the week.
This here^^^ is great advice as always.I am exercising at a rate that i feel necessary to build my strength, lose weight, and boost metabolism... but my calorie goal for weight loss is 1200... and after burning 1000 exercising, that means a 2200 calorie day. I ate a jumbo bowl of popcorn at the end of the day to make up those extra few hundred calories... but it just seems like too much food. leaving me feel heavy. concerned also that the more i eat, the more i will want or need to eat every day... i love food, but would love to just be able to eat about 1700 to 1800 and feel content and healthy. don't want to drop below 1200 net... and 2200 seems way too much... would less exercise be the best option?
If you don't know how to eat like an athlete, maybe you shouldn't be training like one.
You don't need to burn 1000 calories in exercise every day...not really sustainable for most, particularly if you don't know how to properly fuel that activity.
Your calorie deficit for weight loss is built into your calorie goal before exercise...meaning you would lose your weight just eating to that calorie goal. You exercise for fitness and if you aren't a reasonably fit individual, doing that much exercise is likely overtrain. I'm very fit and active and the only days I have burns like that are on my long ride days where I'm out on my bike for 3 hours plus and covering a good 30-40 miles....I know I'm going to burn a lot so I eat a lot...I don't wait until the evening to get my calories in, I plan them into my day.
I would add to that, if indeed you are training like that and burning that many calories on a regular basis, 2200 calories is nothing....on a long ride day I eat around 3500 calories to maintain...I would still lose about 1 Lb per week eating around 3000 calories.
I don't feel like it's flawed. My weekly goal numbers turn out fine. It seems unnecessary to force yourself to eat when you aren't really hungry. Later on in the week I'll have a night where I need that extra snack that makes up for the previous net goal.0 -
I'm trying to understand what exercise you are doing. Also, are you burning 1000 cals every day?
I'm a runner, but not very big. I wear a HRM when I workout and I burn less than 100 cals/mile. For example, I ran 10 miles yesterday but burned less than 950 cals. But I have no trouble eating all my cals and basically graze most of the day until I eat a big dinner.
I hope you're not trying to burn that much each day. You will start to burn out and over train which is also not good!0 -
1000 calories? What on earth are you doing? Most I can burn in an hour is 500?
What if you exercised for two hours?
^^ This.
Plus exercise burns also depend on weight. Heavier a person is, the more they can potentially burn.
I burn around 600 an hour on the elliptical, set to interval training, because I work out intensely. And I am 131Ibs.
I often have 1000 calorie burns. But, I eat to fuel them. As someone else said, if you cannot eat to fuel that sort of activity level, then it is best you reduce your exercise.0 -
Weight loss goal is 25 lbs.. For sine reason my tracker doesn't appear? Each time I exercise, my protien requirements also go up, lol. This is tricky for me too! I did an hour of cardio / strength... almost an hour of "power" walking (it's very hilly here)... and evening yoga! All tips are appreciated. Thanks everyone!0
-
Okay- so why has no one said this
WTH are you eating popcorn?
it's incredibly filling and not that high in caloires unless you are fully loaded cheese/butter popcorn.
you need REAL food- and real calories-I would be drinking a half gallon of milk a day with that kind of deficit.
And 2200 is not THAT much. It feels like it when you are at a deficit- but it's really not.
4 oreo's- 2 servings of ice cream and some fruit is like 5-600 calories.
Have at it.
If you aren't eating enough with those burns- you WILL have a problem.
You need to eat. Even if it means you drink your calories- you need to eat.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions