Does anyone here NOT count calories? Have you tried Intuitiv

burningstar28
burningstar28 Posts: 23
edited September 22 in Health and Weight Loss
I have tried counting calories but it seems to make me obsessive and when I go over my daily limit I feel so guilty and end up way over eating. I am thinking of practicing "intuitive eating" and just listening to my body and doing my best to choose healthy options. Does anyone else here *not* count calories? How has it worked out for you? Feel free to send me a friend request!

Replies

  • CFAITH_WARD
    CFAITH_WARD Posts: 281 Member
    umh...this is a calorie counting site.
  • I stopped counting my calories because I was also obsessing even though 9 times out of 10 I was under my calories. So I stopped counting and found that when I didn't count the calories I wasn't so worried about exercising and ended up loosing all of my energy. As of yesterday I started counting the calories again & hopefully I wont obsess so much
  • ican♥and♥iwill
    ican♥and♥iwill Posts: 176 Member
    I haven't really been counting for the last 3 or 4 months. Like you, I'd get obsessive about it - when I'd go over I'd stress and end up overeating. It wasn't helping my weight loss or my sanity.

    I haven't really lost in that time, but I haven't gained either. So that's good. But I'm tired of maintaining, sooooo I've started counting and logging again...

    I think I just really needed the mental break. I'd hate to overwhelm myself and give up completely.
  • kbefit
    kbefit Posts: 116
    I've heard about what you're talking about but for me personally...if I'd listened to my body all of these years I wouldn't be where I am now. Also, it seems like when I focus too much on that, I either end up under eating or over eating anyway. I think it would be best to count calories first and then when you really get to know your body best, maybe you can start listening to those signals. Best of luck to you!
  • lynzyn
    lynzyn Posts: 119 Member
    I use this site as a guide, to show what is good for me and what is bad for me!!! It helps me see how much i am putting into my body and what i am burning well it isn't 100% accurate but it helps...

    I don't obsess about it cause i am here to get healthy and if i loose weight so be it but my main goal IS NOT TO GAIN WEIGHT...As long as i feel good i am good....So far i have lost 2 pounds but that's it if i loose more cool if not cool too i don't want to gain weight!

    I find as a society we obsess over how we look cause that is what the media says we should look like....It is mind over matter if u want to stop eating crappy food stop.....we all know what is good and what is bad...By using this site i am more educated about that
    Good Luck :)
  • defygravity531
    defygravity531 Posts: 289 Member
    I do enter my food intake into MyFitnessPal's calorie counter but if you asked me my totals at any given time I wouldn't be able to tell you. I think the most important thing is being accountable. If you ate chocolate, write down that you ate chocolate and be honest about how much. Take a week or two to keep tracking your food but ignore the calories. If you go over and it shows it to you in red, angry, negative numbers, say OK, I went over today. I'll work out an extra few minutes and that will be that. No need to obsess, no need to dwell or not eat your next meal or berate yourself. Weightloss is about being good to yourself, treating your body kindly with healthy food and NOT beating yourself up when you slip up. Keep calories in mind as a guideline, not a punishment/reward system. Let them help keep you on track instead of derailing you.

    Good luck!
  • superwmn
    superwmn Posts: 936
    I have not given up calorie counting entirely, but I do have a tendency to get obsessive about it so I use a combination of very lose calorie counting and intuitive eating. So far it's worked out well for me :)

    The book 'Naturally Thin' by Bethenny Frankel introduced me to this concept and I thought it was a pretty decent read.

    Charmagne
  • rybo
    rybo Posts: 5,424 Member
    I counted for a few months when I first got here. Then I just got used to it & stopped. lately I think I have been going a little nuts over the holidays so i am gonna count and see where I am at for a couple weeks. Then probably drop the counting again.
  • camille45
    camille45 Posts: 106 Member
    i have tried weight loss without counting calories and it HASNT worked for me. Having a calorie count helps me because it seems to give me more control. The database is awesome because i feel like no matter where i go to eat i can have a guide that can keep me within my calorie budget. I know how much i can eat, it helps me stay conscious of what im eating and im finding out that I can actually eat more than I think i can, and it keeps me from starving myself. Sometimes I find myself having to eat more to make my caloric intake for the day. Plus when i excercise i give myself a little more breathing room with the calorie budget. Its just like money, if you know you have to make that $20 bucks last all day, you will be more aware of how you spend it. So far its working, and when I slip up and if I dont lose that week, i can look back, see what I ate or how much I worked out and make some changes.
  • CFAITH_WARD
    CFAITH_WARD Posts: 281 Member
    Don't think of it as a diet....think of it as a new way of living....If you go over some it will not kill your life...it may hurt your 'diet'....Eveyday is a new chance to make the right choices.....as long as you make the right choices most of the time it will work...and hey if you go over go exercise to work it off....A friend told me her neighbor used to eat candy while on the tredmill...We laughed at her but hey now I get it....She wanted the treat so she was working it off while she was eating it.
  • ashlee954
    ashlee954 Posts: 1,112 Member
    I too obsess a bit. However, the alternative to me not counting was gaining 17 pounds. The reality of it all is that weighloss is a simple math equation. More calories out (burned) than in (consumed). The only way to know that you are creating a deficit in order to lose is to keep track of the ins and outs. Some people do not need to do this, as weight is not an issue for them. Those people, however, do not search out a weightloss site to assist them in the weightloss process. I hope you find what works best for you hun!
  • cobarlo14
    cobarlo14 Posts: 582 Member
    I have tried not counting calories - some days when I don't want to track on MFP. I only do it infrequently thought.

    MFP says I should be talkin in 2600+ calories.
    My doctor says 1800-2000 per day (after taking a breathing test)
    My nutritionist has given me a 200-300 leyway.

    So I go by 2000 per day, when I want a treat I allow 200-300 extra, NOT every single day.
    so far, so good.

    Good luck :)
  • I have only a couple of suggestions, as I have not ever completely turned off counting calories:

    1) Don't nickel and dime yourself. Depending on what kind of deficit you've set, going over isn't a disaster. A lot of women on here are set at 1200. That's the minimum you should eat and if that's what you're working with then 50 or even 100 is not going to send you into gaining. In fact, it's going to be next to impossible to get a big zero at the bottom.

    2) Once you count for a little while you kind of get into the swing of it. You recognize portion sizes for what they are, know how much of everything you can and should eat and you don't have to count so ferociously. There are days where I let it go a little more than usual, just because I KNOW I'm not going over because I know what I ate.
  • I took a big break from working out and counting calories. I didn't really go up or down in weight, but I noticed my physique go from fit to "not so fit, with some extra padding". I started working out again and could tell my strength and weight were going up, but I was seeing that without monitoring and controlling my caloric intake. As soon as I started watching my intake again, I started feeling better and noticing the fat slowly disappearing.

    I am newer to this site, but seeing as it can work on my phone and online, it is so much simpler to check my calories for the day.

    A word to those who struggle or obsess, keep hydrating. Your body isn't always as hungry as you think, it might just need some more water. Try to drink about 80oz of water (10 cups) throughout the day. Not only is it good for you to stay hydrated, but it lessens the "need to eat". If its a food that is not so great for you but you crave it, have it (in moderation) and then work out long enough to burn 75% of its calories off.

    If all else fails and you get frustrated or feel you need that sweet or more food (and know you really don't) - Grab a water bottle and go for a walk! Not only is the walk and hydration good, but taking a walk (even once around the block) is a good way to just clear your mind and control the needs or frustrations!
  • superjae5
    superjae5 Posts: 64 Member
    If you don't want to count calories (or feel like you can't) here are a couple of ideas. I don't know your diet, but I'll just offer suggestions on food choices to start. Cut way back on meat, especially red meat. If you like fish, stick to that for awhile. Avoid anything with High Fructose Corn Syrup in it, as it is plain junk. The body doesn't recognize it as sugar and sends it straight to the fat cells. Better to choose something with actual sugar in it or sweeteners if you're okay with that. Look at the labels, HFCS is in a lot more than you think. Substitute plain yogurt for sour cream and mayo. I use yogurt on tacos and other Mexican dishes. I also use it on sandwiches--although put it on just before you eat it or it'll soak into the bread. You can also add some rosemary to it on a sandwich to give it some extra kick. Substitute honey as a sweetener. Honey has good bacteria in it which helps keep you healthy. I often use it to sweeten herbal tea or plain yogurt with fruit.

    Use fruit a lot as snacks. Fruits are very low calorie in comparison to other snacks. I get canned pears and peaches from the grocery and look for the ones sweetened with pear juice instead of syrup. It took a little time to get used to the difference, since I used to be a heavy syrup girl, but now that stuff tastes way too sweet. I do the same with applesauce, the no sugar added, natural kind. You can use cinnamon to help if you feel like there's not enough flavor.

    Cook for yourself as much as possible. Preservatives are I think what's fattening up our society. Homemade meals are usually tastier anyhow.

    Avoid corn products, like tortilla chips (or anything sweetened with HFCS). I always go for wheat tortillas or wheat bread. I'm also a big believer in buying local because it nourishes better, so if you can't make your own bread, at least buy from a local vendor (usually it says on the back where it's from).

    Granola I discovered while rich in protein is also rich in calories. You may want to avoid it. Peanut butter also is the same story. Good protein sources I use are mozzarella cheese and cottage cheese. Cottage cheese can be made tastier either with honey and berries (you can use frozen ones, they're frozen seasonal and fresh) or adding a spice like basil and finding a low-cal cracker.

    Most people recommend the 6-mini meals plan. So as a sample schedule, breakfast at 8, snack at 10, lunch at noon, snack at 2, dinner at 5, snack at 8. For snacks often fruits, and sometimes a quick protein, like cottage cheese or a small piece of sandwich meat. This works better if you're exercising too, because you'll build more muscle which burns fat quicker (not ridiculously bulky muscle, just toned).

    Lately I've been doing a quasi-mini meals with healthy snacks in combo with a very light supper and exercise. It seems to work for me. I've never counted calories before, so I'm trying it to shed the extra holiday pounds. When I get back down to my "maintain" weight I'll probably stop the calorie count. I'm using this to help me know which foods are higher in calorie, so that I know where to cut out the extra.

    Sorry for the novel. ;) I lately have been using Extra Dessert Delight gum to help with sugar cravings, plus it's low-cal.
  • Sheila_KI
    Sheila_KI Posts: 206 Member
    Even if you don't want to count "calories" you need to keep a food diary. Just writing down everything you eat is a deterent to eating more. Most of us have been on this journey several times. We know what a portion is, we know we eat when we aren't hungry, we know we eat too much and we know that we should exercise. Everyone needs to find what works for them, but most importantly is to be accountable. When I don't keep a food diary -- I eat more. So keep a food diary and write down what you eat and why you are eating. Is it hunger, frustration, boredom, etc.
  • Honestly for me counting calories is what always works. I do it for a while, lose weight and then I typically stay at my target weight for a while, start to blow back up and start counting again. When I go over for the day I just stop eating until the next day. Even if you get hungry, the hunger pains WILL subside. I eat 5 meals a day around 300 calories each to reach my goals. I set a timer a 9, 12, 3, 6 and 9 to eat. I eat at all those times and will have a low calorie snack in between if I'm getting really hungry. Just remember if you go over your calories that tomorrow is another day and it's ok to take a 1 day break from dieting every so often.
  • tesshaney
    tesshaney Posts: 110 Member
    When I don't count calories and know exactly how much im eating versus what i'm burning off, it always ends in disaster. I eat great but I am awful at guesstimating portion sizes. Even when I think Im going small, im over.
  • shreddingit
    shreddingit Posts: 1,133 Member
    i dont count calories!...I have learned to eat wisely and on time. I like tracking my progress, fitness, and making efriends!..its better to just write down what you eat in a log...some things we eat sometimes dont have exact calories.
  • I stopped counting calories in October because I was not losing at all and I had become obsessed with counting calories. This resulted in me losing 10lbs. I have recently started counting again, not as compulsively, to switch things up and work through this plateau I am in after the holidays.
This discussion has been closed.