Long distance running, not seeing any weight loss
julianpoutram
Posts: 331 Member
So I'm about 200lbs at the moment and Ideally I want to be about 180 -190lbs. I started running 10k and now even further once a week with a few shorter runs in between so about 3 runs a week. I am seeing fitness improvements and I do seem to be gaining muscle, but the scale is not budging(I know that isn't important) and more importantly this belly of mine is still sitting all smug atop my abdomen! I do eat pretty badly at the moment and I don't log on here, but I run out of energy all the time if I don't eat regularly and I certainly wouldn't be able to maintain this level of endurance exercise without it. The amounts mfp suggests for me to eat are just not maintainable, I feel sluggish and tired and cold by late afternoon if I stick to that restriction.
This last bit of weight is becoming a frustrating nuisance now and I'd really appreciate your guys feedback on whether I'm training enough or should I cut down my food or eat more of some particular foods? Thanks.
This last bit of weight is becoming a frustrating nuisance now and I'd really appreciate your guys feedback on whether I'm training enough or should I cut down my food or eat more of some particular foods? Thanks.
0
Replies
-
So I'm about 200lbs at the moment and Ideally I want to be about 180 -190lbs. I started running 10k and now even further once a week with a few shorter runs in between so about 3 runs a week. I am seeing fitness improvements and I do seem to be gaining muscle, but the scale is not budging(I know that isn't important) and more importantly this belly of mine is still sitting all smug atop my abdomen! I do eat pretty badly at the moment and I don't log on here, but I run out of energy all the time if I don't eat regularly and I certainly wouldn't be able to maintain this level of endurance exercise without it. The amounts mfp suggests for me to eat are just not maintainable, I feel sluggish and tired and cold by late afternoon if I stick to that restriction.
This last bit of weight is becoming a frustrating nuisance now and I'd really appreciate your guys feedback on whether I'm training enough or should I cut down my food or eat more of some particular foods? Thanks.
Read. Reread. Read. And reread again this: http://www.acaloriecounter.com/blog/why-am-i-not-losing-weight/0 -
Not logging and most likely not eating enough. +1 rec that you read that link above0
-
So I'm about 200lbs at the moment and Ideally I want to be about 180 -190lbs. I started running 10k and now even further once a week with a few shorter runs in between so about 3 runs a week. I am seeing fitness improvements and I do seem to be gaining muscle, but the scale is not budging(I know that isn't important) and more importantly this belly of mine is still sitting all smug atop my abdomen! I do eat pretty badly at the moment and I don't log on here, but I run out of energy all the time if I don't eat regularly and I certainly wouldn't be able to maintain this level of endurance exercise without it. The amounts mfp suggests for me to eat are just not maintainable, I feel sluggish and tired and cold by late afternoon if I stick to that restriction.
This last bit of weight is becoming a frustrating nuisance now and I'd really appreciate your guys feedback on whether I'm training enough or should I cut down my food or eat more of some particular foods? Thanks.
How much are you eating, and what did MFP suggest for you?0 -
Weight loss has everything to do with how much food you cram into your pie hole and nothing to do with how many miles your run. Run for your health and your mind. Maintain a calorie deficit to lose weight0
-
I have bookmarked that link and I will try to log my cals from now on, I feel like a total idiot for posting on here now0
-
you can't out run a bad diet. that's your problem.0
-
Weight loss has everything to do with how much food you cram into your pie hole and nothing to do with how many miles your run. Run for your health and your mind. Maintain a calorie deficit to lose weight
This right here ^^^0 -
I have bookmarked that link and I will try to log my cals from now on, I feel like a total idiot for posting on here now
That's the purpose of forums and asking questions bud, don't feel like an idiot!!0 -
I think enough has been said on the eating bit - remains king in terms of weight loss.
As for your running .... just make sure you mix in interval training and hill repeats to give yourself that extra boost!0 -
bump to save that link...
when considering following the restrictions MFP gives, I hope you've realized that you get to eat the exercise cals back? Maybe that will help you with feeling sluggish?
Also, when yous start eating more veggies/home made (with a healthy eye) foods, you'll realize you get to eat more than if you're going out to eat all the time. That made a huge difference for me. I still eat out (more often than I should), but I feel much better thanks to the better foods I'm also eating.0 -
Ok i will touch a bit on you saying you cant eat within your calorie limit as you feel hungry and sluggish. As you well know you will need the deficit to lose weight no way around it, but here is the trick you need to deal with your hunger pains while still within your calorie limit.
Eat lots of protien low on calorievand very filling. Drink heavy soups like linten, eat a big breakfast with beans and tuna onions tomatos whole grain bread, its satusfying and low on calories. Learn to use spices, mustard to not make your food blant. Eat two grilled fish for lunch couple hundred calories and you wont be able to finish them. Chicken breasts lean meat.
What im trying to say you can indeed stay within your caloric deficit without feeling hungry or sluggish.0 -
Read. Reread. Read. And reread again this: http://www.acaloriecounter.com/blog/why-am-i-not-losing-weight/
This blog entry is spot on! Scientifically it does boil down to calories in vs calories out. But so many people do not want to believe that..0 -
I have bookmarked that link and I will try to log my cals from now on, I feel like a total idiot for posting on here now0
-
I have bookmarked that link and I will try to log my cals from now on, I feel like a total idiot for posting on here now
You have no reason to feel like an "idiot". In fact, you asked great questions pointing to the opposite - that you were smart enough to seek advice/help to figure things out with regard to what you are experiencing.
Make sure you follow up with your progress for all of us.
All the best.0 -
I have bookmarked that link and I will try to log my cals from now on, I feel like a total idiot for posting on here now
You have no reason to feel like an "idiot". In fact, you asked great questions pointing to the opposite - that you were smart enough to seek advice/help to figure things out with regard to what you are experiencing.
Make sure you follow up with your progress for all of us.
All the best.
Agreed!
And ditto the pp's advice on staying within calorie goals while getting full. I try to follow the 80%/20% rule of thumb with 80% of my food being nutritionally dense foods (veggies, eggs, chicken, fish, etc.) and the other 20% being whatever I want. If that gets too far out of balance I definitely struggle more with feeling hungry and sluggish.0 -
I have bookmarked that link and I will try to log my cals from now on, I feel like a total idiot for posting on here now
No, you've made my day actually. Some of you have re-assured me that my question wasn't stupid or that the answer wasn't obvious. I really enjoy running and I want to get the best out of it! I will let everyone know how things progress, I don't expect it to be plain sailing (this sort of stuff never is), but I will persevere all the same!
Thanks to all who've replied so far with suggestions to help me out, I appreciate it..0 -
I have bookmarked that link and I will try to log my cals from now on, I feel like a total idiot for posting on here now
Nah, don't feel like an idiot. It's a very common misconception that all you have to do is exercise and the weight will fall off.0 -
I have bookmarked that link and I will try to log my cals from now on, I feel like a total idiot for posting on here now
No, you've made my day actually. Some of you have re-assured me that my question wasn't stupid or that the answer wasn't obvious. I really enjoy running and I want to get the best out of it! I will let everyone know how things progress, I don't expect it to be plain sailing (this sort of stuff never is), but I will persevere all the same!
Thanks to all who've replied so far with suggestions to help me out, I appreciate it..
You've fallen into the same trap that many runners are guilty of (myself included), we start running thinking it's a ticket to eat whatever we want.
I wish......but as you observed you've gained fitness and, in my books, that's step #1 and in many respects as or more important than the number on the scale.
Log your food, aim for a modest deficit and keep running!0 -
I have bookmarked that link and I will try to log my cals from now on, I feel like a total idiot for posting on here now
That's the purpose of forums and asking questions bud, don't feel like an idiot!!
Exactly! Running is great for you if you enjoy it, but can sometimes lead to a "well i just ran 6 miles so of course I can eat _____!". I'd suggest logging your food for a few days without any changes to what you normally eat, to get an idea of what/how much you're consuming now. You may learn that you're overeating, under-eating, eating an ok amount but of food lacking in any nutritional value.
You said you weren't eating that great, I find that when I start slipping away from healthier foods on a regular basis I feel sluggish and tired - depending on your settings on MFP, also don't forget to eat back at least some if not all of your exercise calories. If you're running 3 times a week with a long run in there, you need to replenish your body (with good nutritional food!) or you could be setting yourself at too low of a deficit.
EX: I'm I'm running 3-4 miles, I'm typically burning around 400 calories (I use a heart rate monitor.) My diary is set to 1510 calories a day. On a running day, I'm now netting 1100 calories if I don't eat back my exercise - which is too low. Everyone is different - take some time to read the forums and find what exercise and eating plan works best for you and good luck!0 -
I found my self my heaviest during marathon training and I somewhat agree with the diet advice but I wanted to add one other thing...
When we spend all our available time running, we're spending less time lifting weights and building muscles. The longer runs burn more calories yet wreck havoc on metabolism because it tells the body to EAT and CONSERVE. Try switching back to more interval running, HIIT, running hills, and weight lifting. You'll see more changes in your body and start ignoring the scale. A soft body at 180 looks worse that a fit strong body at 200. Good luck!0 -
Couldn't agree more with the comments here. Where I live in Sheffield it is super hilly everywhere so every time I run I have alot of hills to deal with which I think helps with building muscle and metabolism too. I really do want to get into doing some weight exercises (maybe just bodyweight exercises for now like planks and press ups), but I am finding it difficult to motivate myself because I have a pretty weak upper body as you might expect from somebody who never really uses their arms or chest for anything. I need to take it slow and work into it nice and easy I think.0
-
Couldn't agree more with the comments here. Where I live in Sheffield it is super hilly everywhere so every time I run I have alot of hills to deal with which I think helps with building muscle and metabolism too. I really do want to get into doing some weight exercises (maybe just bodyweight exercises for now like planks and press ups), but I am finding it difficult to motivate myself because I have a pretty weak upper body as you might expect from somebody who never really uses their arms or chest for anything. I need to take it slow and work into it nice and easy I think.
Yeah people always forget about the body weight stuff. I think for a lot of us that really all we need. When I was healthy as a kid one one of the things that I worked pretty well for me was to do my body weight exercises right when I got out of bed. It sort of became my morning coffee.
I didn't do a huge amount, but I did it EVERY day. If you can get a pullup bar in one of your doors, a chair for some dips and room for a few push ups you'll be doing better than a lot of people.
Good luck!0 -
Possibly change what you are eating vs calories too. I found that my body was holding weight while running because of my carb intake. It took about 3 weeks to my body to adjust to lower carb ratios, but since that time I'm stronger than ever. My training run on Saturday was 14 miles and I didn't use anything but water and my time was better than my best PR w/o even feeling it.0
-
I now run 20-25miles a week but also do weights a couple of times a week. I've found that improving my core strength as well as my arms/ shoulders has helped my running. I find I can hold my form better for longer and so get less fatigued. The only other thing I'd suggest is make sure you fuel your runs properly so you eat before a long run. That doesn't mean eat extra, but time a meal or snack so it fits with your run schedule. I tend to have porridge or granola 30-60mins before I do my long run and it helps. Good luck0
-
Weight loss has everything to do with how much food you cram into your pie hole and nothing to do with how many miles your run. Run for your health and your mind. Maintain a calorie deficit to lose weight
This is true! I run long distance but don't always monitor my food and as I result I get what I put in.0 -
Weight is Gained or Lost in the KITCHEN.
Your diet has a SIGNIFICANTLY Higher impact on your body mass than your exercise.. It's simple maths - you can eat more 'energy' every day than you can ever dream of burning through exercise.
Exercise will get you fit .. diet will get you the body that you want.0 -
While long-distance running is of course beneficial for your body, as you know considering the results that you've already seen, you could also try mixing in some HIIT (High Intensity Interval Training) to increase fat burn - and the best part is that you continue to burn calories for the rest of the day!
Try mixing up your exercise routine too - maybe have a go at some boxing, rowing or cycling, and introduce some strength training to replace your fat loss with lean muscle gain. It's easy to get into a rut with exercise and your weight loss will plateau as a result - what doesn't challenge you, doesn't change you.
In the kitchen, make sure to eat plenty of lean protein to supplement that muscle gain, and vegetables for those all-important nutrients. Logging your calories is a good idea to make sure your balance of carbs/protein/fat is right.
Here's a really good article on HIIT: http://www.shape.com/fitness/workouts/8-benefits-high-intensity-interval-training-hiit
and here are some excellent high-protein recipe ideas http://www.bbcgoodfood.com/recipes/collection/high-protein0 -
While long-distance running is of course beneficial for your body, as you know considering the results that you've already seen, you could also try mixing in some HIIT (High Intensity Interval Training) to increase fat burn - and the best part is that you continue to burn calories for the rest of the day!
Try mixing up your exercise routine too - maybe have a go at some boxing, rowing or cycling, and introduce some strength training to replace your fat loss with lean muscle gain. It's easy to get into a rut with exercise and your weight loss will plateau as a result - what doesn't challenge you, doesn't change you.
In the kitchen, make sure to eat plenty of lean protein to supplement that muscle gain, and vegetables for those all-important nutrients. Logging your calories is a good idea to make sure your balance of carbs/protein/fat is right.
Here's a really good article on HIIT: http://www.shape.com/fitness/workouts/8-benefits-high-intensity-interval-training-hiit
and here are some excellent high-protein recipe ideas http://www.bbcgoodfood.com/recipes/collection/high-protein
Thank you for the links and advice I will look at these!0 -
The amounts mfp suggests for me to eat are just not maintainable, I feel sluggish and tired and cold by late afternoon if I stick to that restriction.
I think thisis fairly fundamental here, as it may be that you're aiming for a loss rte that's too aggressive. I had a similar situation about a year ago when my MFP goal ended up about 1600 calories, which was unpleasantly low. As a result of moderating my loss rate objectives it reset to a more manageable level, although I now find it very difficult to eat back my calories when I have a long run.
What I'd also say is that the experience pushed me to think about objectives, and that turned out to be more about improving my running performance than my weight loss per se. My weight loss hasn't been rapid, aout 3lbs per month, but my bodyft percentage is significantly reduced as a result of lots of running, with some resistance training.
I'd support the idea of bodyweight work, while your upper body strenght may not be much, it's not going to improve unless you do something about it. I'd suggest You Are Your Own Gym as a solid programme, others will come up with different suggestions. notwithstanding anything else it will help your running as youre core strength will improve, which helps your stability and efficiency.0 -
Won't beat the dead calorie horse, but only offer my empathy. I lost 89 pounds, then got more serious about running distance and training to complete longer races (just did my first 10k and doing a half marathon in November). I find it really hard to maintain good endurance, strength, and motivation to be the best runner I can be while still eating at a serious deficit. I was trying to run 20 miles per week on a 1400 calorie diet and failing on both fronts. Upping my calories to 1800 has helped me run better and more energetically while also starting to finally lose a bit of weight again. Many runners fall into the trap of eating way too much after a long run due to fatique and mistaking dehydration for hunger.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions