The TV Show "I Used To Be Fat" ??????
downtome
Posts: 529 Member
Hi All,
I have watched a couple episodes of the Tv show "I used to be fat", it's a good show, a personal trainer comes to the aid of someone wanting to lose about 90 pounds more. They set a goal to have lost that much weight in about 90 days or less. My question is this, how the heck do you lose 90 pounds in 90 days? That's a pound a day! The trainer even tells the person, you have to lose 7 pounds a week! How is that possible? I realize they work them out like mad and they eat a sensible diet, I believe I heard the trainer tell the girl to have 2 shakes and a sensible dinner, but still, is that even possible? If it is possible, I want to lose 90 pounds in 90 days too? So why can't I? Is it all the exercise or what?
I have watched a couple episodes of the Tv show "I used to be fat", it's a good show, a personal trainer comes to the aid of someone wanting to lose about 90 pounds more. They set a goal to have lost that much weight in about 90 days or less. My question is this, how the heck do you lose 90 pounds in 90 days? That's a pound a day! The trainer even tells the person, you have to lose 7 pounds a week! How is that possible? I realize they work them out like mad and they eat a sensible diet, I believe I heard the trainer tell the girl to have 2 shakes and a sensible dinner, but still, is that even possible? If it is possible, I want to lose 90 pounds in 90 days too? So why can't I? Is it all the exercise or what?
0
Replies
-
I love that show. but i have the same questions as you. it has to be a shock on the body.0
-
Yea I watched that show also well just the first episode. I know how did they do that I wish I can lost 90 lbs in 90 days that would be great but then again like u said they have the trainer to really get on their a** to workout where if we dont want to we take a day off. I do work my a** of I workout about 5 times a wk and count my calories everyday and since Nov I have lost 11lbs and have about 80 or so to get to 150.0
-
When you watch shows like the Biggest Loser, they're taking people who don't do much at all. When you take someone whose body isn't used to being pushed like that, the pounds will melt off in big numbers. If you keep watching the Biggest Loser, these contestants will eventually plateau and have a hard time losing the weight.0
-
I love that show!0
-
You might lose 90 lbs in 90 days if you work out like crazy, eat only 2 shakes and a sensible dinner, but what then? You go back to eating 'normally' and the weight creeps back on.
I eat what I love and do activities that I love and will continue to do so for the rest of my life. Sure, it took me longer than 90 days to get where I am, but my reward for my patience is that I get to stay here for the rest of my life. THAT, and my journey wasn't a miserable one.
Slow and steady
Charmagne0 -
How can that be? Can that even be healthy for a person? I mean so big of change in such short time. Impossible!0
-
Whos knows if shes really losing 90 pounds in 90 days though. Could be all for tv. They lost the weight but who really says it only took them 90 days?
Also if you noticed they don't have much to do other then eat right and work out. If I had all the time to work out my weight loss would be a lot quicker too!0 -
yes. the trainer did tell her that. but she was eatin snacks throughout the day. the shakes may have actually been meal replacement shakes meanin that they had all the nutrients 4 her. & she was eatin a full meal from the looks of what she had cooked.0
-
It's 90 lbs in 90 days for a reason. It's because after 3 month of that even someone with 2 or 300 lbs to lose will stop steadily losing as their body will determine they are starving to death.0
-
It sounds just like that show The Biggest Loser....they work them out most of the day and along with a controlled diet, they lose the weight. Problem is that it's not a realistic way to lose and keep it off. Most of The Biggest Loser contestants gain back alot of the weight they lost once they get back home to reality. And yes, the trainer is on their butt constantly....I would be losing alot of weight if I had someone on my butt all the time too, LOL0
-
Wow! That is a lot to lose fast. I thought it was unhealthy to lose more than 2-3 pounds a week. What about keeping skin and organs and muscle healthy? Don't people get more loose skin from losing so quickly?0
-
I agree 100% with you on this!You might lose 90 lbs in 90 days if you work out like crazy, eat only 2 shakes and a sensible dinner, but what then? You go back to eating 'normally' and the weight creeps back on.
I eat what I love and do activities that I love and will continue to do so for the rest of my life. Sure, it took me longer than 90 days to get where I am, but my reward for my patience is that I get to stay here for the rest of my life. THAT, and my journey wasn't a miserable one.
Slow and steady
Charmagne0 -
You might lose 90 lbs in 90 days if you work out like crazy, eat only 2 shakes and a sensible dinner, but what then? You go back to eating 'normally' and the weight creeps back on.
I eat what I love and do activities that I love and will continue to do so for the rest of my life. Sure, it took me longer than 90 days to get where I am, but my reward for my patience is that I get to stay here for the rest of my life. THAT, and my journey wasn't a miserable one.
Slow and steady
Charmagne
I Ditto Charmagne!0 -
Wow! That is a lot to lose fast. I thought it was unhealthy to lose more than 2-3 pounds a week. What about keeping skin and organs and muscle healthy? Don't people get more loose skin from losing so quickly?
Loose skin comes from a lot of factors. But if you saw the last episode when she was working out at the end in the shorts you could tell her skin on her thighs werent the tighest. But you can lose the weight slowly and still have loose skin.0 -
When you watch shows like the Biggest Loser, they're taking people who don't do much at all. When you take someone whose body isn't used to being pushed like that, the pounds will melt off in big numbers. If you keep watching the Biggest Loser, these contestants will eventually plateau and have a hard time losing the weight.
My wife and I were talking about this watching last week's episode where someone lost 41 pounds in a week. No matter how much they exercise the math just doesn't make sense to me. That's roughly 6 pounds a day. To lose 1 pound you need to create a 3500 calorie deficit, so that's 3500 times 6 or 21,000 per day. I just can't see how you can possibly burn that much every day. That first week is unquestionably a lot of retained water that is lost. Even so, those numbers are still amazing considering i lost 32 pounds in 180 days on P90X and this guy lost more than that in a week.0 -
All I know is with that HUNKY yummy trainer she had, I think I could be motivated to do just about anything! OMG! Did he not have the most gorgeous bod?
LOL I left the show on my DVR not so I could rewatch and be motivated by the girl's 90 lb weight loss, but so I could go back and be motivated by the trainer!! Loved him!0 -
I agree 100% with you on this!You might lose 90 lbs in 90 days if you work out like crazy, eat only 2 shakes and a sensible dinner, but what then? You go back to eating 'normally' and the weight creeps back on.
I eat what I love and do activities that I love and will continue to do so for the rest of my life. Sure, it took me longer than 90 days to get where I am, but my reward for my patience is that I get to stay here for the rest of my life. THAT, and my journey wasn't a miserable one.
Slow and steady
Charmagne
Exactly. If what you do to lose weight isn't something you can do after its lost, don't bother, it will come right back.0 -
The thing is, the people they've helped thus far are like 18 years old and even though i do find it extremely excessive, it is a lot easier to do it at a younger age. The biggest loser, although I love it, is SO unrealistic! One of the contestants lost 41 lbs in week 1? C'mon that is absolutely ridiculous!!! I heard that 80% of the overall contestants put the weight back on after the show.
I know it's lame but slow and steady wins the race :bigsmile:0 -
yeah, maybe they just show 90 days for TV purposes but in reality it's really longer. Heck, it took me 6 weeks to lose 25 pounds and I started out heavier than the girls on the last 2 episodes! If I could afford a trainer by all means I would hire one but the reality is I can't so like most on here, I'm on my own and with the help of all my friends on MFP. I must admit, even though I have lost 25 pounds it doesn't feel like much considering I have 125 more to go. IT may seem like a lot to some people but to me it really doesn't even make a dent. I know you have to start someone and eventually it will add up to bigger numbers. I try not to get discouraged and I keep moving forward but God help me on those days I just feel so fat and unmotivated. I don't want to go back to the way I was eating and how I felt so I will continue on this path of healthier eating and exercising. I know in the end it will all be worth it and the way I feel about myself!0
-
Sounds like a good way to get gallstones....nah Choose the healthy route.0
-
All I know is with that HUNKY yummy trainer she had, I think I could be motivated to do just about anything! OMG! Did he not have the most gorgeous bod?
LOL I left the show on my DVR not so I could rewatch and be motivated by the girl's 90 lb weight loss, but so I could go back and be motivated by the trainer!! Loved him!
Yes, he was a hottie! I was diggin on him as well....... LOL0 -
Okay--so, yes, it is POSSIBLE to lose 90 pounds in 90 days, but seriously, who thinks that is a good idea?? In three months you are just barely beginning to make new habits your own. I've been seriously working on this for 7 months, and I still went totally bonkers at Christmas. I hadn't learned good coping mechanisms for the constant onslaught of Christmas goodies. I think I learned a couple of things this year that I will hopefully remember next year, but if I had lost 90 pounds in 3 months and then been sent out on my own, truly bad things would have happened. Just saying.
Of course that doesn't mean I won't watch the show!0 -
I saw that too and I couldn't believe she lost all that weight in a short amount of time. I thought loosing that much per week was unhealthy and if she stops doesn't the weight come back on? I'd love to lose that much but I'd rather take longer to do it and know I'd be able to keep it off. A personal trainer like hers would be nice 0
-
I love this show, but honestly it pisses me off that they can lose that fast!!!! But the faster you lose the faster you gain it all back! vice-versa! They have a personal trainer and then what happens when they begin to feel comfortable and noone to push them to continue? I hope they dont ever get back to the way they were but im just saying....0
-
I had a really hard time watching it and had to turn it off. It is not healthy, and not realistic. It did not motivate me, it actually did the opposite. Too much is focused on 'weight' and 'vanity' and not 'health'. I'm on MFP because I want to be healthy and losing that much weight in such a short amount of time is anything but. Those "losers" are also not learning the tools they will need to keep the weight off, so how is this really going to help them in the long run?0
-
I agree with charmagne as well. And I hope that the trainer stressed to them how important it is to continue to exercise and porton control. But my own history would say that probably won't happen. I only saw the one with Marci, man that dude had nerves of steel dealing with her! :noway: I am going to watch Gabriella later today. So I think Marci totally could have lost it in 3 months she had all the componants to make that happen no school, very supportive mother, a personal trainer, motivation, she's 18, and as someone else here said, she had never been physically active before so her body and metabolism got a big shake up, ALSO she cut out all that fast food. Given all that, yes it was totally feasible that she could do it. I couldn't shake the feeling though that her weight IS going to come back, oneday. Mostly because she is so young and her love for fast food isn't gone. I hope it doesn't but like I said my own history with weight loss and gain says it probably will :frown:
They just showed a preview of next week with a young man who has a lot more challenges as far as his family's support. But I love transformations so I will be watching! So IMO yes it can happen in 3 months and if you notice these are very YOUNG people who's metabolism is ready and waiting for them to get moving, that is a huge advantage when it comes to losing a large amount of weight in a short time. Any of us could lose a considerable amount of weight if that is ALL we have to do each and every day for any length of time.0 -
:laugh: :laugh: :laugh: hey girl whatever works for YOU!! Are you talking about MARCI'S trainer? :smooched:All I know is with that HUNKY yummy trainer she had, I think I could be motivated to do just about anything! OMG! Did he not have the most gorgeous bod?
LOL I left the show on my DVR not so I could rewatch and be motivated by the girl's 90 lb weight loss, but so I could go back and be motivated by the trainer!! Loved him!0 -
yeah, maybe they just show 90 days for TV purposes but in reality it's really longer. Heck, it took me 6 weeks to lose 25 pounds and I started out heavier than the girls on the last 2 episodes! If I could afford a trainer by all means I would hire one but the reality is I can't so like most on here, I'm on my own and with the help of all my friends on MFP. I must admit, even though I have lost 25 pounds it doesn't feel like much considering I have 125 more to go. IT may seem like a lot to some people but to me it really doesn't even make a dent. I know you have to start someone and eventually it will add up to bigger numbers. I try not to get discouraged and I keep moving forward but God help me on those days I just feel so fat and unmotivated. I don't want to go back to the way I was eating and how I felt so I will continue on this path of healthier eating and exercising. I know in the end it will all be worth it and the way I feel about myself!
You lost 25 pounds in 6 weeks! That in itself is a huge victory! You are doing it right girl...keep going :flowerforyou:0 -
You might lose 90 lbs in 90 days if you work out like crazy, eat only 2 shakes and a sensible dinner, but what then? You go back to eating 'normally' and the weight creeps back on.
I eat what I love and do activities that I love and will continue to do so for the rest of my life. Sure, it took me longer than 90 days to get where I am, but my reward for my patience is that I get to stay here for the rest of my life. THAT, and my journey wasn't a miserable one.
Slow and steady
Charmagne
THIS! Long-lasting success takes time... How many quick "fixes" have we all tried and how many of those pounds just piled back on? I'm willing and ready to be patient and slow with my weight loss and enjoy myself along the way because I want it to last forever. Slow and steady all the way!
I've been on my journey for years now...0 -
I hate shows like that. They're downright mean to the contestants and it can't be healthy to lose that quickly. Plus, you're not learning real 'lifestyle changes'. You're learning how to lose weight fast by pushing yourself hard and barely eating. When they try to go home and live life without the planned meals and working out all day, I imagine they gain all that weight right back. (I've heard that a lot of the people from Biggest Loser do.) Personally, I want to learn changes I can stick with my whole life, like an exercise routine I can enjoy, and better food choices.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions