Jessica Simpson, too muscular? What's ur opinion?

If I am honest there is a line where if a woman becomes too muscular I find her less physically attractive than if she were slightly less muscular but still fit.

But here is the thing. That is just me. There are other people out there who are going to find more muscle more attractive and still others who gag at the sight of ANY muscle. If you try to come up with a "reason" why people like certain things you will basically be running in circles and making up explanations.

Here is what matters. If you are fit you are probably healthier than if you were not fit. If you continue to drop bodyfat and recomp to be more muscular you will be even more fit. I'm guessing there is a point where even more muscle doesn't mean you are that much healthier however if more muscle is what you want for agility or strength or to do the things you love doing then more power to you.

If the woman I love decided to get super muscular for a reason like she loved to deadlift and rock climb or something then I would support her in that and revel and enjoy in her successes as my partner. I cannot control my physical attraction response in such a rational way so would I potentially find her less attractive? Yeah, its possible. But worrying about that sort of thing is not a way to live your life.

So looong story short I don't find her legs particularly physically attractive but I think it speaks loads to her will and her determination and that is pretty hot. If I am gazing from afar then meh, if I am in a relationship with her then I am very happy for her success.

Hopefully people can understand I'm just being bluntly honest and not jump on me for it. I won't defend my attractions, there is nothing to defend...they just are.

She looks fit-and not to take away from her success-but this looks very photoshopped.

Either that or crap lighting and odd position the camera caught her in. There are a lot of weird lines and shadows that make the legs in general look weird.

Aside from that, though? I'm not a fan of her's, but rockin' legs. And the only time there's such a thing as "too muscular" is when someone's on steroids to get more than what they'd normally be capable of.

Muscles??? Where??

I don't understand how that is too muscular. I was thinking she needed to lift more. But whatevs, media.

The people on that website posting b/s comments don't know how weight loss works. She looks great...legs and all.

This content has been removed.

The people in the comment section are ridiculous. Her legs don't even look muscular, just slim.

Since you're asking our opinion on the title I will have to tell I don't like her figure that much, at least that's not the kind of figure I'd like to get or that I admire. But I do admire the fact that she's probably healthy to look like that.

I don't understand how that is too muscular. I was thinking she needed to lift more. But whatevs, media.

What's more sad? The number of people saying that her legs are "manly" and "not feminine." :noway:

Stop body shaming.

I think "too muscular" IS a thing for 99% of people if we are all to be honest. Where that line is drawn is just going to be different for different people. What people find attractive is just what they find attractive, I don't think its fair to attribute fault because you look down on what other people find attractive or not attractive.

That said I agree the comment section on that thread is pretty pathetic. Just because you don't find something attractive doesn't mean you have to mock it.

She can't win can she? Either she's too fat, ridiculed for wearing mom jeans, and now for whatever reason. Gawd help her if she's seen in public with a zit.

If I am honest there is a line where if a woman becomes too muscular I find her less physically attractive than if she were slightly less muscular but still fit.

But here is the thing. That is just me. There are other people out there who are going to find more muscle more attractive and still others who gag at the sight of ANY muscle. If you try to come up with a "reason" why people like certain things you will basically be running in circles and making up explanations.

Here is what matters. If you are fit you are probably healthier than if you were not fit. If you continue to drop bodyfat and recomp to be more muscular you will be even more fit. I'm guessing there is a point where even more muscle doesn't mean you are that much healthier however if more muscle is what you want for agility or strength or to do the things you love doing then more power to you.

If the woman I love decided to get super muscular for a reason like she loved to deadlift and rock climb or something then I would support her in that and revel and enjoy in her successes as my partner. I cannot control my physical attraction response in such a rational way so would I potentially find her less attractive? Yeah, its possible. But worrying about that sort of thing is not a way to live your life.

So looong story short I don't find her legs particularly physically attractive but I think it speaks loads to her will and her determination and that is pretty hot. If I am gazing from afar then meh, if I am in a relationship with her then I am very happy for her success.

Hopefully people can understand I'm just being bluntly honest and not jump on me for it. I won't defend my attractions, there is nothing to defend...they just are.

Nicely put Aaron. I wouldn't fancy her if I were a bloke tbh. I think I'd end up fancying bikini models circa 20% fat. But liking the look of someone and being really into the whole package are two different things. I really like looking at women's bodies, probably more than men's. I personally think it's really easy to go over a tipping point for women into too bulky, I flirt with these lines with my own body. I have to almost force myself to keep some fat on and not lift too heavy, it's detrimental to my speed and my femininity. It's so tempting to go too far though. It's like you feel you can be strong enough to conquer the world.

Here's the funny thing though. I'm not fussy whether my guys have big or little muscles, as long as they are reasonably fit. (And don't have sloping shoulders-only because my lying ex did)There's only one muscle that determines how much I fancy em.

That's right.

Their brains! Nothing sexier than a funny, happy, smart guy.

This content has been removed.