1200 Cal too low??

Hi, I've been on a 1200 calories diet for two weeks now and no, I don't think it is low. In total sedentarism, the body needs between 1400-1600 calories just to function. So, if you're not doing any exercise it is good enough. At first I though it was low and was always hungry (mostly thinking about food actually) but now I am in the range with little effort. All it takes is for you to make healthy choices, you'll see that lots of vegetables and fruits are low cal and that's what 80% of your diet should be. If you keep it mostly fruit and vegetables, you'll have calories to spare in a Starbucks Latte or some cookies.

Still, you may need to work out a little to have a firm skin after you loose the extra pounds

You should eat above your BMR, which is the minimum number of calories your body needs to function at rest. Here's a calculator: http://scoobysworkshop.com/accurate-calorie-calculator/

I tried a 1200 calorie diet years ago and wouldn't recommend it. It was easy and I felt great the first week or two because I was so motivated, but not long after that I started to get hungry all the time, my energy level went down and restricting myself so much lead to huge binges -- so I gained the weight back.

You can lose weight by eating more than 1200 calories. It'll take a little longer, but you're more likely to stick with the calorie goal over the long term, get the nutrients you need and keep the weight off.

I'm in a very similar situation, and MFP recommends 1290 for me. However, I'm typically eating 1350-1650 every day and bringing it down to 1250-1300 with exercise. I'm not sure how well this will work, but I'm giving it a couple weeks to find out...

For me, Scooby's Workshop is saying daily calories based on 20% reduction goal is 1390, so MFP appears to be about 100 cals. on the short side. However, that's if you pick Sedentary. If you claim 1-3 hrs./week of light exercise, Scooby's saying 1585, which is just about right for me, I think.

I too am on the 1200 calorie plan and I am eating mostly fruits and vegetables with 4 oz of protein daily. My problem? All those fruits and veggies contain sugar and I'm only permitted 46 g a day. I usually end up going well over my sugar intake attempting to make 1200 calories so I keep my caloric intake about 900-950, yet I'm still going over by at least 10-15 sugar gs a day, Any suggestions?

Yes. Eat more protein. It will help you maintain lean body mass and help with feeling full. My go to is usually chicken or turkey anything (turkey: pepperoni, ham, burger, bacon)

You definitely need to track your exercise. You get more calories for the exercise and need to eat a lot of them to not put your body into starvation mode. I am 52 and have lost 37lbs. I am usually about 200-300 under my calories after I work out, but a lot of days, I am right at it. It's worked for me. I am only a few lbs. from my goal. Be honest...and accountable. I have accountability partners too. We help keep each other honest.

I'm 26yo, 5'7 and started at 155. I'm currently at 145 and I've been eating 1415 (and eating back calories). I figure out the calories I've burned from my heart rate monitor.

Everyone debates this subject, but its really up to you to decide if that is too low for YOUR body. If you feel fine, and its working, and you aren't exercising excessively then use that calorie intake for your weightloss for a while. Obviously, you can't stick with that for forever, because you might hit a plateau and whatever you do when that happens, do NOT go lower than 1200. 1200 is pretty low, but anything lower is way unhealthy, and will only make you gain weight back once you decide you can't eat such low intakes everyday. However if you decided to start working out I'd go with 1500-1800 a day?
I did 1200 for a while and lost about 10 pounds, and then hit a plateau and upped it to 1800 right afterwards and lost 10 more pounds. And since then I've just ate from 1200-1800 everyday and worked out and the other 14 have slowly come off! Just figure out what works for you, and if you feel hungry on one of those days you are eating 1200, don't deny yourself food, you obviously need food. Calorie intakes are tricky, especially with weightloss. Everyone will tell you theres a right and wrong way based on their opinion, so this is just mine. No right, wrong way in mine, just figure out what works for you
Although if you're going to switch up calorie intakes like I did, I would wait at least 2 weeks with each intake so you're body isn't too confused? Who knows if that even happens? I'm not a doctor. :P Just what worked for me! Best of luck!!

Oh, and by the way, given you are eating 1200 calories you should probably make them count, and not eat poo! :P
So, eat lots of protein, and (healthy) carbs to give you energy, because from experience you will be tired eating 1200 calories even without working out. So fuel your body good luck, again!

Hi, I've been on a 1200 calories diet for two weeks now and no, I don't think it is low. In total sedentarism, the body needs between 1400-1600 calories just to function. So, if you're not doing any exercise it is good enough.

If the body needs 1400-1600 "just to function" then why on earth eat below that?

Scooby is cool for calculating your total calories, but you need to look at your macros (protein, carb, fat). To determine that, use this: http://www.bodybuilding.com/fun/6-pack-abs-diet-strategy-that-gets-results.htm

This doesn't related to the initial question! Sorry Yassy!!

But I asked everyone on my friends list this question earlier, and no one knew, does that site help you figure out the amount of macros you need?
I looked at the scooby site, and you had to have a percent of macros you wanted set up with carbs, fat, and protein.

I too am on the 1200 calorie plan and I am eating mostly fruits and vegetables with 4 oz of protein daily. My problem? All those fruits and veggies contain sugar and I'm only permitted 46 g a day. I usually end up going well over my sugar intake attempting to make 1200 calories so I keep my caloric intake about 900-950, yet I'm still going over by at least 10-15 sugar gs a day, Any suggestions?

Yeah, add more protein and less fruit. :flowerforyou:


Created by MyFitnessPal.com - Free Calorie Counter

Putting your numbers into a BMR calculator like this one

http://iifym.com/bmr-calculator/

Your BMR comes up at 1710 so I would say ya 1200 is way too low if that figure is anywhere close to accurate

1200 cal is how much a large dog eats a day.

I know a lot of people say "well Michelle Bridges puts everyone on a 1200cal diet" and that's great, but it's not realistic.
You should be eating AT LEAST your BMR which would be 1400-1600 for sure. I burn roughly 600-800 cal a day in my exercises and I eat between 1900-2200 cal a day. My BMR is 1600. The process is slower, yes, but it gives your body MORE to use, more energy to rebuild the muscle tissue and to function properly. While your meals should be bulked up by veg, you also need lean proteins in there and some complex carbs (whole grains, sweet potato, red skin potato, pumpkin, beets, quinoa etc). 4oz of protein for a day is bull****. I eat around 3oz of protein per meal. If you are really concerned about calories have a protein powder or protein smoothie as a meal. My favourite is 1 scoop chocolate protein, handful of blueberries (or your berry of choice) and 1 cup unsweetened almond milk.

tl/dr
If you eat 1200 cal a day you will drop weight, but you are more likely to gain it, and more, back.

The number of calories a person needs to maintain or lose weight is highly variable based on body size, age and gender. I've been eating between 1200 and 1400 calories for two years and have maintained my weight. Of course, I'm about the size of a large dog.

My question is, while I'm pretty comfortable with this calorie amount, is it actually healthy for me to only consume 1200 cal a day?

It's conventional wisdom here on MFP that 1,200 calories is way too low for anyone. However, MFP recommends it to a lot of people based on their inputs and The Mayo Clinic provides helpful meal plans for people based on 1,200 calories per day. I've lived on 1,200 calories a day for weeks on end. Still, you don't have to limit it that much to be successful.

No it is conventional wisdom on here that 1200 is too low for most people, not that it is too low for anyone.

For shorter older less active women 1200 is often about right.

However OP is 20 years old and 5 ft 7 in - not in the older or shorter category.
And she only has around 20 lb to lose.

My bet is that OP put in that she wants to lose 2lb per week and thus got 1200.
In fact OP you should only be aiming for 1lb or even 1/2 lb with only 20 lb to lose. If you re set MFP saying that, I'm sure it will up your calories to a more realistic level.
And eat back at least some of your exercise calories too.

In my opinion.

A woman needs 2000 calories per day and dropping to 1500 calories you'll lose weight but I don't think 1200 cals a day is too low since you're not exercising.

I think in the long run you having 100-200 cals over 1200 isn't going to make much difference.

I am 5'7 and 60kgs about 132lb I think. I don't exercise either I am only getting in 900cals a day I don't feel starved and still I have days where I eat almost 3000cals but my weight stays roughly the same.

Good Luck.