Are some people not meant to be thin

Do you walk, go the gym, lift weights, what exercise are you doing everyday? How much do you sit, what size do you wear, also are you eating any fresh veggies and fruit or almost all processed foods?

Are you drinking glass after glass of diet soda?

Some people guess , by eye balling, what they think a serving size is - 1200 calories of what?
If you want answers that apply to you, please provide more information. good luck either way ????

I said that a lot back in the day. "I am big boned"... I have a "big frame". Come to find out.. after losing 50 lbs I have a much smaller frame than I thought. YOu might want to check out....

http://www.healthcentral.com/diet-exercise/ideal-body-weight-3146-143.html


It is an ideal weight tracker for your body type..

Sorry Op, I don't have much to add to your original question but I checked this out out of curiosity...it told me I would need to lose 14lbs in order to be "ideal". Down to 90-99lbs. Not sure I would put too much faith in this. Its better to just go by how you feel and look imho.

Heh, it told me I'm underweight. Guess that means I can have an extra cupcake. :laugh:

So... I tried that - it tells me that if I had short, stubby fingers I'd be at my ideal weight now.
And since I have very large hands (giggity) I need to lose up to 32 pounds.

Bwahaha. So much duck guano on such little info and failure to take into account LBM.

Just wondering. I've hit a plateau at about 148-150lbs. I can't get past 148. I am 26 and looking back I've always been on the thick side since I was a baby. I've never been thin. Maybe I'm not suppose to be. I'm getting frustrated not being able to lose more weight. I started at 170 in feburary. Since May I've been at 150 and u keep losing and gaining the same pound. I've been restricting what I eat to only 1200 calories and still nothing.

I *completely* understand, it's scary how similar your situation is to mine. I'm also 5'5 and 26, have been between 149-152 for 2 months now and I'm doing exactly the same thing I had been doing, it just *stopped* completely on May.

I do think some of us will never be "thin" without starving ourselves and being miserable, and that's no good. We can be healthy and look great, but still be on the higher end of the weight spectrum. I was 130 once when I entered college, and looking back at those pictures I looked ill, even though 130 would be a very normal/healthy weight for my height. I am almost overweight now according to those charts and some people have told me this is the best I've looked. So yes, I have started to think some of us will weigh more even while following a strict diet and exercise program. This isn't a cop out at all because we are not talking about weighing 250 pounds because we are big boned. We are saying a couple of extra pounds because some of us (like me) just have a bigger body or bigger body areas. I would say...try for a couple of more pounds or try something different, but maybe at some point be happy with your weight and focus on fitness...that's what I'm trying to do :S

I said that a lot back in the day. "I am big boned"... I have a "big frame". Come to find out.. after losing 50 lbs I have a much smaller frame than I thought. YOu might want to check out....

http://www.healthcentral.com/diet-exercise/ideal-body-weight-3146-143.html


It is an ideal weight tracker for your body type..

What a load of crap.

For starters, if you have a lot of fat on your wrists, it's going to blow the tests to begin with.

Second, it told me my "ideal weight" was between 70 and 77kg. Well sorry bucko, I remember being 70-77kg, and I was fat.

I believe that any female (barring health or hormone issues) can get to 20% body fat. Where that puts one on the scale DOESN'T MATTER. A female at 20% body fat will look pretty lean. If one doesn't get there, then it's more likely that it's NOT a priority like other things are.

A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness industry for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition

So, in other words, a woman who is not aiming for 20% bodyfat doesn't have her priorities straight? That's pretty lean. Many women can't attain that low a level. But since Scarlett Johanssen and Christina Hendricks don't have their priorities straight, some of us can feel we're in good company.

You know I have been told so many times that if I can't lose weight it's because I didn't want it bad enough....God know how badly I want o be thinner and lighter.. This type of comments make me feel very upset and feel stupid about myself...I must be really dumb because I can't lose the weight and achieve the look I want...

I believe that any female (barring health or hormone issues) can get to 20% body fat. Where that puts one on the scale DOESN'T MATTER. A female at 20% body fat will look pretty lean. If one doesn't get there, then it's more likely that it's NOT a priority like other things are.

A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness industry for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition

So, in other words, a woman who is not aiming for 20% bodyfat doesn't have her priorities straight? That's pretty lean. Many women can't attain that low a level. But since Scarlett Johanssen and Christina Hendricks don't have their priorities straight, some of us can feel we're in good company.

Scarlett Johanssen quote:

"It was many, many, hours, days, and months of stunt training and strength training, but it's fun because I had a goal. The goal was the Lycra catsuit."

http://www.businessinsider.com/extreme-weight-loss-and-gain-for-movie-roles-2012-7?op=1#ixzz36sqbA4TR

Not that I'm planning to stuff my old carcass into one of those, barring a bad Halloween costume concept, but yeah, the woman is gorgeous at any size, and she still had to work at it.

yes, although scarlett or JLO is not my type of ideal body, but I read every where that they do work hard for whatever they've got...

I am also 5' 5" and my goal weight is anything under 150 (high normal according to BMI charts). "Thin" is relative. I am walking around now at 172, wearing a size 8 or 10, and I feel pretty thin everywhere but the gym because many of the people I see around town are so much more overweight than I am. I imagine at 150 I will feel thin most of the time.

At the gym it is different, of course, because you see some committed people who have very low body fat, amazing bodies, and you see some very, very thin people who will do cardio machines for hours. Maybe you want to aspire to be one of those types of people, and that is great if you do--I'm sure you can get to a very lean state with a lot of work and motivation.

If you're looking to become one of those people who is more effortlessly thin, though, I would think that changing your body type is probably unrealistic. When I was a teenager, I was at the low normal end of the spectrum for a while, about 115. I did not feel thin at that time because so many others were thinner. I had broad shoulders and thought of myself as "curvy," "stocky," or maybe "average" certainly not thin--even though I had bones poking out in my chest and ribs --because to me a thin person was narrow and just built differently. I had to restrict calories vigilantly or my weight would shoot up to 130 or 140 right away. We all have probably known one of those people who seem to be "meant to be thin," as you say, who don't obsess over diet and wear a size 00 or maybe a 2 and at the same time don't have a lot of bones poking out. In asking whether you are meant to be thin, it sounds like you know you are not one of those people. . . nothing wrong with that.

Ideal weight for you is whatever number you choose! It only depends on what you want to look like. People differ on what degree of thinness they consider to be ideal. Anyone CAN be model-thin! Personally, I do not want to look that skinny. If I did, I would certainly set my goal at 90-something pounds (I am 5' 3 1/2.") I have never been model-thin; however, in my opinion I look TOO thin whenever under 110 pounds. Whatever weight you feel YOU look best at is the right weight for you!

http://www.healthcentral.com/diet-exercise/ideal-body-weight-3146-143.html

It is an ideal weight tracker for your body type..

I see that many disagree, but I really liked this link. It supports my experience of where I felt healthiest & enjoyed my body the most. I set my goal within this range despite the fact that it still places me on the very upper edge of the "normal" range. I have been significantly lighter. I looked SCARY & UNHEALTHY. I am a wide-hipped, large-chested woman. I'm no Kate Moss, nor should I aim to be! I can, however, be slim & healthy. It's just a number. ????

I disagree BECAUSE there are some people who live to eat. Yes, they probably will shorten their lifespan if they are short and choose to weigh 190 pounds. They choose quality of life over quantity. It is worth it to them to be able to eat more of what food they want, than to live longer. It is worth it to them to be able to eat like that even though they will still look too fat by any standard. There is a wide variance in what people consider "fat" or "thin." To a point. Everyone would consider a 190-pound person to look too fat unless they are very tall. The short person who sets her goal at 190 cares more about being able to eat a lot of fattening food every day than looking slender. She already knows she will look too fat, but food is more important to her. She has every right to make that decision for herself! She would rather enjoy a shortened lifespan of lots of fattening food every day than to live longer and feel deprived, food-wise. If she was over 300, she has chosen a compromise, a middle ground, between quality and quantity of life. Many people choose this option. Personally, I would not be willing to diet in order to live a longer life! I am vanity-driven, and it just so happens that what I consider to be the weight at which I look best DOES fall within the healthy BMI range. I stand by my original statement of, "Ideal weight for you is whatever number you choose."